Swinney says sorry to Gypsy Travellers for ‘trauma' of the ‘tinker experiment'
John Swinney made clear that the treatment of members of this community in previous years had been 'unacceptable'.
His comments came as a new report, published by the Scottish Government, stated that 'the context within which the TE (tinker experiment) occurred is best understood as cultural genocide'.
Between 1940 and 1980, the so-called experiment – supported by councils and the UK government – attempted to strip away the nomadic lifestyle of Gypsy Travellers, providing rudimentary and often cramped huts for people to live in.
When families became too big to be housed in the huts, children would sometimes be taken away.
The Scottish Government has been carrying out research into the impact of what happened – with report, by the Third Generation Project at St Andrews University, revealing 'discriminatory' policies had been carried out in 27 of Scotland's current 32 local authorities.
The Church of Scotland also issued 'a heartfelt and genuine apology for these historic wrongs'.
Mr Swinney, in a statement to Holyrood, said he hoped his apology could be the 'beginning of a new conversation' with efforts to improve the lives of Gypsy Traveller community in Scotland.
The First Minister told MSPs 'without ambiguity' that 'what happened to Gypsy Traveller communities in Scotland was unacceptable'.
He added: 'It is clear to the Government that stark prejudice and lack of cultural awareness led to a series of unfair and unjust policies.
'These policies resulted in children being removed from families, and families were forced to live in substandard accommodation and degrading conditions.
'The trauma that this has caused to individuals, families and groups, including those who regard themselves as 'victims of tinker experiments', is significant and lasting'.
With Gypsy Travellers in Holyrood's public gallery, Mr Swinney continued: 'As First Minister of Scotland, I want to say this directly to Gypsy Traveller communities: the 'tinker experiments' should not have happened.
'These policies were wrong. And we recognise how much it is still hurting so many.
'And more than anything else I want to say this – on behalf of Scotland, we are sorry.'
Mr Swinney added that although Scotland had 'come a long way since the 'Tinker experiments', there was 'still much to do' in tackling the prejudice the community continued to face.
And while Holyrood ministers published a new Gypsy Traveller action plan last year, the First Minister said the experiences shared as part of the government's work 'underline the urgent need for systemic change, greater accountability, and a shift in attitudes at every level'.
He declared: 'We must do better.'
Stressing the need for 'meaningful action' he highlighted the importance of 'challenging stereotypes, confronting everyday discrimination, and committing to long-term efforts that promote understanding, respect, and equity for Gypsy Travellers'.
He stated: 'Our hope is that we now have a foundation for continuing to build trust and fostering renewed relationships with all those who have been impacted by historical policies.'
His comments came as the report described the tinker experiments as being the 'recurring societal and institutional dehumanisation of Gypsy Travellers in Scotland'.
This was 'often carried out under the stereotype of Gypsy Travellers as a people that collectively practised a backwards or undeveloped way of life', it added.
The research highlighted the role of the UK national government 'and specifically the Scottish Office as a primary actor in the construction and enforcement of such policies'.
But it said that others – including local councils, churches and charities – were involved in 'constructing the environment' that allowed this to happen.
Gypsy Travellers in Scotland were housed in accommodation including Nissen-type huts, repurposed military buildings and disused properties, the report added – with these 'known by government agents to be substandard' with such properties 'frequently without' electricity and running water.
The report also highlighted the 'forced transfer of children', with some youngsters being removed from their families and placed in temporary care, while others were permanently taken away, being adopted either in the UK or overseas.
Afterwards, the Reverend Tommy MacNeil, convener of the Faith Action Programme Leadership Team of the Church of Scotland and Dr Mike Cantlay, convener of its Social Care Council said: 'On behalf of the Church of Scotland, we offer a heartfelt and genuine apology for these historic wrongs, highlighted in the report and carried out in the name of the Church.'
They added: 'We wish to say we stand in solidarity with those who suffered, and deeply regret the harm that came to them as a result of actions by the Church in the past.'
