Put a fork in it: America First as a foreign policy doctrine is dead
Getting involved in that war — or even caring about it — seemed to ran counter to the 'America First' foreign policy Trump had long espoused.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
Until recently, American interest in that war was mostly indirect, shaped by higher global energy prices and the possibility that if Russia swallowed Ukraine, Putin would soon be at the doorstep of a NATO ally that the United States is obligated to defend. Beyond that, most Americans were insulated from the consequences.
Yet Trump's foreign policy involvement has gone far beyond Ukraine. He has personally stepped in to de-escalate tensions between Israel and Hamas, Syria, and Iran. He helped broker cease-fires between India and Pakistan, Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo, and Armenia and Azerbaijan.
Through it all, Trump has been clear about what motivates him: he wants a Nobel Peace Prize. He has not only said as much publicly but reportedly
Advertisement
The problem, of course, is that none of those conflicts were inherently about America or American interests. Which begs the question: what happened to being 'America First'?
The answer is that it is essentially dead. The doctrine has become yet another casualty of Trump's ever-shifting impulses, often changing with the last conversation he had or the latest shiny object to catch his attention.
The real break may have come when Trump decided to
For Trump, defending Israel has long been a priority. But if recent negotiations are any guide, he may now be prepared to extend a similar security umbrella to Ukraine as part of a larger peace deal.
This is the precise kind of global policeman role Trump had once promised to reject. The original appeal of 'America First' was that it provided a blueprint for a nation exhausted by decades of costly foreign wars. It was a slogan meant to reassure voters that US soldiers would no longer be sent into conflicts with little direct bearing on their lives.
Advertisement
When Trump entered his second term, America First was very much alive. USAID was gutted as was Voice of America. The integrated free trade status quo was out, and tariffs were in. Trump would no longer defer to other nations' self-determination automatically, but famously
But now, Trump has now positioned himself as the indispensable dealmaker for conflicts spanning multiple continents. His interventions may generate headlines and even, at times, reduce immediate bloodshed. But they also underscore the collapse of a once-defining principle of his political identity.
In the end, America First is not so much a foreign policy doctrine as it is a rhetorical relic, one that Trump has discarded when it no longer suited his ambitions. What remains is not a coherent worldview but a collection of improvisations driven by ego, optics, and the pursuit of personal glory.
What this means for the future of MAGA after Trump is very uncertain. There is an element of the base that certainly was drawn to this idea. But if there are Republicans who want to run for president in 2028 with more of an establishment view on foreign policy, they may no longer be perceived as out of touch.
The loss of America First may also may help explain why foreign leaders are so eager to flock to the White House these days. They know that, for all his bluster about putting America first, Trump is now putting himself at the center of the world stage.
And he is ready to change his mind again.
James Pindell is a Globe political reporter who reports and analyzes American politics, especially in New England.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
a minute ago
- The Hill
Texas Democrat abruptly leaves DNC call after being warned she's committing felony
A Texas Democratic state lawmaker abruptly left a call with Democratic National Committee (DNC) Chair Ken Martin and other top party leaders on Wednesday after she was warned she was committing a felony. 'Sorry, I have to leave,' state Rep. Nicole Collier (D) said at one point in the call, interrupting Martin. 'They said it's a felony for me to do this. Apparently I can't be on the floor or in a bathroom.' 'You told me I was only allowed to be here in the bathroom,' she told someone who was out of view of the camera. 'No, hold on – bye everybody, I've gotta go.' Collier was participating in the call from inside the Texas Capitol, where the state House was currently moving forward with a vote on a GOP-friendly House map. Democrats had initially fled Texas to block passage of the map, but returned earlier this week. Democrats who wanted to leave and come back to the Capitol in between when the House met could only do so after 'agreeing to be released into the custody of a designated DPS officer appointment under the rules of the House,' according to Texas House Speaker Dustin Burrows (R). They also have to sign a form saying they will come back to the state legislature. Collier declined to agree to the terms and instead has slept inside the state legislature in protest. It was not clear exactly what Collier did that constituted a felony, though the incident angered Democrats on the call. Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) blasted the news as 'outrageous,' saying 'Rep. Collier in the bathroom has more dignity than Donald Trump in the Oval Office,' said Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.). 'That is outrageous. What they're trying to do right there, is silence an American leader, silence a Black woman and that is outrageous,' he added.
