Letters to the Editor: Campaign spend, pay equity, rabbits and rail
In response to Mr Bill Southworth's letter (ODT 26.6.25) suggesting that both I and Future Dunedin hold an unfair advantage in the upcoming Dunedin City Council local body elections due to our ability to run a campaign.
While the current rules permit each candidate to spend up to $55,000 on campaigning, Future Dunedin's actual budget is well below that limit. What sets us apart is not the scale of our spending, but the strength of our vision - a vision grounded in genuine change, practical ambition, and a deep commitment to the future of our city.
We look forward to sharing that vision with the people of Dunedin and inviting their support.
Mr Southworth may find reassurance in the fact that, in 2022, the candidate who invested the most in their campaign was ultimately unsuccessful. This underscores a fundamental truth in local democracy: meaningful ideas resonate more deeply than advertising budgets.
Future Dunedin has also made a principled decision not to accept any external donations. We are not aligned with any political party, nor are we funded by outside interests.
Should we be elected, our councillors will answer only to the people of Dunedin.
Andrew Simms
Mayoral and council candidate for Future Dunedin Pearl clutching
''Hipkins said he had changed his position on the appropriateness of the column because of the distraction it was causing, which was 'taking away from what is a very fair issue'.'' (RNZ 15.5.25).
This was the moment Chris Hipkins showed his complete inability to lead and be the next prime minister. Instead of recognising the juicy open goal presented by the most outrageous egregious pearl-clutching episode ever seen in Parliament and treating it with the kind of derision that Helen Clark would have revelled in, he bottled it, conceding weakly to the disingenuous framing of Brooke van Velden and certain media commentators, and threw Jan Tinetti under the bus. The late Bob Jones once called Bill Rowling the ''shiver in search of a spine'': Hipkins owns this now. Pay equity was and is the issue.
Andrew Nichols
Kew Freight hub
What I consider very good news is the proposed freight hub is to be located at Milburn. This is an ideal location and must result in fewer heavy vehicles coming through Dunedin and using SH88 to and from Port Chalmers.
The CEO of Port Otago, Kevin Winders, is very supportive and has indicated this hub will not be in competition with the one to be fully developed in Mosgiel. I suggest Calder Stewart start doing it immediately before all the naysayers get together and act against this plan.
John Neilson
Ravensbourne Oi. Shhh.
Southland Hospital's ban on its staff chatting to each other for more than 5 minutes a day, and never in the afternoon, is brilliant. The management is well aware that talking about the performance of the All Blacks, the Kardashians or Meghan and Harry takes up far too many valuable minutes, and patients may die as a consequence.
To have a taciturn but kindly and efficient staff is clearly the aim, and will surely save the taxpayer many millions.
Mark Stocker
Christchurch We are making rabbits run run run - KiwiRail
I was surprised to read comments highlighting issues with feral rabbits in the rail corridor in Otago, and suggesting that land occupiers and Otago Regional Council staff have had limited success engaging with public agencies to enable effective control of rabbits (ODT 21.5.25).
KiwiRail is committed to controlling rabbits on its land and has been carrying out targeted rabbit control annually since 2019 throughout sections of the rail corridor in Balclutha, Moeraki, Waihola, Milton and Henley.
This has been undertaken in collaboration with both the ORC and the local community.
Pests do not respect boundaries, so pest control is a responsibility of all landowners. KiwiRail is absolutely playing its part.
Ruth Brittain
National vegetation contract manager, KiwiRail Recognition sought
Please could the current government at the very least acknowledge the economic cost that the Labour government had to bear with the four disasters it had to finance during its terms.
Kay Hannan
Weston Somehow not sighting the causal nexus
If the Otago University Staff for Palestine group (Letters ODT 26.5.25) are so blinkered by their prejudice against Israel that they do not see the significant causal nexus between the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023 and the present situation in Gaza, then there is little hope that the group's efforts can actually make any contribution towards their ostensible aims of improving the plight for Palestinians.
