‘A sham trial process': Mother of Seán Rooney criticises Lebanese court
Irish peacekeeper
murdered in Lebanon in 2022, was a 'sham' and not reflective of justice, the soldier's mother has said.
Natasha Rooney issued the strongly-worded statement on Thursday following the conviction of seven men for Pte Rooney's killing by a Lebanese military court earlier in the week.
Pte Rooney (24) and three other Irish peacekeepers, who were serving with the
United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (Unifil)
mission in south Lebanon, were driving to Beruit airport when their
UN
-marked vehicle came under attack.
On Monday one of the men involved in the attack, Muhammad Ayyad, was sentenced to death in absentia. Another six men were given short prison sentences or small fines.
READ MORE
Ayyad, who fired a gun into Pte Rooney's vehicle during the attack in the village of Al-Aqbiya in south Lebanon, was granted bail by the court early in 2023 for medical reasons.
Ayyad was expected to appear at the court hearing on Monday but did not show up. He remains at large.
He is a member of
Hizbullah
, which has been designated a terrorist organisation by the EU. The group has denied responsibility for the attack.
The other accused showed up to the court on Monday, having missed all previous court dates.
[
Irish soldier Seán Rooney: Man sentenced to death over killing in Lebanon
Opens in new window
]
Ms Rooney, from Donegal, was critical of several aspects of the case, as well as the approach of the Irish Government.
'Whilst I am restricted in what I can say due to the live proceedings, I cannot sit idly by and let the truth get lost in the hysteria,' she said in a statement issued by solicitor Darragh Mackin of Phoenix Law.
'What happened in Lebanon was not justice. What happened in Lebanon is unreflective of what we regard as a trial process.'
Ms Rooney said the case was heard in less than half a day 'with little to no information being disclosed or challenged in open court'.
'Instead, we are forced to believe the answers provided by a Lebanese justice system, which from the outset has failed to hold those responsible to account.'
The court proceedings have caused extreme disappointment and heartbreak to the Rooney family, she said.
The hearing was originally due to take place in September but was brought forward with minimal notice, which caused the family unforeseen pressures, she said.
'The verdict in reality is nothing more than a headline to the Lebanese authorities who masquerade this sham trial process as a semblance of justice for my son,' Ms Rooney said.
Ayyad is untraceable, she said. 'Not only did he not appear for his trial, but it is clear that he might never appear.'
Ms Rooney asked what country would sentence those involved in the murder of a peacekeeper to monetary fines.
'To the Lebanese courts, assisting in the murder of my son is worth nothing more than 1,200 dollars. Whilst hurt and disappointed, I expected nothing less from a government that is run hand in glove with a terrorist organisation.'
She also criticised the 'fake news and false narratives' that have circulated about Pte Rooney's death, including claims it occurred after he took a 'wrong turn' while driving to Beirut airport.
These claims are part of a concerted effort to 'shift the focus' regarding the incident, she said.
The response of Irish Government officials to the verdict could be read 'as one of victory for justice', she said. 'Again whilst such utterances are disappointing, they are unsurprising.'
Referring to Tánaiste
Simon Harris
, she said he should have spoken to her first 'before seeking to speak for me, in his public statements.'
She also criticised the flying of Hizbullah flags during a protest outside Government buildings in November 2024. These flags were flown alongside of the tricolour, which Pte Rooney died in the name of, Ms Rooney said.
'I am, however, not angry. I am determined. My son died trying to protect his three comrades as he made all efforts to escape an armed gang who had surrounded their vehicle and fired their shots. He dedicated his entire life to protect those of his three friends,' she said.
'In his name, I will dedicate every bone in my body to ensure justice for Seán, and to highlight the uncomfortable truths about the systematic failings by the United Nations, the Irish Defence Forces and the Lebanese Justice system.
