Bill to undo convictions for consensual gay sex introduced 32 years after decriminalisation of homosexuality
Hundreds of men were convicted since the State's foundation, and the legislation will 'right a wrong, something that should have been delivered many, many years ago', Sinn Féin TD
Aengus Ó Snodaigh
said as he introduced the Disregard of Historic Offences for Consensual Sexual Activity between Men Bill on Tuesday.
The legislation, developed with a number of campaign groups, was cosigned by Opposition parties and Independents. Mr Ó Snodaigh said it was one of 95 recommendations of the report of a working group established in 2021.
The State decriminalised gay sex in Ireland 32 years ago but 'it failed to address the legacy of that' to 'ensure that those men who have criminal convictions can disregard that conviction so that it is no longer a weight on their shoulders and a weight on our society'.
READ MORE
Speaking later outside the Dáil, Mr Ó Snodaigh said the exact number of those convicted under the legislation is not known, but one piece of research showed that in Tullow, Co Carlow in 1970, 12 criminal prosecutions were taken in one month.
Labour
's Conor Sheehan said: 'many men live with the trauma inflicted upon them by a society who told them they shouldn't exist'.
Despite an apology in 2018, no action was taken to disregard these convictions and many men are living with 'shame and stigma' and a trauma that 'drove many people to their graves. Gay men were driven underground', by the legislation, he said.
Urging the Government to support the Bill, Mr Sheehan said he was conscious that he was fortunate enough to be able to live openly as a gay man.
Social Democrats TD Pádraig Rice said 'the prosecution and convictions of hundreds of gay men for consensual sex was a gross violation of their human rights and did immeasurable damage.
'These arrests and convictions destroyed lives. The laws also had a negative impact on those who weren't convicted because the threat of prosecution was used to harass people in the community.'
[
10 milestones in Irish gay rights
Opens in new window
]
He said the arcane laws also had a 'huge impact on the provision of public services, including HIV/Aids prevention'. Mr Rice warned that 'we are running out of time for these men', many of whom were elderly, and they needed immediate action from Government.
Green Party leader
Roderic O'Gorman
said the legislation stated 'whoever shall be convicted of the abominable crime of buggery, committed either with mankind or with any animal, shall be liable to be kept in penal servitude for life'.
He said framing homosexuality in legislation from the 1860s showed the 'absolute moral condemnation' for being gay.
The same approach is being adopted currently, he said. 'It was adopted in Poland up to the recent change in the general election there. It's adopted in Hungary today.
'We see that same language online and I think that's why it is so important that we are moving to disregard these convictions.'
People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy said 'this is not just a matter of righting a historic wrong. It's about sending a message at a time when LGBQ rights are under attack in this country and globally, that love is love and homosexuality is never a crime'.
Independent TD Catherine Connolly said some of the legislation went back to the 17th century and had nothing to do with justice or fairness. 'It was homophobia at its worst.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Japan expresses concern over security of subsea cables off the Irish coast
Japan has expressed concern about the security of subsea cables off the Irish coast, seeking reassurance from the Taoiseach that the Government was taking adequate steps to protect them. During a meeting in Tokyo on Wednesday, prime minister Shigeru Ishiba also raised the issue of cybersecurity . 'I explained to him that two years ago we had a national forum on modern-day security challenges, and how we saw our priority as protecting subsea cables, developing stronger resilience there, and also in terms of cybersecurity,' Micheál Martin said after the meeting. 'We both agreed that we would continue that conversation because in the world of cybersecurity, collaboration is essential, as he said himself, and we agree with that. I think our officials will engage further in terms of expertise and knowledge around that cybersecurity space.' Japanese companies have doubled their footprint in Ireland over the past decade with significant investments in technology, life sciences, financial services and engineering. Mr Ishiba referred specifically to the activity of Russian fishing vessels close to the interconnector between Britain and Ireland and to subsea cables used for data transmission. READ MORE 'He said that Ireland was a very important technology centre with significant traffic conducted through those subsea cables,' the Taoiseach said. 'I indicated to him that we have taken quite a number of measures. We have a national cybersecurity centre. We have an individually tailored plan agreed with Nato , for example, in respect of cybersecurity co-operation and in terms of subsea cables. And also we're part of the Pesco projects within the European Union in terms of cybersecurity and again, subsea cables, building up expertise and knowledge.' The Taoiseach opened the meeting by reaffirming Ireland's commitment to nuclear disarmament and the belief that war and conflict should be avoided 'at all costs'. He told Mr Ishiba that his visit to Hiroshima on Friday would reflect this outlook. 'We are two peace-loving nations who believe in avoiding war and conflict at all costs. And I want to remember those who suffered and the survivors, and going there in all solemnity to reflect our commitment to nuclear disarmament and nuclear non-proliferation,' Mr Martin said. The Taoiseach was welcomed to the Kantei, the prime minister's glass-walled headquarters, by a colour guard from the 302nd military police company of the Japan ground self-defence force. Wearing white dress uniforms, a military band played Amhrán na bhFiann and the Japanese national anthem while the colour guard presented arms with bayonets fixed. Mr Ishiba served the Taoiseach green tea during the meeting, remarking that he had heard about Mr Martin's fondness for it. After the formal meeting they had lunch including Wagyu beef with colcannon, served with Guinness, while the music of Enya played in the background. Mr Ishiba is under intense political pressure in advance of elections to Japan's upper house on July 20th, with polls suggesting that support for his Liberal Democratic Party has fallen by 20 points since the last such election in 2022. Donald Trump this week threatened to impose a tariff of up to 35 per cent on Japanese goods if Tokyo does not agree to import cars and rice from the United States. Later on Wednesday, with Japan's Princess Takamado among those present, the Taoiseach opened Ireland House in Tokyo, a landmark building housing the Irish Embassy and State agencies the IDA, Enterprise Ireland and Bord Bia. At a cost of more than €20 million, it is the biggest single capital project the State has ever undertaken. 'The relationship between Ireland and Japan is a very special one. Ireland House Tokyo stands as a testament to that relationship and a symbol of the economic, cultural, and social values that we share,' the Taoiseach said.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Zero sum recorded for services traded between Ireland and illegal Israeli settlements in 2023
