19-turbine Comrie windfarm plans lodged as nearby 'energy park' talks open
The Glen Lednock turbines would stand 200 metres tall at their tips.
The company behind them, Low Carbon, has lodged an application with the Scottish Government's Energy Consents Unit.
The turbines are part of a larger 'rewilding' strategy being led by Invergeldie Estate owners Oxygen Conservation.
It comes as developers prepare to consult locals on another major renewables project at Fowlis Wester, on the other side of Crieff.
The plans for the Meallbrodden 'energy park' on the Abercairney Estate include eight 200-metre turbines, 60,000 solar panels and battery storage units.
Low Carbon says it has 'actively engaged' with residents in St Fillans and Comrie since the Glen Lednock windfarm project went public in November 2023.
Craig Cunningham, the company's senior project development manager, says the goal is to achieve 'carbon payback' in less than a year and a half, after which the turbines should begin to make a net positive contribution to reducing carbon emissions.
'The final design has been shaped by a significant amount of site survey work as well as extensive consultation with the local community,' he added.
Low Carbon says it will put £5,000 for every megawatt of energy generated by the Glen Lednock turbines into a community benefit fund every year.
This could add up to £589,000 a year to be spent on local projects.
The full application, including an environmental impact assessment (EIA) and supporting documents, can be viewed here or on the Scottish Government's Energy Consents website.
Consultation sessions for the Meallbrodden project will be held in Fowlis Wester Village Hall on June 18 from 4-8pm, and at Strathearn Community Campus, Crieff, on June 19 from 4-8pm.
It is being spearheaded by Eurowind Energy Ltd.
And due to its size, it will also be decided by the Scottish Government, rather than Perth and Kinross Council.
The Danish company says its community benefit fund could provide up to £280,000 a year for local projects.
But critics say the moorland site, which includes a loch, stone circles, standing stones, Roman remains, ancient forest and native species, is not suitable.
And they have raised concerns about the cumulative impact of renewable energy projects across the area.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
4 hours ago
- The National
John Swinney looking at 'whole range of measures' against Israel
Speaking exclusively to The National at Bute House – with the full interview to be released tomorrow (Tuesday) in both article and video format – John Swinney said that, for example, ending public grants for arms firms supplying Israel is an 'area we are, of course, looking at'. It comes after the Scottish Government revealed in a statement last week that it is considering a full state boycott of Israel. It was in response to a letter from Scottish Greens leadership contender Ross Greer, who asked Swinney last Thursday to adopt the principles of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign, which aims to put pressure on the Israeli economy in the mould of the anti-apartheid boycott of South Africa. READ MORE: Ross Greer says bullying within Scottish Greens left him hospitalised twice A Scottish Government spokesperson said ministers would 'consider' the proposal, which would see official guidance issued to businesses urging them to end trade with Israel, as was done with Russia in 2022. Asked to elaborate on what exactly is being considered, the First Minister said: 'What I'm looking at is a whole range of different measures.' He added: 'To fulfil what I consider to be essential, which is that I've got to explore every possible avenue I can take to ensure that we are doing all that we can to make our voice heard on the issue of Gaza and to make sure that we take all the practical steps that we can possibly take.' The First Minister wasn't keen on getting drawn into specifics but did say that ending public grants for arms firms supplying Israel is an 'area we are, of course, looking at'. (Image: Gordon Terris) The Scottish Government has come under mounting scrutiny over the public money it has continuously provided for these companies. The government agency Scottish Enterprise (SE) has given £8 million to 13 companies involved in weapons manufacturing since 2019 – although the SNP Government maintains that the funding doesn't go directly to the production of munitions and that 'due diligence' checks are thorough. However, that has been called into question given that, of the 199 human rights checks between 2021 and 2023, no firm ever failed. Pressure has also built around arms firms' links to Israel. READ MORE: 5 communities across Scotland that are boycotting Israel amid Gaza genocide A review in June concluded that despite funding the manufacturer of parts for F-35s and other military technology, Scottish Enterprise have never funded munitions. When asked about this funding, Swinney made the same argument around munitions. 'We won't support the production of munitions. That's our hard line. And we get criticised for taking that hard line, and I'm very confident that hard line is applied,' he said. The First Minister was then pressed on the argument that any funding – even if ring-fenced by the Scottish Government – will directly help a company's cash flow and could, hypothetically, free up money to be used elsewhere, including in the building of munitions. 'I understand that point. But there are also defence requirements of Scotland. Scotland is part of an island nation. We require, for example, shipbuilding resources to support the maritime defense of the United Kingdom because nobody wants to see us vulnerable to an attack from Russia. I certainly don't want to,' he responded. 'We're living in a world where that's now much more of a relevant factor than it's perhaps been at any other stage in my life. So, I want to be as helpful as I possibly can here and to be as robust as I possibly can be, because I want to do nothing, absolutely nothing, that in any way assists Israel to be able to carry on doing what they're doing, because I am disgusted and appalled by what Israel are doing." He added: "It is beyond comprehension, but there are complex arguments that have to be worked through to make sure we can take a robust stance, but I give you the assurance that we are doing everything we possibly can do and exploring every possible avenue to maximise the effectiveness.' The full exclusive interview with John Swinney will be published online and in tomorrow's print newspaper (Tuesday) and all over social media – including a full-length video recording on YouTube. Pick up a copy or visit to read – and make sure you're subscribed at
