Is France moving towards a ban on cruise ships?
Announcing the ban which comes into effect in July 2025, mayor Christian Estrosi noted concerns about environmental factors and over-tourism, saying that the city in 2024 had 160,000 cruise tourists come ashore, and by 2026, that would rise to 300,000.
He added that smaller ships would still be welcome, saying: "Pleasure boating, yes, floating buildings, no."
With over 5,500km of coastline, France is a popular destination for cruise ships (paquebots or bateaux de croisière in French), but there are increasing concerns about this method of tourism.
The French government tourism agency, Atout France, estimated that mainland France saw more than 3.8 million cruise passengers pass through in 2023, an increase of 13 percent compared to 2019 (pre-Covid). They found that most passengers were German, American or British.
The vast majority of passengers (three million) went to Mediterranean ports. The other 704,500 went to the Atlantic coast, which has been growing in popularity in recent years - more than doubling since 2014.
France's overseas territories - especially the Caribbean islands of Gaudeloupe and Martinique - also see a lot of cruise tourists, but the above data refers only to mainland France, aka l'hexagone.
Which cities get the most cruise traffic?
Marseille stands out amongst French cities. In its 2023 report, the city noted 626 stopovers, with over 2.5 million cruise tourists in total.
It is followed by Ajaccio in Corsica, Cannes, Nice and Villefranche-sur-Mer (which is just outside of Nice), according to a French government report.
Smaller ports along the French riviera are also hot-spots, such as St Tropez, Menton, and La Ciotat.
Map of cruise destinations in France in 2023 (Credit: Atout France)
As mentioned above, the Atlantic coast is less of a cruise destination than the French Riviera, but cruise companies have increased efforts to target south-western France, with a growing number of cruises headed for Bordeaux and La Rochelle.
In 2023 Bordeaux reportedly welcomed 60 cruise ships, compared with 43 in 2019.
Meanwhile, Brittany and Normandy in north-western France also are home to several cruise ports, from La Havre to smaller locations like Douarnenez in Finistère. Cross-Channel traffic is not included in cruise figures.
The global cruise ship industry expects numbers to keep rising, with estimates that they will see 10.7 percent more passengers in 2028 than in 2023.
How much money do they bring into France?
Overall, research is mixed as to the true impact cruise ships have on local economies, in contrast to typical land tourism. Critics point to the money that local governments spend to accommodate ships, as well as the fact that many available statistics about local economic impact are produced by cruise companies themselves.
Cruise ships often follow an 'all-inclusive' model, offering passengers everything they need on board, from bars and restaurants to activities - and therefore reducing the incentive to spend in local bars, cafés and restaurants.
A 2024 study found that factors like length of the visit to the city (from just a few hours to overnight stays), as well as its tourism offerings and the age of passengers, play a role in whether or not passengers will disembark and spend money in the local economy.
In France, the spending depends on the city.
A study by geographer Victor Piganiol, showed that a cruise passenger "spends an average of €150 a day and up to €200 during a stopover" in Bordeaux, compared with an average of €89 in Le Havre and €80 in La Rochelle. This higher spending in Bordeaux is mostly explained by people purchasing wine.
"When they pass through Bordeaux, the cruise promotional brochures highlight the vineyards and their prestigious appellations", the researcher told AFP. Visits to nearby châteaux are often organised and included in the cruise package.
In Marseille, a separate study found that people who spent at least five hours in the city spent on average €57 for the day - compared to €132 per day for non-cruise passengers.
It also found that people who either started or ended their cruise journey in Marseille would spend €78 per day per person, with almost a third opting to spend a night in town before or after the cruise. In this case, they spent €171 a person, L'Echo Touristique reported.
In 2022, the Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA) estimated that cruise ships had a €3.5 billion "total GDP impact" on France, which included things like ship and capacity building, cruise line purchases, passenger spending and crew spending.
CLIA estimated that "cruise line employment (crew and head office employees) equated to 1,245 direct jobs, as well as 36,730 jobs created through direct and indirect effects.