The Hill
a minute ago
- The Hill
Texas GOP poised to pass new map
TEXAS REPUBLICANS are on the brink of passing newly drawn congressional maps to help the GOP win more House seats in the 2026 midterm elections after a grueling political battle that sparked a redistricting arms race across the country. The Texas state House convened Wednesday morning with plans to vote on a new bill to implement the map, which could help House Republicans win five more seats next year. The final vote had been delayed by several weeks after Texas Democrats fled the state to deny the legislature a quorum. The drama has continued since the Democrats returned this week, with public safety officers following the lawmakers around to ensure they don't skip town again. Several Democrats slept in the legislative chambers rather than be followed by law enforcement. NBC News reports Texas Republicans expedited the procedural process to bring up the final vote, which could happen as early as Wednesday evening. Once passed by the House, the bill will go to the state Senate, where it passed in the previous special session. From there, Gov. Greg Abbott (R) plans to sign it into law. There is little Texas Democrats can do to stop the bill's passage by the GOP majority, although they're trying to throw up roadblocks. Texas House Democratic Caucus Chair Gene Wu introduced an amendment that would allow a new House map to take effect only after U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi publicly releases files related to Jeffrey Epstein. State Rep. Chris Turner (D) proposed an amendment seeking to nullify the new map by arguing it violates the Voting Rights Act. That's not the only political fight happening in Texas. State Attorney General Ken Paxton 's lead over incumbent Sen. John Cornyn in the Senate Republican primary has been cut in half, according to a new survey from Texas Southern University's Barbara Jordan Public Policy Research and Survey Center. MEANWHILE IN CALIFORNIA… Republicans are suing to stop Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) from calling a special election to vote on new gerrymandered maps favorable to Democrats. California Democrats unveiled their newly drawn congressional maps on Tuesday, with the aim of picking up five House seats in 2026. Former President Obama praised Newsom's efforts at a Tuesday fundraiser on Martha's Vineyard. 'I believe that Gov. Newsom's approach is a responsible approach,' Obama said, according to remarks obtained by The Associated Press. 'He said this is going to be responsible. We're not going to try to completely maximize it. We're only going to do it if and when Texas and/or other Republican states begin to pull these maneuvers. Otherwise, this doesn't go into effect.' Newsom has grabbed the national spotlight for his retaliatory redistricting efforts and for co-opting President Trump 's style on his social media accounts. The Hill's Amie Parnes writes: 'In an effort to egg Trump on — and rally his own troops in the Democratic Party — Newsom has taken a page from Trump's playbook, mirroring everything from the president's rants to his social media habits cover.' Newsom is winning the attention wars, getting loads of media coverage that has helped propel him to the top of the Democratic presidential primary polls. A new survey from Politico finds Newsom at 25 percent support in California, followed by former Vice President Harris at 19 percent, former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg at 13 percent and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) at 10 percent. Many Democrats are thrilled to see Newsom fighting Trump. 'Standing up for Dem values doesn't mean you have to play by the old rules, and Newsom in particular is showing he'll go as low as he needs to to take on Trump,' said Democratic strategist Jamal Simmons. Still, Newsom's style has not been well-received everywhere. 'The Democrats are trying to find their footing and it's quite embarrassing, actually,' MSNBC host Joe Scarborough said Wednesday. 