The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
SNP's Kate Forbes leaves big gap to fill on Scottish economy
The MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch declared she did not want to 'miss any more of the precious early years of family life'. While the decision is entirely understandable, there is no doubting Ms Forbes will be a major loss to the SNP. She has embraced her Cabinet responsibilities energetically, visiting many businesses. Ms Forbes has celebrated the success of Prestwick Airport, owned by the Scottish Government since 2013. However, she has also been up front when the news has been less good. When I interviewed Ms Forbes in June, she highlighted her disappointment at a further delay in the delivery of the Glen Rosa ferry for Caledonian MacBrayne which had been announced in May by Port Glasgow shipbuilder Ferguson Marine, which has been owned by the Scottish Government since 2019. Asked if she had been unhappy with recent progress at Ferguson Marine, in the context of this delay, Ms Forbes said: 'I, of course, was really disappointed with the delay to the Glen Rosa and the budget implications of that delay. And I was very clear in public at the time that I thought it was unacceptable. 'I felt that we need to deliver these vessels for the sake of the islanders, yes, but also because we need to restore confidence in the yard and those delays don't help with the public narrative about the yard, and it's hard enough for the yard to secure work with all of the political noise that goes on about Ferguson Marine.' As has been typical of Ms Forbes, she painted the bigger picture in relation to Ferguson Marine. While voicing disappointment about the Glen Rosa delay, she highlighted the importance of restoring confidence in the shipyard for it to 'succeed and survive'. And Ms Forbes declared she had 'full confidence in the ability of the yard to submit quality tenders' for future work. Shortly afterwards, it emerged Ferguson Marine had won another major contract from BAE Systems for the Type 26 frigate programme. Read more Ms Forbes also said in the interview: 'I would like to think that all parties in the Scottish Parliament want to see Ferguson Marine succeed and survive, which is why we need to build confidence, not knock it.' The point about the need to build confidence is absolutely on the money. And it should surely be in everyone's interests to continue to have a major commercial shipbuilder on the Clyde. Lamentably, however, we can expect the politics around Ferguson Marine to remain febrile. It has been heartening indeed to hear Ms Forbes's positivity about the prospects for Prestwick Airport, which has for years been another political football. She declared in the June interview that Prestwick Airport's work in building new alliances and relationships means the opportunities for the area around it are 'quite remarkable'. Read more Shortly before the interview, Prestwick Airport announced agreements with Air China Cargo and China Southern Air Logistics to operate freighter services between Guangzhou and Prestwick. And not long after the interview, there was further good news for Prestwick Airport when it was announced British aircraft manufacturer AERALIS had selected it as the location for the final assembly of its UK aircraft. AERALIS noted, when this major win for the Ayrshire airport was unveiled last month, that it is 'the only British programme designing and building a light jet aircraft to deliver a replacement for the Red Arrows and for a lucrative international export market'. In June, Ms Forbes highlighted the 'rapid growth' of the aerospace cluster at Prestwick Airport. She appears to have impressed many in the business community, including those who would disagree with her support for independence. And she has stood out as a serious thinker on business and the economy, in contrast to many politicians in the UK who seem to open their mouths before engaging their brains. Ms Forbes has been very forthright about being 'pro-economy' and 'pro-business'. She said in the June interview: 'Our sentiment, my sentiment is pro-economy, pro-prosperity, pro-business. 'And that underpins all of our other objectives. So without economic growth and prosperity, you don't raise the revenue to reinvest in resilient public services. Without a strong growing economy, you can't get to net zero because you have to partner with innovative enterprising businesses to develop the solutions that we need. And then you can't tackle child poverty unless parents in particular have access to well-paid secure employment created in many cases by the private sector. So I see their role as underpinning our other three objectives and my job is to try and make Scotland as successful and as prosperous as possible.' This is surely a reassuring message, not just for the business community but for all of those interested in a prosperous and socially conscious Scotland. First Minister John Swinney also seems to have been well received by many in the business community, in terms of his approach, and has been forthright about the economy being a priority. Unlike some other politicians who have flagged such a priority, his actions have supported his words. This is reassuring as Ms Forbes prepares to leave the political front line, but you would imagine Mr Swinney will be aware there will be a big gap to fill for the SNP.