Before October 2023, 18,000 Palestinians from Gaza held work permits allowing them to cross the controlled border between Gaza and Israel for work each day. After October 2023, all of these permits were revoked.
Before October 2023, there were no settlers, settlements, or permanent Israeli forces within Gaza, although Israel still controlled the borders. After October 2023, the idea that Israel should not continue to control its borders is ridiculous.
Malcolm Moncrief-SpittleDunedin
[Abridged - editor.]
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
5 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Netanyahu has 'lost the plot': Luxon
By Tuwhenuaroa Natanahira of RNZ The Prime Minister says the war in Gaza is "utterly appalling" and Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has "lost the plot". Christopher Luxon's comments came on a tense day in Parliament, where Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick was 'named' for refusing to leave the House following a heated debate on the government's plan to consider recognising Palestinian statehood. Speaking to media, Luxon said Netanyahu had "gone too far". "I think he has lost the plot and I think that what we're seeing overnight - the attack on Gaza City - is utterly, utterly unacceptable" he said. Luxon said Israel had consistently ignored pleas from the international community for humanitarian aid to be delivered "unfettered", and the situation was driving more human catastrophe across Gaza. "We are a small country a long way away, with very limited trade with Israel. We have very little connection with the country, but we have stood up for values, and we keep articulating them very consistently, and what you have seen is Israel not listening to the global community at all. "We have said a forcible displacement of people and an annexation of Gaza would be a breach of international law. We have called these things out consistently time and time again. "You've seen New Zealand join many of our friends and partners around the world to make these statements, and he's just not listening," the prime minister said. The government is considering whether it will join other countries like France, Canada and Australia in recognising Palestinian statehood at a UN Leaders Meeting next month. Luxon said recent attacks could "extinguish a pathway" to a two-state solution. "I'm telling you what my personal view is, as a human being, looking at the situation, that's how I feel about." he said. Labour leader Chris Hipkins has called the war an "unfolding genocide", echoing the comments made by former prime minister Helen Clark, who visited the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and the Palestinian territory this week. "She's used the words 'unfolding genocide', and yes, I do agree with that. That's a good description of the situation at the moment." Hipkins said calling it an "unfolding genocide" meant that we were not "appointing ourselves judge and jury" because there was still a case to be heard before the International Court of Justice. "Recognising that there is an unfolding genocide in Gaza is an important part of the world community standing up and saying, we're not going to tolerate it. "We should recognise that there is now a growing acknowledgement around the world that there is an unfolding genocide in Gaza, and I think we should call that for what it is, and the world community needs to react to that to prevent it from happening," Hipkins said.
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
Oral Questions for Wednesday 13 August 2025
Questions to Ministers HANA-RAWHITI MAIPI-CLARKE to the Minister of Education: What Maori education providers has she consulted with, if any, regarding the impact her proposed education changes will have on Maori learners across Aotearoa? NANCY LU to the Minister of Finance: What reports has she seen on New Zealand's fiscal policy and tax settings? Rt Hon CHRIS HIPKINS to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by all his Government's statements and actions? CHLÖE SWARBRICK to the Prime Minister: E tautoko ana ia i nga korero me nga mahi katoa a tona Kawanatanga? Does he stand by all of his Government's statements and actions? GRANT McCALLUM to the Minister of Immigration: What recent announcements has she made about supporting businesses to access seasonal workers? Hon Dr MEGAN WOODS to the Minister for Energy: Does he agree with the chief executive officer of Consumer NZ and the managing director of Simplicity, in the Protecting industry, jobs and household budgets as the gas runs out report, that accelerating heat pump adoption will reduce reliance on gas, protect jobs, improve public health, and lower energy costs for New Zealand families and businesses? LAURA McCLURE to the Minister for Children: What recent announcements has she made about improving the experiences of Oranga Tamariki caregivers? Hon WILLIE JACKSON to the Minister for Social Development and Employment: Does she stand by her statement about unemployment that "I'm really confident our approach is working"; if so, why is unemployment worse than this time last year, with 16,000 more people unemployed? Hon MARAMA DAVIDSON to the Prime Minister: E tautoko ana ia i nga korero me nga mahi katoa a tona Kawanatanga? Does he stand by all of his Government's statements and actions? CATHERINE WEDD to the Minister of Conservation: What recent announcements has he made about the Conservation Act 1987? Hon PEENI HENARE to the Associate Minister of Housing: Does he agree with Hon Chris Bishop that homelessness has "potentially ticked up a little bit, up a little bit more in the last couple of years"? GREG FLEMING to the Minister for Mental Health: What recent reports has he seen on growth in the mental health workforce? To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
