'Ideologically biased, scientifically unfounded': New paper rejects criticism of Project Cheetah
criticism of Project Cheetah
, which seeks to reintroduce the big cat to India more than 70 years after its extinction in the country, as "ideologically biased, scientifically unfounded and rooted in misinformation".
Published in Frontiers in Conservation Science, the paper titled 'Beyond rhetoric: debunking myths and misinformation on India's Project Cheetah' addressed concerns ranging from animal welfare to scientific validity and community impact.
The paper, written by environment ministry officials, including National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) Member Secretary G S Bhardwaj, said that while "constructive criticism is essential", the discourse around Project Cheetah has been "characterized by self-referential arguments, selective use of literature and a disproportionate emphasis on negative outcomes".
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Villas Prices In Dubai Might Be More Affordable Than You Think
Villas In Dubai | Search Ads
Get Quote
Undo
It said that "critics have misrepresented key aspects, such as the use of soft-release bomas, ethical concerns and veterinary interventions, while ignoring the project's adaptive management strategies and measurable progress".
One of the most frequent criticisms has been that the cheetahs are being kept in captivity.
Live Events
The paper said the cheetahs in Kuno (Madhya Pradesh) are neither held in artificial structures nor dependent on human provisioning. Instead, they were initially held in soft-release bomas, fenced natural enclosures, which are internationally recognised in carnivore re-introductions.
It added that the bomas allows cheetahs "to hunt independently and exhibit natural behaviours while acclimatizing to their new environment".
The authors cited international studies showing that this model can "increase the odds of reintroduction success by 2.5-fold".
Some critics have described cheetah births at Kuno as captive breeding. However, the paper strongly rejected this claim.
"Cheetahs cannot be forced to breed, even in controlled environments," the paper said, citing how it took Western zoos more than four decades to achieve successful breeding.
In contrast, "the fact that translocated cheetahs in Kuno have produced 25 cubs from six successful litters in 2.5 years...demonstrates that these animals are in a stress-free, near-natural environment", it said.
The paper also said that the cubs born in Kuno are nurtured and raised entirely by their mothers without any form of human intervention.
Responding to questions around cheetah deaths, the NTCA said mortality is a natural and expected part of any translocation effort.
The paper said, "The cheetah mortality rate in Kuno has remained well below the anticipated threshold of 50 per cent."
In fact, "adult cheetah survival rates in Kuno were 70 per cent in the first year and reached 85.71 per cent in the second year".
For cubs, the survival rate over 2.5 years stood at 66.67 per cent, which officials called a "significant figure", given the species' tendency for high infant mortality in the wild.
The officials, however, said that unforeseen challenges, including an unseasonal winter coat, tick infestations, and associated infections, resulted in multiple mortalities in free ranging settings.
They also refuted the notion that Project Cheetah was launched hastily or without scientific basis.
"The decision to introduce cheetahs in India was not made impulsively," they wrote, referring to a consultative meeting held as early as 2009 with IUCN experts, NGOs and academic institutions. Subsequent assessments, including site evaluations and disease risk analyses, followed international protocols.
Critics have also questioned whether India's landscape is suitable for cheetahs.
The officials cited global research and early data from Kuno suggesting that cheetahs are far more adaptable than previously assumed.
"Contrary to the assumption that cheetahs are savanna specialists, several studies reveal their adaptability to diverse habitats and prey types," the paper said.
The authors said that while critics cite the number of medical interventions (90 immobilizations), this "equates to around two immobilizations per cheetah per year, a reasonable figure given the range of necessary management interventions".
Critics have also argued that the project harmed local communities.
The paper clarified that "only one village has been relocated" since the project's start and that too with full consent of the village Gram Sabha under legal provisions.
The paper added that the project has brought benefits to local people, including "employment as forest watchers or cheetah trackers, guides and drivers, and improved infrastructure".
Seventy years after cheetahs went extinct in India, the government launched the Project Cheetah to establish a sustainable population of the big cat in the country.
As part of the reintroduction effort, 20 African cheetahs have been brought to the
Kuno National Park
-- eight from Namibia in September 2022 and 12 from South Africa in February 2023.
