Durham disclosures further undermine Gabbard's claims of plot against Trump
But if her crusade was aimed at proving that Obama embarked on a 'treasonous conspiracy' to falsely show that Russia intervened in the 2016 presidential election to help Trump, Gabbard made a mistake. A previously classified annexe to a report by another special counsel, John Durham – appointed towards the end of Trump's first presidency – has further undermined Gabbard's case.
It was a quixotic enterprise from the start.
After all, the 2019 report from Robert Mueller, the original special counsel appointed to investigate the Russia allegations, and a bipartisan five-volume report the following year from the Senate intelligence committee – then chaired by Marco Rubio, now Trump's secretary of state – both affirmed the offending January 2017 intelligence community assessment, which expressed 'high confidence' in Russian interference.
Vladimir Putin, Russia's president, seemed to validate the intelligence's premise in 2018 when, standing beside Trump at a news conference in Helsinki, he admitted wanting him to win.
The newly unclassified 29-page document from Durham, made public this week, contains a deflating conclusion for Gabbard. It confirms that Russian spies were behind the emails that were originally released as the result of a Russian cyber-hack of internal Democratic information channels and which Trump supporters believed showed the campaign of Hillary Clinton, his 2016 opponent, conspiring to accuse him of colluding with Moscow.
'The office's best assessment is that the July 25 and July 27 emails that purport to be from Benardo were ultimately a composite of several emails that were obtained through Russian intelligence hacking of the US-based thinktanks,' Durham writes. He is referring to Leonard Benardo, of the Open Society Foundation, funded by George Soros, a philanthropist and bete noire of Trump's Maga base.
One of the emails purportedly from Benardo proposes a plan 'to demonize Putin and Trump' and adds: 'Later the FBI will put more oil on the fire.'
That message and others, including from a Clinton foreign policy aide, Julianne Smith, became part of the so-called 'Clinton Plan intelligence'. Benardo and Smith disputed ever writing such emails.
In his 2023 report annexe, released on Thursday in heavily redacted form, Durham at least upholds Benardo's disavowal – concluding that it has been cobbled together from other individuals' emails to produce something more incriminating than the actuality.
For Gabbard, who is feverishly trying to prove the existence of a 'deep state' determined to sabotage Trump, emails suspected to have been confected by Russia is hardly a brilliant look in her evidence package.
Some former intelligence insiders find that unsurprising – dismissing the idea as a Trump-inspired fiction. 'Trump is lying when he speaks of a 'deep state',' said Fulton Armstrong, a retired CIA analyst who served under Democratic and Republican administrations. 'But if there were one, it would not be Democrat. The culture of that world is deeply Republican.'
The national intelligence director – who has never served in the intelligence services or sat on its eponymous congressional committee when she was in the House of Representatives – is likely to see Durham's finding as immaterial to her quest to put Obama officials on trial for 'manufacturing' intelligence.
But Gabbard's insistence – echoing her boss's view – on the existence of a plot to torpedo Trump was dismissed on Friday by John Brennan, the CIA director under Obama, who told the New Yorker that Obama issued instructions that intelligence showing Russian meddling to be kept hush-hush, at least until polling day, to ensure a fair election.
'He made very clear to us [that] he wanted us to try to uncover everything the Russians were doing, but also not to do anything that would in any way interfere in the election,' Brennan said.
Gabbard has cited a 2020 House of Representatives intelligence committee report – endorsed only by its Republican members – challenging the assertion that Putin wanted to Trump to win.
However, Michael Van Landingham, one of the CIA authors of the 2017 intelligence assessment now in her crosshairs, said credible intelligence cast the Russian leader's motives in an unambiguous light.
'The primary evidence to get to Putin's mindset was a clandestine source that said, essentially, when Putin realized that Clinton would win the election, he ordered an influence campaign against Hillary Clinton,' Van Landingham told PBS News Hour.
'Then we saw a series of events that happened with the hacked US materials by the Russian special services or intelligence services to leak those materials similar to the information a clandestine source had provided. At the same time, we saw lots of members of the Russian media portraying Donald Trump in a more positive light.
