Hosps follow transparency bill, start displaying rates
Association of Hospitals of Eastern India has slated a meeting for next week, when plans are on to address the need to consider the flexibility of hospital charges, which often leads to rates varying between initial estimates and the actual bill.
The West Bengal Clinical Establishments (Registration, Regulation and Transparency) (Amendment) Bill, 2025, tabled in the assembly last Monday, states: "Every clinical establishment shall strictly follow the fixed rates and charges....
It shall ensure that intensive care, ventilation, implants, consultation and similar tests and procedures, and any additional treatment or procedure shall not attract additional charges.
.."
Woodlands Hospital already has an LCD display, listing major charges. "We are expanding the list to meet the bill requirement. We plan to counsel patients' families more elaborately on charges. While we have a system of counselling and display, there could be gaps that can be improved," said Rupak Barua, CEO of Woodlands Multispecialty Hospital and AHEI president.
Barua added opinion would be sought from other hospitals to arrive at a consensus on variable charges, like those under packages that could change during treatment.
"Treatment being a dynamic process, costs might increase, depending on patient's condition. After our internal talks, we will approach the govt with a proposal," he added.
BP Poddar Hospital has displayed the rates of its general beds, critical care, double-bed, single-bed and suites on two screens as well as charges for tests, procedures, implants, package rates and consultation fees.
"We maintain transparency across every stage. Keeping in line with NABH guidelines and govt regulations, we ensure all hospital charges and treatment-related expenses are itemised and communicated to patients and their families.
Our tariffs and charge structures are prominently displayed. We are adding a few more speciality units and we plan to install modern devices that will ease patient convenience about tariffs and rates," said Supriyo Chakrabarty, Group Adviser, B P Poddar Hospital.
Peerless Hospital is waiting for more instructions from the health authorities before displaying charges. "We have a manual display, which must now include a lot more categories. It will be difficult without an electronic screen. We had an interaction with the health authorities and were asked to wait," said Peerless CEO Sudipta Mitra. Charnock Hospital, too, plans to follow soon. "There should be transparency, rates displayed and charged should be the same.
Also, hospital treatment depends on patients' condition, which is dynamic. Pre-admission cost estimates may change during treatment. But pricing and billing should be transparent," said Charnock MD Prashant Sharma, Indian Chamber of Commerce Health Committee chairperson.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
16 hours ago
- India Today
How old is too old for IVF treatment?
In an age where career goals, late weddings, and medical progress have extended the limits of parenthood, the query "How old is too old for IVF?" is more pertinent than ever. For most couples facing infertility, IVF (In Vitro Fertilization) is a second chance to conceive. But even science has its limitations—and so does the DOES THE LAW SAY IN INDIA?Under the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act enacted in India, the legal cut-off age for women to undergo IVF is 50 years and for men is 55 years. The age limit mainly exists to protect the child's health and ensure that the parents are physically fit to raise them. The aim is obvious: to prevent circumstances in which a child may be left orphaned in early years of life because the parents are old and have grown very ROLE OF SELF EGGS VS. DONOR EGGSIVF is legally allowed up to 50, the success rate for conception using a woman's own eggs diminishes considerably after 40, and by 41 or 42 years of age, utilization of self-eggs is very rare. Most fertility doctors strongly advise that IVF using self-eggs be done at or before age 41 in order to enhance the likelihood of success. Beyond that point, the eggs' quality and quantity are lost at a very rapid rate, causing fertility to plummet and increasing the risk of genetic abnormalities. This is where donor eggs enter the picture. Women over 42—particularly those close to 50—usually need donor eggs in order to conceive. Donor eggs are commonly obtained from younger, healthier women, thus raising the chances of a healthy and successful RATES AND MEDICAL REALITIESAge is a major factor in IVF success. Using self-eggs:Under 35 years: The success rate is around 50-60% per embryo transfer38–40 years: Falls to around 40%Over 42 years: Below 3% with their own eggsWith donor eggs, though, the success rate is more dependent on the donor's age, rather than the recipient. That's why so many women in their late 40s can still have a healthy pregnancy—if they use donor 47, Delhi "After trying for years and facing several miscarriages, I opted for IVF with donor eggs at age 46. Today, I have twin boys who are 3 months old. I was skeptical at first, but my doctor explained every step, and now I can't imagine life without them."I wanted to try with my own eggs, but after two failed cycles, I switched to donor eggs. It wasn't an easy decision emotionally, but the moment I held my daughter, I knew it was the right one. IVF gave us our miracle." says Meenal , 40 years. Emotional and Ethical ConsiderationsadvertisementTo decide on IVF in your 40s or approaching 50 is not merely a medical choice—it's an emotional and ethical one as well. The law's age limit of 50 is set so that potential parents are mentally, physically, and emotionally equipped with the capability of bringing up the child to how old is too old for IVF? Medically speaking, self-egg IVF is best done before 40. Legally and ethically, India allows IVF until age 50—with donor gametes when necessary. If you're considering IVF later in life, it's essential to consult a fertility specialist early, explore all your options, and plan responsibly—for both your well-being and the future of your by Fertility Specialist Dr. Jyoti Bali, Founder, BabySoon Fertility & IVF Clinic- EndsMust Watch
Hindustan Times
a day ago
- Hindustan Times
Estranged Mumbai couple wage a legal battle over 16 frozen embryos
