Shangri-La Dialogue 2025: Did China really take a back seat by not sending its defence minister?
Major General Hu Gangfeng (C), Vice President of National Defense University of Chinese People's Liberation Army attends the Shangri-La Dialogue Summit in Singapore on May 31, 2025. (Photo by MOHD RASFAN / AFP) AFP
Shangri-La Dialogue 2025 Did China take a back seat by not having its defence minister attend top security meet?
SINGAPORE - Almost everyone was talking about China at the Shangri-La Dialogue this weekend. The main question: Why did Beijing opt not to send its defence minister?
For the large part of the three-day security forum held at the Shangri-La Hotel in Singapore, China was not around to push back against the criticisms levied against it. But it appears that this was a calculated loss that Beijing is prepared to accept.
US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth mentioned China about 20 times in his speech on May 31, as he urged other countries in the Indo-Pacific to increase their defence expenditure, buy more American arms and buffer themselves against the 'threat' posed by China.
French President Emmanuel Macron on May 30 invited the security policymakers and military chiefs attending the forum to think of Russia's aggression in Ukraine as what China might do to Taiwan or the Philippines.
The role of the Chinese defence minister is to conduct defence diplomacy and explain China's security positions to other countries. Had he been at this weekend's top security gathering in Singapore, Beijing would have had the podium for over an hour to respond to Washington and address the concerns raised by other delegates.
Not this year. For the first time since 2019, China's defence minister did not attend. This meant the platform set aside for China had to be downsized accordingly.
Its delegation chief – a military scholar with the rank of a one-star general – spoke in a smaller room to a smaller audience for a shorter time than the minister would have had. He was one of five panellists at one of the three concurrent sessions at the end of the day on May 31.
As the vice-president of the People's Liberation Army National Defence University, Rear-Admiral Hu Gangfeng is not involved in combat operations or policymaking.
He gave a brief response to Mr Hegseth's speech, dismissing his criticisms as 'unfounded accusations' and going against the spirit of the forum, to reduce and not magnify differences.
The Chinese embassy in Singapore, which belongs to the ministry of foreign affairs and usually remains backstage at the defence ministry-driven Shangri-La Dialogue, made the unusual move of posting a response to Mr Hegseth's speech on its Facebook page, describing it as 'steeped in provocations and instigation' and a relentless hyping of the China threat.
But China's overall response to its critics at the forum this year was markedly low-key compared with the year before.
In 2024, the Chinese defence ministry officials briefed reporters hours after then US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin gave his speech; Minister Dong Jun held court at a plenary session the next day; and just before the forum ended, four or five military experts stood in different corners of a hotel room to answer journalists' questions almost in a speed-dating format.
Did China shoot itself in the foot by ceding the space at the annual forum for the US to run with its narrative of rallying allies and partners in the region against Beijing?
Not necessarily.
A Chinese security expert explained that while the delivery style may differ, whoever represents China at the forum is expected to deliver the same talking points that have been pre-cleared by the senior leadership, at the apex of which is President Xi Jinping, the de facto commander-in-chief. He declined to be named as he was not cleared to speak to the media.
Rear-Adm Hu alluded to this on May 31 when pressed to explain the absence of the defence minister: 'Objectively speaking, I'm the appointed person today to convey our thinking and exchange views with you all. I suppose you would've heard clearly our true thinking.'
He argued that China's representation at the forum changes over the years, and this variance should be seen as a 'perfectly normal work arrangement that does not impact the actual efficacy of our sharing of defence policy thinking'.
But this does not mean that China has given up on the Shangri-La Dialogue and will never send its defence minister again. Rear-Adm Hu reaffirmed that China still values and sees the forum as a 'very good platform to engage and discuss with all parties about regional cooperation in Asia-Pacific'.
This raises the question – if so, why didn't Beijing send its top defence diplomat here?
Observers have proffered a number of theories for Admiral Dong's no-show. A likely explanation is that since the leaders of China and the US have not talked and decided at the highest level on how to manage the bilateral relations, which are fractious across trade, politics and security, there is not much that their defence ministers can meet and talk about, in practical terms.
Having bilateral meetings on the sidelines of the forum in the third-party ground of Singapore is the other main purpose of being here, besides to speak at the forum.
For example, when Adm Dong attended the forum in 2024 for the first time as defence minister, his bilateral meetings with the then Defence Secretary was crucial for a reset of China-US military ties, which had stalled after then US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi angered China by visiting Taiwan in 2022.
Given the uncertainty and unpredictability of bilateral ties, China may have opted for a conservative, wait-and-see approach this year by sending a lower-level representation.
Another supplementary consideration is: While Adm Dong appeared to have been in the clear after reportedly being questioned for corruption last year, rumours of other generals being investigated for corruption continue to surface .
The absence of high-level military officials would forestall awkward questions, even in casual conversation .
