We may be waiting weeks for a result in the seat of Calwell – the most complex ever counted in an Australian election
The winner is clear in most House of Representatives seats, one week after the election. But with a record number of votes for minor parties and independents, Australia's preferential voting system has been under increasing strain, with the full complexity of the counting system needed to determine the last few seats.
One seat, Calwell, may take weeks to determine and has been described by the acting deputy commissioner of the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) as 'one of the most complex distributions of preferences we've ever done'.
The House of Representatives electoral system involves a series of rounds of counting. The lowest-polling candidate is knocked out first, and their preferences are distributed among the other candidates, adding to their total vote. The same happens with the next lowest-polling candidate, and so forth.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Eventually you are left with two candidates, one of which has a majority of votes. But those are not necessarily the two that receive the most primary votes – where some candidates are very close on primaries, the preferences of eliminated candidates can change the picture as the count unfolds.
The final distribution of preferences usually happens long after the gaze of public attention has moved on, with the winners already clear. The AEC picks the two candidates likely to come first and second, and on election night it distributes all preferences between those two. Usually the commission gets it right, and those results can be called very quickly.
But the increasing presence of minor parties and independents polling a substantial share of the vote has made it harder to work out which candidates will end up as the top two, and in a number of seats it remains unclear after election day.
In the Victorian seat of Calwell, Labor's Basem Abdo won 30.6% of the primary vote, with the Liberal candidate second on 15.6%. If this was a standard Labor-Liberal contest, Abdo would win comfortably with 66% after preferences.
But that may not be the result. There are two independents not far behind the Liberal on the primary vote, with 12.1% and 11.3% respectively. Then there are a further nine candidates with over 30% of the vote between them.
It is entirely possible that one of those two independents will gain enough preferences to overtake the Liberal candidate and make the final two, but we don't know which one. We also don't know how they would perform in a head-to-head race against Abdo. The full distribution of preferences cannot commence until all postal and absentee votes are returned next week.
The AEC's acting deputy electoral commissioner, Kath Gleeson, said of Calwell: 'That's going to go to a complete distribution of preferences, and we anticipate that's going to be one of the most complex distribution of preferences we've ever done.
'I fully expect that will go well into week five depending on how we track through. We'll have absolute guns on that count given the complexity.'
Calwell – with four candidates still capable of finishing in the top two – is an extreme outlier in this election, but there are numerous other seats where the order of the top three remains unclear. To help clarify matters, the AEC has begun conducting 'three-candidate-preferred' (3CP) counts, where all preferences are allocated between the top three candidates. The AEC used this process for the first time in 2022 in just two seats. This time around it has needed to apply it in at least 10 electorates.
In the Queensland seat of Ryan, the Greens MP Elizabeth Watson-Brown was leading her Labor rival for second place on the 3CP by less than 700 votes as of Tuesday morning. Whichever candidate makes the top two will then gain the other's preferences and easily win the seat over the LNP.
In the seats of Flinders, Fisher and Grey there is still uncertainty about whether Labor or an independent will make the top two against the Liberal. If the independent comes second there is a chance they could win, although they would need an exceptionally strong flow of preferences from Labor. If Labor comes second, the Liberal will win.
