‘Healthocide': experts warn of rise in targeting of health services in conflict
Health services are increasingly deliberately under attack and medics are facing violence and abuse in conflict zones around the world – in particular in Gaza, but also in Lebanon, Ukraine, Sudan, Syria and El Salvador.
This is despite the longstanding principle under international humanitarian law of medical neutrality, which protects healthcare workers and facilities during armed conflict and civil unrest, enabling them to provide medical care to those in need.
In a commentary published in the British Medical Journal, Dr Joelle Abi-Rached and colleagues of the American University of Beirut, Lebanon wrote: 'Both in Gaza and Lebanon, healthcare facilities have not only been directly targeted, but access to care has also been obstructed, including incidents where ambulances have been prevented from reaching the injured, or deliberately attacked.
'What is becoming clear is that healthcare workers and facilities are no longer afforded the protection guaranteed by international humanitarian law.'
The authors cite data from Israel's full-scale invasion of Gaza, which has resulted in at least 986 medical workers' deaths. Recent figures from the Healthcare Workers Watch show that 28 doctors from Gaza are being held inside Israeli prisons without any charge, eight them senior consultants in surgery, orthopaedics, intensive care, cardiology and paediatrics.
The World Health Organization's representative for the West Bank and Gaza stated at the UN security council in January that hospitals in Gaza had 'turned into battlegrounds', while the healthcare system was being 'systematically dismantled and driven to the brink of collapse'.
Healthcare workers in Gaza who were among the hundreds detained by the Israeli military who spoke to the Guardian for the Doctors in Detention project in early 2025 believed they were targeted because they were doctors.
They shared harrowing testimonies of torture, beatings, starvation and humiliation, including being constantly beaten and kept in stress positions for hours at a time, and having loud music played nonstop to prevent them from sleeping. They were also denied food, water, showers and changes of clothes.
Lebanon's ministry of public health has found that between 8 October 2023 and 27 January 2025, 217 healthcare workers were killed by the Israel Defense Forces, 177 ambulances were damaged, and 68 attacks on hospitals were recorded.
Figures from the Safeguarding Health in Conflict Coalition recorded 3,623 attacks on or obstruction of healthcare in 2024, the highest number ever documented.
These attacks included doctors, nurses and allied healthcare professionals who were beaten, arbitrarily arrested, kidnapped, tortured and killed; patients shot in their beds or dragged to detention centres; and hospitals that were deliberately bombed and raided.
The authors of the BMJ article are calling on doctors to 'forsake the principle of medical neutrality' and speak out against 'healthocide' or face emboldening future violators. This might include advocating for enforcement of justice and international humanitarian law, and documenting and exposing abuses of medical neutrality.
Writing in the Guardian, Maarten van der Heijden, a global health lawyer and researcher at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, noted that the international humanitarian laws, the Geneva conventions, leave 'considerable room for interpretation and forgoes accountability', allowing hospitals to be bombed if it is considered 'harmful to the enemy'.
The British Medical Association's medical ethics committee chair, Dr Andrew Green, said: 'In recent years, doctors have been devastated to see the appalling increase in attacks on healthcare, patients and staff in conflict zones, and the disregard for medical neutrality and international humanitarian law.'
He noted that although there were examples around the world, Gaza was the most severe given that 'the population is both at risk of imminent famine, while health systems necessary to look after the starving have been systematically obliterated and health workers killed and arbitrarily detained.'
He urged international medical associations, NGOs, governments and the UN to 'call out when we see human and health rights abused, and hold those breaking international humanitarian law accountable'.
'Those with power must use all levers at their disposal to ensure the provision of humanitarian aid and urgent healthcare to the world's most vulnerable. One clear step would be the establishment of a UN special rapporteur on the protection of health in armed conflict,' he added.