Their statement acknowleged that the Church of Scotland 'tolerated discrimination and the use of derogatory language by its employees and members'
The men stressed: 'We regret and are very sorry for the trauma that was inflicted on Gypsy Traveller communities, families and individuals by our Church.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
John Swinney rules out SNP coalition with Reform UK
Appearing at a live recording of the Holyrood Sources podcast in Edinburgh on Wednesday, the First Minister did not appear to outright reject working with Scottish Labour, while he was much more unequivocal about Nigel Farage's party. When asked by a member of the audience if he would consider joining forces with Scottish Labour after the next election to get his party over the line, Swinney initially said discussions around a potential pact were based on 'scenarios thrown up after the election'. 'I want to do spectacularly well in 2026, that's what my sights are on," he said. READ MORE: Anas Sarwar backs UK disability benefit cuts amid Scottish Labour revolt 'Whatever else the election throws up, then we'll deal with that.' But on Reform UK, he said: 'I'm not going to engage roundabout Farage and Reform, I won't engage with them." When pressed further on potentially working with Anas Sarwar's party, Swinney pointed to the SNP's minority government, which was in office between 2007 and 2011, a period where he was finance secretary and had 'all sorts of folk voting for my lovely budgets'. Recent polling ahead of the election in May still has the SNP as the largest party after a reversal in Labour's fortunes, but the surge of Reform UK has seen them jump into second place in terms of support in some surveys. Swinney admitted the polls were not where he would like them to be. 'I'm not sitting here saying to you where we are in the polls now is just fine for me – it's not,' he said. 'It's not acceptable for me, I need to get us into a stronger position.' READ MORE: Pro-independence Holyrood majority 'matters for future of politics' – John Curtice Pointing to the recent Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election – which the SNP lost to Labour – the First Minister said the party was not planning for it to be sparked, which came after the death of SNP MSP Christina McKelvie, but he would be ready for next year. Later in the same podcast, the possibility of a coalition was put to Mr Sarwar, who said he believed the situation simply wouldn't arise for such a move – describing it as 'mad' – and reiterating his stance that Labour would seek to lead a minority administration if it could. The next parliament, he said, would be a 'parliament of minorities'. 'Of course, with any minority government, you will have to find areas of consensus to make improvements in Scotland,' he said. 'But I genuinely believe, if we get a change of government next year and we are in a parliament of minorities … depending on leaderships and how people choose to act after there's been a change of government in Scotland, I genuinely believe that there will be a scope and an appetite to get things done in our country.'
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Readers' Letters: Everything seems to be getting worse in Scotland
The Scotsman's round-up of life in Scotland today dismays reader Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Yesterday (25 June) we had another edition of The Scotsman which exposes the calamitous state of our nation. Page one reveals more misery for cancer patients with treatment times dropping alarmingly. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Then we have the highest delayed discharge figures since records began in 2016. Awful statistics which explain why beds are unavailable for other patients and procedures. First Minister John Swinney's government is full of ministers unqualified for their role, says reader (Picture: Jane Barlow - Pool/Getty Images) Next up, we discover that the tartan biscuit tin is not as empty as we are told on a daily basis, with the news that Dundee University is to receive a bail-out over three years of £40 million – no doubt this will assist in covering the debts incurred by 'free tuition' for Scottish students, that is, those who can get a place at the expense of a fee-paying 'foreigner' from over the Border or abroad. Then on to house building, now at its lowest level since 2012. Anyone with an iota of common sense knows that the best way to stimulate an economy is house building – again the Scottish Government are complicit in this appalling statistic with their net zero restrictions adding exorbitant costs to builders. And then we have the bloated Civil Service, with almost one manager per member of staff. Another example of the profligacy of the SNP in power. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad And to put the tin lid on this depressing read, class sizes in Edinburgh will be breached to 'save costs'. Of all these examples of the mess we are in, this is the worst, as we fail our next generation and their prospects go down the tube. And at the head of all these examples are the failed 'Ministers' given top jobs with exorbitant salaries and pensions, most with no experience, some of whom can hardly construct a sentence coherently when interviewed. While it was a dreary read to start the day, I applaud the Scotsman and its correspondents for their diligence in bringing this to our attention. The only way to sort this out is at the ballot box in 2026 – but what will be left of our 'services' by then? 