US judge invalidates Biden rule protecting privacy for abortions
The rule prohibits healthcare providers and insurers from giving information about a legal abortion. PHOTO: AFP
TEXAS - A federal judge on June 18 struck down a rule adopted by the administration of former President Joe Biden that strengthened privacy protections for women seeking abortions and patients who receive gender transition treatments.
US District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk in Amarillo, Texas, said the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) exceeded its powers and unlawfully limited states' ability to enforce their public health laws when it adopted the rule in 2024.
The rule prohibits healthcare providers and insurers from giving information about a legal abortion to state law enforcement authorities who are seeking to punish someone in connection with that abortion.
'HHS lacked clear delegated authority to fashion special protections for medical information produced by politically favored medical procedures,' wrote Mr Kacsmaryk, who was appointed by President Donald Trump, a Republican, during his first term.
Mr Kacsmaryk in December 2024 had blocked HHS from enforcing the rule against a Texas doctor who had brought the lawsuit, Ms Carmen Purl, pending the outcome of the case. June 18's decision blocks the rule nationwide.
HHS did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Ms Purl is represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian legal group. Mr Matt Bowman, senior counsel with the group, praised the decision in a statement, saying the 2024 rule 'would have weaponised laws about privacy that have nothing to do with abortion or gender identity'.
The Biden administration issued the rule as part of its pledge to support access to reproductive healthcare after the conservative-majority US Supreme Court in 2022 overturned the 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling that made access to abortion a constitutional right nationwide.
It came in response to efforts by authorities in some Republican-led states that ban abortion, including Texas, to restrict out-of-state travel for abortion.
Texas has filed a separate lawsuit challenging the rule, which is pending in federal court in Lubbock, Texas. HHS in a court filing last month said agency leadership appointed by Mr Trump is evaluating its position in this case.
Mr Biden, a Democrat, said in announcing the rule that no one should have their medical records 'used against them, their doctor, or their loved one just because they sought or received lawful reproductive health care'. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
29 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Thailand summons Cambodia envoy over crisis-causing audio leak
Royalist activists take part in an anti-government protest near the Government House, in Bangkok, Thailand, following the leaked call. PHOTO: REUTERS Bangkok - Thailand summoned the Cambodian ambassador on June 19 to deliver a missive saying it was 'deeply disappointed' about the leak of a diplomatic phone call which has sparked a political crisis in Bangkok. Thai Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra has lost the backing of a key coalition partner who accused her of being deferential and denigrating her nation's army in a call with former Cambodian leader Hun Sen. In the call, Ms Paetongtarn discusses an ongoing border dispute with the Cambodian statesman, referring to him as 'uncle' and describing a Thai army commander overseeing the border region as her opponent. Without the backing of her largest partner Ms Paetongtarn is left with only a slim parliamentary majority, while the other parties which voted her into office are due to hold emergency summits later on June 19. Thai foreign ministry spokesman Nikorndej Balankura told reporters the Cambodian ambassador was summoned around 11am and handed a 'protest letter' over the leaked call on June 15. 'This action taken by the Cambodian side is totally unacceptable. It breaches diplomatic etiquette, is a serious violation of trust and undermines relations between the neighbouring countries,' he said. The letter read: 'The Royal Thai Government is deeply disappointed that the private telephone conversation between the Thai Prime Minister and the senior figure from Cambodia was leaked.' Mr Hun Sen – who still wields considerable influence and whose son Hun Manet is Cambodia's current leader – has said the audio was recorded 'for the sake of transparency' and it was possibly leaked by someone who 'disapproved of the Thai Prime Minister'. An area known as the Emerald Triangle – where the borders of Cambodia, Thailand and Laos meet – has long been disputed by Phnom Penh and Bangkok. The row boiled over on May 28 when troops exchanged fire and one Cambodian soldier was killed. Ms Paetongtarn on June 19 apologised for the leaked audio in a press conference where she appeared flanked by high-ranking military officials. Thailand's military has staged a dozen coups over the past century and the military remain immensely powerful while most politicians avoid antagonising them. 'My intention was to help stabilise the situation and I never expected the conversation to be leaked,' she said. 'Moving forward, I will be more cautious with my negotiating approach.' AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
29 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Paetongtarn Shinawatra, Thailand's prime minister, under siege
