Ombudsman warns telcos to help in poor services areas after 3G shutdown
Cynthia Gebert released her department's first quarter report, which showed that while complaints to the ombudsman about the 3G network had fallen, the issues that remained were complex.
"Particularly in rural and regional settings, where farm operations are impacted, people who need it to operate a small business [and] we have heard circumstances of unreliable service creating life-threatening situations," she said.
Ms Gebert said people had become reliant on phones and connectivity, not just to communicate over the phone.
"Things like medical alert devices, farming equipment, all those sorts of things; they are so important now and people have built lives, communities and businesses around it," she said.
"It's creating all sorts of challenges when they can't be reliant on that."
The data showed complaints to the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman about service providers were up 6.9 per cent in the first three months of 2025, with 25.3 per cent about poor mobile phone coverage, while reports of financial hardship increased by 72 per cent.
The hardship reports included telcos refusing payment plans and disconnecting or suspending phone and internet services.
"Telcos still have work to do in terms of providing tailored support and repayment options for people that reflect their individual circumstances," Ms Gebert said.
The town of Bingara in the north-west of New South Wales has a population of 1,300.
Local accountant Sam Groth said congestion issues resulted in little or no service, even in the centre of town.
"I can be having a coffee with someone in the main street and when we go to open up an email and click on an online link, you just get the wheel of death," he said.
"I get complaints daily from clients who can't even scan a document and email it back."
Mr Groth said EFTPOS services had been intermittent, and text messages and phone calls often did not come through or dropped out, which had a detrimental effect on the town.
"You've got travellers coming through and if they can't connect, that affects your reputation as a tourism provider," he said.
He believed money needed to be spent on increasing the capacity of the tower, but suspected Telstra did not want to spend it on the small town.
"There's not enough subscribers to invest in the infrastructure," he said.
Mr Groth said he had clients running large agricultural businesses who were having significant problems, but complaints to Telstra were getting nowhere.
"Their response has been, 'There are no outages, there is no problem recorded at the tower,'" he said.
In a statement, Telstra regional general manager Chris Taylor said there were plans to upgrade the Bingara site later this year to increase capacity, as well as deliver 5G to the town for the first time."The site can currently get busy during peak periods like the school holidays and this upgrade should help deliver a much better experience all year round," a Telstra spokesperson said.
Farmer Bruce Kreutzberger lives on a property 20 kilometres from Walla Walla in the Riverina region of NSW.
When the 3G network was switched off, he lost phone service at his home and took to driving up a nearby hill to get line-of-sight access to a signal from the nearest Telstra tower.
Mr Kreutzberger later bought a new "blue tick" mobile phone — certified to give superior coverage in rural and regional areas — which he said improved things.
"My new phone shows no bars of signal, but I can actually make a call at the house," he said.
But Mr Kreutzberger said he had experienced congestion issues in his area as well.
He said he had given up complaining about the issue.
Mr Taylor said individual reception could be affected by the handset customers were using and the topography of the region.
"Our 4G coverage is available in and around Walla Walla but the surrounding terrain and vegetation in the area can affect it in some parts," he said.
Mr Taylor said Telstra was also working on plans to upgrade both sites to provide additional capacity and to deliver 5G.
Telstra, Optus and Vodaphone shut down their 3G networks in 2024 to use that spectrum to improve 4G and 5G services, but the ombudsman said she had not seen any signs of improvement yet.
"It's something we're keeping an eye on because … if it doesn't fulfil those expectations, that leads to a lot of frustration," she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
27 minutes ago
- ABC News
Can Jim Chalmers reap a healthy crop with the help of his big worm farm?
