Yukon child advocate finds shortcomings in gov't response to holds, isolation at Whitehorse school
The Yukon government failed to properly respond to and support students and families affected by the improper use of holds and isolation at a Whitehorse elementary school, according to a new report by the office of the territory's child and youth advocate.
Territorial Education Minister Jeanie McLean tabled the report — titled I Am Not Okay, It's Not Okay — in the Yukon legislative assembly Thursday. The 68-page document is the result of a systemic review the advocate's office began in 2021 after reports emerged that some staff at Jack Hulland Elementary School had placed students in physical holds or confined them in isolation spaces.
"I think the title says it," advocate Annette King said in an interview after the report was tabled, emphasizing the "long-lasting impacts" that the practices had on children and their families.
"In our work, we're always dealing with rights violations... But to learn about the magnitude of this in terms of the long-standing 'Jack Hulland way' that wasn't addressed for many, many years — that is alarming."
Holds, where adults use their bodies to physically restrain a child, are supposed to be a last resort when a child is at serious risk of harming themselves or others, while isolation is not supposed to be used in Yukon schools at all. However, an internal review by the education department found that up until 2020, some Jack Hulland staff members routinely used both on students for not complying with directions, including in cases like a child refusing to pull down the hood on their sweater.
"We have witnessed the alarming consequences of a systemic failure in the education system – one that has left vulnerable children subject to harmful practices, without accountability for those responsible," part of the child and youth advocate's report reads.
The advocate office's review was independent from the government's and from a Yukon RCMP investigation that resulted in no criminal charges being laid. The report makes five findings related to major shortcomings in the government's response and lays out eight recommendations "so that this never happens again."
Among the shortcomings were a lack of communication with families throughout the process, which the report says left some "in a state of uncertainty and frustration" and excluded others from being able to participate in investigations or reviews.
The report also says there was inadequate documentation and incident reporting, including when it came to "some individuals" complying with their duty to promptly report suspected child abuse and properly filling out workplace risk assessments. School staff must fill out those assessments whenever there's physical contact between a student and staff member, but the report says that in some cases, assessments at Jack Hulland lacked detail or were not done at all. As well, some of the completed assessments were not properly stored or reviewed by higher-ups in the department in a timely manner.
Other shortcomings, the report says, include staff named in the criminal investigation having continued access to students, insufficient educational programming for students with complex needs, and a failure to provide therapeutic support for both current and former Jack Hulland students since the allegations came to light.
As well, the report says the RCMP's response "was delayed by many months and interviews were not prioritized," which resulted in some victims losing trust in the investigation and deciding not to participate when finally contacted by police.
Minister accepts recommendations 'in principle'
The report's recommendations include improving coordination between government departments and other agencies to ensure reports of child abuse are dealt with promptly and that affected children receive ongoing support. It also recommends creating "a clear and organized process to document incidents," improving post-incident communication with school communities, strengthening school safety policies and procedures, and providing "continued access to supports" for former Jack Hulland students and families dealing with "the life-long impacts."
Besides the findings and recommendations, the report also notes that the office provided "individual advocacy" to 20 affected children and youth, that Indigenous children made up a "disproportionately high number" of Jack Hulland-related referrals to the office, and that while some affected children "struggled with dysregulation, many did not."
The report asks the government to provide an initial response to the recommendations and the work being done to implement them by June 30 and a follow-up by on Dec. 1.
Education Minister Jeanie McLean, who also tabled two other reports by the child and youth advocate this week, unrelated to the Jack Hulland review, was not available for an interview Thursday or Friday. In a news release, she said the government accepted the reports' recommendations "in principle and has already been hard at work to take meaningful steps to address these issues."
