Seán Rooney: Mother of says 'justice was not done'
The main defendant in the case is Mohammad Ayyad. It is understood he did not appear in court on Monday.A number of other men were convicted in relation to the shooting.Unifil, the UN peacekeeping force in Lebanon, said Lebanon's permanent military court found six individuals who were charged over Mr Rooney's killing guilty. One person was acquitted.The death sentence was announced at a military tribunal in Beirut, according to Irish broadcaster RTÉ."What happened in Lebanon is unreflective of what we regard as a trial process," Ms Rooney said. "The trial into the murder of my son was heard and determined in less than half a day. Not only was justice not done, it was not seen to be done, with little to no information being disclosed or challenged in open court," she said. "Instead, we are forced to believe the answers provided by a Lebanese justice system which from the outset has failed to hold those responsible to account."Ms Rooney called the process a "sham trial". She also criticised that the proceedings, originally scheduled for September 2025, were brought forward to this week, something she said caused "unforeseen pressures". In a statement on Tuesday, Tánaiste (deputy Irish prime minister) Simon Harris said he raised his "deep frustration at the slow pace of proceedings" before the Lebanese Military Tribunal.
Irish government reaction
"While noting the sentence handed down to the main defendant, I am disappointed and share the disappointment of Pte Rooney's family at the lighter sentences imposed on a number of those convicted today," Harris said.He added: "I appreciate that this is an incredibly difficult day for the family of Private Rooney. None of us can fathom their unimaginable pain and grief and all my thoughts remain with them at this time."In her statement, Ms Rooney criticised the Irish government for issuing public statements before speaking to the family. Ms Rooney said that "in a country where victims' rights ought to be paramount, it would perhaps be wise for the Tánaiste to speak to me, before seeking to speak for me, in his public statements".
Harris visited Beirut last March and met with the Lebanese Ministers of Foreign Affairs of Defence.RTÉ News on Thursday reported that Harris said in a statement he "cannot imagine the pain and suffering experienced by the Rooney family". "I look forward to meeting Mrs Rooney and arrangements are underway to ensure this happens."Above all, I want to support her quest for justice in any way I possibly can."Unifil said it "welcomes the conclusion of the trial process and the Government of Lebanon's commitment to bring the perpetrators to justice"."Once again, we offer our deepest condolences to the family, friends, and colleagues of Private Rooney and the Government of Ireland."
Ms Rooney said that she will "dedicate every bone in my body to ensure justice for Seán, and to highlight the uncomfortable truths about the systemic failings by the United Nations, the Irish Defence Forces and the Lebanese justice system". "That is the very least I owe my son Seán. It is the very least I owe Seán comrades."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Gaza aid drop kills 15-year-old boy
A 15-year-old boy has been killed by an air-dropped aid package in central Gaza. Muhannad Eid was running towards the heavy packages as they were parachuted into the territory when one crushed him, his brother said. Footage shows five or more large pallets slamming into the ground in front of the ruins of buildings in Nuseirat as Gazans try to reach the aid. The body, believed to be of Muhannad, is then seen in footage being dragged from underneath the crate and carried away from the crowds. In March 2024, falling aid pallets were reported to have killed five Palestinians after parachutes used to slow the crates down failed to open properly. The US and Jordan were among the countries taking part in aid drops at the time, but both of their militaries denied involvement in the deaths. The UN and other aid groups have frequently criticised the aid drops, which are far more costly than trucks and deliver much less food, as being insufficient. They have also warned that they risk killing the Palestinians they are intended to help. Instead, UN agencies and other relief groups have for months been pushing Israel to allow more aid into Gaza by land on trucks and open up access to the territory to prevent starvation among its 2.2 million people, most of whom are displaced. More than 1,300 people have been killed trying to receive aid in the enclave since the US backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) began operating in May 2025, the UN has said, most of them shot by Israeli forces operating near GHF sites. Israel denies having a policy of starvation in Gaza, and says Hamas could end the crisis by surrendering. It also says Hamas and other groups are behind the killings. The death of Muhannad comes as at least 18 people were killed across the enclave on Saturday, including civilians waiting to collect aid, Gaza's civil defence agency said. At least six people were reportedly killed and 30 wounded after Israeli troops were accused of targeting civilians assembling near an aid point in central Gaza. The other deaths were caused by airstrikes elsewhere in central Gaza. Israeli restrictions on supplies into Gaza since the start of the war nearly two years ago have led to shortages of food and essential supplies, including medicine and fuel, which hospitals require to power their generators. Despite mounting international pressure on Benjamin Netanyahu's government to end the war, the Israeli security cabinet approved plans early on Friday to seize Gaza City, moving towards a full takeover of the Strip. Israel's offensive has killed more than 61,000 Palestinians, according to Hamas-run Gaza's health ministry, figures the UN says are reliable. However, they do not distinguish between civilian and combatant deaths.