'Not much' is the clear and obvious answer. David Millar, Lauder, Scottish Borders Keep it Scottish? Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Early this week, the BMA claimed that the NHS is 'dying'. The following day more bad news on cancer treatment in Scotland emerges and as we wait for a statement of some kind we are told Health Secretary Neil Gray is on a trip to Japan – is his favourite football team doing a pre-season tour? Is it any wonder that a third of Scots are now forced into using private healthcare – the very thing the NHS was created to prevent. The problems in the NHS are myriad. But in Scotland they are multiplied by the SNP's apparent insistence on putting a 'Scottish' slant on everything – the latest example being the NHS app in wide use south of the Border for years, which had to be somehow 'Scottified' for use north of the Border. It is madness. Think of the census fiasco when their insistence on an entirely Scottish version cost millions and left gaps in our records. Why cannot we have an administration that will concentrate on Scottish matters and attempt to make life better for all Scots and forget the nationalist claptrap? Alexander McKay, Edinburgh Line of duty So the Health Secretary is in Japan? Not only has he left his post at a time of real crisis for those unfortunate Scots recently diagnosed with cancer but his carbon footprint looms large too. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The SNP seems more interested in bailing out the Edinburgh International Book Festival whose previous sponsor, Baillie Gifford, was dumped by those on the left for the firm's perceived links to oil and Israel. Surely this has nothing to do with appearances there by Nicola Sturgeon and friends? The SNP is failing Scotland in all areas. Holyrood elections are very close. The election can't come soon enough. Gerald Edwards, Glasgow What about Wales? According to Dame Jackie Baillie, the latest figures on NHS Scotland cancer waiting times are 'disastrous' and an indication of 'the SNP's mismanagement of the NHS'. If that is indeed the case, then how would Dame Jackie describe the situation in Wales, perhaps 'catastrophic'? In Wales the devolved Labour government has not only given up (since 2019) on reporting the 31-day target for the start of treatment, which NHS Scotland is achieving in 94.1 per cent cases and NHS England in 91.3 per cent of cases, NHS Wales is only achieving the 62-day target for initial referral to start of treatment in 60.5 per cent of cases. On the 62-day target, NHS Scotland at 68.9 per cent is performing 13.9 per cent better than Wales and NHS England at 69.9 per cent is performing 15.5 per cent better. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Of course, the broader picture is that across the UK the NHS is struggling as cancers are increasingly suspected earlier and people are living longer (NHS Scotland has seen 17.5 per cent and 6.3 per cent increases in 62-day and 31-day referrals since the pandemic) while staffing levels continue to suffer as a result of Brexit and hostile UK Government immigration policies. Stan Grodynski, Longniddry, East Lothian Fair play Murdo Fraser is right to criticise the Robertson Trust's half-baked proposal of a guaranteed income (Perspective, 25 June). Yet the principle is valid, provided it's paid from resource values, as in Norway and Alaska. More generally, publicly created land values should be restored to the citizenry, with them deciding which state services they wish to purchase. Childless people should not, for example, be taxed to pay for other peoples' kids' education. George Morton, Rosyth, Fife Turbine whoppers Good on Councillor Ruraidh Stewart and Skye residents protesting against the developers' plans to 'repower' Ben Aketil wind farm, near Dunvegan (your report, 23 June). The downright dishonesty in claiming larger turbines are more efficient is breathtaking, and shame on the remote Scottish Government for falling for the spin! Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Did our brick-sized mobile phones double or half in size as they became more efficient? The farcical industry claims that larger turbines are more 'efficient' could not be further from the truth! Current turbine blades have been tweaked, over many years, to the nth degree, but the inexorable laws of physics demand that all that can now be done is to make the turbines even larger, even more materials hungry, even more space consuming, even more destructive to our landscapes, even more difficult to recycle, even more damaging, even more unsightly and, with blades that travel in excess of 200mph, even more lethal to wildlife. They are foisting giant, offshore turbines onto beleaguered rural communities, onshore. Far from boasting about 'super' turbines we are in reality being subjected to yet another load of whoppers from the wind industry! George Herraghty, Elgin, Moray Price of life Now that inflation has pounced onto food and airfare prices once again, it just highlights that the cost of living crisis is real and pounding everyone's pockets, as previously. