Growing Call For A Halt To Dangerous And Undemocratic Speed Increases
With no notification to affected communities and questions rising about the unworkability of Simeon Browns Speed Rule, it is reckless in the extreme to push ahead with the speed increases, says Albert-Eden Local Board member Christina Robertson.
2 June 2025
City Vision elected members and candidates are backing their communities and leading road safety organisations in calling for a halt to the dangerous and undemocratic speed increases taking place on over 1400 streets across Auckland.
Auckland Transport has claimed that these increases are necessary under the 2024 Speed Rule, but questions have been raised with both the Minister of Transport Chris Bishop and the AT Board about the conflict between the Speed Rule and AT's statutory purpose to 'contribute to an effective, efficient, and safe Auckland land transport system in the public interest'.
'With no notification to affected communities and questions rising about the unworkability of Simeon Brown's Speed Rule, it is reckless in the extreme to push ahead with the speed increases,' says Albert-Eden Local Board member Christina Robertson.
'We know other cities like Hamilton and Dunedin have interpreted the Speed Rule differently, and that the Minister has said that he's comfortable with their approach. We know raising speed limits will cost lives. Why isn't AT's leadership taking the chance to pause and ask the Minister to clarify how they should resolve this conflict between the Rule and the legislation?' asks Dr Robertson.
'Faced with a conflict between applying a new rule, and clear evidence that that will lead to increased harms and even death, directors have no choice but to explore every avenue to protect the public. Otherwise it is hard to see what their role is even for,' says Patrick Reynolds, former NZTA board member and candidate for Waitematā and Gulf Ward.
The evidence is clear. Raising speed limits–outside train stations, in quiet residential streets, outside parks and early childhood centres and (for 23 hours of the day) outside schools–will contribute to a transport system that is less effective, less efficient, and most importantly less safe.
'30km/hr speeds work. Pushing people back into cars puts kids at greater risk, especially during the school run when the streets are busiest. Auckland Transport math is waiting for at least one of our tamariki to die on our local streets before they will stand up again for safe speeds,' says Emma McInnes, founder of the Waterview School bike train and candidate for Albert-Eden Local Board.
Waitematā Local Board member Alex Bonham notes, 'I've worked with advocates to save an area in Ponsonby from speed increases. The limit was set at 30kph because it made sense in our narrow residential streets. AT accepted that the Speed Rule doesn't apply because it was for the community at large. That speed limits must rise in other areas like Arch Hill, Freemans Bay and Parnell because the consultation there also acknowledged the benefits to children going to school is bizarre.'
'When I've asked, AT have said they don't want to do these changes, and that safety is their priority. And yet AT is persisting down a path they don't have to follow, taking actions that are counterproductive to their stated goals. It's baffling that they haven't been open with the public about why they're doing this, and for communities concerned about their safe speeds, the lack of answers does nothing to rebuild public trust and confidence,' says Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa councillor Julie Fairey.
'AT was created partly to ensure Aucklanders get a transport system that doesn't get destroyed based on political whims. However, what we have here is an indecent rush to overturn evidence-based policy at a cost to ratepayers, all based on a badly written rule out of Wellington,' says Jon Turner, Puketāpapa Local Board member and candidate for Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa Ward.
AT must not knowingly endanger the Aucklanders whose safety it is responsible for. To resolve the conflict between the Speed Rule and AT's duty under law, AT must urgently clarify the status of a rule which conflicts so directly with its legislative purpose. City Vision endorses the call for a pause by civil society groups including All Aboard Aotearoa, Bike Auckland, Walk Auckland, Living Streets Aotearoa, Access Matters Aotearoa and Blind Low Vision NZ, and calls on Minister Bishop and AT Board Chair Richard Leggat to work together to find a common-sense way forward.
