Former N.S. school principal acquitted in historical sexual assault case
A former Halifax-area elementary school principal has been acquitted in a historical sexual assault case.
Judge Alanna Murphy announced her decision in the matter of Steve Hutchins in a provincial courtroom in Dartmouth, N.S. on Tuesday.
Hutchins, 60, was found not guilty in relation to one count each of sexual assault and sexual interference for offences alleged to have occurred in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
"I cannot be satisfied to the degree that I need to be to make a finding of guilt and consequently it would be dangerous for me to make findings of guilt in relation to the two counts before the court," Murphy told the court.
A woman, now 43, alleged Hutchins assaulted her when she was attending grades 3 to 6 at elementary schools in the Eastern Passage area where Hutchins was a gym teacher.
A trial was held over three days in March.
The woman, whose identity is protected by a publication ban, testified Hutchins would hold her in tight embraces in supply rooms adjacent to the gyms in the schools, or sometimes in Hutchins's office.
Hutchins denied all of the complainant's allegations while under questioning by his lawyer, Don Murray.
During his testimony, Hutchins used photographs and hand-drawn floor plans to demonstrate the layout of the schools to suggest the sort of encounters the woman described would not have been possible.
"I cannot say that the complainant's evidence was so persuasive and compelling that it rendered Mr. Hutchins's evidence unbelievable," Murphy said while delivering her decision.
"I can say that at the very least his evidence has left me with reasonable doubt," she said.
Murray declined a request from CBC News for a comment from his client.
Acquitted in separate case
Hutchins was also acquitted in a different historical sexual assault case last fall.
In a separate incident, a woman accused him of giving her an open-mouthed kiss and touching her body at a social function at a home in Hammonds Plains when she was 14.
The woman said she did not go to police until stories surfaced about charges laid against Hutchins involving another woman.
The judge in that case said while she found the complainant's testimony to be credible, she was left with some doubt and so had to acquit Hutchins.
MORE TOP STORIES
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Three-year-old boy dies after being hit in Halifax crosswalk by vehicle
HALIFAX — Police in Halifax say a toddler has died after he was hit by a vehicle Friday night, not far from the city's downtown. Officers say they were called to a crash involving a pedestrian along a street in Bedford, a neighbourhood north of downtown Halifax. They say a three-year-old boy was crossing the street when he was hit by the vehicle. Paramedics took the boy to hospital, where he died of his injuries. Halifax police say they're sending condolences to the boy's family and they thank witnesses and bystanders who remained at the scene. Investigators say no charges have been laid and an investigation is ongoing. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 20, 2025. The Canadian Press
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Squatter fatally shoots roommate over $250 rent feud: ‘Going to kill them all'
A squatter allegedly shot and killed his roommate after he was asked to pay just $250 in rent — shouting 'I'm going to kill them all,' as he marched towards the house, according to law enforcement officials. Angel Gomez Montanez, 21, paid no rent at a home outside of Houston, Texas, for over three months when his roommate Christopher Rodriguez Lara, 18, asked the delinquent to pony-up the paltry sum, KTRK reported. Angel Gomez Montanez, 21, allegedly shot and killed his roommate for asking for his portion of the rent — a paltry $250. Law and Crime The two got into an argument and then Montanez left the shared home with his belongings — only to return on June 12, saying he had the $250 for rent. Montanez insisted on handing the dough directly to the 18-year-old — and when Lara stepped outside, Montanez allegedly shot him on the spot and fled. A 9-year-old witness armed with a rock chased Montanez away, but hid when the crazed alleged gunman started walking back towards the home, the Charlotte Observer reported. 'I'm going to kill all of them,' Montanez said, the 9-year-old told investigators, according to that report. Montanez allegedly fired one more shot that investigators believe was aimed at Lara's brother. A bullet hole in the siding of the Houston-area home. ABC 7 'The only thing we told him is we needed the money for rent,' Zulekya Ortiz, who said Montanez had been living in her family home for the three months span, told the outlet. 'He was the happiness in this home,' Ortiz said of Lara, her brother-in-law. 'My children loved him.' Montanez was arrested on June 15 and is being charged with murder, according to the Harris County Sheriff's Office.
