Horrified Texas lawmakers demand crackdown on body broker industry
Using unclaimed bodies for research is legal in Texas, as it is in most of the country. But many body donation programs have stopped the practice to reflect advances in medical ethics that call for anatomists to treat human remains with the same dignity shown to living patients.
Parker's bills would make Texas one of a handful of states, including Hawaii, Minnesota and Vermont, that prohibit research or training on unclaimed bodies without consent. That restriction did not draw opposition at the hearing, but some body brokers raised concerns that Parker's other proposed regulations could stifle crucial training for doctors and potentially lifesaving medical research.
The committee heard from two people featured in the NBC News investigation: Kimberly Patman, whose ex-husband, Victor Honey, a homeless Army veteran, was cut up and leased out to medical companies and the Army; and Tim Leggett, whose older brother, Dale's, body was shipped to Kentucky to train anesthesiologists. Both learned from reporters what had happened to their loved ones.
'Victor deserved better. His children deserved better. His country owed him better,' Patman said. 'We're asking for accountability and, more importantly, change, so that no other family has to experience this kind of violation and grief.'
Leggett, who learned of his brother's death through a list of names of unclaimed bodies NBC News published, said he thought every day about how Dale's body was treated. 'When does a human being stop being a human deserving of simple kindness and respect?' he said.
The committee's chairperson, Lois Kolkhorst, a Republican, appeared aghast.
'These are horrifying stories, and I don't know where we get to this point in society,' said Kolkhorst, who is a co-author of one of the bills. 'It is a darkness here. Your descriptions. Unthinkable.'
Parker added: 'It is a darkness, and it's absolutely horrific. It's like a horror film.'
The NBC News investigation, published last year, detailed how the University of North Texas Health Science Center in Fort Worth obtained unclaimed bodies from Dallas and Tarrant counties, then dissected and leased them out. The bodies included those of military veterans, the homeless, people with mental illness and a murder victim. Reporters identified at least 26 people whose bodies were sent to the Health Science Center without their relatives' knowledge. Twelve of those people's families learned details of what happened to their loved one s from NBC News, including from a list of names it published.
The investigation prompted the Health Science Center to suspend its body donation program, fire the officials who led it and stop taking unclaimed bodies. Medical technology companies that had received unclaimed bodies from the center said they would change their policies or reconsider their work with the center. Local, state and federal officials expressed alarm and vowed to push for policy changes. The Texas Funeral Service Commission, which regulates body donation, launched an investigation.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
13 hours ago
- NBC News
Cancer patient's fight to get authorization for treatment recommended by his doctor
In our series 'The Cost of Denial,' NBC News' Erin McLaughlin reports on a West Virginia family's appeal after appeal to get insurance coverage for a treatment called histotripsy which uses ultrasound waves to target tumors in the liver.
Reuters
16 hours ago
- Reuters
US health chief says Sen. Cassidy promised pick on vaccine panel
WASHINGTON, June 12 (Reuters) - U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said he told U.S. Senator Bill Cassidy that he would allow Cassidy to pick a candidate for a key panel of vaccine advisers. Cassidy, a Republican, serves as chairman the U.S. Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee. "What I told Senator Cassidy is that I would allow him to put one of his candidates on, which we're going to do," Kennedy said on Thursday during an interview on Fox News' "The Story with Martha MacCallum," referring to the vaccine advisory panel. Kennedy on Wednesday named eight members to serve on the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Advisory Committee for Immunization Practices, which advises the agency on who should get the shots after they are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, after gutting the panel last week.
