Looming over two cases threatening Musk's car company is a single question: Can he be trusted?
In unusual coincidence regulators arguing an Oakland California case tried to pin exaggerated talk about the same Tesla technology at the center of a request to suspend the carmaker from being able to sell vehicles in the state. Musk's tendency to talk big–whether it's his cars his rockets or his government costing-cutting efforts–have landed him in trouble with investors regulators and courts before but rarely at such a delicate moment. After his social media spat with President Donald Trump, Musk can no longer count on a light regulatory touch from Washington. Meanwhile sales of his electric cars have plunged and so a hit to his safety reputation could threaten his next big project: rolling out driverless robotaxis–hundreds of thousands of them–in several US cities by the end of next year.
The Miami case holds other dangers too. Lawyers for the family of the dead woman Naibel Benavides Leon recently convinced the judge overseeing the jury trial to allow them to argue for punitive damages. A car crash lawyer not involved in the case but closely following it said that could cost Tesla tens of millions of dollars or possibly more. 'I've seen punitive damages go to the hundreds of millions so that is the floor,' said Miguel Custodio of Los Angeles-based Custodio & Dubey. 'It is also a signal to other plaintiffs that they can also ask for punitive damages and then the payments could start compounding.'
Tesla did not reply for a request for comment. That Tesla has allowed the Miami case to proceed to trial is surprising. It has settled at least four deadly accidents involving Autopilot including payments just last week to a Florida family of a Tesla driver. That said Tesla was victorious in two other jury cases both in California that also sought to lay blame on its technology for crashes. Lawyers for the plaintiffs in the Miami case argue that Tesla's driver-assistance feature called Autopilot should have warned the driver and braked when his Model S sedan blew through flashing lights a stop sign and a T-intersection at 62 miles-an-hour in an April 2019 crash. Tesla said that drivers are warned not to rely on Autopilot or its more advanced Full Self-Driving system. It say the fault entirely lies with the distracted driver just like so many other accidents since cellphones were invented.
Driver McGee settled a separate suit brought by the family of Benavides and her severely injured boyfriend Dillon Angulo. Shown dashcam video Monday of his car jumping the road a split second before killing Benavides, McGee was clearly shaken. Asked if he had seen those images before, McGee pinched his lips, shook his head then squeaked out a response 'No.' Tesla's attorney sought to show that McGee was fully to blame asking if he had ever contacted Tesla for additional instructions about how Autopilot or any other safety features worked. McGee said he had not though he was heavy user of the features. He said he had driven the same road home from work 30 or 40 times. Under questioning he also acknowledged he alone was responsible for watching the road and hitting the brakes.
But lawyers for the Benavides family had another chance to parry that line of argument and asked McGee if he would have taken his eyes off the road and reached for his phone had he been driving any car other than a Tesla on Autopilot. McGee responded 'I don't believe so.' The case is expected to continue for two more weeks. In the California case the states Department of Motor Vehicles is arguing before an administrative judge that Tesla has misled drivers by exaggerating the capabilities of its Autopilot and Full Self-Driving features. A court filing claims even those feature names are misleading because they offer just partial self-driving Musk has been warned by federal regulators to stop making public comments suggesting Full Self-Driving allows his cars to drive themselves because it could lead to overreliance on the system resulting in possible crashes and deaths. He also has run into trouble with regulators for Autopilot. In 2023 the company had to recall 2.3 million vehicles for problems with the technology and is now under investigation for saying it fixed the issue though it's unclear it has according to regulatory documents.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Arabiya
3 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
Trump order lowering tariffs on EU autos still days away, source says
The European Union will likely have to wait a few more days for an executive order by US President Donald Trump lowering tariffs on imports of European cars and car parts, a source familiar with the EU-US negotiations said. It means US consumers will continue to see tariffs of 27.5 percent applied to the imports of cars including German-made BMW and Mercedes-Benz vehicles and Swedish-made Volvos, the source said, rather than the 15 percent rate Trump and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen agreed in Scotland. The rate will only come down once Trump issues a legally binding executive order. White House officials did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Trump on July 31 issued an executive order setting the EU's baseline tariff at 15 percent, but the order did not cover goods facing so-called Section 232 investigations, including autos, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, wine and spirits and steel and aluminum. The baseline tariff comes into effect on August 7 at 12:01 a.m. EDT (0401 GMT) with an exemption for goods already in transit or warehoused until Oct. 5. The EU-US framework trade agreement will be implemented in stages through White House executive orders followed by a legally non-binding joint statement, which a senior EU official on Tuesday said was at an 'advanced' stage. Under the terms of the agreement, a 15 percent levy will be applied to EU pharmaceuticals and semiconductors, US officials say. EU officials say 15 percent is a ceiling and that the rate could be lower pending the outcome of the Section 232 investigations. EU and US officials are still negotiating a final list of products that would have either a zero-for-zero duty or a significantly lower most-favored nation rate. The EU wants low or zero rates on spirits, wines, some chemicals and medical devices.
