‘Play by the rules': Fortnite developer Epic Games wins Australian court battle against Apple and Google
Fortnite was kicked off the Google and Apple app stores in 2020 after Epic Games offered its own in-app payment system that bypassed the one used by the platforms, and cut out the fees Apple and Google receive for in-app payments.
Epic fought the ban by launching legal action against the two in multiple jurisdictions.
In the Australian cases, Epic Games alleged that Apple's control over in-app purchases – preventing users from downloading apps outside the app store and preventing developers from running their own app store on iOS – were a misuse of market power, which substantially lessened competition in app development.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
The company also alleged Google harmed app developers and consumers in Australia by preventing choice over app distribution and in-app payments on Android devices.
Apple's iOS and App Store are completely closed and controlled by Apple: if an app is on your phone, and there is a payment through that app, it has to go through Apple.
Similar rules apply on Google's Android operating system for the Play Store, but Google also allows 'side-loading' of apps – meaning apps installed directly on the phone without using the app store. It also allows for phone manufacturers such as Samsung to have their own app stores. Fortnite is still available on Android, but only through side-loading or through the Samsung store.
Each company charges fees for transactions in their app stores. Google Play charges a 15% fee for the first US$1m earned by developers each year, increasing to 30% above that. Apple developers pay a 15% fee if the revenue generated the previous year is lower than $1m, but pay 30% if they earn more than that.
Fees are common in the industry – Epic's own store charges developers a 12% fee.
Epic argued that it should be able to offer its own store as competition to Apple's store, and also offer alternative payment options within their app in the official Games Store.
Originally separate, the Australian cases were combined into a single monolith. Justice Jonathan Beach decided to hear the two cases and an associated class action at the same time to avoid duplication of witness evidence.
On Tuesday, Beach found that Apple had engaged in conduct likely to diminish competition, in breach of section 46 of the Competition and Consumer Act over preventing side-loading of apps on iOS, and by preventing developers using alternative payment methods for digital purchases.
For Google, it was found to breach section 46 of the Competition and Consumer Act for the similar Google Play billing system, and over Google's Project Hug, a project that allegedly saw developers enticed to keep their apps in the Play Store.
Epic did not succeed in its other claims against the two companies.
In a post on X, Epic Games stated that its app store and Fortnite would come to iOS in Australia, but noted there were 2,000+ pages of findings that 'we'll need to dig into to fully understand the details'.
'This is a WIN for developers and consumers in Australia!'
A spokesperson for Google said the court recognised the 'stark difference between Android's open platform and Apple's closed system' and welcomed the court's rejection that Epic sought to run an app store within the app store.
However Google disagreed with 'the court's characterisation of our billing policies and practices, as well as its findings regarding some of our historical partnerships, which were all shaped in a fiercely competitive mobile landscape on behalf of users and developers'.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'We will review the full decision when we receive it and assess our next steps,' the spokesperson said.
Any potential changes to the app stores and payment systems for Apple and Google in Australia are likely to be a long way off.
Beach delivered a summary of his judgment in the long-running case on Tuesday in a marathon hour and a half reading to cover the two Epic cases and two class actions, ahead of a full judgment being released with redactions to account for commercial sensitivities at a later date.
The Apple and Google judgments run to over 900 pages each, with the class action judgment running over 100 pages, Beach indicated.
The two class action cases were successful. Brought by app developers against Apple and Google, the cases focused on whether the companies had overcharged developers over app store purchases given their market dominance. The amount that developers would have otherwise been charged by the two companies, and the relief they will see from the case will be determined at a later hearing.
'This judgment is a turning point,' said Kimi Nishimura, principal at Maurice Blackburn Lawyers, the firm representing the app developers.
'It sends a clear message that even the most powerful corporations must play by the rules and respect the rights of consumers and developers alike.'
The case was heard over four months, finishing just over one year ago.
Fortnite has returned to the Apple app store in the US, and users can download via the Epic Games app store in Europe but the app still remains unavailable to download in Australia.