Since then, 26 cheetah cubs have been born in India, of which 19 have survived. Eleven cubs are roaming free in the wild, while the rest are in enclosures at Kuno. PTI
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
12 minutes ago
- Time of India
After 'Frankenstein' rabbits, 'zombie squirrels' are haunting Americans
Source: X Squirrels with grotesque, wart-like tumors have been spotted across the United States and Canada, particularly in states like Maine. The condition, marked by pus-filled tumors and hairless patches, has alarmed residents and fueled viral discussions on Reddit, X, and other platforms. According to reports, sightings of these afflicted animals have surfaced since mid-2023, with numbers rising this summer. Some residents have dubbed them 'zombie squirrels' due to their disturbing appearance. One Reddit user recalled seeing a gray squirrel with a tumor on its mouth on July 31, initially thinking it was eating something in a flowerbed before realizing the growth was attached to its face. The cause: Squirrel Fibromatosis Wildlife experts identify the phenomenon as squirrel fibromatosis—a naturally occurring viral skin disease that looks frightening but poses no risk to humans, pets, or birds. The condition is caused by the leporipoxvirus and spreads through direct contact, often when healthy squirrels encounter the saliva or lesions of infected ones. The transmission mechanism is similar to how herpes spreads in humans. Unlike squirrelpox—common in the UK and often fatal to red squirrels—this virus usually resolves within four to eight weeks. However, in rare cases, internal organ involvement can be fatal. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Use an AI Writing Tool That Actually Understands Your Voice Grammarly Install Now Undo Wildlife biologist Shevenell Webb of Maine's Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife told the Bangor Daily News that the clustering of squirrels—often around bird feeders—may be driving the spread. 'It's like when you get a large concentration of people. If someone is sick and it spreads easily, others are going to catch it,' she said. Uneaten seeds contaminated with saliva or fluid from an infected squirrel can pass the virus on to others. Webb urged residents not to interfere. 'It is naturally occurring and will run its course in time,' she noted. Rabbits with antler-like growths Source: X At the same time, unusual wildlife sightings have been reported in Colorado, where cottontail rabbits infected with Shope papilloma virus—also called cottontail papilloma virus—develop black, antler-like growths protruding from their heads. The disease is spread by parasites like ticks and fleas, which pass on the ailment through their bites, according to Pet MD. While the recent sightings occurred in Colorado, the disease most frequently appears in the Midwest. 'Typically rabbits become infected in the warmer months of summer when transmitted by being bitten by insects like fleas and ticks,' said Colorado Parks and Wildlife spokesperson Kara Van Hoose, per the Coloradoan. Fortunately, Colorado Parks and Wildlife notes that while the virus can spread between rabbits, it is not known to infect humans or pets and is not considered a public health threat.
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Is 3I/ATLAS an alien probe? Harvard scientists spark debate on extraterrestrial life
Scientists all over the world are interested in a strange object that is moving quickly through space. The thing, called 3I/ATLAS , is huge, about the size of Manhattan, and is moving toward Earth at an incredible speed. Some Harvard researchers think it might even be technology from another planet. This has led to discussions about the possibility of an alien encounter this November. Researchers say that even though the study is just a thought experiment, the possible effects of such an encounter could be terrible for people. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Undo ALSO READ: Orca attack mystery: What really happened to marine trainer Jessica Radcliffe This interstellar traveler is moving faster than 60 kilometers per second and is between 10 and 20 kilometers wide. This makes people wonder if it could be more than just a rock in space. Live Events Could this thing really be technology from space? The fact that Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb is involved with 3I/ATLAS is a big part of what makes it so interesting. Loeb has long said that we shouldn't rule out the possibility of alien technology . Loeb, Adam Hibberd, and Adam Crowl from the Initiative for Interstellar Studies in London wrote a paper together that said the object might not be natural, as per a report by WION News. The scientists think that if 3I/ATLAS is a smart ship, its strange orbit might let it get close to Earth without being seen. The study also shows that the object's location near the Sun later this year could give it the chance to move quickly without being seen. What makes November 2025 so important? Scientists think that 3I/ATLAS will be closest to the Sun in late November 2025. It might be hard to find at that time because it could be out of sight of