One observer describes next week's economic roundtable this way: "Chalmers has opened a can of worms — and everybody has got a worm." Even those close to the roundtable are feeling overwhelmed by the extent of the worm farm. There are many hundreds of submissions, five Productivity Commission reports, Treasury background papers, and stakeholders in the media spruiking their opinions ahead of the event. Business, unions and the welfare sector have largely settled into their predictable wish lists. In areas such as the housing crisis, it's actually not difficult to say what should be done — you hardly need this meeting to tell you. It just seems near impossible to get the relevant players (whether they be states, local councils, the construction industry) to do it, or be able to do it. On issues of deregulation generally, when it comes to specifics, a lot is contested. As the ACTU's Sally McManus, who'll be at the roundtable, says, "one person's regulations are another person's rights". As much as Treasurer Jim Chalmers might like to project the sunny side of Australia's situation, independent economist Chris Richardson (who will be at the summit's day three tax session) puts it more bluntly. "We have a problem: the average Australian saw their living standards rise by just 1.5% over the past decade," he posted on X. "That's embarrassingly shy of the 22% lift in living standards enjoyed across the rich world as a whole, and way below what Australians achieved in times past. "You'd have hoped that both sides would have talked about tackling that challenge at the last election, but they didn't." Richardson is hoping the roundtable can achieve "enough consensus to change some things", which the government can use as a springboard. But he's worried the meeting could underperform, given its "lead-up hasn't seen much consensus", Economist Richard Holden from UNSW says to be successful, the roundtable needs to get "broad agreement on some version of the 'Abundance agenda' [a reference to a currently fashionable book focusing on loosening regulatory blocks] — especially as it applies to housing. "In addition, to be successful would require that big issues like federation and tax reform are referred to Treasury for serious consideration and to present the government with options by year's end." There are two approaches for a government that wants to promote economic reform. It can, as then-treasurer Paul Keating did at the 1985 tax summit, put up a model and see how much it can make fly. Or it can, as Chalmers is doing, ask a wide range of participants for their ideas, and then decide how much of what emerges to pursue — in terms of what has wide support and what fits the government's agenda. The closer we get to the meeting, the harder it becomes to anticipate its likely import (or lack of). Signposts are there, but they could be false signals, or ignored later. Despite all the talk about tax, the government — specifically the prime minister — has flagged it doesn't have the stomach for radical reform. Certainly not this term. Anthony Albanese said last week, "The only tax policy that we're implementing is the one that we took to the election." This doesn't rule out new initiatives this term — the phrasing is carefully in the present tense — but from what we know of the PM's approach they would likely be limited rather than sweeping. Independent economist Saul Eslake said that a few weeks ago, he was optimistic the summit would give Chalmers the licence to spend some of the vast political capital the election yielded. "But the prime minister has made it clear he is not getting that licence. The government is not prepared to venture much beyond its limited mandate from the election. "The best that can be hoped for is a willingness to have an adult conversation with the electorate between now and the next election with a view to seeking a bold mandate in 2028," Eslake says. Predictably, the roundtable is putting the spotlight on the Albanese-Chalmers relationship. This can be summed up in a couple of ways. The PM is more cautious when it comes to economic reform, the treasurer is more ambitious. In political terms, it's that "old bull, young bull" syndrome. The different styles are clear. The "old bull" is blunt, sounding a touch impatient, for example, when he's asked about tax. The "young bull" is publicly deferential to his leader. One of the most potentially significant discussions at the roundtable will be around AI. Unlike many well-worn issues, this is a relatively new, and quickly changing, area of policy debate. There are varying views within government about whether firm or light guardrails are needed and whether they should be in a separate new act or just via changes to existing laws. Chalmers is in favour of light-touch regulation. The unions are not on the same page as Chalmers's regulatory preference, and they want a say for workers. The unions were the winners from the 2022 jobs and skills summit — the government delivered to them in spades at the meeting, and later. It's not clear they are in as strong a position this time. Their big claim for the roundtable — a four-day working week — has already been dismissed by the government. The ACTU doesn't seem much fussed by the rejection — it is on a long march on that one. Regardless of the diversity of views among those rubbing shoulders in the cabinet room next week, one man will stand out as something of an oddity. Ted O'Brien, shadow treasurer, invited as a participant, will be as much an observer. O'Brien might say he wants to be constructive, but his role means he will want to be critical. But he has to tread carefully. Others in the room, and outside observers, will be making judgements about him. For O'Brien, the gathering should be a networking opportunity more than an occasion for performative display. Michelle Grattan is a professorial fellow at the University of Canberra and chief political correspondent at The Conversation, where this article first appeared.
