Federal vs. private student loans: What borrowers should know
Many student loan borrowers may not realize how different federal and private loans can be when it comes to repayment.
Student Loan Servicing Alliance executive director Scott Buchanan explains what to know about repayment plans, budgeting strategies, and how to handle loans in default.
To watch more expert insights and analysis on the latest market action, check out more Wealth here.
While student loans offer a grace period for repayment, you will usually eventually have to pay them back. Yeah. All week, we're giving you everything that you need to know about paying back this money. And today, we're breaking down the difference between paying off federal and private student loans. For that, we have Scott Buchanan, who's the Student Loan Servicing Alliance Executive Director. Scott, good to have you here with us. So let's start by explaining the difference between federal and private loans.
Yeah. Thanks, Brad, for having me. Um, yeah, the difference is primarily is who is the lender. Um, federal student loans are lent directly by the federal government using money from Treasury. And private education loans are generally made by banks or other financial institutions, um, using sort of a private credit. Um, they're very similar in private education loans to other consumer credit like credit cards or mortgages or things like that where there are there's a test of credit worthiness, um, that that the lender will make. Um, as opposed to the federal student loan program where generally, it's a federal entitlement, and so if you're going to school have filled out the FAFSA, then you're entitled to get those loans.
How should borrowers approach federal loans?
Listen, federal loans are incredibly flexible in terms of your repayment options. You need to know what kind of loan you have. Do you have a unsubsidized loan? Do you have a plus loan or things like that, um, because they can have different benefits. But there's a lot of options, including forbearances, deferments, income-driven repayment plans, um, that can all dramatically adjust your monthly payment amount. Um, so something you need to always look at is the total balance of your loans and thinking about even when you're in school and thinking about potential repayment, remember you're going to have to borrow the course of two or four years. Um, and think about that in your repayment options.
What about private loans? When should borrowers consider applying for them?
Listen, you should always apply for these loans as early as possible. Once you get your federal financial aid award letter from your institution, talk to the financial aid office. Make sure you've maximized any institutional aid, um, that you can possibly get that would reduce the amount you have to borrow. Figure out how much federal loan ability you have, and then determine what your gap is going to be because the federal loans may not cover all your costs, and that's when you might turn to private education loans. And doing so earlier is better because you can shop around on private education loans and find a lender, um, who's got the best offering for you in terms of an APR, um, and the best sort of program options that are available under that loan.
So what should the plan of attack be for repayment?
Yeah. Well, listen, make a budget like all financial things. Um, you need to know in advance, like that's sort of the advantage of of of, you know, sort of going to school and having this period of time generally when we don't have to make repayment. You have plenty of time to put together sort of what your plan of action is going to be when you graduate and leave. Um, so, you know, number one, don't overborrow in the first place, as I always say. Um, but if you have already borrowed, um, then make sure that you sit down, figure out each monthly payment that you're going to have, the differences between your federal and your private loans because they're going to all have different monthly payments, different interest rates, um, and then put together a budget, a plan of action about how you're going to do it. If, remember, when you first graduate, your income is likely to be a lot lower than it will be in the future, that's when you need to talk to your federal loan servicer and say, hey, here's my financial situation on the federal student loans. How can I lower my monthly payment or how can I meet this this budget that I have today? And they're going to have a lot more options, whereas on the private loan side of things, um, it's going to be relatively set about the monthly payment.
If your loan has gone into default, what are the steps that you should start to take to make sure that you get back into good standing?
Yeah. Well, that's very different between federal and private loans as well. But on the federal student loan, um, once you reach 270 days delinquent, your loan can go into default. And that's when you need to call the Default Resolution Group at the Department of Education. Um, they will reach out and let you know that you're in default, and your servicer will as well. Um, but that's who you need to talk to. There are lots of options, including rehabilitating the loan, potentially consolidating the loan, um, because getting out of default, um, is something that you definitely want to do. And that's why loan rehabilitation would probably be your best bet on federal student loans because that removes that default from your credit history. On private education loans, it's different, and that's why you need to be very mindful about keeping on top of those private education loans because once they go into default and charge off, there's not a whole lot you can do other than sort of negotiate a settlement or potentially a repayment plan, um, to try to resolve the total amount of that debt.
And so once you have finally gotten to the point where you've fully paid off your student loans, then at that point, how are you kind of able to take advantage of other tax advantages as well that you should be making sure that you're also reporting?