'There was other information … collected by the US intelligence community … over time, having a high-quality, clandestine source telling you that Putin was counting on Trump's victory, having members of the Russian state saying Trump would be better to work with because of his views on Russia that don't represent the US establishment, all of those things gave us high confidence that Putin wanted Trump to win.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Child abuser and illegal migrant who rammed car into ICE agents is on the loose
Authorities in Colorado are desperately searching for a convicted child abuser who rammed his vehicle into Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. Jose Mendez-Chavez, 31, a Mexican national, remains on the loose since he tried to assault officers with his vehicle at new home construction sites in Sterling Ranch, south of Denver, on Thursday morning, KOAA reports. None of the officers were injured in the attack, but it prompted one agent to fire his weapon at least three times in a residential area. ICE officials quickly apprehended the other suspect in the vehicle, identified as Francisco Zapata-Pacheo, whom they say is now cooperating with law enforcement. But Mendez-Chavez's whereabouts remain unknown, as ICE agents revealed that he is a convicted child abuser with previous arrests for domestic violence and entering the country illegally a half dozen times, Records obtained by Fox News show Mendez-Chaves was most recently convicted in August 2020 of reckless endangerment in Texas and was sentenced to one year behind bars. He was also arrested in January 2020 for child abuse, and in July 2013, Mendez-Chaves was convicted in Ohio of domestic violence and sentenced to 180 days in prison. 'Mendez-Chaves was not an "innocent victim," he is an abuser who plays the system, and is now wanted for assault on a federal officer,' a spokesperson for the agency said in a statement. ICE officials were conducting a raid on construction sites at around 8.30am The spokesperson also blasted the Colorado Rapid Response Network, an immigrant-rights organization he called 'despicable' for reportedly showing up in defense of Mendez-Chaves 'who has abused children and attempted to injure our officers.' ICE agents began their operation at around 8.30am on Thursday, arriving at a cul-de-sac of new home builds near near Poco and Vollmer Roads, KOAA reports. Upon their arrival, construction workers from different job sites started to run, and Mendez-Chaves and Zapata-Pacheo rammed their vehicle into the officers, prompting one to open fire at around 8.31am. That agent then claimed that one of the two men inside the vehicle fled on foot before the car sped away. Meanwhile, home security footage from the newly-built neighborhood showed a man jumping the fence of a home and hiding under a barbecue grill cover. Officers could be seen in pursuit nearby, but apparently did not notice the suspect jumping the fence as they appeared to chase others who were running. The homeowner has since told KOAA that the unidentified man hid under their grill for at least two hours - before he entered their home while his family was inside. Yet the family, in another room, was unaware of the man's presence as he walked through their house while their grandchild played video games nearby. The two acknowledged each other, but otherwise, the man largely ignored the child as he sought an exit - eventually slipping through the front door and entering a vehicle that seemed to be waiting for him, and drove away. Home security footage taken near the raids showed one man jumping a fence and hiding under a resident's grill cover It now remains unclear whether the man is one of the two suspects ICE agents had sought in connection with the ramming incident. In the meantime, Zapata-Pacheco has been taken to the Aurora ICE Detention Facility. It is unclear whether he was facing any criminal charges prior to his arrest, but officials say he will be held in ICE custody pending immigration and criminal proceedings.
Reuters
4 minutes ago
- Reuters
Reward of $7,500 posted for man wanted on suspicion of shooting 4 dead in Montana bar
Aug 3 (Reuters) - The U.S. Marshals Service on Sunday posted a $7,500 reward for any information leading to the capture of the man accused of shooting four people dead in a Montana bar before he vanished, sparking a search for the suspect in the nearby mountains. The reward was announced as state Attorney General Austin Knudsen visited the small southwestern Montana town of Anaconda to be briefed by investigators and provide a public update on the third day of the manhunt. According to authorities, the suspect, Michael Brown, 45, walked into the Owl Bar late on Friday morning and opened fire with a rifle, killing the bartender and three patrons, then fled the scene. A stolen pickup truck used as a getaway vehicle was later recovered, but law enforcement's last sighting of the suspect was during a brief pursuit about two hours after the shooting, Knudsen told reporters. Investigators have yet to determine a motive, but Brown lived near the bar, was a regular there himself and presumably knew all four of his victims, Knudsen said. They were identified publicly on Sunday as bartender Nancy Lauretta Kelley, 64, and customers Daniel Edwin Baillie, 59, David Allen Leach, 70, and Tony Wayne Palm, 74. The manhunt, which has involved as many as 250 local, state and federal law enforcement personnel and various aircraft, remained focused on a mountainous area west of Anaconda, a town of fewer than 10,000 residents about 75 miles (120 km) southeast of Missoula. "We want to find this guy," Knudsen said. "This is a dangerous individual who has committed an absolutely heinous crime against this community and his victims." Authorities have released a photo showing the suspect dressed only in black underpants and barefoot as he descends a flight of concrete steps with his hands braced against a wall. His face is smudged, and his chest and neck appear to be scraped. Knudsen said the photo was taken after Brown had fled to another location near the shooting where "he got rid of some personal belongings and he got rid of his clothes." The vehicle he is suspected of stealing was loaded with camping gear, and "we have very good reason to believe that he is clothed, he does have shoes, and he's probably able to get around," Knudsen said. The attorney general said Brown also was presumed to still be carrying the murder weapon. Asked whether he believed authorities expected to find him dead or alive, Knudsen said, "He could have committed suicide and be dead, yes, but we are acting under the assumption that he is alive, well armed and extremely dangerous." He said the reward of $7,500 offered by the U.S. Marshals Service for information leading to his arrest was an initial sum, indicating it might be increased.
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
A Taliban sniper nor an IED could kill my husband... but lies, betrayal and a dark secret at home almost did
I picked up the phone, saw the text, and in that instant, I knew my life would never be the same. It was from a friend saying there had been an accident. My heart shattered into a million pieces, and my stomach dropped. They were the words every military wife dreads but prays will never come.