There is only one seat uncalled due to a close race between just two candidates: Longman in south-east Queensland, where the sitting LNP member was less than 200 votes ahead on Tuesday, with a few thousand special votes left to be counted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
How another Labor immigration blunder has allowed a vile child sex offender to remain in Australia
The Albanese government took too long to scrap the visa of a migrant who performed an indecent act in front of a child, so he can stay in Australia, a court has ruled. The Federal Court decision is the latest in a string of immigration policy blunders to weigh on the party since 2023 - causing ex-Immigration Minister Andrew Giles to be demoted - though it seems it didn't harm Labor's performance at the March election. Federal Court judge Christopher Horan found a decision to deport the man, known as XMBQ, was unlawful because there was an 'unreasonable' delay between the appeals tribunal deciding the man could stay and termination of his visa. The ruling, first reported by The Australian, could set a precedent requiring immigration ministers to make decisions within a particular timeframe. Giles - now replaced by Tony Burke - previously came under fire for being caught off guard by the High Court's ruling in November 2023 that indefinite immigration detention was illegal, resulting in the release of more than a hundred criminals. Later, he was criticised over his Ministerial guideline, known as Direction 99, that stated a migrant's family connections to Australia and how long they have lived here should be considered in potential deportation cases, despite a criminal's rap sheet. Giles moved to cancel dozens of visas after it emerged that violent offenders were using the measure to avoid deportation. In the latest case XMBQ, a Somali man, had convictions for kicking a police officer in the face and performing a sex act in front of a 29-year-old woman and a 13-year-old girl on public transport. Lawyers for XMBQ challenged whether the former Immigration Minister's intervention in his case was legal. Giles cancelled the Somali man's visa on June 8, 2024 after the Administrative Appeals Tribunal decided he should be allowed to stay in April 2021. Justice Horan said the delay between the appeal and Giles's decision was far too long, ruling in the favour of XMBQ. 'If the minister is to exercise the power to set aside the original decision and cancel the visa, the minister must do so within a reasonable time,' the judgment said. 'Otherwise, the connection with the original decision as the object of the power will be lost, and it can no longer be said that the minister is addressing or responding to the state of affairs produced by or resulting from the original decision.' Immigration law specialist Simon Jeans said that although Giles had the power to cancel this visa it 'was a risk' and a 'decision [made] in haste' as he was under pressure to save his job. He suggested it would have been less risky for the Immigration Department to cancel XMBQ's visa rather than the minister intervening. XMBQ was born in Somalia in the 1960s before fleeing to Lebanon in 1993. He arrived in Australia as a refugee in 2004. XMBQ was placed on the sex offenders register for 15 years after pleading guilty to the public exposure charges in June 2017. In December 2017, his visa was cancelled by a delegate of the immigration minister but this was later overturned in the Federal Court. Lawyers for the man claimed Giles's decision to cancel his visa had been impacted by XMBQ being charged with two counts of rape, although he was not convicted. Justice Horan rejected this claim. The Albanese government and Mr Giles suffered a similar blow in January this year when a Bhutan-born man who attacked his wife with a meat cleaver was allowed to remain in Australia by the Federal Court. It ruled Mr Giles had made multiple 'jurisdictional errors' by overturning an appeals decision that the man could remain in Australia, because he did not consider the effect of deportation on his children and his stateless person status.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Tasmanians face a fourth election in seven years – but here are two alternatives to fix the political impasse
After a week of drama, the political future of Tasmania could look starkly different by the end of today. The state may be about to get its fourth election in seven years. But there are a couple of alternatives to consider. Let's walk through them. On Tuesday last week, the state opposition leader, Dean Winter, surprised many by moving a motion of no confidence in the Liberal premier, Jeremy Rockliff. The motion was tabled at the end of a budget supply speech. The motion was ostensibly about the budget, arguing Rockliff had wrecked the state's finances, planned to sell public assets and had mismanaged a crucial ferries project. The Greens supported Labor's motion, but unsuccessfully pushed for it to also touch on the government's response to gambling harm and the proposed AFL stadium. After days of debate, the motion succeeded by a razor-thin margin: 18-17. This appears the most likely outcome. After the vote on Thursday, Rockliff said he planned to visit the state's governor on Tuesday to request a statewide poll. But this won't happen until some important business is taken care of. State parliament will resume on Tuesday morning to pass routine supply bills that are essential to keep government departments running. If