Apple was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
11 minutes ago
- The Sun
Drivers warned popular map app used by 130 MILLION is being discontinued on some mobiles as updates stop
DRIVERS have been issued a warning as a popular app used by 130 million motorists is being discontinued on some mobiles. Many drivers now choose to use smartphone navigation apps to help them find the best routes and avoid traffic jams. 1 However, users of Google owned app Waze, may soon be unable to access the latest software. The popular app is ending support for million of Android devices, with the newest versions of the app requiring devices to be running Android 10 or newer. This means that if your device runs Android 9 or older, you will not be able to download any new features or updates. This will also apply to any built in car screens that run on Android. Those with devices running Android 9 or lower will still be able to use the app, but over time it will become less and less reliable. Waze is often used by motorists for for real time traffic updates, that are sourced from Waze users. It also has features such as petrol price comparison, making it a popular alternative to Google Maps. Currently, only the beta version of Waze requires devices to be running Android 10. The beta version of the app is a preview version you can opt in to that allows you to see new features and updates before anyone else. However, when changes appear on the beta app, they are likely to end up on the regular version. Over 10 million Android users told to turn off devices after Google exposes 'infection' – exact list of models affected Android 10 was released back in 2019, but since there are billions of Android devices in use across the world, it is likely that may of them are still using Android 9. If your phone is still running on Android 9 or lower, you may want to think about purchasing a new mobile, as more apps are likely to also stop supporting these devices. More Android news This follows the news that Google has ended support for three Android devices. At the end of March, Google quietly ended support for Android 12 and Android 12L - this is the software that some devices run on. That means the Google Pixel 3a, Samsung Galaxy S10 series, and OnePlus 7 series will no longer receive security updates from Google, according to Android Authority. If there are future updates for affected phones, they will have to come directly from the manufacturers, Samsung and OnePlus. However, Samsung only offers seven years worth of security patches, and OnePlus typically offers three. People with phones still running Android 12 are advised to consider upgrading to a newer device.
Daily Mail
11 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Insane price for a burger sparks outrage: 'Is this a joke?'
Customers have blasted a $55 novelty hamburger at Brisbane 's iconic Ekka show, as organisers rushed to defend what some labelled a 'rort'. Hungry attendees took images of the Smash Burger stall menu at the Royal Queensland Show which advertised a special burger and chip deal for the eyewatering sum. The 'Blockbuster' burger was described as containing double beef patties, double smoky bacon, and liquid cheese, on a 'block bun', according to the menu. But the menu featured an image of a very ordinary looking hamburger. Viewers were quick to slam the price tag on line, with many labelling it a 'scam' and calling for a 'boycott'. 'Jesus Christ. No idea who would buy this,' one person wrote. 'What an absolute p***take,' another said. 'If anyone reading this paid $55 for one of these, you're a f***ing Idiot!' a third wrote. One viewer tried to work out what the burger was really worth using the optional extras' pricing. 'So an extra patty is $4. That means the two patties in the burger are $8. Bacon is $3, so with two slices, that's $6. We're up to $14 now. 'Gluten-free bun is $3, which is more expensive, so let's say the standard bun is $2. Another $2 for the cheese. Now we're at $18. So there must be $37 worth of lettuce, tomato, and sauce in that burger.' Another wrote she would have to be 'insane' to spend $55 on a burger, and would be expecting T-bone steaks for patties if she did. One said there were other more palatably-priced meals at the show. 'Plenty of good food at the Ekka for comparable prices to normal places this year (in my opinion). Though that's more the rest of the world got more expensive rather than the Ekka getting cheaper,' he wrote. But the festival quickly tried to quell consumer's doubts, as the real Blockbuster burger is far larger than the one pictured. 'It's huge... the burger is served in a hollowed half loaf of bread and is packed full of fillings,' a spokeswoman said. The meal has been designed for two people. One photo shared the event's social media accounts showed two children behind the burger which appeared to be about the same size as their heads. 'Visitors to the Ekka love trying new and wonderful food items… and the blockbuster burger certainly stands out among all the options available!' Officials estimate there are more than 110 food vendors at the showgrounds, several of which are offering food options $10 or less. The show has more than 400,000 visitors each year. 'By night's end, more than 70,000 people will have attended Ekka - the biggest People's Day crowd in almost 15 years,' the show's spokeswoman said.
