Ombudsman ‘cautiously optimistic' ‘injustice' over personal transport for disabled people ‘about to be righted'
The Ombudsman Ger Deering has said he is 'cautiously optimistic that a long-standing injustice' in relation to supports for people with
disabilities
to access personal transport 'is about to be righted'.
In his annual report for 2024 published today, Mr Deering welcomed a commitment from the Department of Transport to develop a new scheme to support people with disabilities to access personal transport.
Mr Deering has previously said the manner in which people with disabilities continue to be denied access to personal transport supports was 'nothing short of shameful'.
The Ombudsman's office investigates complaints from members of the public who believe they have been treated unfairly by public service providers.
READ MORE
For more than a decade the Ombudsman and his two predecessors have highlighted the lack of appropriate supports for people with disabilities since the personal Mobility Allowance and the Motorised Transport Grant were closed to new applicants by the government in February 2013.
Details of the new incentives have not yet been published but the
Department of Transport
has undertaken to introduce such a scheme. It will be separate to the extension of the public transport Free Travel Scheme to people who cannot drive due to a disability, which was announced last July.
The Ombudsman said he will 'closely monitor progress on the Government's new scheme.'
He also called onGovernment to provide 'sustainable and annual funding' to support younger people in nursing homes through the Enhanced Quality of Life Supports (EQLS) scheme and, where appropriate, funding to move younger people to more suitable accommodation.
Following the Ombudsman's
'Wasted Lives' investigation in 2021
– which found some younger people with disabilities did not give informed consent about being placed in nursing homes long term -the HSE set up an 'Under 65 programme' and successfully transitioned more than 100 people to more suitable accommodation.
The scheme also improved the lives of those who could not transition out of nursing homes.
However, the HSE later said there was insufficient funding to continue to assist many of the young people move to more appropriate accommodation, or to continue the programme.
The Ombudsman said, 'it is completely unacceptable that this excellent programme, which brought hope and independence to people with disabilities cannot be delivered because of a lack of funding'.
The Ombudsman's team dealt with 4,673 complaints last year – an increase of nearly 5 per cent on the 2023 figure. In 2024, 1,497 complaints were made to the Ombudsman about local authorities, with 218 received about Dublin City Council and 150 about Cork City Council.
Some 1,397 complaints were received about Government departments and offices with the Department of Social Protection being the subject of 604 complaints.
There were 887 complaints about public bodies in the health sector with 705 involving the HSE and 149 about Tusla.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
Lack of progress moving younger people from nursing homes slammed as 'completely unacceptable'
THE OMBUDSMAN GER Deering has criticised the lack of progress made by the HSE to move younger people out of nursing homes, and called for additional government funding to tackle the issue. According to the Ombudsman Annual Report for 2024 – which examined complaints and reports from the Ombudman last year – the HSE has insufficient funding to continue to assist hundreds of young people to move out of nursing homes and into more appropriate accommodation. The Ombudsman in Ireland is a public official who investigates complaints from individuals who believe they have been treated unfairly by certain public service providers. As previously reported by The Journal , more than 1,200 people under the age of 65 in Ireland are living in nursing homes designed for much older people, leaving them frustrated and calling for alternatives . A 2021 Ombudsman investigation found that these people face a number of issues, including isolation from family and friends, a lack of any meaningful social engagement and residing with elderly patients – many of whom suffered from dementia. Since 2021, 102 people have been supported to move to homes of their choosing in the community where this is their wish, as part of a HSE-led 'Under 65 programme'. The Enhanced Quality of Life Supports (EQLS) scheme established in 2021 also improved the lives of those who could not transition out of nursing homes. While the Ombudsman would like to see an increase, the HSE has since said that there is not enough funding to continue to aid many young people in moving out of nursing homes. Deering said in an Ombudsman report that he had received an update from the HSE in November 2024, which made clear that the Under 65 programme 'will falter' this year without additional funding. 'This means that many of those identified for moves to more suitable accommodation will not now be able to do so. This is a major setback and disappointment for the people concerned and their families,' Deering said. 