Critic calls out border bill's proposed new cabinet powers on immigration
OTTAWA — An NDP critic says a provision in the federal government's border security bill that would give cabinet the power to cancel immigration documents looks like an attempt to 'mimic' measures deployed by the Trump administration in the U.S.
'It seems to me … this piece of legislation is Canada's attempt to mimic some of those measures that the United States is adopting. I actually never thought that this day would come where Canada would go down that road,' B.C. NDP MP Jenny Kwan told The Canadian Press.
'However, it is here, and meanwhile the government is saying, 'Don't worry, trust us.''
Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree said that the immigration minister would only be able to exercise the power to cancel, suspend or alter immigration documents in an 'emergency' and after being granted the authority through an order-in-council.
'The tools are in place to ensure the minister of immigration has additional tools to ensure that in a modern era, for example, whether it's a pandemic or issues around cybersecurity, she will have the tools to make those decisions,' Anandasangaree said during debate on the bill Thursday.
Bloc Québécois MP Claude DeBellefeuille said that her party plans to support the bill at second reading so it can be studied by the public safety committee.
Speaking in French, she said the bill needs to be examined closely because it looks to give new powers to government ministers, law enforcement and even Canada Post.
Immigration Minister Lena Diab said Wednesday the legislation is designed to address 'one-off' situations like a pandemic or some other 'exceptional circumstance.'
'I think people, Canadians should feel safe that we are putting in all these safeguards, but again, as I said, it's all part of protecting our country and protecting our system that we value and protecting people that come here because we want to ensure that they are successful as well,' Diab said.
Bill C-2 also proposes giving the immigration minister the power to pause the acceptance of new immigration applications and cancel or pause processing of the current inventory of applications in the event of an emergency.
Julia Sande, a human rights lawyer with Amnesty International Canada, said immigration applicants could lose a lot of money because the legislation doesn't oblige the government to refund affected people.
'People give up their entire lives, in some cases, their life savings or their family's life savings. People go into debt just to be able to come here,' she said. 'And so to have the government be able to pull the rug out from under wide groups of people is concerning.'
Kwan said the proposed new powers are problematic because cabinet decisions are made in secret and there's no firm definition of an 'emergency' in the legislation.
'I don't accept that the Liberals say, 'Don't worry, we're the good guys, so trust us.' I'm sorry, that is just not acceptable,' she said, adding there's no way to know what a future government might do with this power.
The text of the legislation says that if the minister 'is of the opinion that it is in the public interest to do so,' they may trigger the power to cancel, suspend or alter immigration documents through a cabinet order.
'They're saying in an emergency, but that's not what's written. They said if they're in the opinion that it's in the public interest … that could really be anything,' Sande said.
'In the fall, we saw migrants and refugees being scapegoated for the housing crisis. And so, you know, what's in the public interest?'
Last year, then-immigration minister Marc Miller said plans to reduce the number of permanent and temporary visas issued would help stabilize the housing market.
U.S. President Donald Trump has used national security as justification for a host of immigration measures that involve detaining and deporting people, including university students who have condemned the war in Gaza.
Sande said the proposed bill 'attacks' the right to seek asylum by making it harder for migrants to make a claim if they are entering Canada from the U.S., or have been in the country for more than a year.
'They're talking about fentanyl, they're talking about guns and then all of a sudden they're attacking the right to asylum,' Sande said.
'They are completely different things and it's difficult for civil society, for experts to respond when there's so many things going on.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 5, 2025.
David Baxter, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
25 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
In their search for a missing Norwegian hiker, First Nations have shown the meaning of community
There's a lesson in basic humanity and cultural understanding happening in real time right now, along the southern shores of Kitchi Weeneebayko, or Hudson Bay, as the search continues for a young Norwegian hiker. On Aug. 14, 29-year-old Steffen Skjottelvik went missing somewhere between Fort Severn First Nation in Ontario and York Factory in Northern Manitoba along the banks of the Hayes River. It's an area known for its fast-moving waters: tides that can move in quickly, and currents strong enough that they can swiftly push you down and pull you under. Mr. Skjottelvik was on a journey with his two dogs, with his planned path taking him from James Bay to Alaska. He originally started his adventure in Moose Cree First Nation, along the James Bay coast, and he has made many friends along the way. Many have posted on social media about Mr. Skjottelvik's kindness, and of how he also lived for a time in Weenusk First Nation. Now, this is not a journey that anyone would recommend doing solo. He may be an experienced wilderness traveller, but it is dangerous to walk along the shores of the great inland sea, which is home to hungry polar bears and where a wrong step can lead to serious injury. But sometimes young people are called by adventure and a belief they can do anything. For Mr. Skjottelvik's sake, I hope that's still true. On Friday, one of Mr. Skjottelvik's dogs showed up at York Factory, Man. And while the RCMP said that the other dog may have been killed in a wolf attack, locals on Facebook – which remains a major communications tool for First Nations communities – posted an image of a husky matching its description in Fort Severn, Ont., about 300 kilometres away. What's remarkable is how quickly First Nations communities leapt into action to search for Mr. Skjottelvik. Fort Severn First Nation Chief Matthew Kakekaspan got a helicopter up and running along the route on Sunday, agreeing to pay the high costs of renting and fuelling a helicopter to look for the hiker, who's been nicknamed Norway Man by locals on Facebook. Fort Albany First Nation joined in the effort and donated fuel for the aerial search, and many Ininiw, Ililiw and Anisininew community members have donated out of their own pockets. The costs were ultimately untenable, however, and Fort Severn First Nation's efforts were paused on Tuesday – but now, locals are taking on the search themselves, with a helicopter back in the air thanks to donations that are still coming in. Pages of handwritten names thanking the people who have helped are being shared on Facebook. According to the CBC, the RCMP have looked for Mr. Skjottelvik, with one officer stationed in the York Factory area. They have also deployed a drone and have searched by boat. Angus Miles, who is Mr. Skjottelvik's main point of contact, last heard from the Norwegian last Thursday in the early afternoon, when he said that he was about a six-hour walk outside of York Factory. Mr. Miles tried messaging him again at 9 p.m. that night to get an update on his location; he never got a response. Mr. Miles told me on Wednesday that so far, the Canadian government has yet to assist them. 'I don't know what to think anymore, this is exhausting,' Mr. Miles wrote on Facebook. 'I can't imagine what the parents are going through right now being so far away in another country, the bureaucracy behind this I find has been such BS, it's a human life! I don't care where he's from, he reached out to me for this leg of his journey. There was no talking him out of it, so all I could do was support him as best as I could after he said I'd be his main contact.' To be clear, this region is the same one where Prime Minister Mark Carney's government is hoping to fast-track major projects such as deep-sea ports, to ship out the precious minerals that companies hope to dig up from deep in the Earth. But if nothing else, the search for Norway Man speaks to the community spirit of pulling together among First Nations people – and to the inherent sovereignty they have over the land. It doesn't matter where you're from or who you are: your life matters. When I reached Mr. Miles, he was swamped with calls. He told me they were on their way back to York Factory and there was still no word from Canada. 'Donations are coming in from other communities – individuals,' he said. Because that is what one does when someone is in need – you come together and help – and ask questions later.
CTV News
35 minutes ago
- CTV News
Camping trip turns into cat rescue mission
Vancouver Watch A camping trip to a remote Vancouver Island beach for a married couple from Victoria turned into a rescue mission to save a house cat.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Calgary bus driver assaulted
Calgary Watch Calgary police say three youths—one 13-year-old and two 11-year-olds—were involved in an assault against a city bus driver.