The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office minister Hamish Falconer has previously said that the UK government is urging the Israeli authorities to ensure that 'incidents are investigated transparently and that those responsible are held to account and lessons learned'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Gaza latest: Israel draws outrage after Al Jazeera journalists killed in ‘targeted assassination'
At least 31 killed while seeking aid in Gaza as child hunger deaths hit 100 At least 31 Palestinians were killed while trying to collect aid in Gaza on Sunday, according to hospitals and witnesses. Reports said there was gunfire in the Israeli-controlled Morag and Netzarim corridors and the Teina area in the south, with all witnesses accusing Israeli forces of firing at crowds heading for food distributions or waiting for convoys. Fifteen people were killed near the Morag corridor between Rafah and Khan Younis, Nasser hospital said. 'The situation is a death trap,' said Jamal al-Laweh, who claimed Israeli forces opened fire there. 'But I have no other choice to feed the kids.' Six were killed while waiting for aid near the Zikim crossing in northern Gaza, according to Gaza's Health Ministry and Shifa hospital. In central Gaza, Awda hospital said four were killed after warning shots were followed by live fire toward crowds at a distribution site run by the Israeli-backed, US-funded Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). Another six died while trying to reach GHF sites in Khan Younis and Rafah, Nasser hospital reported. GHF, which began operations in May as an alternative to the UN-run aid system, said there were 'no incidents' at or near its sites on Sunday. The Israeli military also denied any incidents involving its troops near central Gaza aid sites. Meanwhile, Gaza's Health Ministry said two Palestinian children died of malnutrition-related causes on Saturday, bringing the total number of child hunger deaths to 100 since the war began. At least 117 adults have died from malnutrition-related causes since June.
The Guardian
11 hours ago
- The Guardian
Netanyahu defends Gaza City plan as UN warns of ‘calamity' and starvation
Benjamin Netanyahu has defended his plan to take control of Gaza City in the face of widespread international outrage, even as senior UN officials warned that the move risked unleashing 'another calamity' on a territory already experiencing 'starvation, pure and simple'. In a rare press conference with foreign journalists in Jerusalem, the Israeli prime minister said the plan, signed off last week by the security cabinet to criticism both at home and abroad, was 'the best way to end the war and the best way to end it speedily.' But during an emergency weekend session of the UN security council in New York, there were repeated warnings that rather than end the 22-month war, the move would exacerbate an already dire humanitarian situation. 'If these plans are implemented, they will likely trigger another calamity in Gaza, reverberating across the region and causing further forced displacement, killings, and destruction,' said UN assistant secretary general, Miroslav Jenca. Amid the heated rhetoric, Gaza's health ministry said that five more people, including two children, had died of malnutrition-related causes, bringing the number of children who have died from such causes to 100. Including adults, the total death toll from malnutrition stands at 217, the ministry says. Ramesh Rajasingham, Ocha's coordination director, told the security council meeting: 'This is no longer a looming hunger crisis – this is starvation, pure and simple.' Israel has imposed a blockade and restrictions on aid entering the territory, but in his press conference Netanyahu said it was 'completely false' that his government was pursuing a 'starvation policy'. He acknowledged hunger, and problems with the food distribution system run by the US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), but accused the media of 'lies' about the scale of the problem. A few hours before he spoke, at least 26 Palestinians were killed while seeking aid in Gaza, hospitals and witnesses said. They included 15 killed while waiting for aid trucks close to the newly built Morag corridor that separates the southern cities of Rafah and Khan Younis, according to Nasser hospital. A further six were killed while waiting for aid in northern Gaza near the Zikim crossing, according to Gaza's health ministry and Shifa hospital in Gaza City. According to the UN, more than 1,370 Palestinians have been killed since 27 May while seeking food. Netanyahu did not take responsibility for the killings and said, without providing evidence, that 'a lot of the firing was done by Hamas'. The Israeli military has repeatedly claimed Hamas is stealing aid, despite the European Commission finding no reports of this. Except on organised and controlled 'embeds' of a few hours alongside Israeli soldiers, international journalists have not been allowed into Gaza since the Hamas attacks of 7 October 2023, when about 1,200 people, mostly Israeli civilians, were killed and more than 250 people were taken hostage. Families of the remaining hostages have also criticised the plan, and many were among tens of thousands of people who marched on Israel's military headquarters in Tel Aviv on Saturday. The plan has also opened a rift between Netanyahu and the IDF leadership, but has not been opposed by the Trump administration, Israel's most important backer. Israel says Gaza City and nearby areas are home to two remaining Hamas strongholds. 'We have about 70 to 75% of Gaza under Israeli control, military control. But we have two remaining strongholds. These are Gaza City and the central camps in Al Mawasi,' Netanyahu told reporters. 'Given Hamas's refusal to lay down its arms, Israel has no choice but to finish the job and complete the defeat of Hamas', Netanyahu said, adding he expected the operation to begin 'fairly quickly'. Hamas says it will not disarm unless an independent Palestinian state is established. Netanyahu pushed back against what he called a 'global campaign of lies'. 'We will win the war, with or without the support of others,' he added. Britain, a close ally of Israel which nonetheless pushed along with others for the emergency meeting, warned in New York that Netanyahu's plan risked prolonging the conflict. 'It will only deepen the suffering of Palestinian civilians in Gaza. This is not a path to resolution. It is a path to more bloodshed,' said British deputy ambassador to the UN, James Kariuki. Algeria's ambassador, Amar Bendjama, called for sanctions on Israel in response to its Gaza City plan. 'The hour has come to impose sanctions on the enemy of humanity,' he said. The Palestinian envoy, Riyad Mansour, said: 'If it was another country, you would have been imposing sanctions a long time ago.' However, the US, a veto-wielding permanent member of the security council, offered support for Israel and accused those nations who supported Sunday's meeting of 'actively prolonging the war by spreading lies about Israel'. 'Israel has a right to decide what is necessary for its security and what measure measures are appropriate to end the threat posed by Hamas,' said the US envoy to the UN, Dorothy Shea. Israel's military offensive has killed at least 61,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza's health ministry, most of them civilians. The figure does not include the thousands believed to be buried under rubble or the thousands killed indirectly as a consequence of the war. Israel's deputy ambassador to the UN, Jonathan Miller, said: 'Pressure should not be placed on Israel, who suffered the most horrific attack against the Jewish people since the Holocaust, but on Hamas.'
