NJ court questions Catholic diocese's bid to block seating of grand jury on clergy sex abuse
TRENTON, N.J. (AP) — Members of New Jersey's Supreme Court sounded skeptical at times Monday about the effort of a Catholic diocese to stop the state from empaneling a grand jury to investigate clergy sexual abuse allegations.
The high court is considering the state attorney general's appeal of lower court rulings that sided with the Diocese of Camden, finding the state cannot seat a grand jury to examine the church officials' behavior because they're not public officials.
The issue dates to a
Pennsylvania grand jury report
in 2018 that found more than 1,000 children had been abused in that state since the 1940s, prompting the New Jersey attorney general to announce a similar investigation.
But the results of New Jersey's inquiry never became public partly because a legal battle was unfolding behind closed doors amid sealed proceedings.
Then, this year the
Bergen Record obtained records
disclosing a trial court's judgment in favor of the diocese and revealing the diocese's objection to the grand jury. And in March, the Supreme Court ordered more documents in the case unsealed.
The core disagreement is over whether a court rule permits grand juries in New Jersey to issue findings in cases involving private individuals. Trial and appellate courts found for the diocese.
On Monday, members of the court repeatedly questioned whether challenging the state was premature since lower court proceedings prevented the state from seating a grand jury, which has not investigated any allegations or issued findings, called a presentment.
'We don't know what a grand jury would say, am I right?' Justice Anne Patterson asked the attorney for the diocese.
Lloyd Levenson, the church's attorney, answered that 'you'd have to be Rip Van Winkle' not to know what the grand jury would say.
'The goal here is obviously to condemn the Catholic Church and priests and bishops,' he said. He noted the state could still pursue criminal investigations and abuse victims could seek civil penalties.
The court didn't indicate when it would rule.
Mark Crawford, state director of Survivors Network for those Abused by Priests, attended Monday's hearing and said he thought the diocese was 'grasping at straws.'
'These victims want their story heard,' he said in an interview. 'They want to get in front of the grand jury and tell that story. They want some level of accountability and acknowledgement.'
An email message requesting comment was sent to the diocese.
Democratic state Sen. Joe Vitale, who pushed through the state's 2019 overhaul of its civil statute of limitations, also attended the hearing. He said he's hopeful the justices will side with the attorney general.
In 2023, a trial court judge sided with the diocese, finding that such a grand jury would lack authority because it would be focused on 'private conduct,' rather than a government agency's actions. An appeals court affirmed that judgment last year, and Attorney General Matt Platkin appealed to the state Supreme Court.
Documents the high court unsealed in March sketched out some of what the state's task force has found so far, without specific allegations. They show 550 phone calls alleging abuse from the 1940s to the 'recent past' came into a state-established hotline.
The diocese argues a grand jury isn't needed, largely because of a 2002 memorandum of understanding between New Jersey Catholic dioceses and prosecutors. The memorandum required church officials to report abuse and said authorities would be provided with all relevant information about the allegations.
But the Pennsylvania report touched off a reexamination of statute of limitations law in New Jersey, which
overhauled its civil statute of limitations
on childhood sex abuse claims in 2019. The new law allows child victims to sue until they turn 55 or within seven years of their first realization that the abuse caused them harm. The previous statute of limitations was age 20 or two years after realizing abuse caused harm.
Also in 2019, New Jersey's five
Catholic dioceses listed
more than 180 priests who have been credibly accused of sexually abusing minors over several decades. Many listed were deceased and others removed from ministry.
The Camden diocese, like others nationwide,
filed for bankruptcy
amid a torrent of lawsuits — up to 55, according to court records — after the statute of limitations was relaxed.
Then
in 2022, the diocese agreed
to pay $87.5 million to settle claims involving clergy sex abuse with some 300 accusers — one of the largest cash settlements involving the Catholic church in the U.S.
