Man pictured naked in his yard on Google Street View wins compensation
An appeals court in Argentina concluded the man's dignity had been flagrantly violated.
BUENOS AIRES - An Argentine captured naked in his yard by
a Google Street View camera has been awarded compensation by a court after his bare behind was splashed over the internet for all to see.
The policeman had sought payment from the internet giant for harm to his dignity, arguing he was behind a 2m-high wall when a Google camera captured him in the buff, from behind, in a small-town in Argentina in 2017.
His house number and street name were also laid bare, broadcast on Argentine TV covering the story, and shared widely on social media.
The man claimed the invasion exposed him to ridicule at work and among his neighbours.
Another court in 2024 dismissed the man's claim for damages, ruling he only had himself to blame for 'walking around in inappropriate conditions in the garden of his home.'
Google, for its part, claimed the perimeter wall was not high enough.
Appeals judges, however, concluded the man's dignity had been flagrantly violated, and awarded him an amount in Argentine pesos equivalent to about US$12,500 (S$16,000), payable by Google.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Asia 11 Thai civilians killed as Thai and Cambodian militaries clash at disputed border: Reports
Asia Singapore urges all parties in Thailand-Cambodia border dispute to exercise restraint
Asia Deadly Thai-Cambodian dispute puts Asean's relevance on the line
Life Hulk Hogan, who helped turn pro wrestling into a billion-dollar spectacle, dies at 71
Singapore Avoid water activities around Tuas Second Link, Raffles Marina after chemical tank accident: NEA
Singapore Khatib Camp to make way for housing, with its functions moving to Amoy Quee Camp
Singapore Mindef to set up new volunteer management unit to grow volunteer pool
Singapore Primary 1 registration: 29 schools to conduct ballot in Phase 2B
'This involves an image of a person that was not captured in a public space but within the confines of their home, behind a fence taller than the average-sized person. The invasion of privacy... is blatant,' they wrote.
The judges said 'there is no doubt that in this case there was an arbitrary intrusion into another's life.'
And they found there was 'no justification for (Google) to evade responsibility for this serious error that involved an intrusion into the plaintiff's house, within his private domain, undermining his dignity.
'No one wants to appear exposed to the world as the day they were born.'
The judges pointed to Google's policy of blurring the faces and licence plates of people and vehicles photographed for Street View as evidence it was aware of a duty to avoid harm to third parties.
But in this case, 'it was not his face that was visible but his entire naked body, an image that should also have been prevented.'
The court absolved co-accused telecoms company Cablevision SA and news site El Censor of liability for the image spreading, saying their actions had 'helped highlight the misstep committed by Google.' AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
40 minutes ago
- Straits Times
In Yosemite, falling tree branches kill a young hiker in ‘freak accident'
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox An autopsy had determined that Ms Angela Lin's death was accidental, resulting from blunt injuries. The trails of Tuolumne Grove, a popular site in Yosemite National Park, wind through forests of pine and giant sequoias, the largest trees on earth. On July 19, after hiking about a mile into the grove, Ms Angela Lin, 29, and her friends heard a snapping sound above them. 'Two to three seconds later, branches fell out of the sky,' Ms Lin's friend, Mr David Hua, told SFGate. 'One big branch struck Angela and then there were a bunch of smaller ones directly behind me.' Mr Hua said he closed his eyes as the branches crashed down. When he opened them, he saw Ms Lin on the ground, blood pooling around her head. He called 911 and performed cardiopulmonary resuscitation until a ranger took over. This week, the Tuolumne County Sheriff's Office released a statement about the incident, identifying Ms Lin and saying that an autopsy had determined that her death was accidental, resulting from blunt injuries. It said a ranger had responded at about 6pm that day after reports that a hiker had been fatally struck by 'falling portions of a tree'. The news has generated interest in the accident, a rare occurrence along a popular trail in one of the nation's busiest national parks. News reports have focused on the allure of venturing into the wilderness despite its potential risks. Falling branch deaths are uncommon but not unheard-of. Two campers died after a branch fell on their tent in Yosemite in 2015. Ms Angela Shih Lin was born in Los Angeles, but lived in Mountain View, California, according to a memorial notice. She worked at Google as a software engineer, according to her LinkedIn profile. The company said in a statement that it 'lost a loved and respected member of our team.' Mr Hua and Ms Lin's family did not respond to requests for comment. Mr Hua created a fundraiser in Ms Lin's name after she died to benefit public media in the San Francisco area. In it, he said Ms Lin 'cherished nature and the outdoors', including mountain hikes. He told SFGate that she was cautious when on hikes. 'She never goes off trails,' he said. 