Iddo Moed: False narratives about Israel have violent consequences
Article content
Article content
The founders of the State of Israel were not aristocrats or members of a wealthy elite. They were refugees and immigrants — men and women who arrived with little more than determination and hope. They fled violence, persecution, and antisemitism from every corner of the world: pogroms in Europe and Asia, attacks by mobs and ultimately expulsion from Arab lands, and the unthinkable horrors of the Holocaust.
Article content
Article content
While Jews have had a continuous presence in the Holy Land for millennia, modern Israel was forged in the crucible of exile and survival. Today, Israel is a thriving liberal democracy with a diverse and multicultural society, a dynamic economy, and a strong defence force.
Article content
Article content
We are proud of these achievements. But we have never forgotten an important lesson from Jewish history: false narratives, when left unchallenged, have violent consequences.
Article content
One need not look far to understand why this lesson is so deeply ingrained in our psyche. Theodor Herzl, the father of modern political Zionism, was moved by what he witnessed during the infamous Dreyfus Affair in late 19th-century France. A Jewish army officer, Captain Alfred Dreyfus, was falsely accused and convicted of treason. The campaign against him was led by the virulently antisemitic press — particularly La Libre Parole, which pushed a dangerous narrative: that Jews were inherently disloyal.
Article content
Given our history, we are highly attuned to the moments these falsehoods begin to surface. That's why, when I woke up Sunday morning to headlines from nearly every major Canadian media outlet — except National Post — about an alleged incident at a Gaza Humanitarian Foundation aid hub in Rafah, I was immediately concerned.
Article content
This war has shown us, time and again, how Hamas manipulates facts on the ground, creating stories of atrocities that either didn't happen or happened in a very different way. The media often amplifies these claims uncritically, and by the time the truth emerges, the damage is done.
Article content
The most egregious example came just weeks after the October 7 massacre. The Hamas-run Palestinian Health Ministry claimed an Israeli airstrike had killed hundreds at Al-Ahli Hospital. Israel immediately launched an investigation — but the media didn't wait. The story exploded across front pages and screens around the world.
Article content
By the time the investigation revealed that the explosion was caused by a Palestinian rocket, which was confirmed by the Canadian Forces Intelligence Command, millions were misled. Worse, some politicians — including Canada's own foreign affairs minister at the time — rushed to condemn Israel before the facts were known.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
2 hours ago
- National Post
'Hamas's propaganda war': Israel battles famine allegations
Article content In late July, Israel announced it would restart humanitarian air drops into Gaza alongside other Arab nations, including Jordan and the United Arab Emirates (UAE), a practice that was stopped last year after it destroyed property and hit civilians. Article content According to the New York Times, Israel had blockaded food from entering the Strip between March and May, citing concerns that Hamas was pilfering supplies. Article content The extent of Hamas's theft of humanitarian aid remains a hotly contested issue. The New York Times reported that the 'Israeli military never found proof that the Palestinian militant group had systematically stolen aid from the United Nations, the biggest supplier of emergency assistance to Gaza for most of the war,' based on anonymous conversations with several Israeli officials. Article content However, on Tuesday, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) released a video purportedly showing Hamas militants with rifles 'looting an aid truck' while civilians gather around. Article content Article content Images shared by Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a Palestinian-American academic and senior fellow with the Atlantic Council, also purport to show Hamas militants stealing aid during an earlier ceasefire. 'Right here before your eyes! But according to NGOs & media, there's still 'no evidence' of theft,' Alkhatib, a vocal critic of Hamas and the Netanyahu government, wrote on X in mid-July. Article content In another post the following day, Alkhatib shared a video alleging Hamas police officers stripped, arrested and beat Palestinians who ventured to the GHF aid distribution site. Article content Hamas's police used pick-ups & donkey carts to steal aid throughout the Gaza war, especially during the ceasefire earlier this year, where hundreds of trucks entered the Strip daily. Right here before your eyes! But according to NGOs & media, there's still "no evidence" of theft. — Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib (@afalkhatib) July 21, 2025 Article content Article content
National Post
2 hours ago
- National Post
Casey Babb: Canada doesn't need an antisemitism or Islamophobia czar
On July 17, Deborah Lyons, Canada's special envoy on preserving Holocaust remembrance and combating antisemitism, abruptly retired. Lyons, who served as Canada's ambassador to Israel from 2016 to 2020, came into this role in October 2023 — just a week after Palestinian terrorists carried out their barbaric attacks in Israel, killing some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and taking over 250 hostages. While she was expected to hold the position for another few months, until October 2025, she decided ' with a heavy heart,' to step down early. Article content Article content With the position now vacant, the time has come to permanently dissolve the post — as well as the position of Canada's special representative on combating Islamophobia. High paying jobs that don't lead to results are bad. Ones that continue to divide people are even worse. Article content Article content For nearly two years, as Canada's Jewish community has been gripped not only by the horrors of October 7 and its fallout, but by surging Jew-hatred from coast to coast, Lyons faced an arduous uphill battle. Still, despite unprecedented obstacles and criticism, she worked diligently to sound the alarm on antisemitism, to bring disparate communities together and — in whatever small ways she could — to mend the wounds of a grieving community that has been completely and utterly abandoned by the federal government. Lyons has said that 'every day' she was 'waking up to a fight,' that she had to deal with 'a lot of angry people … all the time,' often feeling 'despondent and despairing' over how reluctant Canadians were to speak up in support of the country's Jewish population. Of course, criticism of Lyons is understandable. While in her post to combat antisemitism, the situation for Jews in Canada has worsened precipitously. But for Lyons, many of the obstacles she encountered were systemically, institutionally, socially and culturally beyond her control or influence. Article content Article content One glaring issue that likely made Lyons' job more challenging, however, was what appeared to be the relentless counter-efforts made by Amira Elghawaby, Canada's special representative on combating Islamophobia. Article content Article content Rather than focusing on things like peace-building, reconciliation and creating a united front between Jews and Muslims to counter all forms of hatred and bigotry, Elghawaby spent (and continues to spend) most of her attention on things like 'anti-Palestinian racism,' vilifying the only Jewish country in the world (there are approximately 50 Muslim majority nations, by the way), and fuelling the fabricated belief among average Canadians that antisemitism and anti-Muslim bigotry run and exist on parallel tracks, when of course, they most certainly do not. Article content Further, while Lyons repeatedly acknowledged the hostages, the victims of October 7, including the eight Canadians murdered by Hamas, and condemned Hamas and other Islamic terrorist organizations, Elghawaby has — for the most part — acted as though October 7 didn't happen.
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
PM Carney assembling cabinet today to talk U.S. trade, Middle East
OTTAWA — Prime Minister Mark Carney is meeting virtually with his cabinet today to discuss the state of trade negotiations with the U.S. and the situation in the Middle East. The meeting is scheduled for 2 p.m. ET. Minister responsible for Canada-U.S. Trade Dominic LeBlanc is in Washington today meeting with U.S. officials. Carney said Monday that Canada's negotiations with the United States are in an 'intense phase' after President Donald Trump clinched a critical agreement with the European Union. Trump told reporters last week that Canada wasn't a priority ahead of his Aug. 1 deadline to make trade deals. Ministers are also expected to discuss the situation in the Middle East after the government announced Monday that it's adding $30 million to its humanitarian funding for Palestinians in the Gaza Strip and $10 million to 'accelerate reform and capacity-building for the Palestinian Authority.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 30, 2025.
