logo
‘We're Trying to Do the Best We Can Before We Die'

‘We're Trying to Do the Best We Can Before We Die'

The Atlantic6 days ago
George Anton is hungry, but he's become used to the sensation—the urgent, aching feeling in his stomach, the heaviness of his limbs. He hardly has time to acknowledge the discomfort, given all the work he has to do. He is the operations manager for an aid-distribution program operating through the Holy Family Catholic Church in Gaza City, the sole remaining Catholic church in Gaza.
Anton lives at the church in a single room that he shares with his wife and three daughters. Four hundred people are sheltering there, he told me; it was once a sanctuary from the war. Recently, however, the fighting has come to encircle it. An Israeli tank shell struck the church early last month, killing three people there, according to a statement by the patriarchate.
This week, daily pauses in the fighting have calmed the neighborhood somewhat, but not enough for the church to resume aid programs: food hampers, a communal laundry, psychosocial support programs and clinics. Some of these functioned even before the current war. But these days, the church has nothing to distribute. Its food pantry is empty, and supplies have run out. When I reached Anton by phone on Wednesday, he was busy looking for a way to bring more food to the church's pantry.
Anton is one of hundreds of Gazan aid workers—affiliated with religious, international, and local organizations—who are trying to find and distribute supplies to keep others alive. Complicating their work is their own hunger and exhaustion, as well as the paucity of food coming into the territory altogether. An alert on Tuesday from the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, an organization made up of United Nations agencies and aid groups, noted that the 'latest data indicates that famine thresholds have been reached for food consumption in most of the Gaza Strip and for acute malnutrition in Gaza City.'
The people sheltering at the church have, in the absence of communal supplies, begun to ration their own small stashes of food items, mostly gathered from the markets when the situation was stable enough for them to venture out. The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which has become the official mechanism for dispensing food aid, has very few distribution points, all in areas far from the church. Many Gazans fear visiting these sites: According to the UN, more than 1,000 people have been killed by Israeli forces while seeking assistance from GHF, the UN, and other aid convoys. (GHF has called these numbers 'false and exaggerated statistics.')
I spoke with one Palestinian aid worker who did try to get food from GHF. In early June, Youssef Alwikhery, an occupational therapist with Medical Aid for Palestinians, hadn't eaten for close to a week. Several of his brothers, uncles, and cousins had tried to get food from GHF before—30 attempts altogether, he estimated—but only one had succeeded in bringing a box back. So Alwikhery rose one morning at 3 a.m. and made his way to Salah al-Din Street in central Gaza, a main thoroughfare leading to a distribution point that was a little over a mile from his home. He saw thousands of people. Some started running toward the distribution point, and he ran too. 'It was like a game, like a death game,' he told me. Soon came the sound of shots and explosions. Alwikhery turned back. 'It's not help. It's like Russian roulette,' he said. 'If you want to run, you might die, or you might get injured. You might get a box. This is the formula. This is the point.'
Alwikhery now pays exorbitant prices for small amounts of food at the market, and he eats just one meal a day. He lives with his parents and his brothers' families, including 9- and 11-year-old children. They, too, eat only one meal a day, usually around four or five in the evening, and if a family member needs to cook, they burn whatever they can, because the price of fuel is high. One photo Alwikhery sent me shows his occupational-therapy textbook being used as kindling.
I first met Alwikhery in the summer of 2022, at Al-Awda Hospital in the Jabalia refugee camp in the northernmost part of Gaza, when we worked with the same international medical organization. He specialized in helping patients with congenital disabilities carry out their daily activities. Israel ordered the closure of Al-Awda in May, and now Alwikhery works in Medical Aid for Palestinians' emergency clinic in central Gaza. He told me that he finds the state of his pediatric patients disturbing; he described children with cerebral palsy who couldn't move their bodies to do simple exercises because they were so calorically deprived.
My call with Anton was at 9 p.m. on Wednesday, and so far that day, he told me, he had consumed nothing but coffee and tea. He rises early, at 6 a.m. The first thing he does is check to make sure the church's solar panels, water tanks, and piping are still functioning and did not sustain any damage overnight. Then he reads the news, goes to morning prayers, and calls his colleagues in Jerusalem for updates on when food trucks might reach Gaza and how they will be secured.
Around 4 p.m. the day we spoke, his wife and three daughters, ages 9, 11, and 14, had shared one can of tuna with some bread. In recent weeks, his girls have taken to spending much of their time in the family's room, sleeping and reading to conserve their energy. The oldest and youngest used to enjoy soccer and basketball, but now they don't feel safe going out, and anyway, they're too tired. Anton told me he encourages them to pretend they're fasting, as though for Lent.
Photos: Starvation and chaos in Gaza
Sometimes, fellow aid workers or journalists tell Anton about families on the brink, and he gathers any extra supplies he can from the families sheltering in the church to deliver by foot. Recently, a journalist told him about a father of six who used a wheelchair and could not access income or aid. This man had no extended family nearby to share resources. Anton was able to gather only enough food to last the family approximately one week. When conditions were safe enough last Saturday, he delivered the food to the family's tent. The children, two boys and two girls, were 'really suffering,' he told me. 'They're like skeletons, you know.'
Families such as that one, where one or more members have a disability, or whose kinship networks are small or nonexistent, are among those hardest hit by starvation, both Anton and Alwikhery told me.
Anton's day would not finish after we spoke. He said he would try to find himself some bread later in the night. He and some other people sheltering at the church would stay up to monitor the hostilities in the neighborhood, tend to anyone needing help or comfort, and assist some of the elderly to use the communal bathrooms in the dark.
'We're trying to do the best we can before we die, you know,' he told me. 'Because I'm telling you, if this situation will last for a longer time, all of us will die hungry.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Hamada Sho: I Can No Longer Feed Kids in Gaza
Hamada Sho: I Can No Longer Feed Kids in Gaza