'It is completely unacceptable that this excellent programme, which brought hope and independence to people with disabilities cannot be delivered because of a lack of funding,' the Ombudsman said. He added that progress on transitioning people out of the nursing home system ha, to date, been 'unquestionably slow'. In a report, the Ombudsman called on the government to provide 'sustainable and annual funding' to support younger people in nursing homes through the EQLS scheme, and, where appropriate, funding to move to more suitable accommodation. Recalled payment to deceased carer's account Later in the report, the Ombudsman detailed a number of cases which were flagged with his office and upheld last year. One such case saw the Department of Social Protection recall a payment of over €2,700 it incorrectly believed it had paid to the bank account of a carer who had passed away. Anne* contacted the Ombudsman after the Department recalled a payment it believed had been deposited into her late son Martin's account. Martin had been Anne's carer before his death. Anne and her family repeatedly contacted the Department over a 12-month period to explain the situation and request a refund, but the Department refused to act. Advertisement It later emerged that although Anne had notified the Department of Martin's death, payments for Carer's Allowance and the Carer's Support Grant had continued to be issued to his account. Since the account had been closed, the bank automatically returned the funds to the Department. However, the Department failed to update its records to reflect the returned payments and mistakenly believed Martin had received the funds. As a result, it recalled the payment, which led to the money being withdrawn from Martin's closed account in error. The Department has since apologised to Anne and refunded the incorrectly retrieved payment. It also agreed to pay €1,850 to Anne's family in the form of a Carer's Support Grant, acknowledging that Martin would have qualified for it prior to his death. Dentures and shoes stolen from hospital patient In another case, Andrew* contacted the Ombudsman after his mother's personal belongings, including her dentures and shoes, went missing during her stay at St Vincent's University Hospital in Dublin. Hospital staff initially claimed there was no record of the items being with the patient at the time of admission. However, the Ombudsman uncovered documentation indicating otherwise. An early report from a speech and language therapist noted that Andrew's mother had no difficulty eating. A later report, however, recorded that she was struggling to eat and missing some teeth. Additionally, a therapist's note mentioned she had trouble 'putting on her shoes,' further suggesting the items were with her during her hospital stay. The hospital has since apologised to Andrew and his mother and reimbursed them for the missing items. Ombudsman complaints According to the Ombudsman's annual report, there was a continued increase in complaints about public bodies received by the Ombudsman. The Ombudsman's team dealt with 4,673 complaints last year – an increase of nearly 5% on the 2023 figure. In 2024, 1,497 complaints were made to the Ombudsman about local authorities, with 218 received about Dublin City Council and 150 about Cork City Council. 1,397 complaints were received about Government Departments and Offices with the Department of Social Protection being the subject of 604 complaints. There were also 887 complaints about public bodies in the health sector, with 705 involving the HSE and 149 involving Tusla. * The names were changed in the Ombudsman's report to protect privacy Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
CHI chief to apologise to patients, families and public over ‘great pain inflicted' on some in its care
The head of Children's Health Ireland (CHI) is to apologise to patients, their families and the public over 'revelations relating to our culture, governance and practices' that have led to 'great pain being inflicted upon some of those who were in our care'. In a statement to the Oireachtas Committee on Health on Thursday, CHI chief executive Lucy Nugent is expected to say: 'I am sorry on behalf of the management of Children's Health Ireland and I am sorry on behalf of the entire organisation.' She is also to say that CHI will be 'ready and able' to take over the new national children's hospital when it opens. Ms Nugent and senior CHI figures are scheduled to answer questions at the committee following scandals at the organisation including the implantation of unauthorised springs in children who underwent spinal surgery and indications that some children had unnecessary hip operations . READ MORE There was also an internal report highlighting difficult relationships between staff in one unit and it raised questions over how the National Treatment Purchase Fund was operated. In her opening statement, Ms Nugent is expected to say: 'We want the best possible outcome for our children when they go into hospital and when they leave hospital. When that does not happen, children are failed and trust is broken'. She is to say CHI's mission statement includes an aim 'to promote and provide child-centred, research-led, learning informed healthcare to the highest standards of safety and excellence'. 