NBC News
a day ago
- NBC News
Deported family of 11-year-old U.S. citizen recovering from a rare brain tumor requests humanitarian parole
An 11-year-old girl who is a U.S. citizen and is recovering from a rare brain tumor has been living in Mexico since immigration authorities removed her from Texas when they deported her undocumented parents four months ago. Four of her siblings, three of whom are also U.S. citizens, were also sent to Mexico with the parents. Since then, the girl's health condition has not improved, her mother told NBC News. In an attempt to return to the United States to get her the care she needs, the family applied for humanitarian parole with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) on Thursday. 'We're fighting for my girl's life," the mother said, adding that her daughter isn't recovering from "just any disease. ... She is not going to be cured overnight; it's something that takes time.' Their request is for the undocumented parents and the girl's noncitizen sibling to be allowed to enter and live in the U.S. temporarily, so that the ailing girl can have "the full support of her family as she gets treatment to help save her life,' said Danny Woodward of the Texas Civil Rights Project, a legal advocacy organization representing the family. The mother said her daughter's headaches and dizziness have worsened. The symptoms have become so recurrent that the girl's parents spend sleepless nights taking turns monitoring and caring for her. 'She is very scared,' mother said. "We want to be there for her, we want to take care of her 100% like we've been doing so far. We don't want to be separated from her for even a minute." When the girl was in the U.S., under the care of doctors in Houston "who saved her life," the parents were instructed to rush her to the hospital for an emergency check-up whenever she felt these symptoms, the mother said. "But out here, that is impossible," she said in Spanish from Mexico, where her family was deported to Monterrey, an area known for the kidnapping of U.S. citizens. 'Where am I going to go?" NBC News is not publishing the family members' names out of concerns for their safety. Medical records show the child underwent surgery last year to remove a brain tumor caused by an 'unnamed 'novel' condition,' according to Woodward. This means that few medical specialists can effectively treat and monitor her. The mother said the girl's doctors in the U.S. were not just treating her daughter's illness; they were "also studying it because they don't know what caused it, why it was so aggressive." Even from Mexico, she has been in touch with the girl's doctors in the U.S., but they can't really assess what's happening to her from afar. The surgery that saved her life last year did leave the girl with some lasting side effects. The swelling on her brain is still not fully gone, causing difficulties with speech and mobility of the right side of her body as well as memory problems. These require the girl to routinely checking in with doctors monitoring her recovery, get MRI scans every three months, attend rehabilitation therapy sessions and take medication to prevent seizures. But she has not been able to consistently access this care since the family was deported, her mother and attorney said. The mother insists that the rod fixator preventing her daughter's right foot from turning inward needs to be replaced, as the girl trips more than usual. Her seizure medication is being sent to her from the United States because the family can't find the exact one she needs in Mexico, Woodward said. MRIs have also "turned out to be very expensive and challenging for the family to get in Mexico.' The girl has only been able to get one medical checkup and MRI in Monterrey. The experience made the mother realize how difficult it would be to get a new doctor in Mexico who can get up to speed with her daughter's medical history and treat her illness. 'Not any doctor wants to take on such a huge commitment,' the mother said. "It's like starting from scratch, or worse." Additionally, 'the stress of the whole situation has definitely played a negative role' in the girl's recovery, Woodward said. 'This family has been severely traumatized." A family's 'truncated dreams' On Feb. 3, the family was driving from the Rio Grande Valley area, where they lived, to Houston, where the girl's doctors are based, for an emergency medical checkup. On the way, they stopped at a stateside immigration checkpoint, one they have passed through multiple times. But this time, immigration authorities arrested the parents after they were unable to show legal immigration documentation. Five of their children, ages 15, 13, 11, 8 and 6, were with them when they were arrested. Woodward said the parents have never done anything to make them a priority for removal. The entire family was taken to a detention facility, where they spent 24 hours before they were placed in a van and dropped on the Mexico side of a Texas bridge on Feb. 4. "Another layer of this is the fact that the parents were never even given their due process rights, so they never were allowed to go in front of an immigration judge to plead their case," said Rochelle Garza, president of the Texas Civil Rights Project. A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees USCIS, previously told NBC News that reports of the family's situation are 'inaccurate' and declined to speak on the specifics of the case, citing privacy reasons. They said in a statement that when 'someone is given expedited removal orders and chooses to disregard them, they will face the consequences.' The eldest son, an 18-year-old U.S. citizen, was left behind in the U.S. "The older boy woke up one morning and learned that his entire family was gone," Woodward said. He graduated high school alone, without his family. 'It breaks our hearts,' the mother said as she wept, adding that her son dreams of going to college and becoming a neurosurgeon after seeing how doctors saved his sister's life, but 'he can't do that alone. He needs our support — even though we talk to him every day, it's really hard to be away." Instead of going to college, her son is working a fast-food job, hoping to soon see his family return home. While the Trump administration has aggressively stepped up the pace of deportations, including for immigrants who don't have criminal charges or convictions against them, there are three recent cases giving the girl's family hope. A Mexican mother living in California and her 4-year-old girl, who suffers from a life-threatening intestinal illness, were granted humanitarian parole this month following a public plea for deportation relief. In April, a Venezuelan immigrant in Chicago was released from immigration detention under humanitarian parole to serve as an organ donor for his ailing brother. In March, an undocumented mother in California caring for her 21-year-old daughter, a U.S. citizen undergoing treatment for bone cancer, was detained by immigration authorities and later released "for humanitarian reasons." Even though the relatives in these cases were not deported, Woodward said, "I don't think that should make any difference from the perspective of the federal government." "It's a discretionary choice for them to make," he said. "Our case, I think, it's a very strong one for humanitarian parole." The family's parole application includes letters of support from several members of Congress, including Democratic Reps. Adriano Espaillat of New York and Sylvia Garcia and Joaquin Castro of Texas, all of whom met with the family in Mexico last month. "We want them to give us that chance," the mother said. "We are not criminals. We are not delinquents. We simply want to save our daughter."
