Family of Univ. of Idaho murder victim dismisses Bryan Kohberger as a ‘joke' and ‘loser' in searing impact statements
'If you hadn't attacked them in their sleep, in the middle of the night like a pedophile, Kaylee would have kicked your f**king a**,' her sister Alivea Goncalves said to him, earning a round of applause from some of those gathered in the Boise, Idaho, courtroom.
The victim impact statements Wednesday came during a hearing that represents the final opportunity for the victims' families to speak in court and reflect on their loved ones, Kohberger and the case's controversial plea deal.
Kohberger, too, will have an opportunity to speak to the court and answer the question that remains frustratingly unclear: Why?
Earlier this month, the former criminology graduate student admitted to fatally stabbing four University of Idaho students – Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen – in their off-campus home during the overnight hours of November 13, 2022.
He pleaded guilty to burglary and four counts of first-degree murder, and in exchange, prosecutors agreed to a sentence of life in prison, taking the death penalty off the table.
Speaking directly to Kohberger, Alivea Goncalves said her sister would 'call you exactly what you are: sociopath, psychopath, murderer.'
She called Kohberger 'defendant' and asked a series of questions she said 'reverberate violently' in her own head.
'Sit up straight when I talk to you,' she said. 'How was your life right before you murdered my sister? Did you prepare for the crime before leaving your apartment? Please detail what you were thinking and feeling at the time.'
'If you were really smart, do you think you'd be here right now?'
She dismissed him as a sociopath, a psychopath and a delusional and pathetic loser. He is 'as dumb as they come,' she said, adding that 'no one thinks that you are important.'
'The truth is, you're basic,' she said.
'Let me be very clear: Don't ever try to convince yourself you matter just because someone finally said your name out loud. I see through you,' she said.
Steve Goncalves, the victim's father, turned the lectern to directly face Kohberger in his impact statement.
'The world's watching because of the kids, not because of you. Nobody cares about you. … In time, you will be nothing but two initials, forgotten to the wind,' he said.
He called Kohberger a 'joke' and described how easy it was to track him down.
'Police officers tell us within minutes they had your DNA. Like a calling card. You were that careless. That foolish. That stupid. Masters degree? You're a joke. Complete joke,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
a minute ago
- CBS News
Ex-DOGE staffer allegedly injured in attempted carjacking — leading Trump to float federal takeover of D.C
Former Department of Government Efficiency staffer Edward Coristine was allegedly assaulted in an attempted carjacking in Washington, D.C., over the weekend, according to police records obtained by CBS News — an incident that led President Trump to threaten to put the nation's capital under federal control. 19-year-old Coristine — who is known for his online moniker "Big Balls" — was allegedly surrounded and assaulted by a group of approximately 10 teenagers near his car early Sunday morning, according to a report from the Metropolitan Police Department. Two 15-year-olds were arrested and charged with unarmed carjacking. Coristine and his significant other later told police that they "saw the suspects approach and make a comment about taking the vehicle," and "for her safety, he pushed his significant other … into the vehicle and turned to deal with the suspects," the police report said. Police officers who were patrolling the area spotted the incident and stepped out of their cruiser, leading most of the teens to flee on foot, but two of the assailants were stopped, identified by Coristine and arrested. The two arrestees were identified by police only as a 15-year-old male and a 15-year-old female from Hyattsville, Maryland. Police said in a statement that "multiple suspects remain outstanding." Emergency medical services did not transport anybody as part of the incident, D.C. Fire and EMS told CBS News. A black iPhone 16 was also stolen, the report said. Prior to the police report's release, Mr. Trump posted about the incident on Truth Social, sharing a photo of what appeared to be a bloodied "incredible young man" whom he said was "beaten mercilessly by local thugs." Billionaire Elon Musk — the former leader of DOGE — later said the victim was a member of DOGE. He wrote that the staffer spotted a group of people allegedly attempting to assault a young woman, and "ran to defend her and was severely beaten to the point of concussion," although Musk's description of the incident did not align with the police report and the extent of Coristine's injuries was unclear. CBS News has reached out to Musk for comment. Mr. Trump said crime in the nation's capital is "totally out of control" and called on authorities to "prosecute these 'minors' as adults, and lock them up for a long time, starting at age 14." The president also threatened to put D.C. under federal control if the city doesn't "get its act together, and quickly." "If this continues, I am going to exert my powers, and FEDERALIZE this City," he wrote. Mr. Trump has backed the idea of federalizing D.C. in the past. The Constitution gives Congress the power to govern the city, but since 1973, the federal government has allowed D.C. residents to elect a mayor and city council that handle most aspects of local government. The city's autonomy is still limited, with Congress maintaining the right to override local laws — and Congress could choose to repeal the city's 52-year-old self-rule. Jeanine Pirro, the U.S. attorney for D.C., said in a statement: "It's time we start taking crime more seriously irrespective of the age of the criminal. No longer can we coddle young criminals while innocent victims are being assaulted and maimed and young criminals avoid consequences. It's time for this to end." Coristine was one of the best-known members of Musk's DOGE team, which swept through the federal government earlier this year in an effort to cut government spending. He was involved in DOGE efforts at the U.S. Agency for International Development, the Social Security Administration, Health and Human Services and other agencies. Coristine resigned from the federal government in late June. He rejoined federal service days later as a special government employee with the Social Security Administration, which told CBS News at the time he would focus on "improving the functionality of the Social Security website." In May, Coristine was part of a roundtable of DOGE employees who were interviewed alongside Elon Musk on Fox News' "Watters' World." He said his work involved looking at "payment computers" in the federal government. Asked about his "Big Balls" pseudonym, Coristine explained that it was a tongue-in-cheek username he chose on LinkedIn. "People on LinkedIn take themselves super seriously, and they're pretty averse to risk. And I was like, 'Well, I want to be neither of those things,'" he Navarro contributed to this report.