As with many things related to the Communist Party of China, the full picture may never emerge. Two scholars in the official Chinese delegation confessed to The Straits Times that they simply did not know the reason Adm Dong did not attend this year's forum.
For this year, Mr Hegseth gets the spotlight all to himself.
Yew Lun Tian is a senior foreign correspondent who covers China for The Straits Times.
Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Taiwan warns of rise in Chinese military activity around region
Tensions have steadily risen since President Lai Ching-te took office in May 2024. PHOTO: AFP TAIPEI – Taiwan said China escalated military pressure around the region in May, deploying dozens of warships and government vessels daily in what it described as an extreme pressure campaign. China sent an average of 50 to 70 vessels per day across the first island chain – a key strategic arc stretching from Japan through Taiwan and the Philippines – between May 1 and 27, said a senior Taiwanese security official, who asked not to be identified, citing government protocol. The official, who spoke at a briefing on May 29, called it a record high for May, though did not provide comparable figures from last year. A document shared at the briefing showed the scale and range of the deployments stretching from the Yellow Sea to the East and South China Seas. Tensions have steadily risen since President Lai Ching-te took office in May 2024. Beijing, which views the democratic island as part of its territory, has called Mr Lai a separatist and carried out at least seven sets of military drills around the island since his inauguration, a pace not seen in previous years. US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth on May 31 urged partners in Asia to raise defense spending toward 5 per cent of gross domestic product, warning that more urgency is needed to prepare for a potential Chinese invasion of Taiwan. Chinese activity peaked around May 27, when more than 70 vessels – mostly naval – were observed operating in the region, according to the Taipei official. Two aircraft carriers, the Shandong and Liaoning, took part in the activities in May, with the Liaoning conducting takeoff and landing drills for warplanes in the East China Sea for the first time, the official said. Chinese patrols also appeared to press closer to Taiwan's 24-nautical mile boundary during joint combat exercises, which the Taipei official said go far beyond Beijing's defence needs. Separate data from Taiwan's Defence Ministry shows around 254 Chinese warships and government vessels were spotted around the archipelago over May 1-27, averaging nine a day, according to Bloomberg calculations. That's slightly up from an average of seven a day in 2024, the data shows. Bloomberg Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Great hex-pectations: Shamans divided on South Korea's political destiny
INCHEON - The outcome of the upcoming presidential elections in South Korea may still be unknown, but shaman Yang Su-bong told AFP the winner came to her in visions years ago. South Koreans go to the polls on June 3 to choose their next president, a snap vote triggered by ex-leader Yoon Suk Yeol's disastrous declaration of martial law in December 2024. And for Ms Yang, a traditional Korean 'mudang', it's clear that liberal frontrunner Lee Jae-myung will emerge victorious – a prediction that chimes with all major opinion polls that put Mr Lee well ahead in the presidential race. The latest Gallup survey show 49 per cent of respondents viewing Mr Lee as the best candidate, while Mr Kim Moon-soo, from the conservative People Power Party (PPP) was trailing on 35 per cent . 'From the beginning, I've seen Lee Jae-myung becoming president,' Ms Yang told AFP at her office in the western port city of Incheon. 'I saw a presidential aura,' she explained, adding that she faced 'criticism and even threats' for her prediction. 'But I can't lie about what I see.' Shamanism has shaped culture and belief on the Korean peninsula for centuries. South Koreans still regularly turn to them for advice on everything from their love lives to important business decisions and cities, and the registrar of the country's largest shamanic organisation lists 300,000 practising in the country. But the folk religion has also come under the spotlight for all the wrong reasons – two presidential impeachments have been linked to undue influence allegedly wielded by shamans. Former President Park Geun-hye was removed from office in 2017 in an influence-peddling scandal involving claims of, among other things, participation in shamanistic rituals. Ousted ex-leader Mr Yoon and his first lady Kim Keon Hee have also been accused of turning to sketchy shamans when making decisions – including, it is alleged, the fateful martial declaration. 'Intense emotions' Claims like that provoke an 'intense emotional reaction' in South Korean society – in part because the country's history is full of leaders led astray by unscrupulous spiritual advisors, Dr Lee Won-jae, a sociologist at South Korea's KAIST university, told AFP. 'When it comes to dramatising politics, there's nothing quite as effective as invoking shamanistic themes,' he said. 'Mudang' or shaman act as intermediaries between the world of spirits and everyday life. Their elaborate 'gut' ceremonies can be hours-long affairs, with cacophonic music, singing and prayers used to ward off evil spirits or hope for a good harvest. Hit thrillers like last year's 'Exhuma' – which features a group of shamans fighting an ancient evil spirit – have piqued public interest. And some shamans now even turn to social media to ply their craft, livestreaming on YouTube and offering advice over video calls. Shaman Lee Dong-hyeon, who goes by Ohbangdoryeong – 'guardian of the five directions' – says he was approached by local politicians after predicting Yoon's untimely fall three years ago. 