City Vision is an alliance of Labour, Greens and community independents working together for progressive change in Tāmaki Makaurau Auckland. Since 1998, City Vision has championed policies that support a liveable, safe, connected, healthy, economically and environmentally sustainable city for all Aucklanders. City Vision stands candidates in the Waitematā, Puketāpapa and Albert-Eden Local Board areas, and the Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa and Waitematā and Gulf Wards.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
6 days ago
- The Spinoff
The motley crew of contenders trying to take down Auckland mayor Wayne Brown
A list containing Wayne Brown and the people who will almost certainly lose to Wayne Brown. There are 12 people running for the Auckland mayoralty, though running might be a strong term. The incumbent, Wayne Brown, has barely broken into a light canter as he sets course for re-election. It's not just a coronation though. At least some of his rivals are putting up a fight, with at least one of them promising to emulate Elon Musk and turn what he calls his 'great mind' to fixing Auckland's problems. John Alcock When John Alcock ran in the Pakuranga electorate in the 2023 general election, it was on a platform of reclaiming 'New Zealand from ideological extremism'. Though that phrase is usually the hallmark of a candidate who possesses moderate and politically mainstream views, Alcock appears to have some out-there ideas, including decentralising our financial and governmental systems and crafting a future 'where empowered individuals build resilient communities'. Alcock was once a board member for the Act Party and is now highly interested in cryptocurrencies. Wayne Brown Remember when mayor Wayne Brown failed to publicly declare a state of emergency until nearly 10.30pm on the night of the Auckland Anniversary weekend floods? Remember how, in the criticism that followed, he grumped that it wasn't his job to ' rush out with buckets '. Remember how, worst of all, he referred to the universally delightful people of the media as ' drongos '? If you'd told Aucklanders then that in just a few short years' time, Brown would be paddleboarding to almost certain re-election atop an unstoppable wave of mildly favourable voter sentiment, they would have spat a mouthful of brown floodwater straight into your face. Sorry to those stuck in a 2023 time prison, but that's what's happening. Brown has engineered one of the most remarkable redemption arcs in local politics history, going from being perceived as a godawful angry old boomer to a lovable angry old boomer. He's done it through playing against type and learning the art of political compromise. For all his self-aggrandising Mr Fix It branding, Brown's shown a surprising ability to take new ideas on board. He's elevated people from outside his natural circle of allies, demoted naysaying local government lifers, talked up intensification around train stations and busways, and spruiked for cheap mass transit options. Brown still texts the chief executive of AT when he sees a rogue road cone. He remains offensive, in ways that are sometimes funny, and sometimes not. But ask most Aucklanders what they think of him, and they'll say he's grown on them. The man with one of politics' most polarising personalities is somehow one of its most unifying figures. Brown's re-election odds are so good, he seems to have eschewed campaigning to focus all his efforts on getting rid of the councillors he doesn't like. He'll likely win, provided no floods hit between now and October. Eric Chuah Dr Eric Chuah once worked as a strategist for United Future's Peter Dunne, which should stand him in good stead for securing a sliver of the vote in an election race dominated by more popular and well-known rivals. Chuah's promises are nonspecific on minor issues such as minimising rates, reducing unnecessary council spending, and ensuring safer policing. However he gets into granular detail on how to fix dog walking, proposing a timeshare scheme where dog owners would be allowed to walk their dogs between 3 and 5pm, and the rest of the public are permitted to go outside without being mauled by an aggressive labradoodle outside those hours. Michael Coote Michael Coote appears to be a finance professional. He stood for mayor and Waitakere ward councillor in the 2022 local elections, where he distinguished himself by failing to give any detail to and appearing in several lists of people who are also standing for mayor at the bottom of coverage on other candidates. Coote didn't respond to an email from The Spinoff. Ted Johnston Johnston is perhaps best known for his handpainted 2019 local election hoardings, which gave people the distinct impression that if they didn't vote for him, he would murder them with an axe. Obviously the implied threats paid off, because soon after, Johnston became a leader in the New Conservative Party. He was stood down from that gig by the party board in 2023, and is back to his first political love: running strident, ultimately doomed independent campaigns to become Auckland's mayor. Johnston has more than 30 years of experience as a criminal barrister. Kerrin Leoni Kerrin Leoni appears to be the only high-profile candidate actively campaigning for the mayoralty right now. The