Ontario school boards say lawsuits against social media giants clear to proceed
A group of Ontario school boards said Tuesday its legal fight against Meta, Snapchat and TikTok will proceed after a judge struck down the social media giants' motion to dismiss the case.
The group said the case can now proceed based on a judge's ruling that the Toronto District School Board's lawsuit, which represents all boards, has merit.
Since March 2024, 14 Ontario school boards and individual schools have initiated lawsuits against the social media companies, alleging the platforms are negligently designed for compulsive use and have rewired the way children think, behave and learn. The allegations in the lawsuits have not been proven in court.
"The statistics, if true, and the methods and outcomes of social media on the learning environment reveal broad effects that impact not only the immediate access to the right to an education, but to the futures of many young people," wrote Ontario Superior Court Justice Janet Leiper in her decision released Friday.
"It is arguable that an addictive product that interferes with the mental health and educational aspirations of students is a public nuisance that requires a remedy."
WATCH | How social media is affecting the minds of young people:
What social media scrolling is doing to kids' brains
1 year ago
Duration 7:52
With most children and teenagers spending hours a day on a smartphone, CBC's Christine Birak breaks down what research shows about how using social media is changing kids' behaviour, if it's rewiring their brains and what can be done about it.
'First step in achieving justice for the education system': lawyer
Schools for Social Media Change, the group of plaintiffs, said in a news release Tuesday the court's denial of the tech giants' motion for dismissal means the case can proceed to trial.
"This is the first step in achieving justice for the education system, and ultimately the next generation of leaders," said Duncan Embury, a lawyer at the Toronto firm Neinstein, which is heading up the litigation.
Among the plaintiffs are some of the province's largest school boards, including the public and Catholic school boards in Toronto and Ottawa.
The lawsuits make a slew of allegations about how "negligently" designed social media platforms have disrupted the education system at the expense of students' well-being.
They allege more staff and administrator time is being spent on addressing compulsive student social media use, more money is going into the heightened need for digital literacy and harm prevention, and more resources are being spent on handling issues such as cyberbullying and online sexual harassment.
WATCH | Ontario school board lawsuits against social media apps explained:
Why Ontario school boards are suing TikTok, Meta and Snapchat
12 months ago
Duration 4:04
School boards in the Greater Toronto Area and Ottawa are taking some of the largest social media companies to court over their products, alleging they are harming students and the broader education system. CBC's Dale Manucdoc dives into what we know so far about the lawsuit.
Students also struggle to spot misinformation, the suits allege, pushing teachers to spend time and resources to help vet what students see on their social media feeds and prevent them from adopting harmful ideologies they are exposed to on the platforms.
Companies say they're committed to users' well-being
Meta, Snapchat and TikTok have all previously said that they're committed to their young users' well-being.
A Snapchat spokesperson reiterated Tuesday that the platform was "intentionally designed" to be different form traditional social media as it opens directly to a camera rather than a feed of content, and has no public likes or comments.
"While we will always have more work to do, we feel good about the role Snapchat plays in helping close friends feel connected, happy and prepared as they face the many challenges of adolescence," the statement said.
A Meta spokesperson said Tuesday the company has developed tools to support parents and teens, including the introduction of protected teen accounts on Instagram.
"We strongly disagree with the allegations and believe the evidence will demonstrate our commitment to supporting young people," the statement read.
TikTok did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Tuesday.
Together, the plaintiffs are seeking more than $8 billion in damages, and they are calling on the social media companies to redesign their platforms to keep students safe.