CBS News
2 minutes ago
- CBS News
Grand Prairie council censures Mike Del Bosque following assault allegation
After hearing from 60-year-old Austin real estate broker David Collantes, Grand Prairie council members voted Tuesday night to censure councilman Mike Del Bosque. "I think it was the right vote," David Collantes said. "Someone with that kind of temper should not be running for public office." Last April, Collantes reported he was attacked by Del Bosque while he was looking at a property the councilman owns. He says the building was being turned over to another owner after a default judgment, but Del Bosque didn't want him showing the property. "I just was fighting for my life, literally," he said. Surveillance video obtained exclusively by CBS News Texas shows the councilman taking Collantes to the ground, smashing his cell phone, and trying to grab his wallet. The encounter led to his arrest for misdemeanor assault and criminal mischief. After Tuesday's vote, he had this to say: "I'm man enough to do what needs to be done and I took accountability, and I did apologize, but again, we're not going to get in the depth of this because this case is still in litigation," Del Bosque said. "He's doing it to save his own skin," Collantes said. "If he really was truly remorseful, he would've contacted me four months ago. I expected a little bit more, maybe some of the City Council members saying this behavior should not have been tolerated." Del Bosque's attorney has said this video doesn't tell the full story. "David Collantes entered our client's private property," Phillip Linder said. "The back door was in a private office. The female staff felt threatened and when asked to leave he used expletives." But Collantes says that's not true and believes this video speaks for itself. "I never entered his business in the back door," he said. "I plan to continue to follow this and I'm not going to give it up. I will continue to press forward and make sure that justice is served." The Dallas County District Attorney's office says the case will be prosecuted like any other.
CBS News
2 minutes ago
- CBS News
Chicago man can't get money back after falling victim to funeral fundraising scam
After months of back-and-forth with his bank, a Chicago man said he is still out thousands of dollars after he was scammed while walking in Lakeview. He was conned by a scheme that has come up in the headlines several times this year, involving scammers posing as people needing help funding a funeral. For the past five months, Paul Mitchell has been in talks with Citibank. He turned to CBS News Chicago when Citibank would not refund his money. But still, nothing has been done. Mitchell said it was a story that tore at his heart. He said four young men came up to him and his friend at the corner of Southport Avenue and School Street in March, asking for donations to pay for a brother's funeral. "They said: 'No, we can't accept cash. We can only take credit cards,'" Mitchell said. So Mitchell used his Citi card. But instead of paying the $10 he had intended to give the young men, he was charged $5,000. Citi sent him a notification saying a person named Carey Wade was the merchant. The bank asked if it was fraud, and Mitchell said yes. "And they assured me, 'Don't worry, the charge will be rejected,'" Mitchell said. But Mitchell said at some point, the bank approved the $5,000 charge — and for the last five months, he has been trying to get it reversed. "I was asked by Citi, 'Did you have your credit card in your possession at the time?'" said Mitchell. "And I said yes, and that changed the whole perspective in their mind of the incident." Steve Bernas with the Better Business Bureau said some banks and credit card companies have decided they do not have to reimburse when customers give someone permission to use their credit cards. "You gave them the money," Bernas said. "You gave them the access to your phone or your account — even if it's a fraudulent purchase." Bernas said people like Mitchell should send repeated complaints and report to the higher-ups, and physically go visit the bank. He also said anyone else in a similar situation needs really to vet the people asking for donations. "Usually, a legitimate person will want your money today, they will want it tomorrow or next week," said Bernas. "A scammer wants your money now. They want your phone." Mitchell said Citi told him since his card was not lost or stolen, the charge on his card was not fraud. He said the bank asked him to send a copy of the receipt, but since this was a scam, he had no such thing. "Frustrating in my mind that they've taken such a stance," Mitchell said. CBS News Chicago reached out to Citi on Tuesday. The bank declined to comment, because it cannot share customer details. The Better Business Bureau said a woman in a Lincoln Park fell victim to the same scam. The Chicago Police Department said it is investigating, and no arrests have been made.
