Lord of the Rings says burger chain name shall not pass
In a battle between a fantasy book franchise and a vegan fast-food chain, who will be named "Lord of the" courtroom?
The rights holder of the Lord of the Rings novels and films, Middle-earth Enterprises, has launched another attack to take its precious title.
It follows an unsuccessful bid in March, where the franchise attempted to block an Australian vegan hamburger chain from trademarking the words "Lord of the" in its name.
Lord of the Fries has been selling items under its name since 2004 and sought to offer plant-based macaroni and cheese under the trademark in 2022.
The case came before a registrar of trademarks in the federal government agency, IP Australia.
Middle-earth argued it had been successful in other similar trademark applications made globally, and used the mark to sell various items including boardgames, clothing and toys.
But Lord of the Fries said there were many examples of similar marks including Lord of the Pies and the business operated as a niche in an entirely different reputation to the Middle-earth franchise.
The registrar delegate, Nicholas Smith, found the names were not deceptively similar and that Middle-earth had cherry-picked evidence in suggesting the connection.
The matter has since been escalated to Sydney's Federal Court, after Middle-earth's lawyers filed an appeal against the IP Australia decision on March 25.
The grounds for appeal were many and varied, the franchise's lawyer Shauna Ross told Justice Michael Lee.
"My client's case is that Your Honour find the mark should be refused," she said on Thursday.
The grounds for appeal included that Lord of the Fries does not own the trademark and that the IP Australia decision was adverse to Middle-earth, who is the true owner of the mark, Ms Ross said.
Justice Lee ordered both parties attend a mediation before June 20.
If the case is not resolved through mediation, Justice Lee said he would assign the matter to a referee, who would then prepare a report for the decision.
"The reality is I don't have time to look at this matter this year," he said.
Lord of the Fries and Middle-earth Enterprises have been contacted for comment.
In a battle between a fantasy book franchise and a vegan fast-food chain, who will be named "Lord of the" courtroom?
The rights holder of the Lord of the Rings novels and films, Middle-earth Enterprises, has launched another attack to take its precious title.
It follows an unsuccessful bid in March, where the franchise attempted to block an Australian vegan hamburger chain from trademarking the words "Lord of the" in its name.
Lord of the Fries has been selling items under its name since 2004 and sought to offer plant-based macaroni and cheese under the trademark in 2022.
The case came before a registrar of trademarks in the federal government agency, IP Australia.
Middle-earth argued it had been successful in other similar trademark applications made globally, and used the mark to sell various items including boardgames, clothing and toys.
But Lord of the Fries said there were many examples of similar marks including Lord of the Pies and the business operated as a niche in an entirely different reputation to the Middle-earth franchise.
The registrar delegate, Nicholas Smith, found the names were not deceptively similar and that Middle-earth had cherry-picked evidence in suggesting the connection.
The matter has since been escalated to Sydney's Federal Court, after Middle-earth's lawyers filed an appeal against the IP Australia decision on March 25.
The grounds for appeal were many and varied, the franchise's lawyer Shauna Ross told Justice Michael Lee.
"My client's case is that Your Honour find the mark should be refused," she said on Thursday.
The grounds for appeal included that Lord of the Fries does not own the trademark and that the IP Australia decision was adverse to Middle-earth, who is the true owner of the mark, Ms Ross said.
Justice Lee ordered both parties attend a mediation before June 20.
If the case is not resolved through mediation, Justice Lee said he would assign the matter to a referee, who would then prepare a report for the decision.
"The reality is I don't have time to look at this matter this year," he said.
Lord of the Fries and Middle-earth Enterprises have been contacted for comment.
In a battle between a fantasy book franchise and a vegan fast-food chain, who will be named "Lord of the" courtroom?
The rights holder of the Lord of the Rings novels and films, Middle-earth Enterprises, has launched another attack to take its precious title.
It follows an unsuccessful bid in March, where the franchise attempted to block an Australian vegan hamburger chain from trademarking the words "Lord of the" in its name.
Lord of the Fries has been selling items under its name since 2004 and sought to offer plant-based macaroni and cheese under the trademark in 2022.
The case came before a registrar of trademarks in the federal government agency, IP Australia.
Middle-earth argued it had been successful in other similar trademark applications made globally, and used the mark to sell various items including boardgames, clothing and toys.
But Lord of the Fries said there were many examples of similar marks including Lord of the Pies and the business operated as a niche in an entirely different reputation to the Middle-earth franchise.
The registrar delegate, Nicholas Smith, found the names were not deceptively similar and that Middle-earth had cherry-picked evidence in suggesting the connection.
