‘What about my BTO?' — Breakup leaves woman feeling lost just weeks before she's due to collect BTO keys
SINGAPORE: A 34-year-old woman is feeling lost and overwhelmed after her relationship ended just weeks before she was supposed to collect the keys to her long-awaited Build-To-Order (BTO) flat.
'[We] waited five years for BTO…and my relationship just ended,' she wrote in a post on the r/askSingapore forum on Saturday (Jun 14). 'What about my BTO? What are my options for this? Can I move my ex's name to one of my parents? Does my ex have to agree?'
She also shared that her current living situation has been tough. With her parents divorced and both living in smaller flats, there's no space for her to stay with either of them.
'I was renting with the idea of moving to my BTO once done,' she wrote. 'I feel really lost, feel like my hopes and dreams disappeared before my eyes.' 'Don't give up yet; it's still worth appealing to HDB…'
In the discussion thread, one Reddit user said, 'Sorry to hear that. Since you're almost at the key collection stage, you'll probably have to forfeit more than I did in the worst case, but really, it's small money to pay rather than having to divorce later or be in a loveless marriage.'
Another commented, 'Sounds like the relationship has been long gone. Just held together and dragged on by the hurdle of BTO. Like how some couples finally separate after the children have grown up. Try to get a name transfer to your parent.'
However, a third user flagged a potential roadblock: if her parents already own their own Housing Development Board (HDB) flats, it's unlikely she'll be able to list them as co-owners. This is due to HDB's general rule that individuals can't co-own more than one flat at a time.
Despite this, they urged her 'not to give up yet,' adding, 'It's still worth appealing to HDB and telling them everything honestly. Sometimes they can suggest other options or make exceptions. You might also want to ask about taking over the flat solo if you're 35 or close to it.
'Whatever happens, you're not the first person to go through this kind of situation. HDB has heard it before. Go talk to them; it's better than stressing in silence. If you need help drafting an email or message to them, I'm here.' Cancelling a BTO application comes with penalties
If a couple breaks up after applying for a BTO flat, they can still cancel the application by submitting a request to the HDB via MyRequest@HDB.
However, cancelling at such a late stage does come with consequences. According to Singapore Legal Advice, if the Agreement for Lease has already been signed but the keys have not yet been collected, the couple will face financial penalties. These include forfeiting the S$10 application fee, the option fee, and 5% of the flat's purchase price.
Read also: My mum expects me to take care of her by getting a high-paying job in Singapore and marrying a 'traditional' wife
Featured image by freepik (for illustration purposes only)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
38 minutes ago
- Business Times
MilikiRumah eyes US$50 million fund to expand rent-to-own Indon programme
[JAKARTA] Proptech startup MilikiRumah is aiming to raise a US$50 million private equity fund to scale its rent-to-own housing programme in the country, targeting segments of the population typically excluded from conventional mortgage financing. With early backing from regulated asset managers – including Ruifeng Wealth Management, Tembusu Partners and Trigger Asset Management – the company kicked off its fundraising efforts with a planned first close of US$10 million in the third quarter of this year. MilikiRumah aims to raise the remaining capital in successive US$10 million tranches over the next two years, enabling it to gradually scale housing development under its rent-to-own model. Co-founder and chief executive Winston Lee told The Business Times that the funds will be used to develop build-to-order landed homes in collaboration with local real estate developers. The company aims to bridge the financing gap for consumers often excluded from traditional mortgage systems, such as freelancers, influencers, and gig workers. They typically lack stable incomes or have high debt-to-income ratios, making them less appealing to banks. 'We see ourselves as credit doctors. We segment our customers and provide tailored support; many are middle-class Indonesians, families working hard to buy their first home,' noted Lee. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies. Sign Up Sign Up MilikiRumah is owned and operated by Rightkey Capital, a Singapore-registered company. The venture was founded by former PropertyGuru executive Lee, together with co-founder Marine Novita, who also previously held a role at the property platform. The company currently has a pipeline of 500 hectares of land spread across seven to 10 parcels – mostly in Greater Jakarta – that can accommodate up to 45,000 homes. However, fully developing the sites would require between US$100 million and US$150 million in funding. 'With just the initial US$10 million, we can already build around 2,700 landed homes,' Lee pointed out. 