Miami Herald
11 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Doctor posted couple's decapitated baby online, suit says. GA jury awards $2.25M
A 12-person jury awarded $2.25 million to the parents of a newborn who was decapitated at birth, ruling against an Atlanta-area doctor they hired for an autopsy, according to their attorneys. Jessica Ross and Treveon Isaiah Taylor paid Dr. Jackson Gates $2,500 for a postmortem exam of their son, 'Baby Isaiah,' after he died July 9, 2023, according to civil court filings previously reviewed by McClatchy News. Nearly two months later, they sued Gates, saying he took videos of their newborn's body without permission and shared the graphic content online to his Instagram account. The couple horrifically lost Baby Isaiah when the newborn was decapitated by another doctor at Southern Regional Medical Center in Clayton County, according to a separate lawsuit they filed against Ross' obstetrician. The doctor, Tracey St. Julian, was accused of applying too much force on the baby's head and neck during the delivery, resulting in decapitation. Ross and Taylor were heartbroken, then were outraged upon learning Gates shared autopsy videos online of their baby, according to a complaint they filed in Fulton County Court. The case went to trial this week, according to the couple's attorneys, Shofaetiyah Watson of The Edmond Firm and Cory J. Lynch of The Law Firm of Cory J. Lynch, LLC. On the third day of trial, June 18, the jury awarded $2 million in compensatory damages to Ross and Taylor, as well as $250,000, the highest amount possible, in punitive damages, their legal counsel said in a news release. 'While we are pleased that a jury punished Dr. Jackson Gates for his reprehensible behavior, nothing can ease the pain that the parents, Jessica Ross and Treveon Isaiah Taylor, Sr., have experienced in losing their baby boy in such a horrific way,' Watson and Lynch said in a joint statement. 'This young couple trusted him with the remains of their precious baby,' they added. 'Gates, in turn, repaid this trust by posting horrific images of their child for the world to see.' Gates did not immediately return McClatchy News' request for comment June 20. The pathologist and primary care doctor has a practice in Conyers, about a 25-mile drive southeast from Atlanta. With their lawsuit, Taylor and Ross accused Gates of invasion of privacy, intentional infliction of emotional distress and fraud, their attorneys said. When they initially sued him, Gates defended himself in a video he shared to Instagram, saying anything he posted online was for educational purposes, WAGA-TV reported in September 2023. Gates was accused of uploading footage of the baby's autopsy a second time, after taking the videos down in response to a cease-and-desist letter sent to him on the couple's behalf, according to their attorneys. 'Gates initially removed the videos but inexplicably reposted them, even after being informed of the parents' emotional pain resulting from the initial posts,' the release said. Death ruled a homicide In February 2024, the Clayton County Medical Examiner's Office announced the baby's death was ruled a homicide, McClatchy News reported. At the time, the medical examiner's office's director, Brian Byars, told McClatchy News in a phone interview that the baby's head was 'completely separated from the body.' During delivery, the newborn's head became stuck in the vaginal canal in a complicated medical event known as shoulder dystocia, according to Taylor and Ross' lawsuit against St. Julian and Southern Regional Medical Center. That case is ongoing, their legal counsel said. Southern Regional Medical Center denied the accusations involving the facility in a September 2023 statement previously shared with McClatchy News. When the parents sued the hospital and St. Julian, the couple said both parties tried to hide the fact that their baby was decapitated, discouraged them from having an autopsy performed and encouraged them to cremate their son's body. As for the case against Gates, the couple's attorneys said their 'goal was to ensure that Gates was held accountable for his unconscionable lack of empathy and invasion of our clients' privacy.' 'We thank the jury for helping us accomplish that objective,' they added.