The agreement, covering six southern New Jersey counties outside Philadelphia, exceeded the nearly $85 million settlement in 2003 in the clergy abuse scandal in Boston, but was less than other settlements in California and Oregon.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
14 minutes ago
- Axios
D.C. schools are banning cellphones, joining almost half of the nation
D.C.'s public schools will enforce a cell phone ban starting next school year, the district said on Friday. Why it matters: D.C. joins nearly half the country in the bipartisan push to limit students' cellphone use in the classroom. D.C. middle schools and several of its high schools already implemented the ban, the district said. Catch up quick: Phone bans have gained momentum across Democratic and Republican state legislatures in recent years. Arizona, Arkansas and New York 's governors signed bills into law this year to implement bans. By the numbers: As of April, 11 statewide phone bans or restrictions were implemented and seven states issued policy recommendations, according to health nonprofit KFF. An additional 17 states introduced legislation to ban or restrict cellphone use in schools. State of play: The phone bans are aimed at boosting students' attention during class as they struggle to recover from COVID learning loss. Screen time is also partially at fault for a youth mental health crisis, research has found. What they're saying: "Piloting a phone-free program in our middle schools demonstrated that storing students' personal devices throughout the school day enriches academic, social, and emotional learning," Lewis Ferebee, D.C. schools chancellor, said in a statement. "From increased classroom engagement to reduced anxiety and stronger student relationships — DCPS is ready to scale the program so we can keep driving outcomes that positively impact our students." What we're watching: Sens. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) and Tim Kaine (D-Va.) reintroduced a bipartisan bill in February to study the effects of cellphones in schools, but the legislation has not seen movement since. The bill proposes $5 million annually for five years for a pilot program to provide schools with secure containers for the phones. It would allow exceptions for students with health conditions, disabilities and non-English speakers.
Los Angeles Times
22 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Trump administration asks Supreme Court to leave mass layoffs at Education Department in place
WASHINGTON — President Trump's administration on Friday asked the Supreme Court to pause a court order to reinstate Education Department employees who were fired in mass layoffs as part of his plan to dismantle the agency. The Justice Department's emergency appeal to the high court said U.S. District Judge Myong Joun in Boston exceeded his authority last month when he issued a preliminary injunction reversing the layoffs of nearly 1,400 people and putting the broader plan on hold. Joun's order has blocked one of the Republican president's biggest campaign promises and effectively stalled the effort to wind down the department. A federal appeals court refused to put the order on hold while the administration appealed. The judge wrote that the layoffs 'will likely cripple the department.' But Solicitor General D. John Sauer wrote Friday that Joun was substituting his policy preferences for those of the Trump administration. The layoffs help put in the place the 'policy of streamlining the department and eliminating discretionary functions that, in the administration's view, are better left to the states,' Sauer wrote. He also pointed out that the Supreme Court in April voted 5-4 to block Joun's earlier order seeking to keep in place Education Department teacher-training grants. The current case involves two consolidated lawsuits that said Trump's plan amounted to an illegal closure of the Education Department. One suit was filed by the Somerville and Easthampton school districts in Massachusetts along with the American Federation of Teachers and other education groups. The other suit was filed by a coalition of 21 Democratic attorneys general. The suits argued that layoffs left the department unable to carry out responsibilities required by Congress, including duties to support special education, distribute financial aid and enforce civil rights laws. Education Department employees who were targeted by the layoffs have been on paid leave since March, according to a union that represents some of the agency's staff. Joun's order prevents the department from fully terminating them, but none have been allowed to return to work, according to the American Federation of Government Employees Local 252. Without Joun's order, the workers were scheduled to be terminated Monday. Trump has made it a priority to shut down the Education Department, though he has acknowledged that only Congress has the authority to do that. In the meantime, Trump issued a March order directing Education Secretary Linda McMahon to wind it down 'to the maximum extent appropriate and permitted by law.' Trump later said the department's functions will be parceled to other agencies, suggesting that federal student loans should be managed by the Small Business Administration and programs involving students with disabilities would be absorbed by the Department of Health and Human Services. Those changes have not yet happened. The president argues that the Education Department has been overtaken by liberals and has failed to spur improvements to the nation's lagging academic scores. He has promised to 'return education to the states.' Opponents note that K-12 education is already mostly overseen by states and cities. Democrats have blasted the Trump administration's Education Department budget, which seeks a 15% budget cut including a $4.5 billion cut in K-12 funding as part of the agency's downsizing. Sherman writes for the Associated Press. AP writer Collin Binkley contributed to this report.