Time​ Magazine

time6 hours ago

  • Time​ Magazine

Hamada Sho: I Can No Longer Feed Kids in Gaza

Bombs rattled in the distance, and debris lay scattered across the empty corridors of Gaza's hospitals. I stood just outside, heart racing, aware that my wife could go into labor at any moment. Seven months into the war, with hospitals crumbling and doctors improvising under dire circumstances, I felt a paralyzing fear for my newborn's arrival. What sort of world would he enter when basic resources had vanished? I never imagined our first child, Nizar, would be born amid the roar of missiles and the stench of scarcity. Before the war I was Hamada Shaqura, known to many as Hamada Sho, a food blogger and digital marketer who celebrated Gaza's vibrant culinary culture. I shared recipes, restaurant stories, and the joy of good food online. But when our home was destroyed, our studio lost, and the war displaced us to Khanyounis's tent camps, cooking became less about flavor and more about survival. Humanitarian rations offered bare sustenance, canned beans, preserved meats, powdered milk, but they lacked any taste or meaning. I could not bear seeing children eat only to live, not to enjoy. In those early weeks I began cooking only for my family, but I could not ignore the children around me. They were surviving on whatever kept them alive, eating the same bland rations every day. I remembered how much food had once meant to me and how it had always been a source of joy and connection. I wanted these children to feel that again, even in the middle of war. Read More: We Can Stop Gazans From Dying of Starvation Right Now. Here's How We Do It Using my background as a food blogger I began experimenting with the limited ingredients available. I tested different recipes and looked for ways to create flavors with what little I had, trying to make each meal feel special. At first the portions were tiny, but the reactions from the children changed everything. They would take a hesitant first bite, their faces still heavy with the trauma of war, and then break into smiles. They started asking for seconds, and sometimes they would ask when I would return with more. That response gave me hope and purpose. I realized I could do more than just cook for a handful of children. I could create something larger that might bring a moment of happiness and comfort to thousands of children who had been deprived of both. As demand grew it became clear I could not do this alone. I reached out to local organizations that were already helping displaced families and many of them welcomed the idea immediately. With their support I was able to secure larger quantities of ingredients and space to cook for hundreds of children at a time. Over time I crafted dishes like chicken curry, pizza wraps made from tortilla crusts, Gazan‑style tacos, burgers, croissants, and even caramel apples or popsicles, all from basic aid‑package items. Watching children line up patiently, their faces lighting up when they tasted something familiar but special, reminded me why this mission mattered. I was no longer just a food blogger documenting life. I had become a cook with a purpose. Their gratitude was overwhelming. Parents told me through tears that these meals were the first time their children had smiled in weeks. Despite the constant danger and scarcity we were creating moments of normalcy and dignity in the middle of chaos. As the months went by the blockade tightened even further. Aid trucks stopped coming and ingredients that had once been scarce became almost impossible to find. The little flour we had left skyrocketed in price. Even something as basic as a bag of flour could cost $1,000. Cooking large quantities of food was becoming unthinkable and I could feel the weight of that reality every day. The most painful part was the children. They would still come to me hoping for a meal or a treat. I remember once going to a camp to distribute food and a boy came up to me holding a small medal with the Palestinian flag on it. He told me that he followed all my videos and was sure I would visit his camp one day so he made this gift for me. Moments like that gave me strength but also broke my heart because I could see the hunger in their faces. After the first ceasefire we returned to the North hoping to find some trace of our old lives. What we found instead was total destruction. There were no homes left standing and no infrastructure to support even the most basic needs. We had to return to the south simply to have a roof over our heads even though it was not home. That short moment of hope quickly gave way to a new and even harsher reality. When the bombing resumed everything became harder. We had no stable shelter and the place we found to rent in the north was barely livable but it was better than staying in a tent. My wife was pregnant again by then and I wanted her to be somewhere clean and safe—far from the heat, dust, and diseases spreading through the camps. But the situation kept worsening. There was no clean water and barely any food. Diapers and baby formula for Nizar disappeared from the market and if we ever found any they were sold at impossible prices. Even when relatives abroad tried to help, the money often lost half its value before we could touch it. To get $50 in cash we had to send someone $100 through the Bank of Palestine mobile banking app. Every part of survival became a tradeoff and a struggle. In the middle of all of this, my father became seriously ill. As he experienced heart problems, he was admitted to the intensive care unit in a hospital with almost no equipment or resources. We tried everything to get him out of Gaza for treatment abroad. He even has an official referral from the World Health Organization but it has been four months and he is still waiting to be allowed to leave. Knowing he is suffering, and I can do nothing to help, has been devastating. I tried to keep cooking simple things when I could. I baked what I could afford and shared it when possible. But eventually even that stopped. I no longer had access to any ingredients. I began helping distribute clean drinking water because that was all I could still do. People would see me on the street and ask when I would cook again. They told me they were hungry. But then they would pause and look at me and say you look so thin. You lost weight too. That hurt What is happening in Gaza today is bigger than my personal story. Hunger has become a weapon. Entire neighborhoods are living on scraps or going whole days without eating. Children are fainting in overcrowded shelters because they have no food. Parents are skipping meals so their children can eat a little more. People are boiling weeds and animal feed to stay alive. Read More: The Malnutrition Crisis in Gaza Will Outlive the War, Experts Warn The mental toll is as heavy as the physical one. When you cannot feed your child you begin to lose hope. I have seen the despair in parents' eyes and the fear in children who no longer believe a real meal will come. Cooking for them was never only about filling their stomachs. It was about giving them dignity and a small moment of joy in a world that has taken almost everything else. I remind myself of this now that I can no longer cook the way I used to. Every plate of food we served meant more than we could measure. It was a way to say we are still here. We are alive and we refuse to be forgotten. In recent weeks, I have spent most of my time helping distribute clean drinking water because it is the only thing I can still do. The children I used to cook for still come to me asking when I will make food again and it breaks my heart to tell them I cannot. But I hold on to the hope that one day soon I will be able to cook for them again and see their faces light up the way they used to. I still believe that small acts of care can change lives. Cooking a meal for a child who has nothing is about more than food. It is about telling them that they matter and that they are not forgotten. Even now, when I feel weaker than I have ever felt, I know that this work must continue. I hope the world does not look away from Gaza's children. They are enduring unimaginable hunger and suffering but they are still here and they still have dreams. All we ask is a chance to live and to rebuild our lives. I want my son Nizar and my unborn daughter to grow up in a place where they can thrive instead of just survive. I want every child in Gaza to feel that same hope.