Arab News
5 hours ago
- Arab News
Trump imposes additional 25 percent tariff on Indian goods, relations hit new low
US President Donald Trump on Wednesday issued an executive order imposing an additional 25 percent tariff on Indian goods citing New Delhi's continued imports of Russian oil, sharply escalating tensions between the two countries after trade talks collapsed. The new measure raises tariffs on some Indian goods to as high as 50 percent — among the steepest faced by any US trading partner. The move is expected to hit key Indian export sectors including textiles, footwear, and gems and jewelery and marks the most serious downturn in US-India relations since Trump returned to office in January. It also comes as Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi prepares for his first visit to China in over seven years, suggesting a potential realignment in alliances as ties with Washington fray. 'India will take all actions necessary to protect its national interests,' India's external affairs ministry said in a statement, saying it was 'extremely unfortunate that the US should choose to impose additional tariffs on India for actions that several other countries are also taking in their own national interest.' It said India's imports were based on market factors and aimed at energy security for its population of 1.4 billion. Trade analysts warned the tariffs could severely disrupt Indian exports. The additional 25 percent tariff comes into effect 21 days after August 7, the order said. 'With such obnoxious tariff rates, trade between the two nations would be practically dead,' said Madhavi Arora, economist at Emkay Global. Indian officials have privately acknowledged growing pressure to return to the negotiating table. A potential compromise could involve a phased reduction in Russian oil imports and diversification of energy sources. A senior Indian official said New Delhi was blindsided by the sudden imposition of the new levy and the steep rate, as both countries continue to discuss trade issues. Trump's decision follows five rounds of inconclusive trade negotiations, which stalled over US demands for greater access to Indian agriculture and dairy markets. India's refusal to curb Russian oil purchases — which surged to a record $52 billion last year — ultimately triggered the tariff escalation. 'Exports to the US become unviable at this rate. Clearly, risks to growth and exports are rising, and the rupee may face renewed pressure,' said Garima Kapoor, economist at Elara Securities. 'Calls for fiscal support are likely to intensify.' Trump's executive order does not mention China, which also buys Russian oil. A White House official had no immediate comment on whether an additional order covering those purchases would be forthcoming. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent last week said he warned Chinese officials that continued purchases of sanctioned Russian oil would lead to big tariffs due to legislation in Congress, but was told that Beijing would protect its energy sovereignty. The US and China have been engaged in discussions about trade and tariffs, with an eye to extending a 90-day tariff truce that is due to expire on August 12, when their bilateral tariffs shoot back up to triple-digit figures.
Al Arabiya
5 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
Casualties reported in active shooter incident at Fort Stewart in US state of Georgia
Casualties have been reported in an active shooter incident at the Fort Stewart US Army installation in the state of Georgia, Fort Stewart said in a Facebook post on Wednesday. 'The installation was locked down at 11:04 a.m. and law enforcement is on the scene,' it said, adding the incident took place in the 2nd Armored Brigade Combat Team area. No further information was immediately available, including on the number of casualties and their severity.
