Did US strikes wipe out Iran's nuclear facilities? Chinese military experts sceptical
Chinese defence experts expressed scepticism about US President Donald Trump's claim that air strikes had
'obliterated' Iran's biggest nuclear facilities , following reports that core components of Tehran's nuclear assets remained intact.
CNN reported on Tuesday that an assessment by the Defence Intelligence Agency, the Pentagon's intelligence arm, was at odds with Trump's claim that Iran's enrichment sites – Fordow, Natanz, and Isfahan – were 'completely and totally obliterated'.
While the full extent of the damage and its implications for Iran's nuclear ambitions are still unclear, Chinese analysts agreed that the strikes were limited in effectiveness.
They cited factors including the gap between the depth of Iran's underground facilities and the penetration capabilities of the bombs used, and reports that Tehran might have removed enriched uranium ahead of the attacks.
Chinese military aviation expert Fu Qianshao noted that the US said its
'bunker buster' bomb was capable of penetrating 60 metres (197 feet) underground, but if the Iranian facilities were made of specially reinforced concrete, the effective depth would be far less.
'The Fordow facility is buried about 80 to 90 metres underground, so there was a gap there,' he added. 'In the end, the US likely didn't achieve the intended operational goal.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Trump, at Nato summit, defends US strikes on Iran nuclear facilities
US President Donald Trump rejected media reports that US air strikes only partly damaged Iran's nuclear facilities as 'fake news' on Wednesday, maintaining his claim that the targeted sites had been 'obliterated'. Speaking to reporters during the Nato summit in The Hague, Trump said that the US had carried out a 'massive' precision strike on Saturday against Iran's nuclear enrichment facilities. 'It was very, very successful. It was called obliteration. No other military on earth could've done it, and this incredible exercise of American strength has paved the way for peace, with a historic ceasefire agreement,' Trump said. Referring to the Israel-Iran conflict as a '12-day war', Trump said that his administration considers it 'over' and that the two nations would 'not go back at each other', assessing that the damage the US air strike inflicted on Iran was enough to believe that the 'war has ended'. 'Not only have we dealt decisively with the critical threat of Iran's nuclear programme … but we've also reassured the credibility of American deterrence, which is like no other. People at Nato have said this,' Trump said. He also dismissed reports that the air strikes did not impose significant constraints on Tehran's nuclear development programme.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
China-tied AI tools like DeepSeek face US federal ban over ‘threat' to national security
A bipartisan group of US lawmakers introduced a bill in both chambers of Congress to ban the federal use of China-linked artificial intelligence tools such as DeepSeek , writing the latest chapter in the tech rivalry between the world's top AI powers. Titled the 'No Adversarial AI Act', the proposed legislation aims to prohibit federal agencies from procuring or deploying AI technologies developed in China, Russia Iran and North Korea The bill was introduced in the House by US congressman John Moolenaar, a Michigan Republican who chairs the House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party , and Raja Krishnamoorthi of Illinois, the panel's senior Democrat. Rick Scott, a Florida Republican, and Gary Peters, a Michigan Democrat, introduced the companion legislation in the Senate. US congressman Raja Krishnamoorthi, an Illinois Democrat, is the ranking member of the special House committee focused on China. Photo: AP 'Artificial intelligence controlled by foreign adversaries poses a direct threat to our national security, our data and our government operations,' Krishnamoorthi said in a statement.
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
At ‘Summer Davos', Li Qiang vows China will be ‘mega-sized' consumption power
Premier Li Qiang has pledged that China will become a 'consumption powerhouse' capable of fuelling domestic and global growth, even as he acknowledged the country was grappling with a slump in cross-border investment and persistent trade tensions. Speaking at the World Economic Forum's annual meeting in Tianjin on Wednesday, Li reiterated Beijing's commitment to boosting demand in the world's second-largest economy and defending globalisation. 'This will make China a mega-sized consumption powerhouse, on top of being a manufacturing powerhouse,' Li said at the gathering, also known as Summer Davos. 'We are on track to become a high-income country supported by robust consumption upgrades,' he added. Beijing's pivot towards stimulating household spending has gained urgency amid a volatile trade war with the United States and rising global uncertainty. Consumer activity picked up in May, helping offset pressure on manufacturing and exports in a challenging tariff environment. Retail sales rose by 6.4 per cent year on year, compared to 5.1 per cent in April.
