Muhyiddin: Integrity, experience cornerstone for appointment of judges
"A judge with integrity will make decisions solely based on the law and justice, without fear or favour," the former Prime Minister said in a statement.
"Justice can only be upheld when the judiciary is independent and judges are of unquestionable integrity."
Muhyiddin said this principle is clearly outlined in Section 23(2)(a) of the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) Act, which identifies integrity, competence, and experience as the main criteria for recommending judicial appointments.
He was commenting on purported JAC meeting minutes, which were recently leaked online. The documents have raised concerns over judicial independence involving a senior judge.
"These are serious allegations of abuse of power and interference in the judiciary," he said.
Muhyiddin said such conduct, if proven true, could severely damage the public's trust in the judicial system and jeopardise an individual's right to a fair trial.
"The judiciary is the final bastion of justice. If judgments can be influenced by those in power, how can the people be assured of fairness? If integrity is no longer a key consideration, there is a real danger that justice can be bought and sold."
He said the allegations must be thoroughly investigated, and corrective action must be taken to ensure future appointments are free from misconduct.
Earlier today, Bukit Gelugor Member of Parliament Ramkarpal Singh called on authorities to investigate both the leak of the minutes as well as the contents of the documents, which contain allegations of judicial interference.
He said the serious allegations made against a judge in the minutes, if true, would severely compromise the judge's integrity.
Hundreds of lawyers are now marching from the Palace of Justice to the Prime Minister's Office in defence of judicial independence.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Former Bar president calls to amend JAC Act to give 'meaningful interpretation'
KUALA LUMPUR: The government should amend the Constitution to give the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) Act 2009 greater legal weight in the appointment of judges, says former Malaysian Bar Council president Salim Bashir. He said while the JAC Act 2009 had set out the procedural framework for judicial selections and recommendations, it should be given a "meaningful interpretation". "JAC Act 2009 is a federal law enacted under legislative power by virtue of Article 132(1)(a) of the Federal Constitution. "Though it sets out a procedural framework for selections of judges and recommendations, it should be given a meaningful interpretation that its existence is to complement the constitutional discretion bestowed under Article 122B(1) to the prime minister for recommendations and His Majesty for the appointment of judges. "Otherwise, it will certainly render the law redundant, repugnant to its objective and stamp absurdity to the working of rule of law and independence of judiciary," he said. Yesterday, Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reform) Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said said that the JAC Act was not a binding provision in the appointment of judges. She said that such appointments were ultimately governed by Article 122B of the Federal Constitution, which empowered the prime minister to advise the Yang di-Pertuan Agong and the Conference of Rulers. She added that the JAC's role was to screen, assess and recommend names of judicial candidates, but its recommendations were not final or binding. Salim said if the government believes that the JAC Act did not provide any binding effect on the appointment of judges, then it should move to amend the Constitution. "Her (Azalina) statement has given impetus for legislative changes, and the government should consider amending the Constitution to give effect to the JAC Act on the appointment of judges. I am sure legislative members will render their support." Meanwhile, criminal lawyer Datuk Geethan Ram Vincent agreed with Azalina's constitutional interpretation, but cautioned against overlooking the JAC's intended role. "Yes, this is correct. Under Article 122B of the Federal Constitution, the prime minister retains full authority to advise the Yang di-Pertuan Agong on judicial appointments. The JAC can recommend, but not decide. "Despite lacking binding authority, the JAC serves important functions. It provides professional vetting of candidates, ensures some degree of transparency in appointments and maintains records of the selection process. "Even though its recommendations are not binding, the JAC acts as an important institutional check against arbitrary or political appointments." Geethan said the JAC's primary task was to review potential judges based on their experience, skills and professional conduct. "They interview candidates and then suggest names to the prime minister. Although the JAC thoroughly documents the selection process, it has no authority to compel the prime minister to accept its recommendations or to require any explanation if they are disregarded. "In essence, the JAC handles the groundwork but holds no real influence over whether its suggestions are acted upon." He added that while Azalina's remarks were technically accurate, they failed to address the broader issue of judicial independence. "While Azalina's remarks are technically accurate regarding the constitutional framework, they overlook the original intent behind creating the JAC to reduce political influence in judicial appointments. "Her statement reflects the current legal reality but fails to address whether this system adequately protects."
The Sun
3 hours ago
- The Sun
Anwar: Stronger whistleblower protection, new Freedom of Information law by year-end
PUTRAJAYA: The government will table a revamped Whistleblower Protection Act and introduce a new Freedom of Information (FOI) Act by year-end, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim announced today. He said the whistleblower law will be strengthened by removing previous exclusions and establishing an independent Whistleblower Protection Committee to ensure proper oversight. 'We are committed to offering broader and more meaningful safeguards for those who report misconduct,' Anwar said at the Malaysia International Conference on Governance and Integrity 2025. He also said the new FOI Act would provide the public genuine access to government decisions, reinforcing transparency and public accountability. 'This is a crucial step toward building trust and encouraging informed democratic participation,' he said. 'These reforms show our resolve to create strong, fair and transparent institutions that act with integrity for all Malaysians.'
Sinar Daily
3 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
PM's announcement expected to make people smile
'I'm not a magician. Just wait, because it's a surprise." Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Shamsul Azri Abu Bakar hinted that the upcoming announcement by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim will be a surprise expected to bring joy to the people, particularly civil servants. KUALA LUMPUR – Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Shamsul Azri Abu Bakar has hinted that the upcoming announcement by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim will be a surprise likely to bring joy to the people, especially civil servants. 'It's a surprise, but it will make the people happy. 'If it's for civil servants, then it will certainly bring joy to them, InsyaAllah,' he said briefly. He made the remark when asked to comment on a poster shared by the Prime Minister on his official Facebook page yesterday, which hinted at an 'extraordinary appreciation for Malaysians.' While the post did not detail the nature of the upcoming announcement, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim shared a poster that said "COMING" on his Facebook which quickly caught the attention of social media users. The same poster was also shared on the official page of the Public Service Department. However, Shamsul declined to elaborate on the announcement and urged the public to be patient. 'I'm not a magician. Just wait, because it's a surprise. 'It's tightly sealed and cannot be opened,' he quipped after officiating the third Azman Hashim International Business School Action Research Conference (AHIBS-ACT) 2025 at the World Trade Centre Kuala Lumpur on Tuesday. Also present were Universiti Teknologi Malaysia Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic and International) Professor Dr Intan Zaurah Mat Darus and AHIBS-ACT Chairperson Associate Professor Dr Haliyana Khalid. Shamsul added that he would leave it to the government to decide on the most appropriate time to make the official announcement. Earlier, the Prime Minister posted on Facebook that an 'important announcement' would be made soon, which was seen as a form of 'gift' to the people. So far, no official details have been disclosed, but many speculated that the announcement will be a surprise ahead of the upcoming parliamentary sitting. It is understood that the Prime Minister also held a closed-door meeting with Pakatan Harapan leaders yesterday to discuss current issues. The discussion session included preparations for the upcoming parliamentary sitting, following an engagement session with Barisan Nasional MPs last Friday. More Like This