Mothers in Gaza stretch meager ingredients where they can, but say hunger persists
Mothers in Gaza stretch meager ingredients where they can, but say hunger persists

San Francisco Chronicle​

time6 hours ago

  • San Francisco Chronicle​

Mothers in Gaza stretch meager ingredients where they can, but say hunger persists

DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip (AP) — A single bowl of eggplant stewed in watery tomato juice must sustain Sally Muzhed's family of six for the day. She calls it moussaka, but it's a pale echo of the fragrant, layered meat-and-vegetable dish that once filled Gaza's kitchens with its aroma. The war has severed families from the means to farm or fish, and the little food that enters the besieged strip is often looted, hoarded and resold at exorbitant prices. So mothers like Muzhed have been forced into constant improvisation, reimagining Palestinian staples with the meager ingredients they can grab off trucks, from airdropped parcels or purchase at the market. Israel implemented a total blockade on trucks entering the besieged strip in early March and began allowing aid back in May, although humanitarian organizations say the amount remains far from adequate. Some cooks have gotten inventive, but most say they're just desperate to break the dull repetition of the same few ingredients, if they can get them at all. Some families say they survive on stale, brittle pita, cans of beans eaten cold for lack of cooking gas, or whatever they can get on the days that they arrive early enough that meals remain available at charity kitchens. 'The children remain hungry. Tomorrow we won't have any food to eat,' Muzhed said from the tent where her family has been displaced in central Gaza's Deir al-Balah. Once, her bowl would barely have fed one child. Now she ladles it out in spoonfuls, trying to stretch it. Her son asks why he can't have more. The Muzhed family's struggle is being repeated across Gaza as the territory plunges deeper into what international experts have called 'the worst-case scenario of famine.' On some days, mothers like Amani al-Nabahin manage to get mujaddara from charity kitchens. The dish, once flavored with caramelized onions and spices, is now stripped to its bare essentials of rice and lentils. "Nearly nine out of ten households resorted to extremely severe coping mechanisms to feed themselves, such as taking significant safety risks to obtain food, and scavenging from the garbage,' the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification said on July 29. Gas for cooking is scarce, vegetables are costly and meat has all but vanished from the markets. Families in Gaza once dipped pieces of bread into dukkah, a condiment made of ground wheat and spices. But today, 78-year-old Alia Hanani is rationing bread by the bite, served once a day at noon, allowing each person to dip it in a wartime dukkah made of flour, lentils and bulgur. 'There's no dinner or breakfast,' the mother of eight said. 'I had to beg for it,' she said. For some, it's even less. Kifah Qadih, displaced from Khuza'a east of Khan Younis, couldn't get any food — the bowl in front of her has remained empty all day. 'Today there is no food. There is nothing.'