The Independent
a day ago
- The Independent
Briton tells of ‘heartbreaking' moment he put children into body bags in Gaza
A British paramedic has told of the 'heartbreaking' moment he put two dead children in body bags shortly after arriving in Gaza. Sam Sears, 44, from Kettering, Northamptonshire, said his three weeks with frontline charity UK-Med was a 'conveyor belt of carnage', treating a 'steady stream' of patients with blast, shrapnel, and gunshot wounds. Mr Sears said on arrival he was thrown straight into a mass casualty incident where two children, aged nine and 11, died from blast injuries. He said: 'I was tasked with moving the two deceased children out the way to make space for other casualties coming in. I put the children in body bags and zipped them up. 'In the UK I've had to deal with a number of deceased children, but the difference was I'm never involved with putting them in a body bag. It's normally a very calm, slow situation, allowing parents time to grieve. 'So it was particularly heartbreaking putting a child in a body bag, seeing their face for the last time, then moving them out the way so we could treat more people. 'Part of me felt guilty that there was no dignity for them because the emergency situation meant it was a case of 'they are dead, let's get them out the way to free the beds'. 'But there was simply no alternative because with such a high volume of casualties, we had to focus on people we might be able to save.' Mr Sears, a paramedic with East Midlands Ambulance Service, who has also carried out humanitarian work in other countries, said that Gaza is like the Ukraine conflict or the earthquake in Turkey 'times one thousand'. He told of seeing a boy, aged about eight, who was 'lifeless behind the eyes – just numb' after losing his whole family in an explosion. The paramedic said a 16-year-old boy was left paralysed and needing amputation after suffering blast and shrapnel wounds and that his 18-year-old brother wept when told he would now have to care for him alone. He also told of seeing more pregnant women and newborn babies suffering severe malnutrition because the mothers lacked the nutrients to breastfeed. Mr Sears, who returned to the UK on July 31, added: 'It might sound weird, but I am keen to return to Gaza. What keeps you going is that you really are making a difference and saving lives. 'That first night, another child came in with shrapnel embedded in their stomach and bleeding internally. I was personally convinced they would die, but we got him to surgery within 20 minutes. 'Next day when I saw them they were recovering well and the prognosis was really good. Gaza's the hardest thing I've ever done but moments like that that keep you going. We have saved that child's life.' Some £19 million of funding from the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO) has enabled UK-Med to treat more than 500,000 patients at the two UK Government emergency field hospitals in Gaza. The conflict in Gaza began when Palestinian militant group Hamas attacked southern Israel on October 7 2023, killing about 1,200 people, mostly civilians. Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed more than 60,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza's health ministry, which does not distinguish between militants and civilians and operates under the Hamas government. Sir Keir Starmer has pledged to recognise a Palestinian state by September unless Israel meets a series of conditions towards ending the conflict in Gaza. The Prime Minister also urged Hamas to disarm, release its remaining Israeli hostages, and accept it will have no part in the future governance of Gaza. On Saturday, the UK announced another £8.5 million for UN aid to Gaza. The money, to be delivered through the UN's Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), is part of a £101 million UK commitment to the Occupied Palestinian Territories this year.