'The speed at which we hit our 45,000-home target really depends on how quickly we can raise the remaining capital.' MilikiRumah offers a rent-to-own model that allows prospective homebuyers to move into a property while gradually building their financial eligibility. During an initial period of six to 12 months, tenants live in the home and make regular payments, helping them establish a credible payment history. If they meet the required criteria by the end of the term, a partnering bank steps in to provide mortgage financing, enabling the tenant to formally purchase the home. The company has established partnerships with Bank Tabungan Negara (BTN), Indonesia's largest state-owned mortgage lender, and Bank Syariah Indonesia. It is also in the process of finalising collaborations with BTN Syariah and Permata Bank to further expand its financing network. MilikiRumah has entered a joint venture with local developer Badak Perkasa Group to develop a residential complex in Tangerang – an hour's drive from Jakarta. Under its rent-to-own model, tenants pay an average of 4.8 million rupiah (S$378) per month. These payments are divided into rent and savings, with the savings component gradually building equity towards a 10 per cent down payment. This structured approach is designed to help tenants eventually qualify for a mortgage covering the remaining 90 per cent of the home's value. As at the second quarter, the company has launched 95 homes using internal equity. It is aiming for 30 bookings by the end of June, with a target of 60 by July or August. Lee said that the company's research involving 300 underbanked prospective buyers showed that 90 per cent are expected to qualify for a bank loan after building up a 10 per cent home equity deposit through the programme. He added that the fund's dual mission – delivering both financial returns and social impact – has resonated with potential limited partners, especially given its projected annual internal rate of return of 20 per cent. 'What sets us apart from traditional private equity real estate funds is that we're not just building homes, we're building communities.' Founded in September 2024, the company has closed its seed round with S$2 million in funding. It was led by Singapore-based family office Ruifeng Wealth, with participation from angel investors including PropertyGuru co-founder Jani Rautiainen and PropertyGuru Singapore country head Tan Tee Khoon. Lee said that the company is aiming for Series A company funding targeting to close in the first quarter of 2026. A market in need Indonesia is facing a severe housing shortage, with the backlog reaching an estimated 15 million units as at 2025, according to official data. To address this gap, the government is exploring new financing strategies, including the possible issuance of bonds to support low-cost housing initiatives. The challenge is compounded by the fact that around 83 million people, or 58 per cent of the workforce as at August 2024, are employed in the informal sector, making it more difficult for many to access traditional housing finance. Novita indicated that the strongest housing demand falls in the 300 million to 700 million rupiah price range – a market segment that accounts for roughly 70 per cent of national demand but remains underserved by financial institutions. 'There's a nationwide disconnect between where the housing need is and where financing is actually available,' she said. 'It's not just in Jakarta – it extends across Java and beyond.' While MilikiRumah remains focused on the Indonesian market for now, the company is beginning to see growing interest beyond its borders. Novita noted that the rent-to-own model could be relevant in other major South-east Asian cities such as Bangkok and Manila, where challenges around home affordability and mortgage accessibility are similarly pronounced. 'In Bangkok, for example, developers have told us that 60 to 70 per cent of entry-level mortgage applications are rejected,' she added. 'We have had early discussions with several contacts in Thailand who are curious about how our model might work in their context.' MilikiRumah's rent-to-own scheme is not the first of its kind in Indonesia. Previously, state-owned housing finance company Sarana Multigriya Finansial partnered fellow state developer Adhi Commuter Properti to offer residential areas integrated with public transportation hubs. Challenges remain Still, the business is not without challenges. Dian Safitri, a senior property agent, said that rent-to-own schemes could help ease Indonesia's housing shortage. However, one major hurdle is the tax system, which treats rental and sale transactions separately, raising the risk of double taxation. 'This drives up the final price of the unit, making it more expensive for consumers, who ultimately bear the heavier financial burden,' she explained. Nailul Huda, director of economics at the Centre of Economic and Law Studies, said that rising property prices, especially in areas surrounding Jakarta, have made it increasingly difficult for informal workers to afford homes outside government-subsidised schemes. 'With layoffs on the rise and ongoing economic uncertainty, the purchasing power of informal workers to buy homes continues to decline,' he noted.
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
CNA938 Rewind - Grain drain: Japan struggles with a rice crisis
CNA938 Rewind Sky-high prices, rations, emergency reserves. Japan's rice crisis has ballooned, with the essential Japonica grain out of reach from the Japanese consumer – it even led to the resignation of the country's agriculture minister. Andrea Heng and Susan Ng speak with Dr Seijiro Takeshita, Dean and Professor of Graduate School of Management, Informatics and Innovation at the University of Shizuoka on how the problem got this far.