'To become a truly great person, you must learn to carry burdens,' he told AFP. Mr Yoon 'lacks that destiny', he said. And 'despite his age, he lacks judgement', he said. 'Truth can be uncomfortable' Ohbangdoryeong engages in 'sword rituals' – licking the sharp blade of a knife in a bid to receive messages from deities. He isn't so sure that frontrunner Mr Lee will help end South Korea's political turmoil. 'Things will stabilise for two years, but then there will be bloodshed – political purges,' he darkly predicted. Fellow shaman Hong Myeong-hui agreed that turbulent times could be ahead. She said conservative contender Mr Kim Moon-soo has a 'quiet fire' in him. But liberal Mr Lee's 'energy is fast and consuming, like a wildfire in spring', she said. 'His term will be stormy,' Ms Hong said. 'Prophecy isn't for pleasing people – it's for truth. And truth can be uncomfortable.' No matter if the predictions ring true, what is clear that the new president will have to helm South Korea through a period of economic turbulence, as the trade-dependent nation will be facing steep tariffs from the United States while struggling with sluggish demand at home. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
TV graphics put fun into South Korean election count
Seoul - Two candidates vying to be president vigorously plunge a toilet, kick a football, then pop open a soda – it can only be South Korean election night, where whacky graphics strive to make vote-counting fun. 'Harry Potter', 'Squid Game', a rigorous spinning class... no reference is too small or too bizarre to be mined by broadcaster SBS for outlandish CGI-animated graphics to attract viewers – and, the journalists behind it say, make politics more accessible and engaging. Thanks to a dozens-strong specialist team at SBS, the dry work of tallying millions of ballots on the evening of June 3, after South Koreans vote for their next leader, will be transformed into an Olympic-level spectacle. 'The pressure is on,' SBS broadcast journalist Son Hyoung-an, who has been working on the election graphics team since before the poll was announced, told AFP. 'Everyone is asking us what we will do next, and they are excited to see what we'll bring to the table,' said Son. The tradition began around a decade ago, when South Korean networks noticed they could get more eyeballs on election night by leaning into the country's strong K-pop and K-drama tradition, and by trying to make politics fun and entertaining. It started with simple 2D visuals – the most striking of which showed candidates walking up a building horizontally – but, with an enthusiastic response, it has grown in scale and scope. Now, most Korean networks run sophisticated animated sequences that show the candidates' faces and body movements – with their permission – using actors to create the movements, then splicing the real faces on top. Snap election The 2025 poll posed a particular challenge, as it is a snap election after ex-president Yoon Suk Yeol was impeached and stripped of office over his abortive martial law declaration, meaning that SBS's election team had hardly any time to prepare. 'We need to do five months worth of work in a matter of weeks,' Son told AFP, adding that convincing the super-busy candidates to spare them a few minutes to film their faces for the graphics was tough. The front runner, liberal Lee Jae-myung, ran in 2022 and lost to Yoon by the narrowest margin in the country's history – meaning SBS already had footage of him from their previous coverage. The challenge was with Mr Kim Moon-soo, the conservative former labour minister and ruling People Power Party nominee – but his team said he was too busy and kept rejecting the election graphics team requests. Eventually, they secured three minutes with him in front of a green screen. Then they just had to come up with the graphics. One of the themes is 'Squid Game', with the animations showing Lee and Mr Kim competing in classic childhood games from the hit Netflix series, from 'red light, green light' to 'ddakji'. 'Even the smallest ideas are welcome,' SBS journalist Kim Deok-hyun, told AFP. 'We gather personal memories, joyful moments - anything the team finds entertaining – without filtering or holding back.' One team member had a particularly good spinning class and suggested it could work for election night. In the graphic, both candidates' heads bob furiously as they ride indoor bicycles, their vote share rising with each pedal stroke. For voters frustrated by the country's political turmoil, another sequence features a sound effect known in Korean as 'bbeong' – the noise a fizzy drink makes when opened, or the thwack of a football, or the gurgle when a toilet is unclogged. Rap battle SBS is particularly well-known for its election graphics, but all South Korean networks do it – with one rival channel going viral last year for a rap battle between candidates. 'It does make you wonder, can we go this far with people who might become the president?' said Mr Kim. But the journalists behind SBS's offerings say that the purpose of the graphics is to create a 'flow' to engage viewers and keep them hooked on the democratic process. Early in the day while voting is underway, coverage is more restrained, but once exit polls are out 'we'll roll out fast-paced, high-energy items, with rapid-fire summaries to help viewers follow the evolving picture', said Kim. 'We want people to look forward to our election night coverage, the way they anticipate a new film, thinking, 'I can't wait to see what they do this time'.' Experts agree that graphics can help keep viewers – and voters – engaged. 'Eye-catching graphics could be valuable, if they serve to draw attention not just to visuals but to substantive content that helps elevate the political discourse in our country,' Prof Kim Seo-joong of Sungkonghoe University said. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
