
Whangārei Hospital spends $100K sending ED patients to private clinic
'Why can't that money be used within the public sector to pay for nurses and nurse practitioners and doctors to care for patients directly ... instead of losing 10 to 20% on profits?'
Payinda roughly calculated the money would pay for a nurse practitioner to work 28 hours a week, seeing between 2500 and 3680 patients a year.
The use of vouchers shows Northlanders cannot afford to pay for private urgent care, which is 'really tragic', he said.
The coalition Government is putting more money into private urgent care, including a $164 million investment over four years announced in Budget 2025.
But Payinda said this model still relies on people being able to pay, which is not sustainable in Northland.
Fees for the new urgent care services are still being worked out but a new virtual GP service will cost adults $25 to $33 with a community services card, or $69 to $99 without a card.
Alex Pimm, group director of operations for Health NZ Te Tai Tokerau, said the vouchers are offered to people presenting at ED who are assessed to have a medical condition that can be appropriately managed in an urgent care clinic.
Patients are given the option of going to the clinic or waiting to be seen at the ED and get a reminder message if they take the voucher but do not attend the clinic.
A 2018 review in Auckland's Waitematā showed the voucher system had a positive impact on EDs by transferring lower-acuity patients to appropriate primary care, he said.
Economic analysis found it was cost-effective but Health NZ will be reviewing the voucher system in the next financial year, to reassess value for money and identify any improvements, Pimm said.
Whangārei Hospital is 'very busy' at this time of year, with winter illnesses putting extra pressure on all EDs, he said.
However, Pimm would not detail the current occupancy rate at Northland's EDs, instead saying people needing urgent hospital-level care will 'always be able to receive it'.
Health NZ group director Alex Pimm and Health Minister Simeon Brown, pictured at Whangārei Hospital, say new urgent care funding will result in more consistent fees.
Health Minister Simeon Brown, when asked how the unaffordability of urgent care will be addressed, said fees will become more consistent as part of the Budget 2025 announcement.
'Health New Zealand will negotiate with providers in areas where improved urgent care has been identified to ensure services are in place – with a clearer fee structure as part of that work.'
Whangārei has been identified as needing a new 24/7 urgent care service from 2026, building on the urgent care already available, he said.
Extended after-hours services have been identified as needed in Dargaville, Hokianga, and Kaitāia, and enhanced rural urgent care has been identified for Mangawhai, Kawakawa, Kaikohe and Waipapa, he said.
Urgent and after-hours care will also be strengthened in Russell and Kāeo, Brown said.
Denise Piper is a news reporter for the Northern Advocate, focusing on health and business. She has more than 20 years in journalism and is passionate about covering stories that make a difference.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Fourth case of measles confirmed in Wairarapa
A fourth case of measles has been identified in Wairarapa. (File photo) Photo: 123rf A fourth case of measles linked to overseas travel has been confirmed in Wairarapa. Health NZ said the latest person who had fallen ill had been isolating to prevent any spread of the disease. Anyone who visited the Masterton Pak'N Save and the Carterton Library from 1 July to 3 July, should monitor for measles symptoms such as high fever, cough, runny nose, sore eyes or a rash that spreads down the body, it said. Medical Officer of Health Dr Craig Thornley was urging any Wairarapa locals who weren't immunised or who hadn't previously had measles, to get vaccinated. "This includes anyone who may be planning to head overseas in the near future, given there are outbreaks happening in many popular travel destinations such as the US, Canada, the UK, Vietnam, Thailand and India. "Similarly, anyone who has recently returned from an overseas trip, should be watchful for measles symptoms." Thornley said the latest case was a reminider that it was still important for everyone to be fully vaccinated by having two doses of the MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccine after 12 months of age. He said there were a number of pharmacies across Wairarapa that could provide vaccinations. There was also a drop-in clinic at Masterton Intermediate School Dental Clinic which ran every Thursday from 3pm to 6pm. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Nurses vote to go on 24-hour strike, citing safe staffing concerns
Health New Zealand told RNZ it was committed to reaching an agreement. Photo: RNZ More than 36,000 Te Whatu Ora nurses, midwives, health care assistants and kaimahi hauora have voted to strike for 24 hours of what they say is a failure by Health NZ to address their safe staffing concerns. The Nurses Organisation took a ballot of its members on possible industrial action, that would start with a 24-hour strike on July the 30th. A series of other actions would follow. Health NZ is offering a 3 percent pay rise over two years, plus two payments of $325. The union said the agency was refusing to provide safe staffing levels in its latest contract offer. Health New Zealand's latest pay offer was a "massive backward step" for the health system and patients, and there were "very strong indications" members will want to strike, the union said. Health New Zealand told RNZ it was committed to reaching an agreement, but it was also "operating within tight financial constraints". Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Covid Royal Commission enters fifth day
health politics 22 minutes ago The Royal Commission of Inquiry into the government's Covid-19 response has entered its fifth day and follows a tense session of hearings on Thursday, with critics describing what they called red-flags in the vaccine roll-out. Reporter Victor Waters spoke to Tuwhenuaroa Natanahira.