"Our government is committed to creating safer, more inclusive schools that support every student's learning and wellbeing," she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
12-05-2025
- CBC
Police watchdog clears Whitehorse RCMP officers who broke teen's leg during arrest
A police watchdog has cleared two Yukon RCMP officers of any criminal wrongdoing after they broke a 17-year-old girl's leg during an arrest in Whitehorse in 2023. However, investigators with the Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT) also criticize the officers involved for the way they carried out the arrest, being "callous" and acting in a way that "perpetuated negative stereotypes about police officers." "A quick arrest of a youth for a minor offence that results in a broken bone does not serve the public trust in the same way that careful and thoughtful community policing does," reads ASIRT's investigation report. ASIRT is under contract to the Yukon government to look into any deaths or serious injuries involving police officers, as well as allegations of police misconduct. The report, released April 30, describes the circumstances leading to the teen's arrest and injury on April 8, 2023, in downtown Whitehorse. Investigators used video evidence as well as testimony from the injured teen and emergency medical responders to piece together what happened. Neither of the arresting officers provided a statement or notes to ASIRT investigators. "As the subjects of a criminal investigation, that is their legal right," the report notes. The report describes how Yukon Emergency Medical Services (EMS) had called RCMP that evening for help with an intoxicated 20-year-old female and "an aggressive bystander." When the two RCMP officers arrived at the scene they saw two people, one of whom immediately ran away leaving only the teenaged girl. There was no one else around, including EMS, the report says. On arrival, one of the officers told the girl, who was intoxicated, that she was under arrest for causing a disturbance, "only a few seconds after seeing her," the report says. The officers then immediately moved to arrest the girl and get her into the back of their vehicle. The report says that the teen physically resisted the officers' efforts to get her into the car by placing her feet against the vehicle. At some point during that struggle, her foot became trapped in a wheel well. Her leg was injured as the officers continue to try to force her into the back of the vehicle. ASIRT investigators found there was no evidence that the officers knew the girl's foot was stuck in the wheel well. Once the teenager was in the back seat, one of the officers swore, "in an apparent expression of surprise that her leg was trapped," the report says. It says the other officer then told the girl, "yeah, don't fight with the police." The officers then took the girl to the jail and called EMS from there. Emergency responders came and later determined that the girl suffered a fractured tibia, ruptured ligaments and other injuries to her right knee. Officers' actions 'reasonable' ASIRT investigators determined that if the officers had known the girl's foot was trapped in the wheel well, "they clearly would have been acting unreasonably and would face criminal liability." "However, given that the evidence tends to show that they did not know it was trapped, their actions were reasonable," the report says. Still, the investigators faulted the two officers for arresting the youth "for a minor offence without even taking the time to talk to her." They also cited the officer's "callous comment" about not fighting with police, after the girl was clearly hurt. They say that even if the officers did not commit a crime, that "does not mean that the subject officers dealt with the AP [affected person] in a respectful and professional manner." The investigators also pointed to the officers' decision not to call EMS as soon as they understood that the girl had been injured, and instead took her to jail first. "Police officers have a duty of care to those in their custody and this duty includes seeking prompt medical attention," the report states. "While their delay in seeking medical attention for the [affected person] was not significant enough to attract criminal liability, they still should have sought medical attention immediately."
CBC
04-05-2025
- CBC
Yukon RCMP commanding officer reflects on recent increase in gun violence
Yukon RCMP Chief Supt. Lindsay Ellis says there's been a real jump recently in gun-related incidents and crime across the territory. So far this year, police responded to several reports of gunshots, some of which involved 3D-printed guns. Several youths with firearms were arrested this winter, in unrelated incidents that took place in broad daylight in public spaces. In the past few days alone, an individual walked into a restaurant on Main Street, Whitehorse, brandishing a firearm. On a different day, a shooting took place in the city's Riverdale neighbourhood that sent one person to hospital, while another incident involving a replica firearm forced the evacuation of a building as well as homes and businesses within a two-block radius around downtown Whitehorse. Meanwhile, the federal government gave $4 million last November to help address gun crime and gang violence in the Yukon. So how is the local police handling the rise in gun violence? Ellis spoke to Yukon Morning's Elyn Jones Thursday about why this has become a growing issue and what the RCMP's response to it all is. The following interview has been edited for clarity and length. Yukoners have expressed concerns over what appears to be a rise in gun violence. How real is the issue? Over the last recent months, including over the last week or two, the RCMP have reported on investigations that we've undertaken or reports that we've received ... about firearms being displayed, brandished, or us coming upon firearms through the course of investigations. So it's not just a perception — it's real. We're getting some firearms out of traffic stops. That's highly concerning for officer safety and the public. When I'm seeing that my members every day are interacting with individuals that may have on their person operable or even replica firearms, that's a concern. The overarching concern is the fear that the public feels going anywhere in the Yukon and thinking, you know, "Does this person have a firearm? Is something going to take place in front of me that I have no control over? And I'm an innocent bystander, too." What explains this increase? Some of these incidents are perhaps not related. Some are through different demographics. So it could be that there are adult people who are involved in organized crime or gang-type activity. The territory changed in the last 10 to 15 years, but I think that we're just catching up with the rest of the country. Gun violence has been noted by Stats Canada to have increased over the last 10 years across Canada. There's many different reasons for that. I'd like to think that some of the reason that, in the Yukon, we're reporting on this and that we're responding and that we are coming upon perhaps some of these firearms in our duties, is that we are out there and we're focused on identifying and defusing but also preventing crime. We need to have some hard conversations as a community and as Yukoners about what we feel is acceptable and also what we're willing to do about the root causes. Where are the firearms coming from? There's many sources of illegal firearms in the country. Some are purchased legally through reputable dealers and then made their way into hands that they shouldn't be in. Some guns are smuggled in through other countries and some are ordered ... through the Internet and the dark web in separate parts. Some of these firearms are operable; some of them are replicas. The file that we had in Dawson City at the start of April, that was what we would call a ghost gun. So an untraceable firearm. It's a 3D-print ... so a 3D printer can print that gun and can render it operable. I don't want to opine about why some people would be carrying real or replica firearms. There could be many different reasons ... personal protection, actual wish to commit a crime. But there's no good reason in the Yukon for somebody to be carrying a real or replica firearm. How is the RCMP currently responding to the issue? Our response in those situations is the same. It's a professional, modern application of policing to defuse that public safety threat, and do so in the safest manner possible. Some of the incidents that have occurred in public during daytime hours on Main Street, even last night, are highly concerning with a high risk to public safety. And I can understand why Yukoners are concerned about this uptick. I want to be very clear, though, that the police are well positioned to respond. And we encourage people to, if they see something suspicious, call us. Please give us good details. What more can be done? It comes down to prevention and awareness, and also just conflict resolution. When people are feeling like perhaps it's acceptable to carry these firearms and to escalate, for lack of a better term, their beefs or their conflict with each other, I think that we can do maybe better as a community to try and resolve some of these conflicts.