an election is called later in the day, then Rockliff would lead the Liberal party. The date of any potential election is not yet known. Potentially. The governor, Barbara Baker, is not obliged to accept Rockliff's request. She could adopt two alternatives. Baker could instead request the Liberal party room elect a different leader to avoid an election just 15 months after the last state poll. On Monday, some Liberal party figures were quoted in the Mercury calling for Rockliff to resign and be replaced by the former senator Eric Abetz. Guy Barnett and Michael Ferguson have also been touted as potential leaders. But so far, Rockliff has refused to resign and the party room has expressed its support for him. Baker could also ask the Labor opposition to test its numbers and seek support from a collection of minor parties and independents. Theoretically, this is possible. At the last election, Tasmanians elected 14 Liberals, 10 Labor, five Greens, three MPs from the Jacqui Lambie Network (JLN) and three independents. Some call this a rainbow parliament, others call it chaos. But Winter has repeatedly ruled out a power-sharing arrangements with the Greens, despite the minor party being a willing participant. So this appears unlikely. The AFL's proposed stadium is a controversial issue in Tasmania but both the Liberals and Labor remain committed to its construction. One of the conditions set by the AFL for a new team in Tasmania was a roofed stadium, but the expensive project – set to cost about $1bn – faces opposition from some in Tasmania, who instead have called for the money to be spent elsewhere. If an election is called, the stadium would be central issue along with the state's finances and help shape the outcome of the next parliament. An election is likely to delay parliamentary approvals for the stadium for several months. These delays could cost the state government if approval is ultimately granted and the Tasmanian team is forced to play at Bellerive Oval, as it would need to pay fines to the AFL.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Politics and ‘free media' can meet demands of moment, Albanese to say, after journalist shot with rubber bullet in US
Anthony Albanese says government and democratic institutions 'including a free media' can meet the demands of global uncertainty, despite both facing growing attacks around the world. A day after an Australian journalist was shot with a rubber bullet while covering street protests in Los Angeles, the prime minister will use an address to the National Press Club to argue distrust can be countered through economic stability and keeping election promises. 'It is the more corrosive proposition that politics and government and democratic institutions, including a free media, are incapable of meeting the demands of this moment. 'Some simply dismiss such sentiment. Others cynically seek to harvest it. Our responsibility is to disprove it.' Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Days ahead of a visit to the US and Canada for the G7 summit and possible face-to-face talks with Trump, Albanese will say Labor's success in improving Medicare, increasing educational attainment and managing the economy matters for trust in democracy. Emboldened by a stronger-than-expected win in the 3 May election, Albanese has spent the subsequent four weeks reshuffling his frontbench and touring disaster areas. As planning for his second term continues, he is expected to outline immediate priorities for the return of parliament on 22 July and speak about his approach to Trump's growing tariff regime. Albanese will say the government plans to offer a stronger and fairer country, with strength in manufacturing, renewable energy and 'urgent necessities', and reduce frustration through better provision of government services. 'To recognise that some of this frustration is drawn from people's real experience with government - be it failures of service delivery, or falling through the cracks of a particular system,' the preview of his speech reads. Albanese is expected to use Australia's critical minerals and rare earths as a bargaining chip with the US, offering preferred access in a bid to secure exemptions from steel and aluminium tariffs from Trump. The UK government has secured an exemption from 50% tariffs introduced by Trump, through a deal signed with the US last month. Albanese's speech highlights Australia has a 'comparative advantage' from space to to co-locate refining and processing, as well as specialist manufacturing and data centres. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Negotiations about a meeting between Albanese and the US president on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Alberta are continuing this week. So far, the pair have only spoken over the phone. The opposition leader, Sussan Ley, will address the Press Club on 25 June to outline a new style of Liberal party leadership that is more consultative, inclusive and collaborative. Peter Dutton shunned the traditional forum to speak to journalists in Canberra during his three-year tenure as opposition leader. Ley's speech is expected to reveal how the Coalition will rebuild from its election drubbing, with a focus on the values and priorities that will guide her leadership. 'Aspiration is the thread that connects every single part of Australian society and by focusing on that, the Liberal party can once again earn the trust of communities across the country,' Ley said in a statement.