'So usually, when you hear about these incidents, someone is doing something dangerous, like playing in water or near a cliff or something.' He added: 'There's nothing we could have done to predict or prevent this.' Vehicle crashes, drownings and falls are the top three leading causes of unintentional deaths in US national parks, according to mortality data in a five-year period through 2019. Tuolumne Grove is known for its nearly 5km trails through majestic forests and for a tunnel carved through one of its giant trees. From the trailhead, hikers walk about a mile among ponderosa and sugar pines before reaching a mixed conifer forest with the soaring giant sequoias. Ms Elisabeth Barton, a founder of the Echo Adventure Cooperative, which gives tours in the park, said that when visitors asked her about dangers in the parks, she usually mentioned mountain lions, bears, waterfalls and rock slides. Falling branches from a sequoia, which can reach 97m tall with a single branch as big as 2.5m to 3m around, are not usually on her list. 'All of those trees are very, very big,' she said. 'It is a freak accident unfortunately.' Ms Barton was guiding a group on a popular 'hike and BBQ' tour on July 20, a day after Ms Lin died, when she discovered that law enforcement officials had blocked access to the trail. Ms Barton said she had never before been turned away from the grove. The perils of branches falling from above are part of trail lore. Ms Barton said she had a close call in 2009 on the Appalachian Trail when she woke up to find a tree had fallen less than 1m her tent. A trail acquaintance once narrowly missed a limb hitting his head, and has since been called 'Duck'. 'It really is a situation where we are entering the wilderness and anything can happen,' she said. 'It is another sign that the wilderness can be wild.' NYTIMES
Straits Times
40 minutes ago
- Straits Times
South Korean restaurant owner puts pet dog inside fridge to prevent animal from overheating
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox South Korean animal rights groups are taking a more reserved approach toward the case after the dog's health conditions were revealed. A photo of a small dog inside a fridge at a South Korean restaurant sparked disputes over possible animal abuse. The owner of the dog, however, claimed on July 31 that the measure was taken to prevent the extreme heat from exacerbating the animal's heart issues. The Busan Jungbu Police Station received a report of potential animal abuse at around 8.10pm on July 29 , saying a dog was being kept inside a glass door refrigerator at a local pizza restaurant. The police checked the site and said the temperature inside the fridge was 'not very low', and are investigating the case to see if the dog's owner had violated the Animal Protection Act. The dog's owner, a restaurant owner in her 60s, told local media outlets that she put the 11-year-old Maltese named Cookie inside the fridge to prevent her from overheating. She said Cookie has recently been treated for acute heart issues, and the vet had told her that extreme heat could be fatal to Cookie. 'The air conditioner at the restaurant broke down, so I put a cushion inside the refrigerator and had her (Cookie) sit on it for short periods of time,' the owner said. She said the dog was like her daughter, and apologised for putting the dog inside a fridge that also contains sauces for customers. Small dogs like the Maltese do tend to overheat due to their long, white hair, which traps heat easily and prevents it from dissipating effectively through perspiration. An excessively high body temperature could lead to heart strokes and other life-threatening medical conditions. Animal rights groups are taking a more reserved approach toward the case after Cookie's conditions have been revealed. 'As of now, (the owner's) explanation suggests that she had no intention of abusing the dog, although she would need to be careful about keeping her pet inside a refrigerator,' Mr Sim In-seop, the head of the local animal rights group Live in Freedom and Equality, was quoted as saying. Experts suggest cooling pads for dogs more susceptible to heat, rather than keeping them inside a refrigerator. THE KOREA HERALD/ASIA NEWS NETWORK
Straits Times
40 minutes ago
- Straits Times
3 men charged over living on the earnings of prostitution
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Desmond Yee, Angus Tan Chen Jie, and Chua Yi Hao were each handed one charge under the Women's Charter of living in part on the earnings of a woman's prostitution. SINGAPORE - Three men who allegedly facilitated the operation of an online vice syndicate have been hauled to court on Aug 1. In raids conducted against the syndicate on July 30, the police seized more than $610,000 worth of assets , including two luxury cars and 18 luxury watches. Desmond Yee, 45, Angus Tan Chen Jie, 30, and Chua Yi Hao, 36, were each handed one charge under the Women's Charter of living in part on the earnings of a woman's prostitution. The three Singaporean men allegedly did so between July 4 and 30. There was a gag order issued on the woman's identity. A police prosecutor asked for all three to be remanded at Central Police Division, with permission to take them out for investigations. Their cases will be heard again on Aug 8. If convicted, they could each be jailed for up to seven years and fined up to $100,000. They are among eight men and 20 women, aged between 21 and 61, who were arrested for their suspected involvement in vice-related offences. In a July 31 statement, the police said the raids on July 30 took place around Jalan Layang Layang in the Toh Tuck area, Pasir Panjang Road, Boon Lay Avenue, Craig Road in Tanjong Pagar, Jurong West Street 71, Beach Road, Tai Seng Avenue, Bencoolen Street, Kim Yam Road in River Valley, Onan Road, Orchard Road, and Jalan Kemaman off Balestier Road. Other items seized included cash, funds in bank accounts, two mobile phones, laptops and vice-related paraphernalia. Police investigations against the others arrested are ongoing.