Since Paetongtarn Shinawatra became prime minister August 2024, she has struggled to deliver on her party's promises. PHOTO: AFP BANGKOK - After less than a year in office, Thailand's Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra has her back to the wall - and little room left to manoeuvre. For months, the 38-year-old - the second woman and the youngest Thai to hold the position - has grappled with a faltering economy that has stalled her Pheu Thai party's flagship economic scheme while coping with an unwieldy ruling coalition. But the leaked audio of a phone call with Cambodia's former leader Hun Sen, after weeks of bickering between the two South-east Asian neighbours over a disputed border, could be the final blow to her 10-month term. 'Paetongtarn is untenable now,' said Dr Thitinan Pongsudhirak, a political scientist at Bangkok's Chulalongkorn University. 'The leaked conversation is deeply compromising to her position as prime minister and deeply damaging for Thailand. I think there's no way she's going to last.' In her June 15 call with Mr Hun Sen, who she referred to as 'uncle', Ms Paetongtarn not only appeared to kowtow before the veteran Cambodian politician but also denigrated a senior Thai military commander - seen as red lines by her critics and allies alike. Facing an unprecedented backlash, Ms Paetongtarn - a political novice who held no government position before becoming premier - delivered a public apology on June 19 , insisting that she did not know the call with Mr Hun Sen would be recorded. 'This was a private call from my personal phone,' she told reporters. But it came after the conservative Bhumjaithai party - the third largest in parliament's Lower House - pulled out of the ruling coalition late on June 18 , citing the audio of the call, which was released in full by Mr Hun Sen after the initial leak of a clip. The Pheu Thai party now only holds a narrow majority in Thailand's 495-member parliament, and the exit of some other coalition partners, some of which are due to hold individual meetings to decide their respective positions, could swiftly bring down the government. Thailand's main opposition, the People's Party, underlined the lack of public trust in Ms Paetongtarn on June 19 and called on the government to dissolve parliament, which would trigger fresh elections. 'Paetongtarn needs to take responsibility for what has happened,' said Dr Pavin Chachavalpongpun, a Thai academic at Japan's Kyoto University, referring to the audio in which she described a prominent Thai army commander as being part of 'the opposite side'. 'She may not trust the army. But she should not be telling this to foreign leaders.' Brand Shinawatra Ms Paetongtarn, educated at Chulalongkorn University and Britain's University of Surrey, was primarily involved in the Shinawatra family businesses before becoming prime minister but has spent much of her life exposed to the tumult of Thai politics. She was eight when her father, Mr Thaksin Shinawatra, entered politics in 1994 and began a meteoric rise to become prime minister by a landslide in 2001 - only to be ousted in a coup five years later. In 2011, her aunt and Mr Thaksin's sister, Ms Yingluck, also found her way to the premiership but was ejected by a court ruling, followed by a military coup. On the campaign trail in 2023, seeking to resuscitate her family's political fortune, Ms Paetongtarn harked back to the track record of previous Shinawatra administrations and promised robust government policies to kick-start South-east Asia's second largest economy. Ms Paetongtarn, who is married with two children, also made no bones about her closeness to her father, Thailand's most influential but divisive politician who returned to the country in 2023 after over a decade-and-a-half in self-exile to avoid a prison term. Since she became prime minister August 2024 , following the abrupt removal of her predecessor by a court order, Ms Paetongtarn has struggled to deliver on her party's promises, even as she operated under the long shadow of her father, who is himself facing court cases that could see him return to prison. In particular, a decision last month to freeze a US$14 billion (S$18 billion) cash handout programme, a key plank in the 2023 election, in the face of potential US tariffs has hit Pheu Thai's popularity. But this crisis will likely damage the party's standing further, making it even more challenging to head into fresh polls, according to analysts. A snap election, however, may not be amenable to some current and former members of the ruling coalition, including Bhumjaithai, and instead favour the People's Party, said Mr Olarn Thinbangtieo, a political science lecturer at Burapha University. 'This is more about pressuring the prime minister to resign than dissolving parliament,' said Mr Olarn, outlining the possibility of parliament picking Bhumjaithai's leader Anutin Charnvirakul to replace Ms Paetongtarn. Move Forward, a forerunner of the People's Party, won most seats in the 2023 election but was blocked from taking power by an unelected senate, paving the way for second-place Pheu Thai to cobble together a coalition and form a government. Still, there is a possibility that Pheu Thai can engineer a survival strategy to retain power, but Ms Paetongtarn's actions may also determine the future of Thailand's most prominent political dynasty. 'This could be the end of the Shinawatra brand,' said Chulalongkorn University's Dr Thitinan. 'She has really damaged it.' REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Business Times
37 minutes ago
- Business Times
Malaysia sues Telegram over alleged malicious content
[KUALA LUMPUR] Malaysia said Thursday (Jun 19) it had filed a civil suit against social network Telegram for allegedly disseminating content that could erode trust in public institutions and threaten social order. This is the first such legal action taken against a social media platform in the country, the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC), which filed the suit, said in a statement. Two local Telegram channels, Edisi Siasat and Edisi Khas, were 'found to have published content that violated provisions under the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998', MCMC said. It accused Telegram of a 'serious failure to address content that has repeatedly been reported to them, despite various negotiation efforts by MCMC'. The commission did not give details about the civil suit or the allegedly malicious content. But it said the High Court had issued an injunction to stop the spread of the alleged offensive material and prevent similar content from being published. 'Telegram will be given appropriate space to present its defence in accordance with the principles of justice and human rights,' the commission said. MCMC also warned that authorities would not hesitate to take similar action against other providers, adding that all social media platforms have a social responsibility to ensure that their content does not violate Malaysian laws. Telegram officials were not immediately available for comment. AFP