ABC News
27 minutes ago
- ABC News
Parliamentary inquiry to probe Cook government's anti-'NIMBY' planning laws
A newly established parliamentary inquiry will scrutinise a controversial West Australian planning pathway used by developers vying to build multi-million-dollar projects. Backed by the Legislative Council on Tuesday, the inquiry will focus on WA's significant development pathway, which allows developers of major projects to sidestep local council approval. Opposition and crossbench MPs backed the committee over the Cook government's objections. Planning Minister John Carey accused the opposition and crossbench of being "anti-development", saying the system had allowed for the approval of $5 billion worth of projects. "They're proposing reforms that will put a critical handbrake on the Western Australian economy," he told parliament on Thursday. First introduced as a stimulus measure during the COVID-19 pandemic, the significant development pathway was last year enshrined as a permanent feature of the planning system. The State Development Assessment Panel, now called the Significant Development Assessment Panel (SDAU), is considering controversial plans for luxury resorts at Gnarabup and Smiths Beach in WA's South West. The inquiry will also put a spotlight on the Cook government's plans for a street motorsport circuit in Perth's Burswood Park. The inquiry's select committee will be chaired by Liberal MLC Neil Thomson and composed of Liberal, Labor and crossbench MPs. Opposition Legislative Council leader Nick Goiran said it would be a fair way to look at WA's planning system. "It can look into any of these land transactions [and] planning decisions … they have the opportunity to call witnesses in, to summon them, to subpoena documents," he said. "A select committee of parliament doesn't have the power to stop any of these things, but they do have the power to call them in and hold them accountable." Two weeks ago, Mr Carey told a Sydney Institute forum the planning reforms had been designed to tackle "NIMBYism" — or "not in my backyard" attitudes. "I do want to address NIMBYism, or as I call them, the BANANA people: build absolutely nothing anywhere near anything," he said in the address. He spoke of the "balanced" planning decisions by the SDAU, which is made up of three planning professionals and two council members. Developer Saracen Properties opted to submit its plans for a $138 million luxury resort at Gnarabup through the significant development pathway. The Shire of Augusta-Margaret River opposes the multi-million-dollar resort, 280 kilometres south of Perth, but will not be the final decision maker. Shire President Julia Jean-Rice welcomed the inquiry. She said she was concerned the Cook government was "slowly but surely" removing the powers of local government. "We are not all NIMBY councils," Ms Jean-Rice said "We're the closest to the people, and quite often we feel the impacts of whatever is happening in the community; we're the people on the ground. Further up the coast at Yallingup, a group of residents has been fighting for a tourism village near Smiths Beach to be scaled back. Save Smiths Beach Action Group spokesperson David Mitchell said he hoped the inquiry would uncover answers for locals. "There's a lot of concerns that the SDAU process has really just created a vehicle for the developers to bypass proper assessment and transparency," he said "We hope that our project is used as a test case because this impacts all coastal areas around the state, not just Smiths Beach." The inquiry will have a year to hand down its findings.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
E-bike safety law changes set to impact tourist bike hire businesses across NSW
A recent deadline extension for new e-bike laws in New South Wales has been no reprieve for small business owner Mick Cooper. The 70-year-old has spent five years building his bicycle tour and hire business in Dubbo. He said a fleet of 13 e-bikes accounted for 80 per cent of his revenue. But from February 1, 2026, none of Mr Cooper's e-bikes will be legal to hire. He could face fines of up to $825,000 for non-compliance. He said the issue had been a new certification scheme for the sale of e-bikes being implemented by the NSW government, which aimed to reduce fires from unstable or damaged lithium-ion batteries. Under NSW law, a hire is classed as a sale. Unlike retailers who can sell non-certified stock before the February deadline, hire operators rely on the e-bike manufacturers to get the certification, or replace their fleets themselves. Bicycle Industry Australia