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The Latest: Combs' ex-girlfriend sobs while recounting ‘hotel nights' that lasted for days
NEW YORK (AP) — Sean 'Diddy' Combs ′ recent ex-girlfriend, testifying under the pseudonym 'Jane,' sobbed on the witness stand Friday while describing their many drug-fueled sex marathons, saying he ignored her when she signaled that she wanted to stop and chided her for crying after one of the encounters. The Latest: Lawyer asks judge to crack down on people who are trying to reveal Jane's identity Jane's lawyer Lindsay Lewis spoke up during a break in testimony while the jury was out of the courtroom. She said some media outlets and social media accounts have or are attempting to reveal Jane's identity. Judge Arun Subramanian didn't immediately act on Lewis' request. He asked her to send him any examples of concerning posts. Subramanian noted that there's little he can do about members of the public doing their own sleuthing to figure out Jane's identity based on what she's said on the witness stand. The judge previously warned reporters and members of the public observing the trial not to describe Jane in detail. He's also told sketch artists not to draw her. Jane was heartbroken when Combs flew to the Caribbean with another woman Soon after co-opting her birthday into a 'hotel night' in 2023, Combs jetted off to Turks and Caicos with another woman, Jane said. She told jurors she saw Instagram posts of Combs and the woman in the Caribbean archipelago, where they spent some of their earliest times together. 'It broke my heart because I just finished my birthday with these guys having sex with me,' Jane testified. Combs was planning the trip during her birthday celebration, which involved her having sex with three men, she said. In a text message, she told him: 'It feels like you used me to get off and then go away for a week.' Jane wrote a frustrated note to Combs but never sent it Irritated with the imbalance of their relationship, Jane poured her thoughts into the Notes app on her phone in November 2021, drafting a message to Combs but never sending it. 'I don't know what you're calling me for, but I'm sorry I don't want to do drugs for days and days and have you use me to fulfill your freaky, wild desires in hotel rooms,' Jane wrote in the unsent missive. Jane said she was tired of waiting for Combs to fulfill promises he'd made to her, such as date nights, togetherness, quality time and doing things she wanted to do — not the 'hotel nights' that had come to dominate their relationship. Jurors hear audio of Jane confronting Diddy about another woman In November 2021, Jane confronted Combs about cheating on her after she saw Instagram posts from a woman who was at his Miami-area estate. In an audio recording played in court, Combs explained that the woman had come to his house to work out. But Jane didn't buy that and responded that the woman had been there for days. Jane said she'd known that Combs was seeing other women, but the Instagram postings reinforced for her that he was giving another woman quality time she yearned for. She said she felt used, telling jurors that at the time she thought: 'It's not me that he wants. It's these nights.' Afterward, Jane said, Combs called her on FaceTime and calmed her down, repeating a pattern she said happened each time she objected to continuing with 'hotel nights.' Jane says the sex marathons caused her to suffer from back pain and UTIs Jane wiped away tears as she recounted the many ill-effects of 'hotel nights,' including constant back pain, frequent urinary tract infections and soreness in her genitals and pelvic areas. Combs' former longtime girlfriend, Cassie, testified she also suffered UTIs after enduring hours of sex during sex marathons involving Combs and male sex workers. Both women testified they were made to have sexual encounters before they were fully recovered from UTIs. Jane is shown photographs of herself and male sex workers during 'freak-offs' The images were not shown to the courtroom audience or on monitors in overflow courtrooms, in keeping with the judge's order barring evidence from being displayed to reporters and the public while Jane testifies. Jane says she arranged some of the 'hotel night' sex marathons Sometimes, it was a surprise to keep Combs happy, Jane said. Other times it was because he demanded it, she said. 'I knew it was to be expected,' she testified. 'He expected me to coordinate a night where we had an entertainer join us.' Combs would often ask for 'hotel nights' in a roundabout way, Jane said, relying on a type of code they'd developed. 'He didn't have to directly, specifically tell me to do things,' Jane said. 