'On occasions we have failed to do that,' she is expected to say. Ms Nugent is also to say that between January and May, a further 254 procedures had been added to the spinal surgery waiting list at CHI. 'This is compared to 193 procedures added for the same period in 2024. While we are doing more spinal surgeries this year (210 so far), we are also seeing more outpatients and adding more procedures to the waiting lists,' she is to say in the statement, which adds that important progress is being made every month. Ms Nugent is to tell the committee that initiatives taken by the spinal surgery management unit have reduced the waiting time for outpatient appointments by 40 per cent. 'We acknowledge that waiting times for patients are still too long, and we continue to work to reduce the length of time that patients are waiting for appointments.' She is also to say that the recent audit of developmental dysplasia of the hip surgeries, which involved 147 random and anonymous cases, found that thresholds for recommending pelvic osteotomy procedures varied between CHI at Crumlin , CHI at Temple Street and the National Orthopaedic Hospital in Cappagh . 'All families have been sent a letter which details if their child was part of the audit and what their next steps will be,' Ms Nugent is to say in her statement. 'Multi-disciplinary team review clinics have started. This is a once-off review to assess complications only and determine the current clinical state of each patient. After this, patients enter the recommended normal follow-up process. To date 105 appointments have been offered, with 60 patients seen. 'We are arranging these clinics as quickly as possible and hope to have seen all children within six months.' Ms Nugent is also to say that integrating services, functions and teams across three centres to become a single organisation had 'not always been easy'. 'But it is being done and continues to be done. We will continue to ensure and progress CHI's readiness as an organisation to move into the new hospital.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Concerns over ‘care deficits' in two Emeis-run nursing homes are referred to gardaí
The healthcare watchdog has referred to gardaí its concerns about 'care deficits' in two nursing homes run by Emeis Ireland, TDs and senators are to hear. Representatives from the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) will on Wednesday appear before the Oireachtas Health Committee to discuss standards of care and related practices in nursing homes along with the oversight of these matters. The appearance follows an RTÉ Investigates programme on June 4th highlighting instances of alleged abuse and neglect of frail, elderly residents at two nursing homes: Beneavin House, Dublin, and The Residence, Portlaoise. Both homes are run by Emeis, the largest provider of private nursing home beds in the State. The programme included footage of frail, older people, some of whom had dementia, allegedly being manhandled, 'forced' down into chairs, being left in chairs for hours, being left in incontinence pads for so long their clothes were soaked, being ignored when they pleaded for help to go to the toilet and requests for simple activities like going for a walk being fobbed off. READ MORE In her opening statement to the committee, Angela Fitzgerald, chief executive of Hiqa, is expected to say the conduct of staff and the behaviours witnessed in the RTÉ programme are 'wholly unacceptable in any circumstance'. 'Hiqa's chief inspector is addressing these fundamental issues directly with the nursing homes and its parent company, Emeis Ireland, and is engaging in additional escalatory actions,' her statement says. 'These include conducting a number of unannounced inspections in both Firstcare Beneavin Manor and The Residence Portlaoise over the past two weeks, including during the early hours of the morning, late at night and during the day.' Ms Fitzgerald is to say the chief inspector required an immediate meeting with senior officials from Emeis Ireland following the programme. 'The providers of the two nursing homes were issued with an official warning of cancellation of registration should they fail to implement significant improvements in the centres,' she is to say. 'Emeis Ireland told us what immediate action they have taken, including: restricting admissions in Beneavin Manor pending their assurance and ours that the services in these nursing homes are safe; disciplinary action with a number of staff; and notifications to the gardaí. 'We have also notified the gardaí about our concerns on the care deficits observed in the programme.' Ms Fitzgerald is to say Hiqa has sought 'immediate assurances' on the other 23 homes run by Emeis Ireland and these will be independently assessed in the coming weeks. She is also to expected say Emeis has 'significant work to do', but acknowledges so too does Hiqa 'in relation to reviewing our regulatory process'. 'We are fully committed to examining what we can learn from recent revelations, and we have commenced work in this regard,' she is to say.