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
The Nazis would have been proud of Hamas's vile propagandists
Desperate people clamouring around a truck begging for food. An emaciated child on death's door. Women, girls, children, babies: no innocent is immune from Israel's psychotically cruel campaign of bloodlust in Gaza. It is unbearable to see. Who can stand by and watch such crimes? This, at any rate, is what most of the world's media, from the most respectable broadcaster to the grimiest freesheet, is eager for you to think. It is also what Hamas wants you to think. As long-term masters of some of the most cynical propaganda the world has ever seen, Hamas is succeeding in its plan with resounding success. Keir Starmer last week appeared to speak for the whole of Britain when he said that scenes from Gaza fill us with 'revulsion' – against Israel, of course. Largely because of such images of suffering, Starmer wants to reward the forces of Palestinian terror with the recognition of a state. 'I think people are revolted at what they are seeing on their screen,' he said. The next day he spoke of 'starving babies, children too weak to stand, images that will stay with us for a lifetime'. Pictures. Images. Screens. These are what appear to be deciding Israel's – and the Palestinians' – legal status on the world stage. It is not that there isn't immense suffering in Gaza. There is. Hundreds of thousands of Gazans are in dire straits, have lost family members, are in pain, injured, hungry, homeless, desperate, scared, the terrorist group's blood-soaked grip always around their necks. It's a tragedy. But a lot of what sets the world alight is massaged, manipulated and in many cases downright fake. One of the most iconic images of the last few weeks, which helped consolidate the false worldwide consensus that Israel has become a rogue, genocidal state while the Palestinians deserve a state, was the skeletal boy allegedly nearly starved to death by an Israeli blockade, held in his mother's arms. What the great and the good left out in their haste to publish this picture, posed as a tableau reminiscent of Mary holding Jesus, was that the boy suffered from a congenital disease. It was later quietly acknowledged by The New York Times – way too late – that he had pre-existing health problems and they would have highlighted this if they had known before publication. We see lots of pictures of desperate people clamouring for food banging pots and pans. Some of these might represent the strangled reality on the ground. But as the German tabloid Bild bothered to discover, one of the most prominent pictures of such clamouring hunger in recent weeks has photographer Anas Zayed Fteiha, a freelance journalist commissioned by the Turkish news agency Anadolu, snapping the photos in the manner of a director. Fteiha, as Bild reveals, isn't quite the impartial documentarian suggested, but an activist whose agency answers straight to Turkey's Hamas-sympathising president, Recep Erdoğan. Fteiha's social media profile is informative. His Instagram page includes a video captioned 'F** Israel' plus a painting by an arch-anti-Semite. He is publicly committed to the 'free Palestine' end game. But his pictures, notable for their perfect lighting and close-ups of idealised suffering, especially of children and mothers, were swallowed without question, disseminated in New York Magazine, CNN, the BBC, plenty of German papers and more. The wildfire success of such lies tells you much less about people's gullible compassion than about how far Hamas now rules the global playbook of anti-Semitism, Israel-hating and Israel-blaming. Let us be clear. For the terrible suffering in Gaza, the blame falls squarely on Hamas's manifold crimes. Hamas invaded Israel, knowing that, with its tunnels, weaponry and soldiers embedded in homes, schools and hospitals and behind civilians, Gazan civilians would take the brunt of Israel's inevitable response. The terror group's continued stranglehold in the Strip and refusal to hand back the hostages is the only thing prolonging the war and suffering, all of which could have ended long ago. Aid distribution systems have been corrupted, smashed or perverted, keeping food from some who badly need it, and ensuring it goes to those with the right connections. None of this is because of Israeli cruelty. All of it is because of Hamas's cruelty and infinite scheming. The truth has never mattered, though. Hamas knew Israel would be blamed, ostracised, and punished on the world stage on a scale never seen before, its very legitimacy called into question amid irreparable diplomatic crises. It was easy; Hamas was just kicking at a door its own predecessors helped kick open. Hamas is finessing and darkening a tradition of propaganda built by Yasser Arafat, a master of the fabricated sympathetic picture, such as that during Israel's 2002 operation in the West Bank that showed him alone and besieged in his compound. He sat at his desk with only candlelight to see by – an image the world lapped right up – only for lights to go right back on after the shoot. As the historian Richard Landes describes in his essential book, Can the Whole World Be Wrong? Lethal Journalism, Antisemitism and Global Jihad, one of the defining images of the 21st century, the signal 'icon of hatred' against the Israel and the Jews, was the 'eyewitness' film apparently capturing Muhammad al-Dura, a defenceless 12-year-old boy, being shot in cold blood by the IDF, while held in his father's arms, on September 30 2000. It spread like wildfire. Analysis of the footage later contradicted this narrative. The IDF didn't kill the boy. But by the time it was corrected, the damage had been done. Nobody cared, then, or now. This laid down a grotesquely immoral media-age template that has been used ever since. Those of us who have followed media bias against Israel for many years are well versed in the absolutely central role of 'Pallywood' – the well-known industry in the Palestinian territories that oversees the staging of fake news footage of Palestinian children and women suffering at the hands of Israel, producing a stream of emotive imagery for the world's media. No true imagery produced by Israel, or even the true, boastful footage from Hamas of the Israeli hostages it has starved and murdered at close range, can even begin to counter Pallywood's work. The use of emotive imagery to peddle genocidal ideology is hardly new. Leni Riefenstahl, the director of the Third Reich's propaganda films (who lived to the age of 101), offers an interesting comparison. Whereas Pallywood stages suffering, Riefenstahl's art pretended that even those bound for Auschwitz were just fine and dandy. She cast gypsies as frolicking extras, then said they all survived the Holocaust. Not only were they sent to Auschwitz, Riefenstahl was thought, in some cases, to have helped them on their way though she denied it all. While people were tortured, executed after show trials, or sent to the gulag, the Soviet propaganda department ensured a constant flow of idealised images of healthy, happy, sturdy people: courageous, righteous, industrious, reproductive and the biggest lie of all: finally free. What makes the global hook, line and sinker acceptance of Hamas propaganda so surreal is that it comes a century after Stalin took power, and nearly a century after Hitler did. What has history taught us? Sadly, those in Israel who know the answer are ignored and vilified, and those outside Israel who know the answer are now too old to provide it.