Schools for Social Media Change says changes will help reduce mental health harms to youth and disruptions to the education system.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
7 minutes ago
- CTV News
Meta signs over US$10 billion cloud deal with Google, source says
The Meta logo is seen at the Vivatech show in Paris, France, June 14, 2023. (AP Photo/Thibault Camus) Google has struck a cloud computing deal with Meta Platforms worth more than US$10 billion, a source familiar with the matter told Reuters on Thursday. Under the agreement, Meta will use Google Cloud's servers, storage, networking and other services, the source added. Google and Meta did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The deal was first reported by the Information. The news comes after Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg's comments in July that the company would spend hundreds of billions of dollars to build several massive AI data centers. In June, Reuters reported that OpenAI was planning to add Alphabet's Google Cloud service to meet its growing needs for computing capacity. Meta is seeking outside partners to help it fund the massive infrastructure needed to power AI by offloading $2 billion in data center assets, the company disclosed in a filing earlier this month. Reporting by Sayantani Ghosh in San Francisco and Angela Christy in Bengaluru; additional reporting by Yazhini MV in Bengaluru; editing by Alan Barona
Toronto Sun
4 hours ago
- Toronto Sun
Burger King worker fired month after going viral while managing store alone
Nykia Hamilton, a single mother of three from South Carolina, announced she was fired from her job at Burger King a month after going viral for managing a store alone. Photo by @kianolabel / TikTok A Burger King worker in South Carolina was fired from her job a month after she went viral for running the store solo. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account Nykia Hamilton, a 25-year-old single mother of three children, tearfully explained in a TikTok video shared earlier this month that she was no longer employed at the fast food restaurant in Columbia. 'Burger King fired me because I've been late because of my kids,' she said in the video. 'My kids come first. Y'all don't pay for no baby-sitter or nothing,' she added. Hamilton said she was not looking for fame nor fortune by publicizing her plight. 'My mind is already f—ed up. I'm trying to keep pushing for my kids but I cannot do this s— no more,' she said wiping away tears. A month earlier, a Burger King customer shared a video also to TikTok of Hamilton taking orders, making burgers and fries, and handling the drive-thru window. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'I just need y'all to know that at this Burger King right now … we got one beautiful person working here all by herself,' an unidentified woman said while filming Hamilton busy in the kitchen. 'She's doing everything. She's doing the fries, she's doing the burgers, she's doing the chicken sandwich. She's doing everything by herself because nobody wants to work no more.' RECOMMENDED VIDEO Hamilton is then seen assembling and bagging an order for a customer. 'I'm not lying,' the woman continued. 'There's nobody in the back. She's doing this by herself. I need y'all to show her some love, OK.' Hamilton told a local news station last month that she was working more than 12 hours a shift to provide for her family. 'One of my employees just quit on me, and they didn't have anyone else to come in, so I had to work by myself, and close by myself,' Hamilton told Fox affiliate WACH. At the time, Hamilton explained that it's been difficult to be employed because of her criminal record, and thanked the store manager for hiring her. 'I wouldn't have no job because I do have a record, and it is hard to find a job with a record. And by grace of God, she gave me a job. So that's the only reason why I stayed for her,' she said. Read More Toronto & GTA World Columnists Columnists Celebrity
11 hours ago
The next generation of smart glasses is getting a push from AI
As the battle for AI dominance heats up, Big Tech is coming for your face. A number of companies are going all-in on artificial intelligence-enabled glasses, banking that consumers are ready for a new generation of smart devices with convenient, hands-free features . Since launching in 2021, Meta's Ray-Ban smart glasses have dominated the market, with a performance version by Oakley rolled out (new window) this summer. A new, pricier model, with a display screen (new window) , is said to be launching next month. They're not the only ones ramping up AI-enabled eyewear. Google has partnered with Warby Parker for their upcoming Android XR glasses (new window) , while Chinese tech giants Alibaba (new window) and Xiaomi (new window) each revealed pairs last month. Apple has been rumoured (new window) to have a set in the works, and Snap recently announced its forthcoming AI-enabled augmented reality Specs (new window) . The wearables can be used to translate languages in real time, shoot hands-free video, or identify objects around you. You can ask an AI assistant to answer questions, set a reminder or offer a restaurant recommendation — things your smartphone can tackle, but all while looking like typical eyewear. Consumer appetite for AI Enlarge image (new window) A person looks through a display of the parts that make up the Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses at the Meta Connect conference in Menlo Park, Calif., on Sept. 25, 2024. Photo: Associated Press / Godofredo A. Vásquez For those who've grown increasingly comfortable with using AI tools every day, they essentially offer a convenient new contact point — literally before your eyes. Frankly, we're realizing that people have had their head in their phone many hours of the day, and looking for other ways to have computing that's less obtrusive, said Joelle Pineau, a professor of computer science at McGill and former vice-president of AI research at Meta who now works with the Canadian AI firm Cohere. Glasses are a natural choice, she said, as a large percentage of the population already wears glasses. WATCH | Testing Meta's Ray-Ban smart glasses: In February, Ray-Ban's parent company