Whau ward councillor was the sole respondent when Auckland university's debating society invited three candidates to a debate last month. She's put up hoardings touting her experience as an 'economist and business owner'. She's taking what chances she can to talk down Brown in the media. Though her chances remain relatively slim, Leoni remains the mayor's most credible rival in the race. Her policy priorities include building more affordable housing and prioritising investment in public transport, walking and cycling. Rob McNeil Rob McNeil is the executive president of the Animal Justice Party. He could fill a similar nature-focused political niche to Michael Morris, who campaigned to replace concrete in the city centre with greenery and confine development to places with 'little or no biodiversity' while running for the Auckland mayoralty under the Animal Justice Auckland banner in 2022. Ryan Pausina According to his 2022 candidate blurb, Ryan Pausina's local political awakening came after a friend encouraged him to run for mayor of Coromandel. He quickly realised he would fix everything there within five months and decided to turn his talents to a more substantial challenge. Anything other than running the nation's biggest city would be, as per the blurb, a waste of his talents. 'It has been said that Elon Musk realised at one point in his life that other people don't think like he does,' the text concludes. 'People with a great mind should use it.' The blurb doesn't contain any advice for what people should do if they're blessed with the gift of great humility. Jason Pieterse Jason Pieterse did not respond to an email from The Spinoff asking who he is and why he's standing for mayor of Auckland. A person with that name does appear to have offered support to the New Zealand rugby team 'The All Blacks' in a Facebook comment from a year ago. Simon Stam A man named Simon Stam ran in Round The Bays in 2014, achieving a time of 48 minutes and 18 seconds, at a pace of nine minutes and 39 seconds per kilometre. Peter Wakeman Wikipedia describes Peter Wakeman as a 'perennial candidate', and he does appear to have stood in a remarkable number of political races around the country over the last few decades. In 2013, Wakeman rushed the stage during the launch of Lianne Dalziel's campaign to become Christchurch's mayor. Though he had to be restrained, his actions were credited with breathing new life into the race. Denise Widdison Facebook lists two Denise Widdisons in Auckland. One regularly offers free stuff to Te Atatu residents, including toys and, most notably, a full box of lemons. Another is a self-employed former student of Auckland Girls Grammar. Which one is standing for mayor? You decide.
Scoop
10-07-2025
- Scoop
City Vision Opposes Helipads In Residential Areas
City Vision does not support private helipads in residential areas – the impacts on direct neighbours and wider neighbourhoods are too great. Julie Fairey, Councillor for Albert-Eden-Puketāpapa, and our team in Waitematā, are appalled that the consent for the new helipad in Rawene Avenue, Westmere has been granted in the face of council and community opposition. 'It was disappointing, and surprising, to see independent commissioners approve the new helipad in Westmere. Although it's outside my ward the noise travels to Pt Chevalier so has an impact on my constituents and I attended Helen White MP's meeting with Quiet Sky Waitematā in November. The discussion about the effects on neighbours and the environment were very concerning' says Fairey. 'It seems absurd commissioners equated the noise from a helicopter with that of a motorbike or a bus (assumedly diesel and we are phasing those out!).' City Vision is focused on working towards an enduring solution for the community on the broader issue of helipads in residential areas of Auckland, as well as identifying how to best support those who wish to oppose the specific approval given for the Westmere site. City Vision member on the Waitematā Local Board Alex Bonham has been working on this issue for some time, including presenting at the hearing to oppose the granting of the consent for Rawene Avenue. 'The impact of noise pollution on a growing urban population and all waterfront users is a problem that will only get worse' says Bonham. 'Impacts on neighbours and users of the beaches and coastline include rotor wash (down draught) and distressing noise. The environmental impacts on beaches, the foreshore and coastal bird habitats are irreversible. Once granted, helicopter consents in perpetuity will permanently destroy peaceful neighbourhoods, waterfronts and biodiverse habitats.' Bonham and Fairey have supported work already underway to tighten rules for helicopter use in residential areas, including a current plan change for operations in the Hauraki Gulf. Waitemata & Gulf ward candidate for City Vision, Patrick Reynolds, shares these concerns. 'City Vision will work to do what is necessary to fix the Auckland Unitary Plan during next year's review, working alongside the community and interested parties to protect residential areas and the environment' says Reynolds. City Vision representatives, including Bonham and Reynolds, will be at Quiet Sky Waitematā Public Meeting on Thursday 10th July at 7pm at Hawke Sea Scout Hall, 55 West End Road.