telescopes on Earth. This window has led to speculation that the object could try to sneak up on Earth if it is being controlled by intelligent beings The Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System (ATLAS) telescope in Chile was the first to see the object, which added to the suspense, as per a report by WION News. ALSO READ: Apple iPhone 17 Air and Pro get surprise release date change — here's the new timeline What are scientists saying about the risks? Even though the headlines are scary, the study's authors stress that their work is only a theory. They make it clear that they are not claiming that aliens are a direct threat, but that they are testing a theory. The study says that even though the idea may sound strange, it is worth looking into scientifically. The team also says, though, that if the hypothesis were ever proven true, things could get very bad. People may have to think about ways to protect themselves, even though the researchers say that these efforts may not work against advanced technology in the end. A scary but possible idea Avi Loeb has caused a lot of talk about possible alien probes before. He famously said in 2017 that the interstellar object ʻOumuamua might have been an artificial spacecraft. Many astronomers disagreed with him, but his arguments got people talking about how people understand strange cosmic events. The nature of 3I/ATLAS remains a mystery at this time. Scientists will keep a close eye on it as it speeds toward the inner solar system, whether it's just another cosmic rock or something much more advanced, as per a report by WION News. FAQs What is 3I/ATLAS? ATLAS telescopes found it, and it could be alien technology. It's a huge object in space. When might it be dangerous to Earth? The object will come closest to Earth in late November 2025, according to scientists.
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
IIIT-A researchers develop AI tech for real time crop disease detection in Indian farms
Prayagraj: In a groundbreaking advancement for Indian agriculture, researchers at the Indian Institute of Information Technology (IIIT) Allahabad developed an innovative technology that allows farmers to detect crop diseases directly in their fields without needing to consult agricultural experts. This cutting-edge solution uses a combination of Artificial Intelligence (AI), Internet of Things (IoT), Deep Learning, and Federated Learning to analyse plant health based on leaf images and environmental conditions. This AI model— CVGG-16 was developed by Pramod Kumar Singh, a research scholar under associate professor and head of the Information Technology department at IIIT-Allahabad, Manish Kumar. This model was published in the international journal Internet of Things by Elsevier. The CVGG-16 model was trained on real-world images from farms — including dusty, low-light, or weather-affected conditions — making it robust and reliable across various regions and climates. What sets this model apart is its multi-concept data fusion network, which doesn't rely solely on photos. It integrates sensor data such as soil moisture, temperature, humidity, and weather patterns, allowing it to provide highly accurate analysis of a plant's health. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo "For testing the viability of the model, we collected the sample data of the farms around Prayagraj, and we can assure that the model not only saves the precious time of the farmers (when it comes to identifying the health of the crop) but also provides precise information regarding any diseases very much in the preliminary stage, which helps in containing the same in an effective manner," said Manish Kumar. The model achieved an impressive accuracy of 97.25% and in specific tests, it recorded 96.75% accuracy in identifying maize diseases and 93.55% in potato disease detection. A key innovation in this project is the implementation of Federated Learning, which ensures that farmers' data remains private. Instead of sending data to a central server, the model is trained locally near the farms, using a new algorithm named Extreme Client Aggregation. This ensures data privacy and decentralisation while still achieving high performance across datasets from different geographical regions. Since we have the picture of the entire farmland it is easier to spot the 'culprit' even in the deepest part of the crop, he added. Prof Manish Kumar emphasised the model's scalability and adaptability, stating that it can be applied to any crop in any region across India. Whether it's maize fields in North India or potato farms in the South, the model's multi-layered structure allows it to adjust to varied agricultural conditions. The researchers aim to make the technology even more accessible by developing mobile-based solutions and local language interfaces to ensure that small and marginal farmers can benefit from this advancement. This breakthrough could mark a turning point in Indian agriculture, empowering farmers with real-time, intelligent diagnostics — and ensuring healthier crops with minimal dependency on external consultations, he said. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