general manager Peter Bourke said many hire operators did not realise the laws applied to them. He described the potential fallout as "extremely problematic" for regional operators and urged the state government to assist cycle hire and tourist businesses with a further extension or grandfathering clause or a grant program to replace fleets. NSW Fair Trading declined to be interviewed about the scheme but said in a statement that hire operators had been given one and a half years to adjust. "NSW Fair Trading announced the new safety requirements in August 2024 and provided a 12-month transitional period," a spokesperson said. "Recognising the need for further adjustment, an additional six-month extension has been granted, bringing the total transition period to 18 months, ending on 1 February 2026." There are very few e-bikes on the market that comply with the new rules because manufacturers are still certifying new or existing models. Mr Bourke said some manufacturers were choosing not to certify at all given NSW was the only jurisdiction in the world with the new testing framework and "whole-of-bike" certification requirement. The extra six months has not provided Mr Cooper with more options. He said his e-bike manufacturer was not certifying the model he carried and without a minimum of $50,000 to replace his 13 bikes, "it's probably not viable to continue the business". Campbell Shepherd in the Northern Rivers town of Murwillumbah faces a similar dilemma. The models of his 50 e-bikes are all about three years old. He has been exploring costly private certification, or he said he would be forced to close and fire six employees. "Each model needs to be certified and my understanding is to test one costs about $9,000 and to certify is another $1,200," he said. "We also have to give them two bikes [that cost $5000 each] per model that we don't expect to come back because they're going to trash them … they have to put it through all the paces of being broken or hit." NSW Fair Trading said the new whole-of-bike certification was required to reduce fires from unstable or damaged lithium-ion batteries. "In some cases, this includes impact testing, which is critical given e-bikes are susceptible to high-impact incidents such as crashes or rough use," a spokesperson said. "These impacts can compromise the integrity of electrical systems, particularly lithium-ion batteries, posing serious fire risks. "Ensuring the entire e-bike model can withstand such impacts is essential to maintaining safety." E-bike tourism has surged alongside investments in cycleways around the state. Outdoors NSW & ACT chief executive Lori Modde said the sector had received $51.8 million in government trail funding in the past few years. She said the "lack of consultation" with the tourism and recreation sector over the new laws came as a shock. "I don't think [NSW Fair Trading] understood the implications of their legislation into industries that rely on income from hiring e-bikes," she said. Visitor numbers rose by 89 per cent from the previous year on the NSW south coast where upgraded bike trails were launched by the state government in April around Narooma. An economic boost of $69.5 million in visitor spending was also recorded. The announcement highlighted Sally Bouckley's local bike hire business which had grown from "two part-time workers in 2023 to three full-time workers and eight casuals" because of demand. But from next February, none of Ms Bouckley's 17 e-bikes will be certified because they are more than two years old. She contacted the international manufacturer and asked if any models had been associated with a fire. The answer was no, likely because of its certified high-grade battery. In nearby Eden, Jessica Taunton only added 10 e-bikes to her hire business last year after demand from customers. She has been given some reassurance from the manufacturer that they were recent enough models to be certified, but said the process had been stressful. Steve Back in the northern Tweed Shire town of Mooball has already weathered the COVID pandemic and 2022 flood that destroyed his business when it wiped out the national park trails around Mullumbimby. He rebuilt in 2023 with the launch of the Northern Rivers Rail Trail and now has 50 e-bikes. He said at least half might be certified by February but any design change, even to the handlebars or seat, required new testing. "I have one model which is about 60 per cent of my fleet," he said. "That model is currently selling … so in theory, that should be OK. "But if [the manufacturer] changes that design … all my bikes will be illegal."