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad While Sir Keir Starmer talks about cutting green levies for business, by up to 25 per cent – what about everyone else. So with supermarkets offering their own special deals with store card advantages and high street stores offering continual all year round sales, one has to ask, what is the true and real price of anything, these days? Archie Mackinnon, Glasgow Unfair attack During the weekend Sir Keir Starmer defended the US bombing of Iran when he said it was necessary to 'alleviate' the threat of Iran developing a nuclear weapon. I wonder if he recalls an incident during a speech by Benjamin Netanyahu at a meeting of the UN Security Council in 2012, when the Israeli leader brandished a cartoon of a bomb and insisted Iran was close to developing a nuclear weapon. In 2015, the US estimated Iran could produce enough fuel for a nuclear bomb in 12 months if it was so inclined. In an article published on 13 September 2021, the New York Times claimed Iran was just a month away from being able to produce sufficient fuel for a nuclear bomb! So why has Iran not produced that bomb long before now? Our Prime Minister also said at the weekend, 'We call on Iran to return to the negotiating table and reach a diplomatic solution to end this crisis'. Perhaps Sir Keir should ask himself who caused the crisis by mounting an illegal attack on a sovereign state? It has evidently also slipped his mind that Iran was at the negotiating table when it was attacked! Alan Woodcock, Dundee Hold on to hope Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Amidst all the discussion around assisted dying it is important to distinguish between the terms 'terminal' and 'incurable' when describing life-threatening disease. Terminal should only be used when death is imminent – days, weeks or at most a few months. In recent media announcements several famous people have had their advanced cancers described as terminal, when they are obviously very much alive and in some cases only in the early stages of treatment. Today most cancers – even at stage 4 – are treatable, where appropriate management can result in good quality of life for considerable periods of time. Incurable, yes, but so are many common conditions such as diabetes, hypertension, arthritis etc. In many thousands of conversations with patients at the time of their diagnosis and treatment planning I have emphasised that although their disease is incurable it is certainly not a death sentence. Hope is a very valuable medicine in its own right. Doctors should never withhold truth about the seriousness of any illness but the prognosis for any individual depends on their specific response to treatment, and good communication should prevent automatic assumption a diagnosis of cancer implies imminent death. So please could the media stop using the word terminal as a blanket term for all advanced cancers. Thank you. (Professor) John F Smyth, Edinburgh Write to The Scotsman
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Union seeks more public money for Alexander Dennis
But he says that support should be conditional on the company having a long term commitment to Scotland. And the union says that it cannot take away from the recovery of Grangemouth. Unions however have warned that "time is running out" on the company with the consultation over jobs due to expire in a few weeks, while there was no response yet to a request for an extension to August 15, and while the Scottish Parliament goes into summer recess between June 28 and August 31. It has been suggested that a taxpayer-backed furlough scheme could be put in place to allow ADL to remain in Scotland at a cost expected to be between £4m and £5m. The idea was to support staff for a few months until work on new bus orders could get under way. Ministers were accused of "strategic neglect" after The Herald revealed £90m of public money was ploughed into the firm in Scotland that is now planning to move to England. According to Scottish Government records, ADL received £58m of public 'subsidy' for green vehicles since 2020 under two schemes aimed at transitioning Scotland to green buses - despite the company having embarked on a 2020 plan to axe a third of its Scottish workforce. And some £30m of jobs grants for research and development over 10 years has come from the Scottish Government's economic development agency Scottish Enterprise. Some £11.2m of those jobs grants from Scottish Enterprise came in 2023, three years after concerns were raised over ADL embarking on major job cuts in 2020. John SwinneyThe Herald also revealed how the First Minister John Swinney was warned Alexander Dennis was "reconsidering" its "entire investment" in Scotland a year before announcing its plans last week to relocate to England putting 400 jobs at risk. This news follows the loss of more than 400 jobs just a few miles away in Grangemouth, where the oil refinery recently closed and was converted into an import terminal. Calls have already been made to claw money back if Alexander Dennis follows through with its proposals. Now Unite has suggested that Grangemouth money that is not earmarked for its recovery could be utilised to support ADL in Scotland. Sir Keir Starmer in February announced £200m investment in the Grangemouth site calling the announcement an "investment in Scotland's industrial future". The £200m investment will come from the National Wealth Fund which publicly-owned and backed by the