Gaza aid distribution site photos are staged for emotional effect, German media claims
Gaza aid distribution site photos are staged for emotional effect, German media claims

Yahoo

time21 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Gaza aid distribution site photos are staged for emotional effect, German media claims

The BILD report focuses on a widely circulated photo of desperate Gazan women and children holding pots and pans in front of a food distribution site. There has been significant media attention over the last few days regarding reports by two German-language papers - BILD and Süddeutsche Zeitung - that accuse Gaza-based press photographers of staging photos of starving civilians. The issue of staged photos or photos taken out of context came to a head at the end of July when the Coordination of Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) said that a picture of a Gazan youth being portrayed as starving is actually suffering from a genetic disease. TheBILD report focuses on a widely circulated photo of desperate Gazan women and children holding pots and pans in front of a food distribution site. Except photos taken by others at the same site show that the hoard is actually standing opposite freelance photographer Anas Zayed Fteiha, commissioned by the Turkish news agency Anadolu, BILD argues. The pots and pans are not being held up to the food distribution site, but the photographer, which Bild claims is staging for means of propaganda. Undistributed photos show Gazans calmly receiving aid Additionally, BILD adds that his photos at the Gaza aid distribution site show mainly women and children, but that other photos at the same site show mostly adult men calmly waiting for and receiving food. Fteiha did not distribute these ones. "I assume that many of these pictures with starving and sick children are simply staged or come from other contexts," emeritus history professor and photography expert Gerhard Paul told SZ. Paul, who has been researching images from Israel and Gaza for 25 years, said the photos are not fake, but "people are presented in a certain way or provided with a falsifying caption to mobilize our visual memory and emotions." Paul told SZ that he and his students at the University of Flensburg recreated the scenes from images of various wars in three dimensions in order to understand the situation depicted, which is often not easy to understand from the two-dimensional image. "Where is the photographer? Who is standing around him?" he asks. "What do the people depicted in the picture see? Do they see what we suspect, for example a food distribution? Or are they facing photographers?" "The images also have an additional function," Paul explained. "They are intended to overwrite the brutal images of the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023. Many people don't even remember these pictures. Hamas is a master at staging images." However, he stressed that the journalists and photographers in Gaza are in a dangerous position, and due to their proximity to Hamas terrorists, cannot move freely. "Little bypasses Hamas," Christopher Resch of Reporters Without Borders told SZ. Resch also told SZ that the concept of photographers staging photos is not unique to Gaza, and is not necessarily problematic. "I don't think it's reprehensible when a photographer instructs people to stand here and there with their pots," he said. "As long as it approximates reality." Nevertheless, BILD's report stressed that the photographer in question - Fteiha - is not exactly unbiased in his photojournalism. He posts videos to social media saying "f*** Israel" and works for a news agency that speaks directly to the Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan who has had ties to Hamas. As a result of the investigation, the German Press Agency and Agence France Press told BILD that they will no longer work Fteiha and would carefully check the pictures of other photo reporters as well, whereas Reuters says his photos "meet the standards of accuracy, independence and impartiality." "Despite his bias, his photos are published by major outlets like CNN, BBC, and Reuters," Israel's foreign ministry seethed in its response to the two reports. "With Hamas controlling nearly all media in Gaza, these photographers aren't reporting, they're producing propaganda." "This investigation underscores how Pallywood has gone mainstream with staged images and ideological bias shaping international coverage, while the suffering of Israeli hostages and Hamas atrocities are pushed out of frame," the ministry concluded. The Jerusalem Post watched the video taken from the aid destruction site a few days ago, shared by Al Jazeera Arabic. It is worth noting that the same setting of the women and children with pots and pans is seen in the video, and they are receiving food, so it is possible that the photo by Fteiha was taken before the aid workers arrived. Solve the daily Crossword

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store