
HC acquits 2 convicted in electrocution case in 2004 that resulted in man's death
Raipur: Citing lack of evidence, direct link and the deceased's own negligence, the Chhattisgarh High Court has acquitted two men convicted in an electrocution case.
The court overturned the lower court's verdict, which had sentenced the men to six months' rigorous imprisonment in the two decades old case.
"The prosecution has utterly failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased died because of the act of the accused persons/applicants," the court said in its judgment.
"The death of the deceased was wholly of his own negligent act. The deceased was not trained in electrical work but skilled in mechanical tasks. Despite this, he climbed the electric pole to connect a wire, indicating his own negligence.
Being an adult and sensible person, he was expected to understand the risks involved in handling electricity. If he chose to proceed despite the dangers, he alone is responsible for the consequences," Justice Radhakishan Agrawal remarked in his order.
The case stemmed from an incident on May 4, 2004, where Shahjahan died after being electrocuted while connecting a thresher machine to an electric pole at Sitapur in Surguja district.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Viral Video: मृत्यू कसाही येऊ शकतो! सीसीटीव्हीत कैद झाली काळीज पिळवटणारी घटना
Latest News
Read More
Undo
The prosecution alleged that the accused, Shabbir Khan and Shamim Khan, had asked Shahjahan to connect the wire, assuring him the power was disconnected.
The trial court and the appellate court had convicted the men under Section 304-A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), which deals with causing death by negligence. However, Justice Agrawal, in his order, noted that the prosecution failed to establish a direct link between the accused's actions and the deceased's death.
The court observed that key witnesses, including Mansoor Khan, the deceased's brother, admitted in their statements that they did not witness the incident. Mansoor also acknowledged that his brother was not an electrician but a mechanical worker. HC noted that the deceased was an adult and aware of the dangers of working with electricity.
The court also pointed out inconsistencies in the witnesses' statements, including the omission of Shamim Khan's name in the initial police report. The judge cited Supreme Court rulings, emphasising the need for a direct nexus between the accused's negligence and the victim's death. The high court allowed the criminal revision and acquitted Shabbir Khan and Shamim Khan. Their bail bonds will remain in effect for six months, as per legal procedure.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
Man pledges fake gold, dupes SBI of 7 Lakh
Meerut: An FIR was registered on Sunday after the State Bank of India (SBI) branch in Sarurpur village, Meerut, suffered a loss of over Rs 7 lakh when a man secured loans using fake gold jewellery. According to the bank, the accused, Mohd Nazim — a resident of Meerut — took a loan of Rs 5.7 lakh in 2015 by mortgaging jewellery that was later found to be mostly silver. In 2018, he secured another loan, bringing the total disbursed amount to nearly Rs 11 lakh. However, a recent assessment found the pledged ornaments to be worth only Rs 3.7 lakh, causing a loss of Rs 7.2 lakh to the bank. Bank manager Aditya (who goes by his first name only) said the jewellery had been certified by a well-known jeweller from Meerut's Sarafa Bazaar, and the bank had relied on that purity certificate, which turned out to be fake. SP (Rural) Rakesh Kumar Mishra said, "An FIR has been registered against both the borrower and the jeweller under IPC section 420 (cheating), 406(cfriminal breach of trust ) at Sarurpur police station. We are investigating and expect a breakthrough soon."


Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
Nepal man held with explosives near key suspension bridge in Pithoragarh
Pithoragarh: A 37-year-old man from Nepal was arrested by the Sahastra Seema Bal (SSB) on Sunday night near a key suspension bridge in Dharchula area of Pithoragarh district, which connects India and Nepal, after explosives were found in his possession. Officials said SSB personnel spotted Yam Bahadur Khatri, a resident of Padampur village in Surkhet district, "loitering suspiciously" near the bridge. Upon searching his bag, they recovered one kilogram of explosive emulsion and five detonators. He was immediately detained and handed over to Dharchula police on Monday for further investigation. KS Rawat, circle officer of Dharchula, said, "The explosives Khatri was carrying were made in Nepal. During interrogation, he claimed he was transporting the material for construction purposes. He said the route on the Nepal side was in poor condition, so he decided to take the Indian road to reach his destination. That's when he was arrested by an SSB patrol team." Dharchula SHO Brijendra Saha said, "A case has been registered against Khatri under sections 4 (punishment for attempts to cause explosions, or for making or keeping explosive substances with the intent to endanger life or property) and 5 (punishment for making or possessing explosive substances under suspicious circumstances) of the Explosives Act. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Good News: You May Be Richer Than You Think Undo He was produced before a judicial magistrate on Monday and remanded to 14 days' judicial custody. Further investigation is underway." The suspension bridge is among the few pedestrian crossings over the Kali river that directly connect Indian and Nepali territory. It is frequently used by locals from both countries for trade, essential services and family visits. Citizens are permitted to cross the border without a visa or passport. The area holds geopolitical significance as it is situated near the India-Nepal-China tri-junction. The nearby Lipulekh Pass is a strategic corridor for India that connects to the Kailash Mansarovar Yatra route and overlooks China's Tibet Autonomous Region.


Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
2 Charred To Death As E-Rick Being Charged Catches Fire
New Delhi: Two men, including a 55-year-old, died after a fire broke out when an e-rickshaw was being recharged in east Delhi's Dilshad Garden late on Sunday night. The deceased were identified as Shashi and Ballu. Police received information about the fire in Tahirpur Kodi Colony around 11.39pm on Sunday. The cops described the building where the incident took place as a ground floor and three upper floors built on an approximately 25 sq yard plot. "The fire had broken out on the ground floor of the house. Head constable Rajkumar acted promptly and evacuated a woman named Meera Devi," a police officer said. After the fire service extinguished the flames, the bodies of Shashi, 25, an e-rickshaw driver, and Ballu, 55, a vagabond who occasionally drove e-rickshaws, were discovered. They were sent to the hospital to ascertain the cause of death. Two e-rickshaws were also found scorched. Police said that the charging point was illegal. "Inquiries revealed that e-rickshaws were being recharged on the ground floor of the house. The fire was caused by a short circuit," the officer revealed. Shashi lived in the house with his parents and three brothers. A case under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita's sections 106(1) (causing death by negligence) and 287 (negligent conduct with respect to fire or combustible matter) has been registered at Nand Nagri police station. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Trade Bitcoin & Ethereum – No Wallet Needed! IC Markets Start Now Undo Investigation is in progress and the crime team and the forensics team have scoured the spot for clues. Anurag, Shashi's brother, claimed the fire was triggered by a short circuit in the electrical board. He said the malfunction caused the inverter to catch fire, which quickly spread and burnt a motorcycle parked nearby. "My brother worked as a bus conductor, but more recently, he had started earning a living by driving an e-rickshaw," said Anurag. He added, "Ballu, who had no permanent residence, occasionally accompanied my brother on rides in the e-rickshaw. At night, Ballu usually slept on the ground floor with Shashi. At the time of the fire too, they were together." Anurag explained that after the flames started spreading, the tenants present in the building managed to escape safely. His elderly mother was also evacuated from the premises in time. "We used to charge both our e-rickshaws outside the house because there wasn't enough space inside," he said.