'If he said, 'I can't want to see what you have for me,' or something along those lines, I knew what task was being asked of me.' Jane felt obligated to continue doing 'hotel nights' for Combs Jane recalled another occasion where she told Combs she wasn't interested in sexual encounters with other men. On a trip to New York in 2023, she said she told him, 'I didn't want to do it anymore, these nights with these men.' Combs didn't listen, she said, and they proceeded with the encounter. Jane said she objected again in a subsequent conversation and Combs told her she didn't have to engage in such sexual encounters anymore. But Jane said she felt obligated. Just a few months earlier, she had moved into a home that was paid for by Combs. Jane told jurors she was apprehensive about going to New York in the first place because she worried Combs was trying to set up a 'hotel night.' Sure enough, on the flight, she said she received a text message from Combs asking: 'Do you want entertainment tonight?' Jane's testimony resumes Jane, who had been crying steadily when a lunch break was taken, returned composed to the witness stand after the hour-long break. The jury was brought into the Manhattan courtroom shortly afterward. And the prosecutor, Maurene Comey, resumed her questioning, which began Thursday. Immediately, Comey confronted her with a picture of one of the male sex workers. Jane says her longest 'hotel night' lasted three and a half days Cassie, Combs' girlfriend from 2007 to 2018, testified during the trial's first week that her hundreds of marathon 'freak-off' sessions with Combs and a male sex worker usually spanned multiple days in which she and Combs used drugs to stay awake. Jane testified Friday that her longest 'hotel night' with Combs and a male sex worker was three and a half days, while most went 24 to 30 hours. Jane said she relied on ecstasy to dull her senses. 'I just feel like I had to take them. When I wouldn't, it would feel too real, like the atmosphere,' Jane said. 'And I didn't want to feel like it was too real.' In a parallel to Cassie's testimony, Jane recalls how Combs ruined her birthday Jane said Combs brought her to have sex with sex workers on her birthday in 2023, even though she was hoping for time alone with Combs. Jane said she wasn't interested in having her birthday subsumed by Combs' fantasies. She said she turned into something of a robot, telling jurors, 'I would just tune out and kind of get like in a zone.' Jane said Combs' mood soured when she asked for a condom for the sex worker to use. Afterward, Jane said, Combs took her to another hotel suite, where he was loving and gave her cake and flowers. But then, Jane said, another male sex worker came into the suite. When they were finished, Jane said, a third man entered the room. It was 'just hours and hours of that,' Jane said. Combs held sex marathons just weeks before his arrest, Janes says Combs was continuing to have so-called 'freak-off' sex marathons as federal investigators were closing in on arresting him last year, Jane testified Friday. Jane said she was involved in sexual encounters with male sex workers at Combs' Miami-area estate as late as last August, just weeks before his arrest at a Manhattan hotel. Jane estimated there were about five such encounters between February 2024 and his arrest last September. None of them were in hotels, a frequent venue for activities she dubbed 'debauchery' and 'hotel nights.' Federal agents raided Combs' home on ritzy Star Island, along with his home in Los Angeles, in March 2024. Prosecutor focuses on allegations of sex trafficking and forced labor Prosecutor Maurene Comey has been deftly mixing in questions for Jane that cut to the heart of the case, including charges of sex trafficking and forced labor. As Jane was describing her many 'hotel nights' with Combs and paid sex workers, Comey asked her, 'who did the most work' during those encounters. 'It was all me, from just start to finish,' Jane testified. When asking Jane about recruiting a sex worker, Comey underscored the geographic scope of the alleged crimes. Jane testified that she'd booked flights to Los Angeles and New York for the Atlanta-based sex worker. One of Combs' charges is interstate transportation for purposes of prostitution. Later, Comey asked Jane about transporting drugs across state lines for Combs. Jane says she was Combs' drug mule on at least two occasions Jane described how she nervously smuggled pills in her checked luggage on commercial flights from Los Angeles to Miami. Jane said both times Combs asked her to 'pick up a package' at his Los Angeles mansion and bring it with her when she visited him at his Miami-area estate. Jane testified that she wasn't comfortable with the request, but Combs' chief of staff Kristina 'K.K.' Khorram told her: 'It's fine, I do it all the time.' Jane said she delivered the drugs to Combs and ended up using some of the drugs with him. Jane says Combs pressured her to continue having sex, even after vomiting Combs pledged to get clean from drugs in 2023, Jane said, but first wanted to have another of their 'hotel nights,' dubbing it a 'sobriety party.' Jane testified that she typically took drugs to get through the encounters, but abstained that night in a Beverly Hills hotel room as Combs ingested ecstasy and cocaine. After having back-to-back sex with two sex workers, she said, she felt sick and vomited in the bathroom. Jane said Combs came in and told her: 'That's good. You'll feel better now that you've thrown up. So let's go.' Jane then went back to the party and had sex with a third man, she said, telling jurors she was 'repulsed' and 'deeply regretted' doing it. 'I hated it so much,' she said. Prosecutor zeroes in on the control Combs had over Jane One of the prosecution's central arguments is that Combs coerced women to submit to his sexual fantasies by using his fortune to make them reliant on him. To bolster that claim, Prosecutor Maurene Comey had Jane read aloud texts in which she complained to Combs that it seemed that 'hotel nights' were 'the only reason you have me around and pay for the house.' She said in the messages that she was 'doing things that make me disgusted with myself.' Still, she expressed her love for Combs, saying in the messages that 'my heart is really in this and it's breaking.' By September 2023, Combs had been paying Jane's rent for about five months. Comey asked Jane what she feared would happen if she stopped doing hotel nights. 