CBC
03-05-2025
- CBC
Yukon child advocate finds shortcomings in gov't response to holds, isolation at Whitehorse school
The Yukon government failed to properly respond to and support students and families affected by the improper use of holds and isolation at a Whitehorse elementary school, according to a new report by the office of the territory's child and youth advocate. Territorial Education Minister Jeanie McLean tabled the report — titled I Am Not Okay, It's Not Okay — in the Yukon legislative assembly Thursday. The 68-page document is the result of a systemic review the advocate's office began in 2021 after reports emerged that some staff at Jack Hulland Elementary School had placed students in physical holds or confined them in isolation spaces. "I think the title says it," advocate Annette King said in an interview after the report was tabled, emphasizing the "long-lasting impacts" that the practices had on children and their families. "In our work, we're always dealing with rights violations... But to learn about the magnitude of this in terms of the long-standing 'Jack Hulland way' that wasn't addressed for many, many years — that is alarming." Holds, where adults use their bodies to physically restrain a child, are supposed to be a last resort when a child is at serious risk of harming themselves or others, while isolation is not supposed to be used in Yukon schools at all. However, an internal review by the education department found that up until 2020, some Jack Hulland staff members routinely used both on students for not complying with directions, including in cases like a child refusing to pull down the hood on their sweater. "We have witnessed the alarming consequences of a systemic failure in the education system – one that has left vulnerable children subject to harmful practices, without accountability for those responsible," part of the child and youth advocate's report reads. The advocate office's review was independent from the government's and from a Yukon RCMP investigation that resulted in no criminal charges being laid. The report makes five findings related to major shortcomings in the government's response and lays out eight recommendations "so that this never happens again." Among the shortcomings were a lack of communication with families throughout the process, which the report says left some "in a state of uncertainty and frustration" and excluded others from being able to participate in investigations or reviews. The report also says there was inadequate documentation and incident reporting, including when it came to "some individuals" complying with their duty to promptly report suspected child abuse and properly filling out workplace risk assessments. School staff must fill out those assessments whenever there's physical contact between a student and staff member, but the report says that in some cases, assessments at Jack Hulland lacked detail or were not done at all. As well, some of the completed assessments were not properly stored or reviewed by higher-ups in the department in a timely manner. Other shortcomings, the report says, include staff named in the criminal investigation having continued access to students, insufficient educational programming for students with complex needs, and a failure to provide therapeutic support for both current and former Jack Hulland students since the allegations came to light. As well, the report says the RCMP's response "was delayed by many months and interviews were not prioritized," which resulted in some victims losing trust in the investigation and deciding not to participate when finally contacted by police. Minister accepts recommendations 'in principle' The report's recommendations include improving coordination between government departments and other agencies to ensure reports of child abuse are dealt with promptly and that affected children receive ongoing support. It also recommends creating "a clear and organized process to document incidents," improving post-incident communication with school communities, strengthening school safety policies and procedures, and providing "continued access to supports" for former Jack Hulland students and families dealing with "the life-long impacts." Besides the findings and recommendations, the report also notes that the office provided "individual advocacy" to 20 affected children and youth, that Indigenous children made up a "disproportionately high number" of Jack Hulland-related referrals to the office, and that while some affected children "struggled with dysregulation, many did not." The report asks the government to provide an initial response to the recommendations and the work being done to implement them by June 30 and a follow-up by on Dec. 1. Education Minister Jeanie McLean, who also tabled two other reports by the child and youth advocate this week, unrelated to the Jack Hulland review, was not available for an interview Thursday or Friday. In a news release, she said the government accepted the reports' recommendations "in principle and has already been hard at work to take meaningful steps to address these issues." "Our government is committed to creating safer, more inclusive schools that support every student's learning and wellbeing," she said.