'Gavin Newsom, have you see what he's doing online? It's like, take a deep breath. Don't try to turn the ship 180 degrees. They don't know what to do. I have a good idea, instead of trying to school Donald Trump, talk into the camera about affordability. Talk about making groceries more affordable. Talk about what you'll do for housing. Talk about what you'd do for energy prices which keep going up.' MORE POLITICS… • The Democratic Party is facing a registration crisis, according to a new analysis from The New York Times: 'Of the 30 states that track voter registration by political party, Democrats lost ground to Republicans in every single one between the 2020 and 2024 elections — and often by a lot. That four-year swing toward the Republicans adds up to 4.5 million voters, a deep political hole that could take years for Democrats to climb out from.' • The Wall Street Journal reports that Elon Musk is pumping the brakes on launching his independent political party, in part because he's developed a friendship with Vice President Vance and might support his potential presidential campaign in 2028. 💡 Perspectives: • Washington Examiner: Is socialism as popular as the media think? • New Republic: Dem establishment's shunning of Mamdani is disqualifying. • New York Post: Newsom's desperate bid to claim the 'new Trump' mantle. • Racket: What's the point of selling Fannie and Freddie? • After Babel: We are rushing into the same mistakes with social media. Read more: • Trump's war on mail-in voting could boomerang on GOP. • Pesticides test MAHA-MAGA alliance. • Trump targets museums as last remaining segment of 'woke'. • Philanthropic organizations commit $37M to fund public media stations. • Education Department threatens funding for Northern Virginia schools over trans student policies. CATCH UP QUICK A federal judge rejected the Trump administration's bid to unseal grand jury materials used to charge disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein with sex trafficking, instead saying the government is the 'logical party' to make any sweeping disclosures. A federal judge tossed a defamation lawsuit against Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.) filed after she took to the House floor to accuse a man of being a predator. Bed, Bath & Beyond Chairman Marcus Lemonis announced Wednesday the store will no longer open retail stores in California, saying, 'This isn't about politics — it's about reality.' The Trump administration launched its first TikTok account, even as the fate of the social media app in the U.S. remains unclear. US, allies meet on Ukraine security guarantees U.S. and NATO military officials met Wednesday as they sought to hash out an agreement that provides Ukraine with future security guarantees against Russian aggression. 'Great, candid discussion among NATO Chiefs of Defence, today,' Adm. Giuseppe Cavo Dragone, NATO's military chief, posted on X. 'We are united, and that unity was truly tangible today, as always,' he added. President Trump has opened the door to U.S. involvement in securing Ukraine, although he's ruled out NATO membership and U.S. boots on the ground. Secretary of State Marco Rubio is leading the U.S. efforts on Ukrainian security. NBC News reports that Gen. Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, hosted several European Chiefs of Defense on Tuesday evening to discuss the matter. Trump reportedly called Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban this week to to win his support for Ukraine to join the European Union (EU). However, Russia said Wednesday that discussions around Ukrainian security guarantees are a 'road to nowhere' unless Moscow is involved in the talks. 'This will not work,' said Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov. A day earlier, Lavrov signaled Moscow would slow-walk a potential meeting between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, even as the White House says Putin already agreed to it. The Trump administration is working to secure the meeting between the two leaders, with Trump set to join a trilateral meeting, if that goes well. 'I thought it would be better if they met without me, just to see,' Trump said in an interview on 'The Mark Levin Show.' 'I want to see what goes on. You know, they had a hard relationship, very bad, very bad relationship.' Meanwhile, the summits Trump has been holding have put his threats of new sanctions against Russia on ice. Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) posted on X earlier this week that Congress is ready to pass sanctions if Trump says the word. Israel is preparing to take over Gaza City. 'I instruct you to use all tools and all power to strike the enemy until it is subdued, and to protect I.D.F. soldiers,' Defense Minister Israel Katz told troops in a statement released by the military. The Wall Street Journal reports that Israel called up 60,000 reservists ahead of the invasion. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is considering a new ceasefire proposal that Hamas has reportedly agreed to. In the interview with Levin, Trump described both himself and Netanyahu as war heroes. 'Bibi is a good man. He's in there fighting. He's fighting. You know, they're trying to put him in jail on top of everything else. How about that?' Trump said. 'He's a war hero, because we work together. He's a war hero. I guess I am, too.' The Trump administration announced Wednesday it would impose sanctions on four members of the International Criminal Court, saying they are engaged in efforts to unjustly 'investigate, arrest, detain, or prosecute' Americans and Israelis. 💡 Perspectives: • New York Post: Trump redefines what it means to be commander-in-chief. • The Guardian: There is no Trump doctrine. Only chaos. • The Australian: Albanese's Palestine call comes at worst time for allies. • The Hill: Palestinians deserve a state. • BIG: Data centers aren't the main villain behind higher electric bills. Roundup: Trump officials probe DC crime stats The Justice Department launched an investigation into Washington, D.C. 's crime reporting data after Trump accused local officials of understating the severity of crime in the nation's capital. The investigation comes amid the president's surge of troops in D.C. for what he's described as a public safety emergency. The District's own crime data shows a decline in crime following a spike in 2023. Last month, a D.C. police commander was suspended for allegedly manipulating data to make it seem that crime had fallen. A new poll finds that a strong majority of residents in Washington oppose Trump's takeover of the police department. Still, the Trump administration is relishing the fight. Vice President Vance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller visited Union Station on Wednesday to meet with National Guard troops stationed there. Miller railed against what he called 'stupid white hippies' who were at Union Station protesting the crackdown. Vance praised what he described as progress in cleaning up the historic train hub. 'I think Union Station is a great example of what's possible when you actually have the political willpower to bring law and order and common decency back to the public spaces of the United States of America,' he said. • Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard revoked the security clearances of 37 current and former intelligence officials, many of them from the Biden administration. 'Being entrusted with a security clearance is a privilege, not a right,' Gabbard posted on X. 'Those in the Intelligence Community who betray their oath to the Constitution and put their own interests ahead of the interests of the American people have broken the sacred trust they promised to uphold. In doing so, they undermine our national security, the safety and security of the American people and the foundational principles of our democratic republic.' Gabbard previously revoked clearances for former President Biden, former Secretary of State Antony Blinken, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, former Vice President Kamala Harris, former Rep. Liz Cheney (R-Wyo.) and former Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.), among others. • Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), the former chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, created a legal defense fund as he prepares to fight a Trump administration investigation into the purchase of his Maryland home. Trump has accused Schiff of illegally obtaining favorable lending terms. Schiff denies the allegations. 'It's clear that Donald Trump and his MAGA allies will continue weaponizing the justice process to attack Senator Schiff for holding this corrupt administration accountable,' Marisol Samayoa, a spokesperson for Schiff, said in a statement. 'This fund will ensure he can fight back against these baseless smears while continuing to do his job.' • Trump on Wednesday called for the resignation Federal Reserve governor Lisa Cook following allegations by the head of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) that she committed mortgage fraud. FHFA Director William Pulte wrote on social media Wednesday morning that Cook had designated two of her houses as her primary residences. 'Lisa D. Cook, committed mortgage fraud by designating her out-of-state condo as her primary residence, just two weeks after taking a loan on her Michigan home where she also declared it as her primary residence,' he said. Trump called for Cook to step down shortly after.
