logo
India claims to be a leader of the Global South – but its strategic silences subvert that assertion

India claims to be a leader of the Global South – but its strategic silences subvert that assertion

Scroll.in17-07-2025
'It's time for us to work together to give the Global South its rightful seat at the table,' Prime Minister Narendra Modi told the Trinidad and Tobago Parliament earlier this month. This rallying cry, echoed by External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar's assertion that India had 'walked the talk' on amplifying the voice of the Global South during its G20 presidency in 2023, suggests a deep commitment to justice, equity, and solidarity among formerly colonised nations.
Yet, beyond the stage-managed speeches and summit diplomacy lies a starkly contradictory reality.
India's foreign policy under the Modi regime has demonstrated a troubling dissonance between word and deed, particularly when it comes to supporting contemporary anti-colonial, anti-imperial struggles – the very foundation upon which Global South solidarity has been built historically.
While India continues to posture as a champion of decolonial justice, its abstentions, evasions and silences on key issues indicate a growing complicity with forces driven by the impulses New Delhi claims to be standing against.
Shared history
The Global South is united not simply by geography but a shared history of political and economic subjugation, a history shaped by centuries of colonisation and extractive global capitalism.
The fight of formerly colonised nations to assert their sovereignty and self-determination is not merely a legacy struggle – it is ongoing. The Palestinian resistance, the Iranian challenge to Western hegemony and the Tibetan struggle for cultural and political autonomy are contemporary examples of this unfinished decolonial project.
India's recent positions on these issues, however, reveal a pattern of selective advocacy, where solidarity is expressed only when it does not offend powerful global interests.
Take Palestine. For decades, India was among the most steadfast supporters of Palestinian statehood, reflecting its own anti-colonial roots. But under the Narendra Modi government, this solidarity has been eroded. India has cultivated an increasingly close strategic relationship with Israel, evident not just in defence and intelligence cooperation, but in diplomatic alignments as well.
Despite widespread international condemnation of Israel's military actions in Gaza, including from traditional Western allies such as France, Germany, and the United Kingdom, India chose to abstain from the latest United Nations General Assembly resolution on June 12 calling for an immediate ceasefire.
A nation that once prided itself on principled non-alignment has, in this case, aligned itself with occupation and impunity.
Civilisational ties
The case of Iran presents a different but related form of hypocrisy. India and Iran share strong civilisational ties and the two nations have often found common ground in opposing Western domination. Yet, India's response to the recent illegal Israeli and American strikes on Iranian nuclear scientists and facilities has been disappointingly muted.
When the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation issued a statement condemning these attacks, India conspicuously distanced itself. In doing so, it failed not only a long-time partner, but also the broader principle of sovereignty in the face of imperial aggression.
Iran's anti-imperial history – from the 1953 Central Intelligence Agency-backed coup to the 1979 revolution – may be ideologically inconvenient for Western powers, but it is central to any serious conversation about Global South resistance. India's silence here is not neutrality. It is acquiescence.
Then there is Tibet, a far more uncomfortable test for India's claims, given the oppressor is China, a fellow member of the Global South. India has long hosted the Tibetan exile community and the Central Tibetan Administration in Dharamshala, but it has increasingly adopted a policy of studied disengagement.
Most recently, the Ministry of External Affairs declared it 'does not take any position' on the Dalai Lama's succession, on the grounds that the matter is a purely religious one. But the stakes of the Dalai Lama's succession are political not merely spiritual. Beijing's attempt to impose its own candidate for the next Dalai Lama is part of a broader strategy of cultural colonisation and political control over Tibet.
For India to pretend otherwise is to abandon a people whose resistance it once quietly supported. Again, this is not impartiality. It is strategic cowardice.
A clear pattern
What emerges is a clear pattern: when support for oppressed peoples comes at no geopolitical or economic cost, India is willing to speak. But when taking a stand would require confronting global or regional powers – be it China, the United States, or Israel – the Modi government prefers silence dressed up as non-alignment.
This is not the behaviour of a principled leader of the Global South. It is the behaviour of a state guided more by realpolitik and economic self-interest than by any genuine commitment to decolonial solidarity.
To be a true voice of the Global South is not merely to invoke its name at summits or in speeches before foreign parliaments. It is to stand up for the people who suffer under the same structures of power that once subjugated India itself.
It is to challenge, not appease, the powers that perpetuate occupation, intervention, and cultural erasure. It is to walk the talk – even when the path is uncomfortable.
However, India's current foreign policy attempts to have its cake and eat it too. It wants the prestige of leading the Global South without paying the political costs of standing with its oppressed. It wants to appear as a moral power while remaining diplomatically cosy with economic and military hegemons.
But in the crucible of global justice, such duplicity does not go unnoticed. Solidarity, after all, is not a slogan – it is a choice. India, tragically, is choosing silence.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Remove non-biological PM too: Trinamool MP's taunt amid Bihar poll roll revision
Remove non-biological PM too: Trinamool MP's taunt amid Bihar poll roll revision