Local response to cruises
Despite some evidence that cruise ships can stimulate local economies, many residents across French port towns have complained of over-tourism and negative environmental impacts from cruise ships.
Most recently, members of the environmental groups 'Stop croisières' and Extinction Rebellion in inflatable kayaks sought to block cruise ships from entering Marseille's port.
In 2022, over 44,000 people in Marseille signed a petition against pollution caused by cruise liners, and in March 2023, residents' associations in Marseille lodged a legal complaint over ocean traffic pollution in the port area, which regularly exceeded European Union limits.
Meanwhile, in 2023 the small port-town of Douarnenez in western France made international news when local residents banged on saucepans and chanted 'go home' to passengers of the 'World Traveller' cruise ship.
La Rochelle is planning to only allow 27 ships to stop over in 2025 - in contrast to 31 in 2024 and 37 in 2022 - and set a goal to halve emissions from cruise ships.
Meanwhile, in Bordeaux, the city council in August proposed that cruise ships no longer moor in the city centre, and instead move further along the right bank of the Garonne, in hopes of addressing aesthetic and environmental concerns.
The mayor Pierre Hurmic, from the Green Party told AFP: "More and more people in Bordeaux are being disturbed by the arrival of cruise ships in the city centre, and it's becoming increasingly unpleasant, adding that they resemble "actual floating buildings in some of the most aesthetically pleasing parts of the city".
Environmental impact
Cruise liners are known to be huge polluters - a 2019 study by the NGO Transport & Environment found that cruise ships were responsible for more pollution than all of Europe's automobiles combined.
As for the port of Marseille, France's top cruise stopover, it is one of the most polluted in Europe, according to a recent study.
This picture will hopefully improve after May 2025, when Mediterranean-wide rules will from the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) will require that cruise ships cut sulphur oxide emissions by 80 percent. It is estimated this will lead to an annual reduction of 8.5 million tons of emissions into the atmosphere, and protect marine life.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local France
8 hours ago
- Local France
14 Essential websites and apps for summer in France
Please note: links here are to the websites. You can download apps from your usual app store. Météo-France Knowing what the weather will be like is always useful - and France can do torrential showers and glorious sunshine in a single day - but the French national weather forecaster Météo France does more than a simple 10-day forecast. It's also updated regularly with the latest weather warnings, covering everything from high temperatures and heatwaves , to sudden and dramatic storms that can bring down trees and cause floods. France has some serious weather which can put lives at risk, so it's a good idea to be aware if a warning is issued. READ ALSO Explained: What does a red weather warning mean in France? You can check alert levels for each area via Météo-France, while anyone in France is advised to sign up for the FR-Alert system , which sends text messages in the case of emergency, including orders from local authorities to evacuate. Advertisement Soleilrisk Soleilrisk is an app developed by the French National Union of Dermatologists in conjunction with Météo-France that helps users get a glowing tan while avoiding risks thanks to daily UV index readings across the country. Alerts can be activated when the UV index is high, and users also have access to a directory of dermatologists. Everything you need for safe sunbathing…. Bathe safely Is it safe to take a dip in the sea?You'd like to think so, but you can be sure with the Infoplage app, which offers real-time information on the quality of the bathing water, weather conditions and the colour of the safety flags at beaches the length and breadth of the country. Feux de Forêt Linked to the weather, summer is wildfire season in France – when high temperatures, low rainfall (despite those sudden storms) and strong winds combine to heighten the fire risk. This is a particular problem in the warmer south of the country. Firefighters have already had to deal with numerous blazes – and some parts of the Mediterranean arc are on high alert for forest fires, which can cause (and have caused) widespread damage and travel disruption. READ ALSO Is France ready for a summer of increasingly severe wildfires? There is an app that allows anyone from any location to monitor forest fires in France, called 'Feux de Forêt' and is available for download on iPhones and Android. It sends alerts of any new fire outbreaks in your area. It could also be particularly useful for second-home owners, as you can also monitor ongoing fires from a distance by updating your notifications to decide which départements you would like to get alerts for. Bison Futé There are some days – particularly