'That is the very least I owe my son Seán. It is the very least I owe Seán's comrades.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Poland's new pro-Trump president brings nation into uncharted waters
Poland's new president Karol Nawrocki has vowed to defend his country's political independence from the EU , boost its role in Nato and restore a 'normal Poland'. Nawrocki's inauguration on Wednesday brings Poland into uncharted waters, intensifying decades-old political culture wars and creating a new, powerful opponent for prime minister Donald Tusk . His preferred candidate lost out narrowly in June's presidential election to Nawrocki, a 42-year-old amateur boxer, conservative historian and political newcomer. Nawrocki's 'Poland First' campaign, backed by the opposition national conservative Law and Justice (PiS), chime with voters - many of whom gathered with flags outside the Sejm parliament on Wednesday. READ MORE 'I will be the voice of those who want a sovereign Poland that is in the European Union ... but [which] is and will remain Poland,' said Nawrocki, promising to block any attempts by Brussels to 'take away Poland's powers'. He promised a new constitution by 2030 and signalled a new round in the standoff over Poland's judiciary by challenging Tusk administration efforts to roll back politicised appointments from the previous PiS administration. Echoing a PiS narrative, Nawrocki framed these rollback efforts as an attempt to 'undermine Poland's legal order' and hit out at the country's independent judiciary. 'Judges are not gods — they are here to serve the country and its citizens,' he added. As new titular head of the armed forces, Nawrocki pushed for a greater Nato presence in Poland and reaffirmed his country's security commitments, in particular to the US. [ Polish presidential election: Pro-Trump candidate Karol Nawrocki wins vote Opens in new window ] Nawrocki has called for a "sovereign Poland" and promised to "fight those who are pushing the nation towards decline". Photograph: Sergei Gapon/ AFP US president Donald Trump, who hosted Nawrocki during the campaign, sent the new president an inaugural gift of an American eagle statue. Wednesday's inauguration was a political triumph for opposition PiS chairman Jaroslaw Kaczynski , whose previous protegé occupied the presidential palace for the last decade. Polish analysts are waiting to see how much of Nawrocki's robust campaign rhetoric follows him into office. On the campaign trail he presented himself as a conservative family man, defender of national identity, security and a bulwark against neo-liberal politics. The PiS-backed candidate promised to use his veto on domestic policy to reject illegal migration, attempts to raise the retirement age and block Nato membership for Ukraine . Those promises have cast a pall over the Tusk administration, a broad anti-PiS coalition with often competing political priorities that is riven with disagreement and enjoys just 48 per cent popular support. Given gloomy predictions for the months ahead, Tusk chose to accentuate the positive on Wednesday. The 68-year-old saw 'room for co-operation in key fields such as security', a nod to his government's harder line on security and migration affairs in recent months. Meanwhile, foreign minister Radoslaw Sikorski expressed optimism that having a prime minister close to the EU and a president close to Donald Trump will allow Poland to 'play on two pianos at once'. On the campaign trail, Nawrocki shrugged off revelations about his past as a football hooligan. Photographer: Damian Lemanski/Bloomberg While there is a consensus that Nawrocki poses a political challenge for Tusk, some see him as closer than others in PiS to extreme right-wing parties whose candidates polled well in the June election. On the campaign trail, Nawrocki shrugged off revelations about his past as a football hooligan and signed a political pact presented by the far-right populist Confederation party. Given all that, Tusk told journalists on Wednesday that the new president could soon declare his political independence and prove a handful for his PiS backer, 76-year-old PiS chairman Jaroslaw Kaczynski. 'Perhaps the only person more nervous and sad in the room was Jaroslaw Kaczynski,' said Tusk outside the Sejm parliamentary chamber. 'I'm not surprised. There is a change of guard on the right and there is clearly a new leader'.
RTÉ News
3 days ago
- RTÉ News
NI minister to appeal High Court ruling on A5 upgrade
Stormont's Infrastructure minister is to appeal the decision of a Belfast court to overturn permission for Northern Ireland's biggest roads project. In June, Belfast's High Court found in favour of landowners who had opposed the redevelopment of the A5 road through Tyrone and Derry. The judge said there was insufficient evidence that the project complied with Stormont's own legally binding climate change legislation. Stormont's Climate Change Act of 2022 puts an onus on Stormont departments to ensure Northern Ireland meets its emissions targets and carbon budgets on the way to net zero by 2050. Mr Justice McAlinden said he had seen insufficient evidence that the building and operation of the new A5 fitted with this legal requirement. The £1.2 billion upgrade is an important link for the wider northwest, including Donegal, and is being supported with €600m of Irish Government money. In July, Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins flagged her intention to appeal but needed the support of her Executive colleagues. Today she said she had secured executive approval, and the case could now proceed to Northern Ireland's Court of Appeal. "I have instructed legal counsel to submit an appeal, and that will be done imminently ahead of the deadline for appeal, which is Friday 8 August," she said. She added: "So that is be it currently being finalised. I think it's fair to say that the officials and myself and my team have been working night and day to ensure that we are submitting a very robust appeal, whilst also looking at all of the other options, and we continue to work through that in parallel to the appeal that we will be lodging." The High Court decision to quash permission for the project was greeted with dismay by supporters. They had campaigned vociferously on behalf of the new road, citing safety concerns on what is an existing single carriageway that carries a large volume of business and farm traffic. The huge upgrade is a flagship project of the Northern Ireland Executive. Since the scheme to build a dual carriageway was first proposed, more than 50 people have been killed along the road. It has been dubbed the most dangerous road in Ireland. Landowners have successfully challenged the project three times, predominately on environmental grounds. They are opposed to the impact on farms and homes and say the existing road could be improved rather than building a new one. The land vested runs to more than 3,000 acres and affects more than 300 farms. Niall McKenna of the A5 Enough is Enough group said the news of the appeal comes as as a relief to the families of victims of this road and will be very much supported by them. In a statement, he said that "enough people have died on the A5. It is high time the courts stopped future lives being lost on this cruel road."