'That he would take it away, that Sean would take the house away,' Jane responded. It was then that Comey asked her how Combs responded to her messages. 'He said: 'Girl stop,'' Jane answered. Combs taps his fingers as Jane sobs As Jane broke into sobs talking about how she 'just really wanted my partner to get sober' when she tried to do a 'hotel night' without drugs in October 2023, Combs tapped his fingers against one of his legs, occasionally glancing toward the jury or his lawyers and away from Jane. Jane texted Combs that she wanted to stop having 'hotel nights' Jane tried to put an end to so-called 'hotel nights,' texting Combs in 2023 that she longed to return to the early days of their relationship, before the drug-fueled encounters started to dominate their time together. Jane told Combs that she felt obligated to perform for him and that she regretted ever getting involved in the encounters, writing: 'ever since I opened Pandora's box, I haven't been able to close it.' 'I don't want to keep feeling like that,' she wrote, telling Combs that she wanted them to 'talk like adults and figure out where we're going from here.' Combs responded: 'Girl, stop.' Jane sometimes leaned into Combs' fantasies even though she 'didn't like them' Jane acknowledged sending sexually explicit text messages to Combs between their hotel encounters, telling jurors she wanted to convey her love and interest in having sex with him — not strangers. At times, she said, she did lean into his fantasies, sending graphic messages describing what she said she wanted to do with sex workers while Combs watched. On the witness stand Friday, she said she sent those messages because she wanted to make him happy. In reality, she said, she wanted the encounters to stop. 'I didn't like them,' she said. 'I was realizing this was becoming the dynamic of what we were.' Jane says Diddy stopped condom use during 'hotel nights' Jane testified that Combs intervened to stop a man she identified as Don from using a condom, even after she requested it. The moment was captured in audio played for the jury. She said it happened during their first 'hotel night,' which Combs had arranged, and that he blocked condom use again in a later encounter. Jane testified that Combs 'guilt tripped me out of it. It wasn't something he wanted to see.' Prosecutors play audio of 'hotel night' encounter. Later, Jane breaks down sobbing Prosecutors played an audio tape in which Jane asked a man to wear a condom who was about to have sex with her. It was the first time jurors in the trial, now in its fourth week, heard any recording from what Jane has called 'hotel nights' and what Cassie called 'freak-offs.' During hotel nights, a male sex worker would have sex with Jane while Combs watched, according to testimony. Later in the testimony Friday morning, Jane broke into sobs as she described crying on two occasions during 'hotel nights' with Combs. In tears, Jane says Diddy ignored her resistance to group sex Jane wept as she told jurors how Combs ignored her 'subtle cues' that she wanted to stop engaging in sex acts during their drug-fueled 'hotel nights.' She said she'd tell him she was tired or hungry or make gestures and facial expressions indicating that she didn't want to continue. Combs, she said, would tell her to keep going and 'finish strong.' Asked by a prosecutor why she didn't tell him directly that she wanted to stop, Jane said, 'I just, I don't know,' as she cried loudly. Jane's second day of testimony starts with sexual topics Comey, the prosecutor, questioned Jane about sexual subjects right from the start on Friday, beginning with a trip Jane said she took with Combs to Las Vegas in 2023 when they had a 'hotel night' with an 'entertainer.' The prosecutor asked Jane if Combs ever used the word 'freak' with her. Jane said he would say 'he wants his freak.' She said she understood that to mean 'he wanted me to be wild and sexual.' Jane's description of 'hotel nights' has closely paralleled Cassie's earlier testimony about 'freak-offs' she had with male sex workers, under Combs' direction. Jane returns to the courtroom Jane is back to resume her direct examination by Assistant U.S. Attorney Maurene Comey. The jury has entered the room. Combs, wearing a dark sweater on Friday, is conversing with his lawyers and writing notes. The judge gave prosecutors a small victory prior to the resumption of testimony when he ruled that statements Jane made that cast a disparaging light on the sexual performances she endured during her three years of dating Combs can be used during her examination. Defense lawyers had argued they should be inadmissible. But the judge said the opening statement by the defense opened the way for admission of the exhibits because the defense asserted that Jane was a willing participant and that sexual activities were all consensual. Judge meets with attorneys before jury arrives As he has throughout the trial, Judge Arun Subramanian is meeting with prosecutors and defense lawyers in the courtroom on Friday before the jury is brought in so disputes about evidence can be settled. The judge also discussed efforts to improve the ability of Combs to communicate with his lawyers from the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, where he has been held since his September arrest. The Associated Press