Geeky Gadgets
40 minutes ago
- Geeky Gadgets
iPadOS 26 Beta 6: This is the Beta You've Been Waiting For
Apple's iPadOS 26 Beta 6 introduces a range of thoughtful updates aimed at enhancing the overall experience of using an iPad. This release focuses on improving key areas such as multitasking, onboarding, personalization, and visual design. While the changes may appear subtle at first glance, they collectively refine the operating system, making it more intuitive, efficient, and engaging for users. Each enhancement reflects Apple's commitment to delivering a seamless and user-centered experience. Here's a closer look at the updates in this release in a new video from SlatePad. Watch this video on YouTube. Smarter Multitasking for Enhanced Productivity Managing multiple tasks on your iPad has become more streamlined with the latest multitasking improvements. The multitasking feature, Exposé, now incorporates app icons at the bottom of each window. This seemingly small addition simplifies navigation by allowing you to quickly identify and switch between open windows. By aligning Exposé with the broader multitasking interface, Apple has created a more cohesive and efficient workflow. These updates are particularly beneficial for users who rely on their iPads for productivity, as they reduce unnecessary interruptions and make multitasking more intuitive. Whether you're juggling work documents, creative projects, or entertainment apps, the enhanced multitasking functionality ensures a smoother and more organized experience. Interactive Onboarding: A Dynamic Start For new users or those upgrading to iPadOS 26, the onboarding process has been completely reimagined. Instead of static instructional screens, you are now greeted with an interactive animation that highlights the operating system's key features. This dynamic approach not only captures your attention but also ensures you understand the most important updates from the outset. The new onboarding experience is designed to be both engaging and informative, making it easier for users to familiarize themselves with the latest enhancements. By presenting essential features in an interactive format, Apple has created a more user-friendly introduction to iPadOS 26, making sure that users can quickly adapt and take full advantage of the system's capabilities. Expanded Personalization with New Ringtone Options Personalization takes center stage in iPadOS 26 Beta 6 with the addition of several new ringtone variations. Building on the default 'Reflection' tone, Apple has introduced options such as 'Buoyant,' 'Dreamer,' 'Pond,' 'Pop,' 'Reflected,' and 'Surge.' These new tones provide greater flexibility for customizing your device's sound profile. Whether you prefer a calming tone to create a serene atmosphere or an energetic ringtone to keep you alert, there is now a wider selection to suit your preferences. This focus on personalization allows users to make their devices feel more tailored to their individual styles, adding a subtle yet meaningful layer of customization to the iPad experience. Refined Visual Design for a Cohesive Experience Apple continues to enhance the visual design of iPadOS with a series of subtle yet impactful updates. These refinements contribute to a more polished and cohesive aesthetic, making sure that every interaction feels intentional and seamless. Key visual updates include: Improved transparency effects on the lock screen, creating a sleeker and more modern appearance. on the lock screen, creating a sleeker and more modern appearance. Chromatic refraction effects in tab bars, adding a sophisticated touch to navigation elements. in tab bars, adding a sophisticated touch to navigation elements. Liquid glass effects applied consistently to toggle switches, enhancing their tactile and polished feel. applied consistently to toggle switches, enhancing their tactile and polished feel. Subtle animations in apps like Preview, improving the fluidity of interactions and transitions. While these updates may not be immediately noticeable, they collectively elevate the overall user experience. The attention to detail in these design elements reflects Apple's dedication to creating an operating system that is both functional and visually appealing. Incremental Refinements for Everyday Use Rather than introducing sweeping changes, iPadOS 26 Beta 6 focuses on incremental improvements that enhance usability and address minor pain points. This approach underscores Apple's strategy of perfecting the iPad experience through consistent, detail-oriented updates. By optimizing existing features and refining the user interface, Apple ensures that the iPad remains intuitive, reliable, and enjoyable to use. These incremental refinements are particularly valuable for users who rely on their iPads for both work and leisure. From smoother multitasking to more personalized settings and visually cohesive design updates, each enhancement contributes to a more seamless and satisfying experience. A Step Forward in Usability and Design iPadOS 26 Beta 6 exemplifies Apple's commitment to delivering a polished and user-focused operating system. The smarter multitasking features, interactive onboarding process, expanded ringtone options, and refined visual design all work together to enhance the overall usability of the iPad. While each change may seem small on its own, its combined impact is significant, demonstrating how attention to detail can elevate the user experience. With this release, Apple continues to position the iPad as a versatile and sophisticated tool for both productivity and entertainment. The thoughtful updates in iPadOS 26 Beta 6 ensure that the iPad remains a powerful and enjoyable device, meeting the needs of a diverse range of users. Take a look at other insightful guides from our broad collection that might capture your interest in iPadOS 26 Beta 6. Source & Image Credit: SlatePad Filed Under: Apple, Apple iPad, Top News Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
