Two people allegedly involved in surveillance of 'spy' case man are named in court case
Retired private investigator, Mark Murran, otherwise known as Rock Investigations, was allegedly the driver of a car involved in following and surveilling Keith O'Brien, a former Dublin-based payroll manager with Rippling, a US-headquartered multibillion-dollar HR software provider, the court heard.
Cliona Woods of Dublin-based Gotham Services was allegedly involved in organising "discreet surveillance". Both were joined as defendants in Mr O'Brien's action over the matter.
Both "categorically refute" Mr O'Brien's allegations of intimidation and harassment and say the surveillance was discreet, their barrister John O'Regan told the court on Tuesday.
The case was back before Mr Justice Brian Cregan to deal with a number of applications in advance of the hearing of the case, including changing the defendants from "persons unknown" to the two named defendants.
Deel Inc
It was also back in to consider whether Deel Inc, the other US-based HR firm involved, should also be joined to the case. Deel allegedly paid Mr O'Brien, of Balrothery in north Dublin, to pass on Rippling's trade secrets to it, a claim it denies.
Imogen McGrath SC, for Mr O'Brien, said the defendants had consented to an order not to surveil Mr O'Brien pending determination of the proceedings.
Counsel said she was not making an application to join Deel as the purpose of the case was to resolve the dispute between her client and the defendants. There may also be a third defendant but her side needed time to write to that potential defendant, she said.
Counsel also said there was a significant dispute over whether the surveillance amounted to harassment which the defendants say it did not.
Mr Justice Cregan said he had been mulling over the issue and he was considering joining Deel at the motion of the court.
While this was against the wishes of the O'Brien side, he did it in the context of an earlier claim that the surveillance was an interference with the administration of justice as Mr O'Brien is a defendant and witness in separate proceedings being brought over the alleged spying affair by Rippling against Deel.
It was also in circumstances where Deel's lawyers had, in a pre-litigation letter in reply to Mr O'Brien's solicitor, said it had no knowledge of the particular alleged surveillance being carried out.
The judge said:
Now that letter is either a blatant lie or a misrepresentation.
He said the defendants were employed by Deel which meant it was directly implicated. Ms McGrath asked the court to first allow the parties (her client and Deel) to exchange pleadings in the normal way.
Paul Gardiner SC, for Deel, said he took "grave exception to what the court said".
He believed the court should not be pronouncing on a letter as misrepresentation until it had heard all the facts. His side had written that letter according to what it believed to be true at the time, he said.
If the plaintiff says it did not want Deel joined, it was not for the court to say it should, he said. His client had actually invited the O'Brien side to do so but it chose not to.
Counsel also pointed out that Mr O'Brien has entered into a co-operation agreement with Rippling, has agreed not to seek any reliefs against him in the separate Rippling/Deel case and has waived all claims against him.
The judge said he knew that joining a defendant to proceedings at the court's own motion was an exceptional jurisdiction but that was in the circumstances of the allegations of intimidation and a letter which appeared to be manifestly misleading.
He said he wanted to reflect on the matter and will decide at the end of the week whether to hear submissions from the parties on the issue.
He also said given that Mr Gardiner accepted the letter was incorrect, he did not see why counsel took "such umbrage at my interpretation". Ms McGrath said she thought Mr Gardiner "is making a mountain out of a very small molehill".
He continued the injunctions restraining surveillance of Mr O'Brien and requiring the defendants to preserve any evidence which may be used in the case. He would also hear an application on Friday by the defendants requiring Mr O'Brien to preserve evidence.
Read More
Case involving alleged spy now focusing on where payment to him came from
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
5 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Man, 25, settles €4.75m action after being struck by steel jack at road works
A 25-year old man who suffered a traumatic brain injury when it was claimed he was struck by a steel jack which was dislodged when a car drove by road works has settled a High Court action for €4.75 million. Karam Ali, his counsel Edward Walsh SC, instructed by Connellan Solicitors, told the High Court, was a general operative and was working laying ducts on Shantalla Road, Galway city, when the accident happened five years ago. Counsel said a car struck a steel jack which then collided with Mr Ali. Liability, counsel said, was conceded last year and the case was before the court for assessment of damages only. The settlement was reached after mediation. He said Mr Ali suffered an acquired brain injury and now has difficulty with concentration and excess fatigue and other issues. He had been in this country for eight months when the accident happened. Karam Ali, 25, with an address in Bradford, England, had sued car driver Mohamed El Helali of Barnacranny, Bushy Park, Galway, as a result of the accident on May 1, 2020. It was claimed that the car suddenly and without warning struck a steel jack which in turn hit Mr Ali and he suffered catastrophic injuries. Mr Ali was wearing a safety helmet which it was claimed was knocked off in the accident. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week It was claimed there was a failure to appreciate the presence of Mr Ali on the roadway and a failure to appreciate that works were ongoing. It was further claimed that the driver allegedly neglected to look where he was driving and allegedly failed to drive with due care and attention and to proceed cautiously past the works where Mr Ali was working. There was also, it was contended, a failure to take account of the roadworks and traffic conditions pertaining at the time and to take heed of Mr Ali on the public road. Mr Ali, who sustained a head injury, including fractures to the skull, was taken to hospital in Galway and later transferred to Dublin, where he had to have an operation to remove part of his skull to manage brain swelling due to severe traumatic brain injury. His family travelled to Ireland to be at his bedside and he was later transferred to a UK hospital. Approving the settlement, Mr Justice Paul Coffey said it was fair and reasonable.