Sure, absolutely. Uh, there's a there's a federal interest deduction on on student loans that you can take advantage of potentially. Now, that is tied to income. Um, so, you know, the higher income you are, the less likely are you to be able to take that benefit. But you should definitely during all of your repayment make sure that you're uh that you're uh as you're doing it in TurboTax or working with your accountant, make sure that you calculate the amount of interest that you pay. You'll get a statement from your loan servicer, just like you get W-2s and other things, um, from uh from your employer, and they will tell you how much interest may be eligible, and you should definitely take advantage of that.
Scott, thanks so much for taking the time and breaking this all down.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Nasdaq, S&P 500 close higher on trade hopes
Both the Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC) and S&P 500 (^GSPC) closed slightly higher on Monday; the Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) was flat. Trade talks between the US and China have investors hopeful that a deal could be struck between the two nations. Learn more about today's trading in the video above. To watch more expert insights and analysis on the latest market action, check out more Market Domination Overtime here. And it looks like things are taken a little bit of a leg lower as we, uh, close out today's session, this Monday session, the Dow now down about a point, little changed on the day here. After starting the day in the red, it's kind of made a round trip here. Uh, not necessarily any specific headlines in the last hour that necessarily would have sent things in this direction, but we're seeing it for all three major averages. The S&P 500 also heading back to the unchanged line. The Nasdaq hanging on to a gain of a third of 1%. And it is the least sort of, even though we've seen some intraday volatility here, uh, sort of the most stable by comparison between positive and negative during the session. In terms of the trade headlines that we continue to watch out of the US-China talks happening in the UK, um, it looks like they have concluded for the evening. And Treasury Secretary Benson was quoted as saying that things are going relatively well so far. That said, not seeing any big enthusiasm today. Jared's got a closer look at the action here, Jared. Yes, not a lot of big movement in the majors today. Although, I will pull up the S&P 600, which is the small caps. This is a two-day look. We've had decent pops both days and the result is up 2.17%. I'll show you the quick year-to-date and we are still trying to break out. We have just ever so slightly broken out, but, uh, not definitive just yet. And, uh, in the meantime, I've been tracking volatility. The VIX was up ever so slightly today. Let's put the two-day view on that as well. Uh, but not by very much. And then the bond market, I was watching the 30-year in particular. That's going to come into focus this week as we have about 120 billion plus in, uh, auctions from the Treasury here. And that has closed the day at 4.95%. So, those are going to be closely watched at 1:00 p.m., Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. And then, of course, Wednesday we got that big CPI announcement before the market opens. Here is the sector action. Let's dial that up. And we got consumer discretionary in the lead followed by materials and then tech, that's XLK, then XLE, which is energy. All four of these outperforming the S&P 500. Everything else in the red there, uh, led to the downside by utilities and then financials. And if we take a look inside the Nasdaq 100, mixed board. We got Tesla up 4.5% and I'll show you, let's take a look at the three-day. And that's going to show us still down 7% after that huge drop that we saw last Thursday. So, haven't quite, uh, clawed all that back, but we've been up two days in a row there. Apple down 1.21% after some news, uh, after the latest about its, uh, plans for the future, its devices, services, etc. Meta also down on the day. And let's close here with the Dow. Dow is looking pretty similar to the Nasdaq in terms of the mix between green and blue. Uh, an outlier here, Boeing to the upside in the lower right. That's up about 3.17%. As well as Caterpillar. So, two industrials. And for that matter, Boeing and defense stock. Defense has been on fire. Defense and aerospace.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
The five considerable problems with the chancellor's U-turn on winter fuel payments