announced (new window) they've sold two million pairs of the Meta glasses since late 2023, and are aiming to produce 10 million units annually by the end of 2026. One analysis, by the San Francisco-based Grand View Research (new window) , says the global smart glasses market was valued at an estimated $1.9 billion US in 2024, and is projected to reach $8.2 billion US by 2030. Privacy and data concerns The lingering question is whether consumers will buy in en masse, especially since AI-enabled glasses raise significant privacy and social acceptance concerns, potentially affecting people beyond the wearer. There have been some troubling signs of inappropriate use, such as surreptitiously filming people on the street. During the recent trial of hockey players in London, the judge temporarily barred a man from attending because he was wearing smart glasses in the courtroom, where filming isn't permitted. Last fall, two Harvard engineering students (new window) demonstrated they could modify Meta's glasses in order to identify a stranger. And the FBI said the man behind the deadly New Year's Day truck attack in New Orleans wore Meta glasses to record video and allegedly scope out the area (new window) in advance. Meta's glasses, for one, do have a small light that blinks while a video is being taken, but someone unfamiliar with the tech might not even be aware of it. A YouTube search also turns up many tutorials on how to conceal it. There's also the question of what kind of data the glasses may access and keep. Last spring, Meta updated their privacy policy for voice services on their wearables, and users' voice interactions are now stored to improve its machine learning. Text transcripts and audio recordings of your voice interactions are stored by default to help improve Meta's products, reads the updated privacy notice (new window) . You can manually delete individual interactions, but there's no way to simply opt out. There's also the question of aesthetic; Google Glass famously flopped (new window) in 2014, with criticisms centred on privacy concerns, cost — and an overly futuristic design. And virtual- and mixed reality headsets have been used for years in gaming, but haven't found broad acceptance. An attendee tries Google Glass during the Google I/O developer conference in San Francisco on May 17, 2013. The early smart glasses were discontinued by 2015 as they failed to win over consumers. / Justin Sullivan The key to gaining consumer approval may be in giving users control over what they're comfortable with, said Pineau. She points out that while some people have a very high tolerance around personal information shared with algorithms, others have a very different sort of preference and tolerance for these kinds of behaviours. So ideally, we provide a lot of control for the users to be able to make those choices, Pineau said. The tricky part is right now, the interface to a lot of these controls is pretty complicated. The AI race and investor dollars The move toward glasses comes as the AI space faces a period of intense competition, with tech companies scrambling for investment dollars and speculation that we're in the midst of an AI "bubble (new window) ." Right now, if you're not talking about AI, the market is not rewarding you, said longtime tech writer Om Malik. Joelle Pineau is chief AI officer at Canadian firm Cohere, as well as a professor of computer science at McGill University. Photo: Kimberly Wang In a July earnings call (new window) , Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg pointed to smart glasses as key to his company's future vision for AI, saying the wearables will eventually be our main computing devices — a suggestion they could eventually replace our cellphones. I continue to think that glasses are basically going to be the ideal form factor for AI, because you can let an AI see what you see throughout the day, hear what you hear, talk to you, he said. Zuckerberg then went on to compare the future use of AI glasses to the mundane use of contact lenses today. If I didn't have my vision corrected, I'd be sort of at a cognitive disadvantage going through the world, he said. And I think in the future, if you don't have glasses that have AI, or some way to interact with AI, I think you're kinda similar. We'd probably be at a … pretty significant cognitive disadvantage compared to other people. ANALYSIS Is the stock market in an AI bubble? (new window) If AI is woven more closely into our devices in future, we may develop more of an appetite for always-available AI, said Pineau. If you have [AI] agents that have access to your visual world, not just your digital world, you're opening up new ability for the agents to be proactive about finding ways to help you, she said. There are already signs that AI will be increasingly integrated into more of our devices, beyond glasses. Google, for example, plans on bringing its Gemini AI to its smartwatch (new window) and Google TV. Pretty much every device will have intelligence built into it, said Malik. Others question whether an AI-glasses strategy is truly a vision. David Karpf, an associate professor of media and public affairs at the George Washington University, has written about Meta's push for 'personal superintelligence.' Photo: Submitted by David Karpf David Karpf is associate professor of media and public affairs at The George Washington University who has written about Meta's AI vision — which it brands "personal superintelligence" (new window) — and glasses. Meta and other big tech companies are viewing generative AI as a race, and they all want to be the one who wins it, he said. But Karpf questions the link between that race and the push toward glasses. So they've got those goggles, or the glasses, and they're hoping that they can use them for something, Karpf said. It seems more like [Zuckerberg's] spending all the money and then just kind of saying, 'The future of AI is gonna bend toward our existing comparative advantages.' Nora Young (new window) · CBC News · Senior Technology Reporter Nora Young is senior technology reporter with CBC News. Her technology show, Spark, aired on CBC Radio One for 17 seasons. She is author of The Virtual Self. Her favourite technology is her bicycle.