India Today

time35 minutes ago

  • India Today

Remove non-biological PM too: Trinamool MP's taunt amid Bihar poll roll revision

In a fresh broadside against the BJP over the revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, Trinamool Congress MP Kalyan Banerjee sarcastically demanded that the "non-biological" Prime Minister should be excluded from the list of eligible at an event in West Bengal's Hooghly district, Banerjee referenced PM Modi's past comments about being 'sent by God,' a remark that has since been used by several opposition leaders to mock the Prime PM Modi is non-biological and he is born spiritually as like Goddesses Kali, Durga and Lord Ram, then PM Modi is also not the Citizen of India. So his name should also be removed from the voter list,' Banerjee jibed. His taunt stems from a 2024 interview in which PM Modi said, 'Until my mother was alive, I used to think I was born biologically. After her demise, when I look at my experiences, I am convinced that I was sent by God... I'm nothing but an instrument that God has sent.'Kalyan Banerjee's remarks came amid an escalating row over the SIR process in Bihar, which opposition parties have slammed as an attempt to disenfranchise voters ahead of the assembly elections later this year. The first week of Parliament's Monsoon session was a washout due to repeated disruptions over the issue, as the Opposition demanding an immediate halt to the supremo and West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has also opposed the revision drive, calling it 'nothing short of a scam.' Echoing her, Kalyan Banerjee alleged that the SIR was designed to help the BJP manipulate the electoral process.'Earlier, the voters used to decide the government of the country... Now the government of the country is deciding who can vote or not. No one's name will be in the voter list except BJP or BJP people... Election Commission is also the same,' Banerjee senior Trinamool leader questioned the logic of house-to-house verification being undertaken as part of the SIR.'What is the point of going from house to house and checking the voter list... If I don't stay in my house at that time, then my name will be removed from the voter list. How does that make any sense?' he parties in Bihar have claimed that crores of eligible voters, especially minorities and the marginalised, could be struck off the rolls due to a lack of required documentation. They have accused the BJP of using state machinery to target voters who are likely to support rival BJP has defended the SIR as a standard administrative exercise aimed at cleaning up voter rolls. However, the timing and scale of the revision have triggered political pushback just months ahead of the Bihar elections.- EndsTune InMust Watch

Monsoon Session of Parliament: No more toolkit, just suitkit!
Monsoon Session of Parliament: No more toolkit, just suitkit!

Time of India

time38 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Monsoon Session of Parliament: No more toolkit, just suitkit!

Just before the beginning of Parliament 's monsoon session, the all-weather babbler at the Oval Office claimed downing of five fighter jets during the recent India-Pakistan conflict . And in the evening of the session's first day, Indians were jolted by Jagdeep Dhankhar 's abrupt resignation as Vice President. In both cases the government decided to move on by either ignoring the remark or swiftly starting the process of electing a new Vice President. But the most interesting part was the absence of noise over 'toolkit'. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Finance Operations Management Project Management CXO Degree Product Management Public Policy MCA Management Leadership Data Science Cybersecurity Healthcare Design Thinking healthcare others Data Analytics PGDM Digital Marketing Artificial Intelligence Technology Others MBA Data Science Skills you'll gain: Duration: 7 Months S P Jain Institute of Management and Research CERT-SPJIMR Fintech & Blockchain India Starts on undefined Get Details Skills you'll gain: Duration: 9 Months IIM Calcutta SEPO - IIMC CFO India Starts on undefined Get Details Any avid observer must be wondering which toolkit caused 'downing of jet' comment and which software speeded up the resignation process. Several theories and queries related to these events, after floating in the troposphere, may soon enter the exosphere, giving much relief to the governing apparatus. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This might be relevant for you Undo Toolkit gained so much traction in recent times, especially during Parliament sessions , that it had turned into a real political hot potato. But its out-and-out absence in this session is as astounding as the freezing moment captured by Coldplay's 'kiss cam'. Maybe, a toolkit can be better termed a suitkit - do it as and when it suits you. Who knows that better than lawyers. At one moment legal eagles can be seen arguing in blackbuck cases, and at other they can suit up as constitutional experts. Live Events Whether the timing of the two unrelated incidents was just a coincidence or was there something more to it? The answer will continue to be speculative, at least for some time to come. But it's certain that this time the tools were so tightly fitted in a kit that they failed to slip out, fall and create a clattering screech.

India proved terror has no safe haven: PM Modi
India proved terror has no safe haven: PM Modi

Time of India

time41 minutes ago

  • Time of India

India proved terror has no safe haven: PM Modi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi asserted that Operation Sindoor demonstrated India's response to threats against its sovereignty, fostering a new sense of self-assurance nationwide. He highlighted that the operation sent a clear message that enemies and terrorists targeting India would find no refuge. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday said Operation Sindoor showed the world the way India would respond if its sovereignty was attacked and that the cross-border military offensive has created a new self-confidence across the Sindoor also proved that for enemies and terrorists targeting India, there is no safe haven, Modi said in his address at an event here to honour the Chola emperor Rajendra Chola Modi emphasised that the cultural unity practised by the Chola rulers of the South is being carried forward by his government at the Centre as he referred to the Kashi-Tamil Sangamam , Saurashtra Tamil Sangamam and the installation of the Sengol in the Parliament Prime Minister visited the Gangaikonda Cholapuram temple and addressed the Aadi Thiruvathirai festival in who is also the Lok Sabha MP from Varanasi, underlined the connection between Kashi and the South with reverence for the Ganga river as a binding factor.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store