There are considerable problems with the winter fuel payment U-turn, but perhaps the political argument in favour outweighs them all? First, Rachel Reeves has executed without working out how to pay for it. This, for an iron chancellor, is a wound that opponents won't let her forget. A summer of speculation about tax rises is not a summer anyone looks forward to. Politics latest: Second, the fig leaf that she and Treasury ministers are using is an improvement in economic conditions. If you were being polite, you'd say this is contested. The OBR halved growth this year and the OECD downgraded UK forecasts, albeit only by a little, last week. The claim that interest rates are coming down ignores that their descent is slower because of government decisions of the last six months. Third, the question immediately becomes, what next? Why not personal independent payments (PIP) and the two-child benefit cap? At this stage, it would feel like a climbdown if they did not back down over those. But then, what will the markets - already policing this closely - make of it, and could they punish the government? Fourth, this is aggravating divisions in the Parliamentary Labour Party: the soft left Compass group and ministers like Torsten Bell pushing bigger spending arguments. Those MPs in Tory-facing seats who rely on arguments that Labour can be trusted with the public finances are this has created a firm division between No 10 (the PM) and No 11 (the Chancellor). No 10 is now conscious that it does not have enough independent advice about the market reaction to economic policies and is seeking to correct. Others, I am told, are just critical of the chancellor's U-turn - for she wobbled first. Read more: Given the litany of arguments against, why has it happened? Because the hope is this maxi U-turn lances the boil, removes a significant source of pensioners' anger and brings back Labour voters, a price they calculate worth paying, whatever the fiscal cost. We wait to see who is right.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
QQQ Attracts $2.4B in Assets as S 500 Hits 6,000
The Invesco QQQ Trust (QQQ) pulled in $2.4 billion on Friday, boosting its assets under management to over $338 billion, according to data provided by FactSet. The inflows came as the S&P 500 surged 1% to touch 6,000 for the first time since February after nonfarm payrolls rose 139,000 in May, beating the 125,000 forecast. The SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF (SPLG) attracted $707.9 million, while the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV) gained $506.4 million. The Communication Services Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLC) collected $199.7 million, and the iShares MSCI South Korea ETF (EWY) pulled in $194.4 million. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) saw outflows of $2.6 billion despite the market rally. The iShares Russell 2000 ETF (IWM) lost $719.3 million, while the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT) experienced outflows of $639.5 million. U.S. fixed-income ETFs collected $93.7 million in net inflows, while international fixed-income ETFs gained $643.8 million. International equity ETFs attracted $567.2 million, and commodities ETFs pulled in $93.4 million. Overall, ETFs gained $867.6 million for the day. Ticker Name Net Flows ($, mm) AUM ($, mm) AUM % Change QQQ Invesco QQQ Trust Series I 2,413.30 338,098.45 0.71% SPLG SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF 707.92 68,556.62 1.03% IVV iShares Core S&P 500 ETF 506.43 585,200.21 0.09% XLC Communication Services Select Sector SPDR Fund 199.71 22,546.69 0.89% SGOV iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF 195.79 48,340.78 0.41% AGG iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF 195.57 125,516.57 0.16% EWY iShares MSCI South Korea ETF 194.35 3,725.06 5.22% SOXS Direxion Daily Semiconductor Bear 3x Shares 192.30 1,239.05 15.52% QQQM Invesco NASDAQ 100 ETF 185.77 49,210.71 0.38% BWZ SPDR Bloomberg Short Term International Treasury Bond ETF 149.28 497.62 30.00% Ticker Name Net Flows ($, mm) AUM ($, mm) AUM % Change SPY SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust -2,549.65 603,603.42 -0.42% IWM iShares Russell 2000 ETF -719.29 61,129.39 -1.18% TLT iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF -639.47 49,213.59 -1.30% RSP Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF -419.90 70,979.92 -0.59% LQD iShares iBoxx $ Investment Grade Corporate Bond ETF -419.44 29,790.99 -1.41% TQQQ ProShares UltraPro QQQ -292.10 24,424.96 -1.20% XLF Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund -278.62 48,781.08 -0.57% SMH VanEck Semiconductor ETF -226.14 23,402.96 -0.97% SOXL Direxion Daily Semiconductor Bull 3x Shares -209.89 11,811.12 -1.78% JEPQ JPMorgan NASDAQ Equity Premium Income ETF -174.06 26,169.77 -0.67% Net Flows ($, mm) AUM ($, mm) % of AUM Alternatives -1.74 10,017.55 -0.02% Asset Allocation -10.63 24,953.68 -0.04% Commodities ETFs 93.38 217,648.75 0.04% Currency -235.21 138,757.69 -0.17% International Equity 567.15 1,811,464.90 0.03% International Fixed Income 643.79 293,245.40 0.22% Inverse 254.60 15,135.29 1.68% Leveraged -590.19 118,340.82 -0.50% US Equity 52.73 6,824,072.08 0.00% US Fixed Income 93.71 1,666,330.59 0.01% Total: 867.60 11,119,966.76 0.01% Disclaimer: All data as of 6 a.m. Eastern time the date the article is published. Data are believed to be accurate; however, transient market data are often subject to subsequent revision and correction by the | © Copyright 2025 All rights reserved