Irish Times
13 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Crime figures: Homicides fall, while sexual and public order offences on the rise, CSO finds
There have been 'notable' decreases in the number of homicides, burglaries, robberies and kidnappings over recent months, according to the latest crime figures from the Central Statistics Office (CSO). The number of recorded crime incidents for most offences fell in the year to March of this year, compared to the same period in 2024. The most significant drops were for homicide, which was down 34 per cent over the period and robbery, extortion and hijacking offences, down 8 per cent. However, there were increases in the number of crime incidents of sexual offences (15 per cent), public order and other social code offences (5 per cent), attempts/threats to murder, assaults, harassment (3 per cent) and weapons and explosive offences (3 per cent). READ MORE Victims of crime incidents of attempts/threats to murder, assaults and harassments fell by 1 per cent to 5,370 in the first quarter of this year from the same period in 2024 . The number of male victims fell by 3 per cent and the number of female victims rose by 1 per cent. [ Murders, sex crimes, drug importation increasing as other crimes drop in Ireland Opens in new window ] Victims aged 60 years or more showed the largest decrease over the year. Male victims in this age cohort fell by 13 per cent and female victims fell by 8 per cent. Other notable changes were a fall of 6 per cent in male victims both aged under 18 years and 45-59 years at the time of the incident. For female victims, there were increases of 3 per cent and 2 per cent respectively for those in the 30-44 and 45-59 year age groups. The CSO said over the four-year period from 2022 to 2025, the largest percentage changes in the number of recorded crime incidents have been for theft, robbery, extortion and hijacking offences. In the year to March of this year, there were 74,102 recorded crime incidents of theft, up by 23,181 incidents, or 46 per cent, since the same period in 2022. The number of crime incidents of robbery, extortion and hijacking offences rose by 24 per cent over the same period. Weapons and explosive offences are up 14 per cent from 2,575 incidents in 2022 to 2,943 this year.
Irish Examiner
18 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Fraud case hears of Catherine O'Brien's 'zero-risk investment' offer in €20k French racehorse
An alleged phantom sale of a French racehorse, pitched as a lucrative investment that was 'too good to be true', is at the centre of a fraud case against a Cork woman. Catherine O'Brien met John Blake on dating site Plenty of Fish, and over time convinced him to invest €20,000 in a thoroughbred stallion called Shakeel. By investing €20,000 in breeding rights in this stallion, investors would make €14,000 per annum from foals or covering rights, she said. 'I promise I won't let you down,' she told Mr Blake in one of many messages between the pair read out to Waterford Circuit Court. She wanted 'ordinary people' to have fun and make money from horses, she said. While there were huge profits, often tax-free, in the industry, they were currently being made by only a few and she said she believed in opening that opportunity to more people. In messages, she told him of her international travel and of buying and selling horses. She also spoke of how much of her time and resources she gave to charities, helping children with additional needs and the poverty stricken in India. She spoke of caring for her elderly uncle and visiting her father's grave. 'You're an angel sent from heaven,' Mr Blake said in one of their many messages when she promised him large, tax-free profits from equine investments she would organise for him. 'I just want ordinary people to see the equine world, enjoy it and benefit from it,' Ms O'Brien said in a message. She claimed that investing breeding rights in the stallion was a "zero-risk investment', with returns of €14,000 for the first three years, with the first return due in just months. Mr Blake said that the investment was too good to be true in messages. But he never got the promised return on investment, prosecuting barrister Conor O'Doherty told Waterford Circuit court, while opening the case for the State. While Mr Blake had little to no knowledge of the bloodstock industry, Ms O'Brien claimed to have a lot of knowledge of the equine industry, Mr O'Doherty said. She said that he could make huge profits by investing in a brood mare to be covered by the thoroughbred stallion Shakeel which he had already invested in. French mare - Lingreville For another €20,000 investment, he could buy a French mare called Lingreville, which had already raced and produced some foals and which she would keep for him for free in her Cork property. Lingreville had been sold to Mr Blake as a brood mare of exceptional pedigree which would be a brilliant investment, Mr O'Doherty told the jury. Mr Blake would also have to pay €984 to transport the mare from France to Ireland to prove ownership, she said, Mr O'Doherty told the court. Ms O'Brien told him she was buying a large volume of mares to try to make the stallion Shakeel - which he had already invested in - a success. Mr Blake was not a man of considerable financial means and €20,000 was a lot of money, particularly after putting in money already for the breeding rights share on the stallion Shakeel, Mr O'Doherty told the court. 'He told her he would have to get a credit union loan,' Mr O'Doherty said. John Blake did hand over €20,000 he got from a credit union loan. But this money was to go to Ms O'Brien directly – not to the agent selling the horse in France – Mr O'Doherty said. Ms O'Brien is accused of deception charges related to John Blake and the purchase, transport and insurance of a French mare called Lingreville. It is alleged that she 'dishonestly by deception' induced Mr Blake to pay €20,000 to purchase the horse – which was not purchased, the State alleges; to pay €1,100 insurance for the mare – which the State said was not paid; and €984 to transport the horse from France to Ireland - which was not transported as alleged. Ms O'Brien, of An Grianan, Ballinroad, Dungarvan, Co Waterford, has pleaded not guilty to the three charges of making gain or causing loss by deception contrary to Section 6 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act 2001. Ms O'Brien, aged 47, formerly living in Buttevant, Co Cork, is represented by defence barrister Simon Donagh, BL, instructed by solicitor Ray Kavanagh. The trial, in front of his Honour Judge Eugene O'Kelly and a jury of seven women and five men, continues.