Irish Times
4 days ago
- Irish Times
Letters to the Editor, August 4th: On a dangerous time to be a woman, landlords and rent, and President Trump's favour
Sir, – Three times over the past week I have watched news reports on women survivors of physical, sexual, emotional and psychological violence perpetrated by trusted males, some of them close family members. I heard sisters Paula Fay and Catherine Wrightstone describe the lifelong sentence of emotional pain, broken trust, and struggle to reclaim self-worth that their brother inflicted upon them. I heard Niamh Herbert talk about the feeling of giving a piece of herself away on every step of her path to justice. I heard Nikita Hand say that the legal case has retraumatised her over and over again. And I listened as each one of these brave women encouraged others who have experienced similar abuse to speak out, reminding them that they have strength within, that their voice matters and that justice can eventually prevail. READ MORE All this, as the horrific news about the killing of Vanessa Whyte and her two children unfolded over the week. At what stage do we call a halt to the head-shaking, the hand-wringing, the repeated expressions of shock and bewilderment and acknowledge the fact that Ireland is not a safe place to be female? Why are we not collectively howling from the rafters at the violence, the depravity, the pervasive level of threat that is endemic in our society today? How many more women must be traumatised, brutalised or even die, how many more candlelit vigils take place before we take educational and legislative steps to ensure that this stops now? To position ourselves in the world as a liberal democratic state, and to uphold the values of such, presumes a basic equity among citizens. Have we fallen at this first step? – Yours, etc, CAROLANNE HENRY, Churchtown, Dublin 14. Landlords and rental income Sir, – If the article written by Dr Lorcan Sirr was an essay for one of his own economic courses with the title 'What do landlords actually earn?' I think he'd get a D at best. It's a scattergun attack on landlords premised by the claim that we're all part of a secret club milking it. The only actual earnings quoted are general income which include the salary from a job or business. I'm one of the small landlords he's trying to vilify. Not having the luxury of a defined benefit pension from a taxpayer's funded job, the properties are my pension. When the ECB increased rates recently the repayments on one property increased from €1,200 a month to €1,650, while because of rent controls my rent was stuck at €1,100. And yes those figures are correct, a pre-2008 property. There are plenty of landlords who aren't creaming it. – Yours, etc, CHARLES McLAUGHLIN, Portobello, Dublin 8. Is Trump doing us a favour? Sir, – The Department of Finance feels that up to 70,000 fewer jobs will be created over the next five years as a result of the US tariffs as these tariffs will result in a reduction of economic activity of roughly 1.5 per cent (' US tariffs will mean 70,000 fewer jobs created in Irish economy, Department of Finance warns ,' August 1st). However, we have been informed that our economy is operating at full employment (full employment equates with 4 per cent unemployment), our population has increased by 20 per cent over the past five years resulting in an acute shortage of housing, huge waiting lists for medical treatment, a shortage of school places and lastly our infrastructure is incapable of catering for our expanding population. So perhaps Trump has come to our rescue after all? – Yours, etc, JO TRESTON, Blackrock, Co Dublin. Sir, – The report that Department of Finance officials warned that up to 70,000 fewer jobs will be created in the next five years due to US tariffs should not be a cause for concern. The solution can be found by copying the action of president Trump last Friday when the Bureau of Labour Statistics revealed higher unemployment numbers. He simply sacked the commissioner, to be replaced by someone who will alter the figures in his favour! – Yours, etc, GERARD CLARKE, Dundrum, Dublin. Policing the traffic and gardaí Sir, – Regarding 'S ome frontline gardaí expressed lack of interest in doing their jobs, review finds ,' (August, 1st). Yesterday, I was almost knocked to the ground by a passing scooter on the pedestrianised South King Street, close to Grafton Street. I then noticed the scooter turning left down Grafton Street. As I approached the top of Grafton Street, I noticed two gardaí on duty, observing the throngs of people down along Grafton Street. I brought the matter of the scooter to their attention. Yes, they had seen it go down Grafton Street, and further, scooters are going up and down the street all day. Surprised at this ready acceptance of this situation, there was more to follow; 'And we can't do anything about it,' they said. Startled by this, I