during the long summer holidays – when it's best simply to leave motorway travel to everyone else. There are days when it seems like the entire population of France is on one of the country's autoroutes or another, with a good chunk of northern Europeans also using France as a rat-run to southern Europe, and the sun. Advertisement Fortunately, the busy days are mostly predictable. Keep an eye on France's roads watchdog Bison Futé, which forecasts traffic levels on the country's main arterial routes, and signals trouble using a colour-coded map of France. Green is good. Red is not. Black is, basically, nationwide gridlock. And avoid, at all costs, the chasée-croisé . SNCF Connect There is no better way to see France than by train – this is just a fact. The SNCF Connect app allows you to book your rail travel, using any discount cards you may have, and provides real-time updates on train times, platform changes, or delays on the line. Michelin Route Planner This handy map app from the tyre manufacturer and food critic does everything other map apps do – and also estimates how much your planned journey will cost in fuel, time, and any tolls. The Fork Speaking of food, if you want to eat out, The Fork lists a huge selection of restaurants (around 40,000) in every one of France's main cities, with ratings, comments, photos and special offers. Advertisement The app is easy to use, and you can book a table via the app without having to speak a word of French. Pollen Index One for allergy sufferers. France has developed an early warning pollen forecast device, called the Atmo France Pollen Index. It's calculated and updated using real-time statistical data, pollen readings, weather forecasts and information from the Copernicus platform, which provides a three-day air quality and pollen count forecasts nationally, regionally, and right down to individual towns and villages. The website offers an interactive map of the country, which shows pollen levels using six different colours. You can even get information and pollen forecasts for the next couple of days at a commune level. Paris If you're visiting Paris there are a few specific apps and websites that you might find helpful Bonjour RATP / Ile de France Mobilités Two website / apps in one here, but both are indispensable for using public transport in and around Paris, and allow you to buy tickets on the app, without having to queue at ticket machines in the stations. They also offer real-time updates – handy in summer because of station closures – and a handy Metro route-planner. The Citymapper app is also for planning a journey in any of France's bigger cities. Advertisement Paris en Seine This summer, for the first time in more than 100 years, it's possible to swim in the River Seine, in three designated areas. You'll need to check the opening times in advance, and check the regularly updated map of water quality - the water is tested every day and if pollution levels are judged too high for safe swimming, the bathing spots will be closed. This can happen after heavy rain. La vasque If you were watching the Paris 2024 Olympics you might remember the spectacular hot air balloon rising over the city. Well, it's back this summer - the balloon is tethered in the Tuileries gardens and rises into the air each night at sunset. This site gives details of the rise time, as well as updated if the lift-off is cancelled due to bad weather. . . . and a couple of language options Google Translate Translation apps still aren't as good as knowing a language well enough to hold a conversation, but for the basics of day-to-day holiday living, they'll do just fine. With Google Translate, you can take a picture of a sign – or, say, a menu – on your phone and a translation will appear in your preferred language. The much-touted conversation feature – which is supposed to be able to automatically identify spoken language – is still very much a work in progress, by all accounts, but a little lateral thinking will get you by. British consumer watchdog Which? recently found it – and rival translation tool DeepL – were the most accurate of four big language apps tested (the others were Microsoft and Apple). DeepL, it said, was better on colloquial language you might encounter – but the sheer number of languages available on Google, and the fact it works offline, counts in the internet giant's favour. Both Google Translate and DeepL, it has to be said, are pretty good with French. Duolingo Conversations via translation app are one – slow and jarringly disjointed – thing, but nothing beats being able to hold a conversation with a local in their language. And if you don't mind being emotionally abused by an imaginary owl, then Duolingo will help you do that. We're not about to suggest Duolingo will get you from zero to fluent in a matter of weeks (if learning French was that easy, everyone would do it), but you'll gradually pick up more and more without referring to your translation app, or heading off in the wrong direction after listening to a blizzard of directions from a speed-talking Toulousain.