Otago Daily Times
18 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Letters to the Editor: elections, birthdays and passports
Today's Letters to the Editor from readers cover topics including a dose of anti-government indoctrination, Luxon's birthday quote, and the change to our passports. Vamping it up over blood-sucking leader Well, whammo. The ODT has opened its 2026 election campaign, heavily against the government, with a totally biased editorial (9.8.25). Painting the government as either blood-sucking vampires or lords of darkness, the editor attributed Wellington's doldrums to Nicola Willis' "right-sizing" of the public service. No mention of any other possible causes to balance the dark picture, such as Covid lockdowns which also zombiefied many other CBDs in the rest of the country, or the Left's massive hiring of public servants during their term in office, thereby hiding unemployment and driving up costs for no return. The editor knifed "dark lord" Seymour for his efforts to reduce regulation and free up business, again with no reasonable balance. Anyone can see at least a few benefits in cutting the obvious overload of red tape that we all complain about. Maybe because Labour is keeping its policies secret there is little to comment on, but if Saturday's ODT is anything to go by the editor is nevertheless planning on subjecting readers to a heavy dose of socialist-leaning anti-government indoctrination over the next year or so. [The editor has no such plans. Ed.] On the other hand Great editorial (9.8.25), thank you. Team players Congratulation to Bill Acklin. You proved yourself to be a loyal and honest team member, brave enough to speak up when you felt that our mayor was being targeted unfairly ( ODT 24.6.25). You get my vote along with Mayor Jules Radich, deputy mayor Cherry Lucas and just four more of the other present councillors. If only Aaron Hawkins' supporters, and some of those who think they can do a better job as mayor, had been voted out at the last election, our present mayor would have had more support from a respectful, co-operative and united team. In every group individuals will have differing opinions but those who hold positions of power must be willing to listen to the people who they serve, discuss the best options and make the right decisions so that basic projects can be completed and at a reasonable cost. Most "nice to have" projects should be rejected after their first hearing. With this upcoming election all voters need to research and vote wisely. Voters take note of future ODT reports and Letters to the Editor during the next few weeks. Each of us has a responsibly to vote wisely. Both Dunedin City Council and Otago Regional Council really need experienced people who are respectful, wise and committed to working for the people who they represent rather than themselves. Happy birthday to him Every day I look at the birthday list to see who is mentioned and enjoy some of the quotes of the day. On July 21 I discovered that Christopher Luxon was born on this day in 1970 and I thought he is just a young person. I then read his quote of the day: "Let me be clear, I'm wealthy, I'm, you know, sorted." It sounded very self-satisfied and made me wonder what does he mean by this comment? This country's distinctive original language Last month Internal Affairs Minister Brooke van Velden announced a change to our passport design. (That is, our distinctive, classy, internationally-recognised passport). The plan is to swap the word order so that the English words are first "as it is the language most widely spoken by the New Zealand public". English might be the predominant language of Aotearoa, but te reo Māori was pre-existing: it is, and will always be, the first language of this whenua. Brooke van Velden is clearly the young face of the government, but she speaks with an old, stale, colonial voice. She would be wise to better understand what our young people are experiencing in 2025. I recommend she attends an amazing week-long event coming up in September, Polyfest. In Dunedin alone, 173 groups have registered for Polyfest. Thousands of tamariki and rangatahi will perform, from the early childhood centres, primary, intermediate and high schools. This is where she could hear the voices of young New Zealanders and the beautiful, powerful language of this land, te reo Māori. Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@