reminded them that what they were observing was an act of law-breaking. I got the same answer about not being able to do anything to stop it. In frustration, I terminated the conversation, leaving them to continue their important job of observing the laws of the land being blatantly ignored in front of their eyes. – Yours, etc, EAMON O'FLYNN, Merrion Road, Dublin 4. Bargain cycling lanes Sir, – Rita O Brien (Letters, July 31st) claims that the ¤45 million spent on the Dundrum to Dún Laoghaire cycle lane is a bargain since the users will not be expected to pay a cent in road tax, insurance or licensing. By this reasoning, will all cyclists, pedestrians and EV drivers be exempt from any share in the massive fine coming our way due to massively exceeding our carbon budgets? – Yours, etc, COLETTE McNAMEE, Dublin 19. Sir, – Roads in Ireland are funded by the exchequer. Most taxes in the State are paid into the exchequer (income, VAT, etc). There is no 'road tax', although there is a 'motor tax' levied on most motorised vehicles. These funds also go to the exchequer. Since almost everyone pays some tax, everyone contributes to the cost of road construction (including cycle lanes) even if they don't drive or cycle. Introducing requirements such as motor tax, licensing, etc, for cyclists would dramatically reduce the rate of cycling, with the attendant negative effects on traffic congestion, public health, climate change, traffic congestion and so on. Whether or not the ¤45 million cost represents value for money is a different issue. – Yours, etc, CONALL DORAN, Co Sligo. Sir, – With reference to Rita O'Brien's letter, I wish to inform your correspondent that as a motorist I do not pay a cent in road tax. I do however pay motor tax, based on the CO2 emissions of my car, to offset the environmental impact of my car. As for insurance, that's paid to a private company that has nothing to do with the provision of transport infrastructure. Let's make cycling as difficult as possible to stop the indignity of motorists sitting in a traffic jam having to watch cyclists sail by. – Yours, etc, DECLAN RYAN, Blackhorse Avenue, Dublin 7. A generous offer Sir, –Frank McNally, Irishman's Diary (August 1st), writes about his annual jaunt to Ballybrit, bemoaning the lack of breakfast at his digs. I hereby offer him a bed with the full Irish for 2026 on condition he doesn't write about it! – Yours, etc, ANNE MARIE KENNEDY, Craughwell, Co Galway. Asylum and statistics Sir, – Nick Henderson of the Irish Refugee Council, in rebutting Senator Michael McDowell's suggestion that many asylum applicants are economic migrants, states that 'The data does not support this claim,' (Letters, July 31st). The only statistic he provides is that 60 per cent of asylum applications this year have been refused. He subjectively concludes that these were refused on technicalities such as insufficient paperwork, but that they were genuine asylum seekers. He then partly attributes blame for the IPA accommodation crisis to McDowell himself, as he did nothing about it during his five years as minister for justice. McDowell ceased in that role 18 years ago. I know we ideally want far-sighted politicians, but expecting clairvoyance is not realistic. – Yours, etc, DAVE SLATER, Kilkea, Co Kildare. Not so bonny photograph Sir, – I am in accord with Finn McRedmond's opinions in her Bonnie Blue article – apart perhaps from this being the best time to be alive (' Bonnie Blue: Why the free-sex 'content creator' is nauseating and wrong ,' July 31st) But why on earth is the article illustrated with a large, unavoidable and rather silly picture of Miss Blue? The Irish Times isn't social media and should avoid the 'Oh you are awful, tell me more' redtop vibe. Why publicise this person's image? Please, Irish Times remember your journalistic standards! – Yours, etc, MAIRIDE WOODS, Dublin 13. Filler thriller Sir, – I always smile when I turn over to the Letters page and see a smattering of short ones or 'fillers' as I like to call them. You just can't beat an eclectic and diverse mix of opinions. – Yours, etc, DEE DELANY, Raheny, Dublin 5. Germ supporter Sir, – Recent correspondence on our immune system and germs (Letters, July 31st and August 1st) reminded me of an expression often used by my late mother. When, as children, my brothers and I would often arrive home from an evening exploring in the fields or scrambling through the nearby woods stained from top to toe with soil and any other detritus that came our way and she would smile saying it was just 'clean dirt'. Looking back it's clear she knew the importance of beneficial bacteria and of building a robust immune system. Her philosophy has stood me in good stead to this day. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater in an obsessive desire to cleanse our environment of all germs, be they good or bad. – Yours, etc, PAT MULLEN, Kilkerley, Co Louth.