Le Figaro
13 hours ago
- Le Figaro
In Hong Kong, Madeleine Progin Keeps the Flame of French Literature Alive
Some 12,000 kilometers from Paris, the founder of the independent bookshop Parenthèses remains steadfast in her mission: keeping French literature alive in Hong Kong. One walks into the Parenthèses bookshop in the heart of Hong Kong as as one might enter a church — quietly. On the second floor of the Duke of Wellington House building, which is aristocratic in name only, this shrine to French-language literature stands in defiance of a world in constant acceleration. No stress, no pressure. Time can be savored like a priest reading his prayer book, far from the hustle and bustle of an overheated city where luxury and finance reign supreme. Madeline Progin, the high priestess of Parenthèses, settled in Hong Kong over forty years ago. Originally from a small village near Neuchâtel, Switzerland, the self-described 'country girl' followed her city-dwelling husband, Marc, to the ends of the earth, convinced that the whole adventure would only last a short time. Enchanted by this 'city where anything is possible,' the young woman decided to make a childhood dream come true there: to open her own bookshop. Publicité "There were no books at home, but I knew how to read before I went to school. My father was a farmer, and my mother worked a variety of odd jobs. I'd scour the village library, stealing books from girlfriends. Every Christmas, every birthday, I'd order books. They were my greatest gift," she recalls. When she arrived in Hong Kong, there was only a very modest French-speaking outlet on the fourth floor of the same building. It sold books, but also chocolate, champagne… Books that travel halfway around the world "Hong Kong was a city of entrepreneurs with incredible energy. People worked night and day, it was all very exciting," recalls this emblematic figure of the French-speaking community. At the age of 26, the young woman obtained assistance from the French Consulate and bought the business with her husband. A few years later, the Parenthèses bookshop was approved by the Centre national du livre (CNL) and became a 'benchmark French-language bookshop.' "We receive around 150 to 250 kg of books a week. Novels, biographies, fiction, poetry, but also comics, history, mathematics, cookery, language learning — 95% of our books come from France," confides the bookseller, as she sweeps a half-amused, half-despairing gaze over the walls of this discrete sanctuary where literature stacks up like a bastion against oblivion. 'Our mission is to remain eclectic, curious and inclusive of all genres' —Madeline Progin, founder of Parenthèses bookshop "Our customers are demanding — they want the latest releases, whether from Gallimard, Grasset, Le Seuil, or Picquier for Chinese translations. Our mission is to remain eclectic, curious and open to all genres. Books take about two weeks to reach us. Inevitably they're a little more expensive, but that's the price of passion, independence and a book chain that crosses half the globe," explains Progin with the energy of a fanatic. A large, brown leather club chair, studded, worn and crackled, sits at the entrance of the bookshop. It's here, for the past 30 years, that some of France's greatest writers have come to sit down for a signature, a meeting, a photo. Like Michel Houellebecq, over 10 years ago: 'It was quite something,' says Progin with a smile. "The day before, he had given a reading of his poems at Macumba, Hong Kong's only African bar. It was a bilingual reading, together with translator Sonia Au. He read in French, Au in Cantonese. In the room were expats, curious passersby, poetry lovers and, of course, Houellebecq fans. All hanging onto the writer's every word. Publicité Changing reading habits On the walls of the bookshop, customers can see the faces of Pierre Assouline, Philippe Claudel, Susie Morgenstern, Camille Laurens, Jean-Philippe Toussaint, Dany Laferrière, David Foenkinos, Andreï Kourkov, Chantal Thomas, Marie Darrieussecq, or that of Boualem Sansal, with his eternal adolescent look. Kamel Daoud was due to come in June, but declined the invitation following an international arrest warrant issued against him by Algeria. Today, those blessed days when authors paraded around to meet their public seem to be over, and the future of Parenthèses may be in jeopardy. "Since COVID, habits have changed. People no longer want to leave their homes, which explains the drop in attendance. Add to that the declining number of interested expats, competition from online platforms and the rise in operating costs — rent, salaries, transport, everything has gone up. We can no longer cover our costs," laments the bookseller, who has given herself until the end of the year to make a final decision. In a swansong-like sentiment addressed to the French-speaking community, Madeline Progin urges literature lovers to get out and buy their books from Parenthèses. 'Reading habits have also changed,' concludes Madeline Progin. "These days, we're afraid to venture into literature. We open a book. We leaf through it, skim it, no longer pay attention to the style, the characters, the twists and turns. People don't have the energy to get involved anymore, and that's a shame.' It's hard to say whether Parenthèses will make it through the winter. 'Reading is a friendship,' wrote Marcel Proust. In Hong Kong, this friendship still exists in French — but for how long?