Scoop
01-07-2025
- Scoop
Children Most At Risk As Government Forces Reversals Of Safe Speeds On 1 July
Just as the school holidays get under way, children around the country will be at higher risk on streets in their neighbourhoods as the Setting of Speed Limits Rule (the Rule) introduced by Minister Simeon Brown and implemented by current Minister of Transport Chris Bishop requires councils to revert to dangerous higher speed limits from 1 July, with variable speeds in place only at school gates at the start and end of the school day. 'Children across the country are at risk from higher speeds when they're walking, biking or scooting around their neighbourhoods. If hit by a vehicle going 50km/h, children have an 80% higher likelihood of being killed or seriously injured than at 30km/h. We also know that 85% of crashes that injure or kill people on streets around schools happen outside of those short periods at the beginning and end of the school day', says Caroline Perry, NZ Director of Brake, the road safety charity, and a spokesperson for the Save our Safe Streets campaign. 'The heightened risk is especially concerning in Auckland, where Auckland Transport has taken an unusually strict interpretation of the Rule that has seen over 1400 mainly quiet residential streets swept up in speed limit reversals. Not only has AT gone far further than other councils in applying the rule, they have rushed the work, resulting in confusing, incomplete, contradictory and dangerous signage,' says Ms Perry. The Save our Safe Streets campaign is an alliance of leading road safety experts and transport advocates. In a briefing paper to Auckland Council's Transport, Resilience and Infrastructure Committee, they have documented AT's flawed approach to the Rule. In particular they note that the rollout of reversals back to unsafe speeds – against the wishes of impacted communities – will result in harm to Aucklanders, wasteful expenditure, unnecessary disruption, higher costs and more extensive traffic management processes, environmental and economic damage, and a less efficient, more congested transport network. Group member Pippa Coom says, 'Instead of doing everything it could to defend its world-class road safety programme from ill-advised reversals, AT has capitulated effectively throwing Aucklanders under the bus at every opportunity. Moreover, the small handful of streets that have retained safe speeds were saved only due to tenacious intervention by residents and advocates – with neither public acknowledgement nor thanks from AT.' 'Throughout, AT has operated in secret. It has not been transparent or proactive in its dealings with Council and the public about its process around the Speed Limit Rule, nor has it communicated the impacts on communities. AT has had plenty of opportunities to limit the perverse and harmful outcomes of the Speed Limit Rule but chose not to, despite increasingly urgent requests from community leaders, advocates, and elected members,' says Ms Coom. Councillor Julie Fairey expressed profound disappointment in the outcome for Auckland. 'AT just were not interested in moving on this, despite being given plenty of opportunities and excuses they could use. Sadly, I think we won't have a full realisation of the liability question until someone is hurt or killed. The advocacy efforts on this have been amazing, huge amounts of research and effort put in, all voluntary, and the stonewalling at senior levels of AT has been heartbreaking'. She has gone on to say, 'I find it particularly cruel that many of the staff who have had to roll this out were those who understand the evidence, championed and implemented safer speeds.' The higher speeds kick in on 1 July, during the school holidays, and the reality of central government overriding evidence and local preference is only just becoming clear to many communities. For example, a stretch of beach north of Auckland is rising from 50km/h to 70km/h against community wishes, while further south, a nonsensical 100km/h will be installed on a dangerous stretch of road through a Lake Taupō campground. Ms Perry adds, 'A few fortunate communities, such as Rakaia and Nelson, will be rightly celebrating their common-sense retention of safe speeds, but this only came after a hard-fought campaign resulted in public consultation on the proposed speed limit increases to these stretches of road.' 'It should be common-sense to always apply the evidence to keep children safe. Everyone benefits when children can move independently, when people are free to walk and cycle without fear of serious injury and death, and when streets are safer for all of us,' says Ms Perry.