Boston Globe
a minute ago
- Boston Globe
With higher education under attack, some faculty members leaving field
Seemingly relentless attacks and funding cuts since the start of Donald Trump's second presidential term have been 'the straw that broke the camel's back,' said Cossette, who left higher education on the eve of the pandemic, in 2019. 'I'm hearing from a lot more people that it's too much.' Advertisement An exodus appears to be under way of Ph.D.s and faculty generally, who are leaving academia in the face of political, financial and enrollment crises. It's a trend federal data and other sources show began even before Trump returned to the White House. On top of Advertisement Nearly 70 percent of people receiving doctorates were already As for faculty, more than a third of provosts reported 'People who can get out will get out,' said L. Maren Wood, director and CEO of the Center for Graduate Career Success, which works with doctoral and other graduate students at 69 colleges and universities If the spree of general job-switching that followed Covid was dubbed 'the Great Resignation,' Wood said, what she's seeing now in higher education is 'the Great Defection.' Getting a Ph.D. is a traditional pipeline to an academic career. Now some of the brightest candidates — who have spent years doing cutting-edge research in their fields to prepare for faculty jobs — are leaving higher education or signing on with universities abroad, Wood said. 'It's going to affect the quality of a student's experience if they don't get to study with those leading minds, who are going into private industry or to other countries,' she said. 'What's the joke about those who can't do, teach? You don't want to be in a situation where the only people left in your classrooms are the ones who can't do anything else.' Advertisement Parents sending children to college in the fall should know that they'll be taking classes 'with a faculty member who is worried about his or her research funding and who doesn't have the help of graduate student teaching assistants. And that's really going to impact the quality of your student's experience,' said Julia Kent, a vice president at the Council of Graduate Schools, who conducts research about Ph.D. career pathways. 'The quality of undergraduate education is at stake here,' Kent said. Even Ph.D.s who want to work in academia are being thwarted. During the Great Recession and the pandemic — two recent periods when there were few available faculty jobs — doctoral candidates could continue their studies until things got better, Wood said. This time, the Trump administration's cuts to research funding have stripped many of that option. 'This is way worse' than those earlier crises, she said. 'Doctoral students are in panic mode.' The same deep federal cuts mean doctoral candidates in science, technology, engineering, math and other fields can't complete the research they need to be eligible for what few academic jobs do become available. 'You're basically knee-capping that younger generation, which undermines the intergenerational dynamism that takes place in higher education. And that trickles down into the classroom,' said Isaac Kamola, an associate professor of political science at Trinity College and head of the Center for the Defense of Academic Freedom at the American Association of University Professors, or AAUP. Doctoral candidates early in their programs are questioning whether they should stay, said Wood. That could reduce the supply of future faculty. So will the fact that some universities have Advertisement 'Our graduating students right now are thinking differently about what it means to start a doctorate,' Burke said. Meanwhile, he said, 'all the things that were dismaying to many faculty of long standing just feel worse. People who would have been totally content to stay put, whose prospects were good, who had good positions, who were more or less happy — now they're thinking hard about whether there's a future in this.' That means undergraduates could experience fewer available classroom professors and teaching and graduate assistants or the 'only tenuous presence of faculty who are thinking hard about going somewhere else,' he said. 'There are going to be programs that are going to be shut. There are going to be departments running on fumes.' The route to a university faculty job has always been hard. Finishing a doctoral degree takes a median of Doctoral students who manage to finish their programs have always had to fight for faculty positions, even before institutions announced cutbacks and hiring freezes. Universities enroll far more doctoral candidates, to provide cheap labor as teaching and research assistants, than they will ever hire. The number of doctoral degrees awarded Advertisement With colleges and universities under stress, still more doctoral candidates now face the prospect of spending years 'training for a career that isn't actually available,' said Ashley Ruba, a Ph.D. who left higher education to work at Meta, where she builds virtual reality systems. 'If you told someone going to law school that they couldn't get a job as a lawyer, I don't think they'd do it,' said Ruba, who is also the founder of People already in faculty jobs appear equally on edge. More than 1 in 3 said in a recent survey that People with The proportion of faculty considering leaving their jobs who are looking for work outside of academia has spiked. Before the pandemic, it was between 1 and 8 percent each year. Since then, it has been between 11 and 16 percent, according to R. Todd Benson, executive director and principal investigator at the Collaborative on Academic Careers in Higher Education at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, or COACHE. The figure comes from Advertisement A Facebook group of dissatisfied academics, called 'It's difficult to overcome the stereotype of a university professor, which is that they're coddled, they're overprivileged, they're arrogant and just enjoying total job security that nobody else has,' said Kelsky, who also wrote 'The Professor Is In: The Essential Guide to Turning Your Ph.D. Into a Job,' a second edition of which is due out this fall. Today, 'they are overworked. They're grossly underpaid. They are being called the enemy. And they're bailing on academia,' she said. 'Every time I talk to a tenured professor, they tell me how miserable they are and how desperate they are to get out,' said Kelsky. 'And there's no way this isn't having real-life, tangible impacts on the quality of education students are getting.' Contact writer Jon Marcus at 212-678-7556, or jpm.82 on Signal. This story about people with Ph.D.s leaving was produced by , a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. Sign up for our . Listen to our .