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
Still more room for growth for decarbonisation in Apac economies: MSCI
[SINGAPORE] Despite the reliance on fossil fuels, 837 Asia-Pacific corporations have disclosed their climate-transition plans, doubling the commitment growth from 25 per cent in 2023 to 50 per cent in 2025, a report by investment research firm MSCI showed. This demonstrates a 'growing momentum towards adopting transition plans and advancing technological innovation to support corporate decarbonisation efforts', MSCI added. It noted that the doubling of the number of companies that have committed to the Science Based Targets initiative standard indicated a strategic focus on real economy decarbonisation. There are 3,874 constituents in the MSCI AC Asia Pacific Investable Market Index (IMI). Twenty-two per cent (or 837) of the companies disclosed transition plans in 2024, with the information technology sector being the highest with 27 per cent having transition plans, followed by industrials at 26 per cent, and materials sectors at 23 per cent. Internationally, Japan had the highest disclosures at 45 per cent, followed by South Korea at 33 per cent, and Taiwan at 30 per cent, with an increase of disclosed transition plans from 12 per cent in 2022 to 22 per cent in 2024 in Apac. MSCI added that companies with transition plans were more likely to disclose key climate metrics than those without. They were also more likely to report their Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions as well as set climate targets. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Friday, 12.30 pm ESG Insights An exclusive weekly report on the latest environmental, social and governance issues. Sign Up Sign Up Apac economies also heavily rely on fossil fuels, contributing more than 40 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions in 2023. As the global average temperature surpassed the threshold set by the Paris Agreement, reaching a record high of 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels in 2024, MSCI examined corporate transition plans across 13 Apac markets, with a focus on clean-tech investment. The research firm noted that corporate disclosure of transition plans may drive clean-tech demand by signalling the need for emissions reduction technologies. The speed and scale at which Apac corporations can decarbonise will depend not only on their ambition, but also on their technology road map, capital allocation, and access to commercially viable clean technologies. To better understand how transition plans can drive clean-tech demand in Apac, MSCI analysed the transition plans in areas such as energy, utilities and materials sectors. The effects of these policies are reflected in the energy sector. Of the 90 companies in the energy sector in the MSCI AC Asia Pacific IMI, 18 per cent (or 16 companies) of them disclosed their transition plans, planning to invest in hydrogen, renewable energy and electric vehicles (EVs) to diversify their revenue streams towards clean energy. They have also integrated hydrogen fuels into their transition plans, reducing greenhouse gas emissions across all modes of operations. In addition to the 16 energy companies, 200 companies or 5 per cent of the MSCI AC Asia Pacific IMI constituents hold hydrogen-related patents, with technologies that demonstrate hydrogen's potential to fully replace other less-sustainable choices such as fossil fuels. The emerging technologies may demonstrate hydrogen's potential as a low-carbon energy carrier. But MSCI noted that 'scaling up hydrogen production and balancing supply and demand may face significant challenges due to high production costs and infrastructure requirements'. Electric and hybrid vehicles in transition plans However, the market penetration of the policies in electric and hybrid vehicle companies is not as successful. Of the constituents of the index, only 4 per cent (or 150) of the companies provide clean transportation solutions. Despite the low disclosure rate, 4% of companies, such as Zhejiang Leapmotor and LG Energy Solution, posted a compound annual growth rate of over 150% in total sales from 2020 to 2023. CREDIT: MCSI ESG RESEARCH However, MSCI said that makers of these vehicles can capitalise on market growth and the rising demand for clean transportation solutions. EV solutions providers and EV component makers such as Zhejiang Leapmotor and LG Energy Solution posted a compound annual growth rate of over 150 per cent in total sales from 2020 to 2023. Success in utilities sector More than 80 per cent of the 23 Apac utilities constituents indicate transition plans involving the use of clean fuels in their road maps, such as hydrogen-fired generation, reflecting the success and growing priorities for sustainability in the sector. The diversification of low-carbon power generation can be attributed to research reflecting that renewable powers surpassed 50 per cent of the electricity market share. Waaree Renewable and KPI Green, which derive most of their revenues from renewable energy solutions, reported a compound annual growth rate of more than 100% between 2020 and 2023. CREDIT: MCSI ESG RESEARCH This is reflected in two Indian companies – Waaree Renewable and KPI Green, which derived most of their revenues from renewable energy solutions and reported a compound annual growth rate of more than 100 per cent between 2020 and 2023. Despite the success and expansion, certain countries and market dynamics are not as promising due to slower phase-outs of coal-fired power plants, such as China, Indonesia and India; other countries such as Japan still provide petrol subsidies, which slow decarbonisation efforts. Growth in materials sector According to the report by MSCI, more than 90 per cent of companies in the materials sector disclosed their transition plans, developing low-carbon steels. A common challenge faced in this sector is the intense heat required for operations, making fossil fuels the most practical option. Despite the heavy use of fossil fuels, less than half of the companies considered adopting carbon capture and sequestration, which involves capturing the carbon produced to store them underground. The success of companies disclosing their transition plans are reflected in steel industries such as Tianqi Lithium, Chifeng Jilong Gold Mining and LB Group, growing the low-carbon patent quality for their materials by 70 per cent from 2020 to 2023. Room for growth in carbon credits However, only 2 per cent of the carbon projects are rated 'A' or 'AA', with 65 per cent of projects falling into 'B' to 'CCC' ratings. This indicates a shortage of high-quality options for credible transitions. It also raises concerns about their environmental impact and the reputational risks for companies.