LeMonde
a day ago
- LeMonde
Montmartre residents denounce the Paris neighborhood's 'Disneyfication'
From the public bench on Place Dalida, just behind the Sacré-Cœur Basilica, one can witness a peculiar spectacle at any time of day. Dozens of Spanish, Indian, Chinese and American tourists line up to pose next to the statue of the singer Dalida. Not just any pose: Each holds her breasts. The gesture is unusual and the faces are laughing, as stroking Dalida's chest is said to bring good luck in love. On Rue de l'Abreuvoir, the same lines of tourists form – this time, to snap a photo in front of La Maison Rose, a café featured in the American series Emily in Paris. Further down, on Rue des Trois-Frères, another queue blocks a narrow sidewalk: It's for the vintage photo booth, a social media sensation. Three places Emily forgot to visit in Paris The Carnavalet Museum Anyone who loves Paris should go here. Dedicated to the history of the capital, the beautiful building in the Marais reopened in 2021 after four and a half years of work. On the first floor, the collection of signs recalls the city's commercial vocation, long before the high-end brands Emily loved: Au griffon (furniture dealer), A la couronne d'or (innkeeper), and so on. In the garden, a tempting café would be an ideal setting for the series. 23, rue de Sévigné, Paris 3 e. Tuesday to Sunday, 10 am to 6 pm. Free admission for the permanent collections. The National Museum of the Middle Ages Not far from Emily's home, this institution reopened in 2022, after... eleven years of work. After the kiss given to Gabriel under the big clock at the Musée d'Orsay, the American could take her new darling, Alfie, there. We're pretty sure she'd love the hyper-stylized lady with the unicorn on her large six-panel tapestry. As for the frigidarium, it is a unique testimony to Gallo-Roman baths, even before the advent of the Middle Ages. Paris was then Lutetia. 28, rue du Sommerard, Paris 5 e. Tuesday through Sunday, 9:30 am to 6:15 pm. From €10 to €12. Bourse de commerce - Pinault Collection At Les Halles, the Bourse de Commerce has long remained closed to visitors. Since 2021, the billionaire François Pinault, owner of Gucci (Emily is wearing a Gucci bag), has been the tenant for fifty years. He exhibits part of his contemporary art collection there. Restored and transformed by the Japanese architect Tadao Ando, the site is also worth seeing for its spectacular glass dome, around which wraps the allegorical fresco of world trade created in the 19 th century by four different painters. 2, rue de Viarmes, Paris 1 er. Wednesday to Monday, 11 am to 7 pm. From €10 to €14. Welcome to photogenic Montmartre, with its hidden gardens, windmills, vineyard, funicular, street artists – and millions of visitors from around the globe. In this neighborhood where ice cream, crêpe and miniature Eiffel Tower vendors thrive, even the traffic seems orchestrated by Disneyland. Sidecars, 2CVs, Méharis and tuk-tuks crisscross the Butte for a few dozen euros per person, crossing paths with tourist trains – there are five in total. But in recent months, a fracture has appeared in this fairy-tale setting. In this neighborhood of 27,000 residents, banners have popped up in windows: "Residents forgotten!"; "Let Montmartre residents live"; "Behind these facades, there are people." School buildings display signs: "No to class closures!" Street signs announcing pedestrianization have been spray-painted with "Stop." In just a few months, overtourism in Montmartre has become a political issue, taken up by residents' associations, business owners and elected officials from across the political spectrum.