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
Would-be leaders of Palestinian state are extremists, Starmer warned
Sir Keir Starmer has been warned that recognition of a Palestinian state will 'lay the groundwork for the next Oct 7'. The Prime Minister is under pressure to reconsider the move amid concerns that Palestinian children are being radicalised. A report by an Israeli-founded non-profit organisation warned that the Palestinian Authority (PA), the current government in the territories, is 'indoctrinating' children with school textbooks that 'glorify terrorism'. It is expected that the UK would treat the PA as the sovereign government of a Palestinian state following recognition. But the report by Impact-se (the Institute for Monitoring Peace and Cultural Tolerance in School Education) is likely to raise fears about any move to recognise a state. Examples in the report include reading comprehension exercises describing terrorist attacks on Israeli civilians as 'heroism', maths exercises asking children to count the number of 'martyrs' who died in the First Intifada, and children's books circulated for National Reading Day depicting a suicide bomber who killed 21 Israeli civilians. It also draws attention to the PA's so-called 'pay-for-slay' scheme, an arrangement whereby convicted terrorists are given financial rewards in proportion to the severity of their prison sentences. The report notes that 316 convicted terrorists have become 'millionaires' under the scheme. Marcus Sheff, the chief executive of Impact-se, told The Telegraph: 'British recognition without urgent curriculum reform would embolden indoctrination, not peace – laying the groundwork for the next Oct 7.' He also warned that British aid is funding the distribution of such materials and 'indoctrinating another generation for jihad'. 'Curriculum fuels anti-Semitism' Mr Sheff said: 'UK taxpayers were told for years that the Palestinian Authority was reforming the radical curriculum that fuels anti-Semitism, violence and hate. 'Our forensic review of every single page, in every textbook, for every grade and subject shows these promises were empty. Not one substantive change has been made. 'The same material that glorifies murder of civilians, teaches maths by counting 'martyrs', and explains Newtonian physics through slingshot attacks is still in place. 'Even after pledging reform to the EU and UK in July 2024, the PA created a tailor-made curriculum for Gaza in January – a carbon copy of the hate-filled texts – spitting in the face of donor governments. 'Less than a year ago, a senior Palestinian ministry of education official told local media there would be no changes to the curriculum, in reaction to rumours that there might be changes, flatly rejecting even the idea of reform. 'To make matters worse, the UK has signed off over £100m in taxpayer funds under a new agreement that has stripped out previous clauses on removing incitement to violence and hate from the curriculum.' Figures in Sir Keir's own party have also joined calls for him to think again about recognising a Palestinian state, warning that 'the PA needs to undertake serious, meaningful and substantive reform'. Michael Rubin, director of Labour Friends of Israel (LFI), said: 'There's a reason Israelis and Palestinians alike are so distrustful of President Abbas' government. 'It incites violence and terrorism against Israelis, is authoritarian and riddled with corruption, and commits shocking human rights abuses against its own people. 'If we're going to recognise a Palestinian state, the PA needs to undertake serious, meaningful and substantive reform. 'To start, it must abolish the pernicious payment of 'salaries' to terrorists and stop poisoning young minds by glorifying suicide bombers in school books and naming schools after terrorists and Nazi collaborators.' The PA said in February it planned to abolish the so-called 'pay-for-slay' in what was widely seen as an olive branch to President Trump. However little progress on the issue has been reported since. Lord Walney, Sir Keir's former independent adviser on political violence and disruption, said: 'Those who are pushing the fallacy that a Palestinian state is just round the corner like to portray the Palestinian Authority as peace-loving moderates in contrast to the Islamist Hamas terrorists. 'But this important dossier highlights that a vein of extremism runs right through PA too, embedding intolerance with appalling education textbooks. 'The United Nations and the UK have long turned a blind eye to the indoctrination that they have been indirectly funding for many years – that must change if there is any hope of a fresh start for Israel and Palestine.' Mr Sheff is a British-Israeli former journalist who was serving as a reservist in the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) at the time of the Oct 7 attacks.