Sixteen frozen embryos are at the centre of a unique custodial battle in Mumbai that raises key legal and ethical questions. Estranged Mumbai couple wage a legal battle over 16 frozen embryos In 2022, a couple from south Mumbai who were married the previous year decided to freeze embryos grown from the man's sperm and the woman's eggs. But in 2023, their marriage soured. Now, the legal battle over the embryos has reached the Bombay High Court. The woman wishes to have a child, and wants the fertility clinic currently storing them to transfer them to another clinic . Her husband has allegedly blocked the transfer. The 46-year-old woman is now before the Bombay High Court urging it to direct the concerned authorities to allow her to proceed with the transfer of her cryopreserved embryos to another clinic without the consent of her estranged husband. 'In matters so intrinsically tied to the woman's body, health and identity, the law must recognise the primacy of her informed and enduring will over procedural hurdles grounded in outdated patriarchal notions of spousal dominion,' her petition says. In her petition filed through lawyer Jamshed Mistry, the woman contended that a provision under the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) (ART) Act, 2021 that requires the consent of both spouses for transfer of the embryos, needs to make an exception for marital abandonment, separation and irretrievable breakdown of marriage. On Thursday, a division bench of Justice Revati Mohite Dere and Justice Neela Gokhale issued notices to respondents including the husband, the clinic and the National ART and Surrogacy Board in and adjourned the case till August 21. The petitioner also argued that while the ART Act allows single women to avail assisted reproductive services, it imposes 'rigid barriers' on married women deserted by their husbands. The couple married in October 2021 when the woman was 42 and her husband was 46. On January 22, 2022, they signed a joint consent form for freezing of embryos -- comprising the woman's eggs and the man's sperm -- at an IVF clinic in Kemp's Corner. They also agreed to pay an annual storage fee of ₹25,000 for the cryopreservation of the embryos. In November, 2022, the woman was found to have multiple uterine fibroids and was advised to undergo a myomectomy to remove the fibroids. In December, 2022, the woman wrote to the clinic in Kemp's Corner asking them to transfer her 16 preserved embryos to another clinic at Colaba. 'She felt more comfortable there,' her lawyer told HT. But caught up in a range of procedures, the woman did not follow up. Around the same time, the couple's relationship soured and the woman's husband allegedly deserted her on August 6, 2023. She initiated proceedings against him under the Domestic Violence Act before a magistrate. On August 9, 2023, the woman was informed by the clinic storing her embryos that her husband had, through an email, asked the clinic to put a hold on all procedures regarding the embryos. The woman claims the clinic at Kemp's Corner referenced Section 29 of the ART Act and said that consent of both the genetic contributors would be required to allow the transfer of embryos. The woman, who still needed a myomectomy, underwent the procedure in February 2024 at Breach Candy Hospital. She says she sought a written assurance from her doctors that four-five months after the myomectomy would be a good time to implant the embryos in her womb. During a mediation in their domestic violence case before a magistrate court in Mazgaon in December 2024, the woman alleged her husband demanded ₹25 lakh to allow the embryo transfer. On May 29 this year, she filed an FIR at Nagpada police station against her husband for threats, endangerment to her bodily integrity, reproductive rights and conspiracy to obstruct her medically sanctioned fertility procedure. The case is pending before the magistrate's court. No action has been taken on the FIR yet. The woman filed a petition before the Bombay high court earlier this month. The woman contended before the high court that the mandatory spousal consent required under the ART Act needs a rethink in case of marital abandonment. She stated that a woman physically and emotionally prepared for motherhood is being denied that experience by her estranged husband by his unilateral withdrawal of consent. 'Such a rigid and literal interpretation of statutory consent requirements reduces a woman's autonomy to the wilful inertia of an absconding spouse,' her petition stated. Amit Karkhanis, a lawyer who specialises in medico-legal cases, said that there is no precedent in the law for such cases but the woman may have some remedies. 'The clinic is right to ask for the consent of the husband because the genetic material with them belongs to both parties. There is an option to file an application before the family court. The woman can state before the court that her husband is refusing to give consent for transfer or embryos. If he does not come before the court, the court may even give an ex-parte order in her favour,' said Karkhanis. He said if she gets a divorce, she can get a sperm donor and create new embryos too.
Time of India
18-07-2025
- Time of India
Illegal IVF & surrogacy centre busted in Gurgaon; first FIR in Haryana, says CMO
Gurgaon: A fertility clinic that ran an illegal surrogacy and IVF (test tube baby) business in the city has been busted. A team from the health department found the clinic in Sushant Lok 1 was operating a "full-scale IVF and surrogacy setup without following the rules". The clinic, running without proper registration, charged up to Rs 3 lakh for the procedures and arrangements, health officials said. During the inspection, the team seized several registers that listed frozen embryos, egg donations and semen storage. The records showed the clinic was using a large number of egg donors and surrogates, many of them from poor backgrounds. An FIR was lodged at DLF 1 police station on Thursday. Chief medical officer Alka Singh said, "This is the first FIR in Haryana against an IVF centre. We have formed a six-member team of doctors. The team is investigating all such centres in Gurgaon. In this particular case, we received mail from an anonymous source about illegal activities being conducted at the centre. We informed DG (health) and district authorities and carried out a raid. We found several violations. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo First, the centre was not registered. Second, there was evidence of ongoing IVF, IUI and egg donation procedures being carried out without requisite approvals. We also found 84 embryos." You Can Also Check: Gurgaon AQI | Weather in Gurgaon | Bank Holidays in Gurgaon | Public Holidays in Gurgaon According to the FIR, "During the inspection, Manju Sharma, the clinic's owner, admitted in a signed statement over 80 embryos were being stored at the centre and IVF procedures were being conducted since April-May 2025. She named another partner, Dr Nidhi, and confirmed that the clinic took over operations from the previously known Joyce IVF Centre." "The inquiry found evidence of at least 68 semen samples frozen between April and June 2025, with entries including names of foreign nationals such as Carlus Danielle, Andrew Charles and an Australian couple," the FIR stated. Officials said the clinic violated the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021.