The matter has since been escalated to Sydney's Federal Court, after Middle-earth's lawyers filed an appeal against the IP Australia decision on March 25.
The grounds for appeal were many and varied, the franchise's lawyer Shauna Ross told Justice Michael Lee.
"My client's case is that Your Honour find the mark should be refused," she said on Thursday.
The grounds for appeal included that Lord of the Fries does not own the trademark and that the IP Australia decision was adverse to Middle-earth, who is the true owner of the mark, Ms Ross said.
Justice Lee ordered both parties attend a mediation before June 20.
If the case is not resolved through mediation, Justice Lee said he would assign the matter to a referee, who would then prepare a report for the decision.
"The reality is I don't have time to look at this matter this year," he said.
Lord of the Fries and Middle-earth Enterprises have been contacted for comment.
In a battle between a fantasy book franchise and a vegan fast-food chain, who will be named "Lord of the" courtroom?
The rights holder of the Lord of the Rings novels and films, Middle-earth Enterprises, has launched another attack to take its precious title.
It follows an unsuccessful bid in March, where the franchise attempted to block an Australian vegan hamburger chain from trademarking the words "Lord of the" in its name.
Lord of the Fries has been selling items under its name since 2004 and sought to offer plant-based macaroni and cheese under the trademark in 2022.
The case came before a registrar of trademarks in the federal government agency, IP Australia.
Middle-earth argued it had been successful in other similar trademark applications made globally, and used the mark to sell various items including boardgames, clothing and toys.
But Lord of the Fries said there were many examples of similar marks including Lord of the Pies and the business operated as a niche in an entirely different reputation to the Middle-earth franchise.
The registrar delegate, Nicholas Smith, found the names were not deceptively similar and that Middle-earth had cherry-picked evidence in suggesting the connection.
The matter has since been escalated to Sydney's Federal Court, after Middle-earth's lawyers filed an appeal against the IP Australia decision on March 25.
The grounds for appeal were many and varied, the franchise's lawyer Shauna Ross told Justice Michael Lee.
"My client's case is that Your Honour find the mark should be refused," she said on Thursday.
The grounds for appeal included that Lord of the Fries does not own the trademark and that the IP Australia decision was adverse to Middle-earth, who is the true owner of the mark, Ms Ross said.
Justice Lee ordered both parties attend a mediation before June 20.
If the case is not resolved through mediation, Justice Lee said he would assign the matter to a referee, who would then prepare a report for the decision.
"The reality is I don't have time to look at this matter this year," he said.
Lord of the Fries and Middle-earth Enterprises have been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
4 hours ago
- The Age
Elevate Kiosk
This venue is a finalist in the market stall category in Good Food's Essential Sydney Cafes and Bakeries of 2025. Essential Sydney Cafes and Bakeries of 2025: Best Market Stall See all stories. Previous SlideNext Slide Cafe$$$$ This is the transient outpost of Seven Hills cafe Elevate Specialty Coffee, where baristas are serious about Australian-roasted single origins. It's parked among the mirrored glass office blocks of Blacktown's CBD, offering workers a welcome alternative to the national chains dominating the nearby shopping centre. Sandwiches (like the pickle-heavy, pastrami-packed Reuben) are toasted to order and most pastries are made in-house. Good to know: After a mid-afternoon snack? Chances are you might get a discount.
Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
When Aussies will get faster internet
Massive upgrades in internet speeds are now just 100 days away for Australian households. From September, government-owned telecommunications company NBN, which supplies internet providers like Telstra and Optus with the physical infrastructure that connects households to the internet, will deliver massive upgrades to its network speeds. The accelerated, high-speed wholesale products will be available to providers to sell to eligible residential and business customers connected to the NBN network via fibre to the premises or hybrid fibre coaxial options. The Home Fast package will increase speeds from 100/20Mbps to 500/50Mbps, delivering a five times improvement in downloads and 2.5 times faster uploads. The Superfast package will increase speeds from 250/25Mbps to 750/50 Mbps, while Ultrafast will double upload speeds from 50Mbps to 100Mbps. The Hyperfast offering will deliver 'blazing-fast speeds for top-tier connections', with 2000/200Mbps (on fibre to the premises) and 2000/100Mbps (on hybrid fibre coaxial). It is expected Hyperfast will be sold to retailers for a wholesale price of $115 per month. More Australian households are connecting multiple devices to the internet. Supplied Credit: News Corp Australia Customers who purchased one of these higher speed tiers, or choose to upgrade, would automatically accelerate to the new, faster speeds when the plans were made available by the retailers, the company said. NBN general manager Jane McNamara said the speed changes would 'future proof' Australia as the world moved online. 'Back in 2015, the typical Australian home had two or three internet-connected devices,' she said on Friday. 'Today, the average number is about 25 and includes devices like smart phones, laptops, TVs and smart speakers, all of which need the internet to work. 'With people in Australia averaging more than 6½ hours a day online, streaming and gaming more than ever before, the number of connected devices (is) expected to rise to more than 44 by the end of this decade.' But the company has warned that the technological boost will only be available to certain households. 'Higher speed plans are only available on NBN's fibre to the premises and hybrid fibre Coaxial technologies,' it said. 'Check your address to see if higher speed plans are available at your place, and for those customers on fibre to the node or fibre to the kerb, whether you are eligible for a fibre upgrade.' An upside-down modem. The NBN says simple adjustments to a home's set-up can impact speeds. Supplied Credit: News Corp Australia Some households might need to upgrade their home equipment to make the most of the new speeds, the company added, and simple adjustments to a home's set-up, such as how modems and routers are placed, could also impact speed. 'Many objects and materials in the home can reflect or absorb your wi-fi signal, either slowing the speed as they pass through or blocking it altogether,' the company said. 'Metal doors, appliances, mirrors, solid walls, floors, and ceilings can significantly reduce signal efficiency and effective distance. 'Interior walls, furniture and even windows can do the same but to a lesser degree. 'Liquids, like those in fish tanks, fridges, hot water systems and even bottles can absorb wi-fi signal, preventing it from reaching your devices. 'Other technology, including radios, baby monitors, microwave ovens, Bluetooth devices, use signals that can interfere with your wi-fi.' The NBN advises to keep wi-fi routers out in the open.
West Australian
4 hours ago
- West Australian
100 days to go before massive NBN internet speed upgrade for Australians
Massive upgrades in internet speeds are now just 100 days away for Australian households. From September, government-owned telecommunications company NBN, which supplies internet providers like Telstra and Optus with the physical infrastructure that connects households to the internet, will deliver massive upgrades to its network speeds. The accelerated, high-speed wholesale products will be available to providers to sell to eligible residential and business customers connected to the NBN network via fibre to the premises or hybrid fibre coaxial options. The Home Fast package will increase speeds from 100/20Mbps to 500/50Mbps, delivering a five times improvement in downloads and 2.5 times faster uploads. The Superfast package will increase speeds from 250/25Mbps to 750/50 Mbps, while Ultrafast will double upload speeds from 50Mbps to 100Mbps. The Hyperfast offering will deliver 'blazing-fast speeds for top-tier connections', with 2000/200Mbps (on fibre to the premises) and 2000/100Mbps (on hybrid fibre coaxial). It is expected Hyperfast will be sold to retailers for a wholesale price of $115 per month. Customers who purchased one of these higher speed tiers, or choose to upgrade, would automatically accelerate to the new, faster speeds when the plans were made available by the retailers, the company said. NBN general manager Jane McNamara said the speed changes would 'future proof' Australia as the world moved online. 'Back in 2015, the typical Australian home had two or three internet-connected devices,' she said on Friday. 'Today, the average number is about 25 and includes devices like smart phones, laptops, TVs and smart speakers, all of which need the internet to work. 'With people in Australia averaging more than 6½ hours a day online, streaming and gaming more than ever before, the number of connected devices (is) expected to rise to more than 44 by the end of this decade.' But the company has warned that the technological boost will only be available to certain households. 'Higher speed plans are only available on NBN's fibre to the premises and hybrid fibre Coaxial technologies,' it said. 'Check your address to see if higher speed plans are available at your place, and for those customers on fibre to the node or fibre to the kerb, whether you are eligible for a fibre upgrade.' Some households might need to upgrade their home equipment to make the most of the new speeds, the company added, and simple adjustments to a home's set-up, such as how modems and routers are placed, could also impact speed. 'Many objects and materials in the home can reflect or absorb your wi-fi signal, either slowing the speed as they pass through or blocking it altogether,' the company said. 'Metal doors, appliances, mirrors, solid walls, floors, and ceilings can significantly reduce signal efficiency and effective distance. 'Interior walls, furniture and even windows can do the same but to a lesser degree. 'Liquids, like those in fish tanks, fridges, hot water systems and even bottles can absorb wi-fi signal, preventing it from reaching your devices. 'Other technology, including radios, baby monitors, microwave ovens, Bluetooth devices, use signals that can interfere with your wi-fi.' The NBN advises to keep wi-fi routers out in the open.