Daily Record
11 hours ago
- Daily Record
Perth and Kinross Council objection to super-sized solar farm in Coupar Angus sparks public inquiry
Councillors have voted to object to a 110MW battery and solar energy park on 105 hectares of prime agricultural land A public local inquiry has been sparked after Perth and Kinross councillors voted to object to a massive energy development on prime agricultural land. The 105-hectare plant is the latest of many renewable energy proposals for the Coupar Angus area, prompting concerns the Perthshire town - famed for its fertile land - was transforming into "Solar" Angus. On Wednesday, August 6 Perth and Kinross Council's (PKC) Planning and Placemaking Committee voted - against council officers' recommendation - to object to Stirling Battery and Solar Energy Park. Sirius EcoDev (Stirling) Ltd submitted an application to the Scottish Government's Energy Consents Unit (ECU) to develop a 110MW energy plant on land between Burrelton and Coupar Angus, 600 metres north-west of Caddam Cottage, Keithick. The planning application is being considered by the Scottish Government's ECU due to it generating over 50MW of power. The 50MW battery storage system and 60MW solar energy park would be erected on prime agricultural land the size of over 146 football pitches. At Wednesday's meeting, councillors were simply asked whether or not PKC should object to the application as a statutory consultee. PKC'S Building Standards and Development Management service manager Kristian Smith reminded councillors the National Planning Framework 4's (NPF4) policy "allows this sort of energy development proposal on prime agricultural land". He said council officers had considered the cumulative impact and deemed it as being "acceptable". However, uncertainty does still loom over the controversial nearby 91-hectare Markethill Solar Farm proposal, which drew 173 objections. It was refused by councillors in December 2023. The decision was subsequently appealed and called in by Scottish Ministers. Mr Smith said: "It's been sitting with Ministers since May of last year and we have chased multiple times to get a decision and that has not - as yet - been forthcoming. "It would have been very helpful to have had an outcome on that application over the last year and a half but, notwithstanding, we've still taken into account that proposal and feel the cumulative impacts related to the proposals that are subject to this consultation are acceptable." Conservative councillor Keith Allan said: "What is the ceiling? Where do we feel the line is where we would say, 'we can't consider that'?" He added: "Looking at the map, and the bits that have previously gone under consideration, it seems excessive. If this all goes ahead, we can change its name from Coupar Angus to Solar Angus." Liberal Democrat councillor Claire McLaren added: "The frustration is the recognition food producing land (prime agricultural land) - where there is only eight per cent in Scotland - is being overlooked within NPF4. Food supply to food retailers is an important matter and there is a cumulative impact on that." Conservative Blairgowrie and Glens councillor Bob Brawn moved to formally object to the application. He said he did not object to renewable energy developments but added: "The important thing is they have to be in the right place. And I feel that over the past few months we are slowly seeing Coupar Angus potentially becoming some form of industrialised site for solar farms and in doing so we're losing prime agricultural land. "Our own policy says prime agricultural land should be protected and it does allow it for essential infrastructure. I would argue that, at the moment, this is not essential and the cost of losing agricultural land - in this instance and what we have seen and what is already approved - is getting to the point of too much." Cllr Brawn suggested national planning policy makers perhaps did not believe "prime agricultural land would be thrown at developers like this". He said: "That wasn't the spirit of what NPF4 was about. It was about producing renewable energy in the right place at the right time. I feel we're witnessing abuse of NPF4, simply by people throwing prime agricultural land out to do this." PKC objecting will trigger a local public inquiry, which Cllr Brawn welcomes. He said: "I think a public local inquiry is deserved in this instance in this area. I think it would be a good thing for everyone whatever the outcome is. People will get their chance to speak." Cllr Ian James seconded the motion. SNP councillor Ian Harvey tabled an amendment not to object. Cllr Richard Watters seconded the amendment with the proviso "a thorough investigation is done into the cumulative impact on prime agricultural land around Coupar Angus and across Perth and Kinross". Seven councillors - four Conservatives, one Lib Dem, one Independent and local Strathmore ward SNP councillor Grant Stewart - voted to object to the Coupar Angus development. The remaining four SNP councillors voted not to object to the development. Convener SNP councillor Ian Massie thanked councillors for their votes and said: "Therefore that means the consultation goes forward with an objection from Perth and Kinross Council."