Treasury, and invests alongside the private sector in projects - primarily focusing on initiatives that support clean energy. The UK government said its aim was to direct "tens of billions of pounds" of private investment to decarbonise the British economy. But Derek Thomson, Unite Scotland's regional secretary said there was no sign that that wealth fund money has been deployed anywhere yet. The oil refinery, owned by Petroineos, is set to close by the summer with the loss of more than 400 jobs. Scotland's first minister announced £25m of new 'just transition' funding which he said brought the Scottish government's total investment for the site to £87m. An Alexander Dennis bus (Image: Pic supplied) Mr Thomson said: "There are significant public funds being allocated towards the Grangemouth area by government ministers. This includes £200m from the UK National Wealth Fund and a further £25m in the Just Transition Fund set up by the Scottish government. There is minimal information on the criteria and conditionalities associated with accessing this public money which was increased due to pressure by Unite after the announcement by PetroIneos to close the oil refinery." Read more: "The question needs to be asked as to whether any public funding streams can be used to help support not only the refinery workers but also those at Alexander Dennis and the wider industrial cluster. We need to ensure that workers are properly supported particularly when they are integral to the nation's strategic manufacturing base and wider energy transition." Ministers are said to be looking at ADL's costs and considering what additional support that can ben provided to to help lower then, increase productivity and ensure there is demand for their buses. They are working with the procuring authorities - the people who actually own and run the buses - in Scotland and further afield, to look at how the ADL order book can be developed. The SNP-led Scottish Government and the Labour-led UK Government have agreed to establish a joint working group to discuss options to find a solution and avert job losses. The SNP-led Scottish Government and the Labour-led UK Government have agreed to establish a joint working group to discuss options to find a solution and avert job losses. If Alexander Dennis left Scotland it would mark the end of more than a century of manufacturing excellence and innovation. ADL and bus production are synonymous, with more than a century of manufacturing excellence and innovation growing from Walter Alexander's original coach works in Falkirk. Union representative were yesterday told how the firm's move to England is a 'political failure' which would be 'catastrophic' for a region already facing economic difficulties. Earlier this month, the company announced it was considering relocating production from its Larbert and Camelon sites near Falkirk to Scarborough in North Yorkshire, citing cost-cutting reasons. Robert Deavy, the senior organiser for manufacturing with GMB Scotland said the situation would require a political intervention to resolve. 'Speaking to our members, this is something that we as a union have been raising for some time – I'm pretty sure Unite have been as well,' he said. 'We believe that this is a political failure that now requires a political solution. He added: 'Now we need everyone to come together – trade unions, politicians and, really importantly, we need ADL involvement on this.' Alexander Dennis has said that they are engaging with both governments "in good faith on the possibility of any intervention" and has stressed that a final decision on the move had not yet been made. The company, the unions said, is losing out on contracts to cheaper foreign alternatives as a result of their lower costs, with Mr Thomson calling for direct awards to be made from government to the company and for workers to be paid until work on the contracts begins. 'What we understand is that pending those direct awards or contracts being done, there is a four month gap between bringing those contracts online and the end of the consultation period,' he said. 'What we have been asking for and speaking to the Deputy First Minister about is a time-limited furlough scheme where we can support those workers through that period of the contract being awarded.' Mr Deavy warned that if the sites close, then 'the skills are lost forever' in the area. Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes said: "The absolute focus right now is on supporting ADL, its workforce, as well as the families and communities they support. We also recognise the significance of the company within the local economy and across the wider supply chain. 'The Scottish Government has committed to exploring all viable options throughout the consultation period to allow the firm to retain their hard-working employees and manufacturing and production facilities at Falkirk and Larbert. 'We will continue to work in close collaboration with the company, trade unions, Scottish Enterprise, Transport Scotland and the UK Government. 'Since 2020, ADL secured orders for more zero emission buses than any other single manufacturer through the Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge Fund and its predecessor the Scottish Ultra Low Emission Bus Scheme. ADL has received £58 million of Scottish Government subsidy for vehicles under these programmes.'