A sum of 'zero' was recorded for services between Ireland and illegal Israeli settlements in 2023, the Oireachtas committee scrutinising the draft legislation to ban trade from them has heard. The total figure for goods imported into Ireland from the settlements in the occupied territories in 2024 was €214,000, senior officials from the Department of Foreign Affairs told the committee. However, when it came to services, the department's political director, Gerard Keown said there were no reliable figures and the latest available, for 2023, was zero. He and his colleague, Declan Smyth, the department's legal adviser, said that services could be traded on the internet and by email and were very difficult to monitor and quantify. READ MORE In contrast, any goods from the occupied territories had to be presented to Irish customs before entry. Most imports from the settlements into Ireland are fruit and vegetables. The officials were attending a meeting of the Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee which is carrying out pre-legislative scrutiny of the Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025. The draft legislation proposes to ban goods imported from the region but not services. Chairman John Lahart said there was broad agreement across all parties that services should be included in the Bill. [ Despite the politics, Ireland is Israel's second-biggest export market for goods Opens in new window ] Mr Smyth outlined several times that while services are not included in the Bill at present, the Attorney General Rossa Fanning has been asked to give legal advice to the Government on incorporating this category into the Bill. Asked when that decision would be made, both officials said the Attorney General and Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris were both very aware the issue was now before the committee. Mr Keown said the Tánaiste would act 'expeditiously' on the matter once the advice was received. Seán Ó Fearghaíl (Fianna Fáil) said the volume of goods and services being traded was not the important issue. 'If the value was only €10, the symbolic value of the legislation is still enormous,' he said. It was 'frustrating' that the committee was discussing the Bill without having the opinion of the Attorney General on services, he added. Sinéad Gibney (Social Democrats) said she was surprised at the zero sum for services given that properties in the illegal settlements are let on Airbnb. Mr Keown said they were difficult to quantify. 'Services are intangible. We do not have an accurate picture,' he said. Mr Smyth told the committee that external trade with territories outside the EU was the exclusive competence of the union and not of member states. He said that there were some 'public policy exceptions' in EU regulation on the imports of goods that did give member states leeway to prohibit the import of goods. A country like Ireland could do so on public policy grounds. However, he said there was no such specific EU legislation that the department's legal advisers could find that would allow Ireland act in a similar fashion with services. The Bill is influenced by a judgment by the International Court of Justice on trade from illegal settlements. Mr Smyth agreed with Senator Patricia Stephenson (Social Democrats), Senator Alice Mary Higgins (Ind) and TD Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire (Sinn Féin) that the judgment referred to both goods and services. However, when asked whether international law trumps EU law, Mr Smyth replied that both had to be reconciled. The committee was told that several countries have contacted the department to inquire about the Bill. Shay Brennan of Fianna Fáil, asked Mr Keown had any countries 'pushed back' against it. 'There has been contact at official level from the United States around this, under the previous (Biden) administration to inquire about the intentions around this legislation', Mr Keown said. Michael McDowell said the EU laws were 'devoid of common sense'. He said a state can block goods or services from another EU state but cannot block goods or services from a state outside the EU. Senator Frances Black, who drafted the original Bill, said she was confident services could be included. 'I am 100 per cent certain that we can get the wording right. I believe there are no legal barriers to it,' she said.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Arts Council almost doubles legal costs on botched IT project
The Arts Council has almost doubled its spend on legal costs arising from its botched €6.7 million IT project , an Oireachtas committee has heard. The project began in 2018 and was designed to overhaul the Arts Council's system for receiving and processing funding applications with an original budget of €3 million. However, following issues and delays and with the budget increasing as time went on, the project was shelved towards the end of 2023 with an estimated loss of about €5.3 million. Senior staff at the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport appeared before the Oireachtas committee on arts on Tuesday. READ MORE Feargal Ó Coigligh, secretary general at the department, told the committee that while a figure of €60,000 was previously given for the costs of legal redress, that has since changed. 'The Arts Council have since informed the department that it is actually approximately €119,000," Mr Ó Coigligh said. The committee was previously told the council had commenced legal proceedings against two contractors for the failed IT system and was in the pre-action stage in relation to two others. This action was taken to try and minimise the cost of the IT system to the taxpayer, the council previously told the committee. [ Former Arts Council director Maureen Kennelly: 'The Minister saw the opportunity for a scalp. I was an easy target' Opens in new window ] The department had asked the council to cease any further expenditure on these legal cases. However, on Friday, the council informed the department of the increased spend. Mr Ó Coigligh told the committee on Tuesday he was 'taken aback' by the upwards revision of legal costs. 'We requested the Arts Council to cease all further expenditure, and we've since entered into discussions with the Attorney General's office for advice,' Mr Ó Coigligh said. When asked if he felt the department was not given the full picture by the Arts Council on the legal costs, Mr Ó Coigligh said: 'I think they could have been more forthcoming on the issue.' The Irish Times previously reported three companies shared €4.8 million between them from the abandoned project. Documents distributed to ministers named the main technology delivery partner, Codec, as having been paid €1,967,278, including VAT, for its work on the project – with €51,217 withheld. A second company, named as Ergo, was paid €2,107,206 including VAT across a series of contracts, several of which were extended during the project. A third firm, named as Expleo, was paid €734,701 including VAT, with another €149,125 withheld by the Arts Council.
