No 'Cheers' In Gujarat High Court
The incident occurred before Justice Sandeep Bhatt on June 26, when Tanna was seen drinking from what appeared to be a beer mug while on a phone call. A video clip of the incident is now circulating widely on social media.
Just a week earlier, another video went viral showing a man attending a High Court hearing virtually-while sitting on a toilet.
These recurring instances raise uncomfortable questions: In an era when virtual courts are meant to facilitate speedier justice, do such incidents trivialise the institution and erode the decorum it demands?
The Virtual Reality
A division bench of Justices A.S. Supehia and R.T. Vachhani has questioned whether Tanna should retain his senior counsel status, given his "outrageous and glaring" conduct. The court will take further action after a hearing in two weeks. The bench rightly noted that such behaviour has "wide and serious ramifications" for the judicial system and the rule of law.
Virtual hearings, introduced during the COVID-19 pandemic, have brought with them their own set of challenges-and embarrassments.
Like physical courtrooms, virtual sessions require all participants to maintain dignity. Any lapse undermines the decorum courts stand for. The image of a man relieving himself with the camera on, even if inadvertently, is deeply disturbing.
Courts were quick to adapt during the pandemic, but virtual hearings soon revealed lapses-from informality in dress to shocking behaviour. These episodes prompted the higher judiciary to stress that minimum courtroom etiquette must be observed-even online. Lawyers, in particular, are expected to appear presentable and ensure their surroundings are appropriate for court proceedings.
The Larger Issue
The 'beer incident' has sparked debate in legal circles about professionalism in the digital age. While sipping water during arguments is common, drinking beer during a live hearing-especially in a dry state like Gujarat-crosses a line. It reflects a troubling casualness toward judicial institutions.
"A person behaving inappropriately during a virtual hearing lowers the dignity of the court," said Gujarat High Court advocate Vijay Patel. "And when a senior advocate behaves this way, it sends an even worse message."
Court proceedings are streamed live, and recordings are accessible to students, junior lawyers, and the general public. Senior advocates serve as role models, and their conduct sets the tone for future generations. "Seniors are examples for juniors-this sets a bad precedent," Patel added. "This incident not only invites contempt charges but also merits disciplinary action."
Courts have laid down rules for decorum in virtual proceedings-including attire and behaviour. Gujarat's own High Court (Live Streaming of Court Proceedings) Rules, 2021, were cited in this case.
Also relevant is Gujarat's prohibition on alcohol. Residents can procure liquor only with health permits. While Tanna may have obtained beer legally, consuming it during a court session-even virtually-may invite strict judicial scrutiny.
Time for a Framework
With virtual hearings here to stay, the judiciary needs a clear, comprehensive legal framework to govern online proceedings. Judicial norms must be preserved not only in physical courtrooms but in every space where justice is delivered-even when no one appears to be watching.
The legal profession carries a legacy built on discipline, propriety, and public trust. It falls on all stakeholders-judges, lawyers, and litigants-to honour that legacy, online and offline.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
an hour ago
- United News of India
T&T PM Persad-Bissessar lauds PM Modi's compassion and solidarity during pandemic by sending vaccines
Port of Spain, July 4 (UNI) Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Kamala Persad-Bissessar has commended Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's compassion and solidarity during the Covid-19 pandemic, praising India's Vaccine Maitri initiative under which the tiny Caribbean nation received much-needed vaccines. 'When the Covid-19 pandemic brought the world to its knees, while some other countries were hoarding medical supplies, you ensured that vaccines and supplies reached even the smallest nations, including Trinidad and Tobago,' she said in an address at the Community Diaspora Event in honour of the Indian Prime Minister, held at the National Cycling Centre in Couva. This elicited sustained applause from the hundreds gathered in the audience. Reflecting on this, Persad-Bissessar continued, 'Through your benevolence, you brought hope and calm where there was fear. I say again, this was more than diplomacy; this was an act of kinship. 'This was an act of sheer humanity; this was an act of love, and this is one of the many reasons we are deeply proud to bestow upon you, Excellency, the Order of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago, our nation's highest honour.' That ceremony is scheduled to take place this morning at President's House, Port of Spain. On April 13, 2021, T&T received 40,000 doses of the Oxford/AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccines after Prime Minister Modi responded to a request for assistance from Port of Spain during a period when acquiring vaccines was particularly challenging. She told the audience that it was a 'profound honour to be graced' by one of the world's most esteemed and admired visionary leaders.'Your presence is a great inspiration to all of us, particularly to the Trinbago Indo community,' she said. Persad-Bissessar said the relationships between both nations go beyond time and distance, as she lauded Modi for positioning his country as 'a prominent and dominant global power through visionary and futuristic initiatives.' 'We bow to you, sir,' she said. She acknowledged his efforts in supporting the Indian diaspora and the common history shared by the two nations. 'The ties that bind India and T&T are ties of ancestors, kinship, sacrifice and love,' Persad-Bissessar said. 'We here are the grandchildren of Mother India, separated by oceans but united by love and respect. The ties that bind our two nations are truly unbreakable.' She asked that the two countries continue this journey together, as partners, as brothers, and as sisters. During her initial term as Prime Minister, Kamla Persad-Bissessar travelled to India in January 2012, in recognition of the historical and cultural connections between the two countries, which date back to the arrival of Indian indentured labourers to T&T in 1845. A significant aspect of her visit was her role as the Chief Guest at the Pravasi Bharatiya Divas (PBD) in Jaipur where she was honoured with the Pravasi Bharatiya Samman Award, acknowledging her contributions and the strong relationship she embodied between the Indian diaspora and their homeland. UNI RN
India Gazette
an hour ago
- India Gazette
PM Modi congratulates Trinidad and Tobago on adopting UPI
Port of Spain [Trinidad and Tobago], July 5 (ANI): Prime Minister Narendra Modi paid an official visit to Trinidad and Tobago from July 3-4 at the invitation of Kamla Persad-Bissessar, Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago. During his visit, the two countries expressed strong interest in expanding cooperation in the digital domain. PM Modi congratulated Trinidad and Tobago on being the first country in the Caribbean to adopt the Unified Payments Interface (UPI). 'The two countries expressed strong interest in expanding cooperation in the digital domain. Prime Minister Modi congratulated Trinidad and Tobago on becoming the first Caribbean country to adopt Unified Payments Interface (UPI), India's flagship digital payment platform. They agreed to explore further collaboration in the implementation of India Stack solutions, including DigiLocker, e-Sign, and the Government e-Marketplace (GeM). Trinidad and Tobago requested support from India in digitization and upgradation of the system for state land registration. The leaders also underlined that digital governance and public service delivery can act as enablers of inclusive development, innovation and national competitiveness,' the statement by the Ministry of External Affairs said. Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar commended India's leading role in saving precious human lives during the difficult times of COVID-19 pandemic. She appreciated India's quick response and valued supply of Covid vaccines and medical equipment to Trinidad and Tobago. She especially appreciated India's support under the USD 1 million 'HALT (High and Low Technology) in the COVID-19 project', with supply of mobile healthcare robots, telemedicine kits, and hand hygiene stations. PM Modi announced a gift of 2000 laptops to support Trinidad and Tobago's flagship educational programme. 'Prime Minister Modi lauded Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar's ambitious vision of digitizing education and announced a gift of 2000 laptops to support Trinidad and Tobago's flagship educational programme. Prime Minister Modi also encouraged the students of Trinidad and Tobago to explore higher educational opportunities in India under various scholarship programmes offered by the Government of India,' the statement said. The leaders identified agriculture and food security as another priority area. India's gift of agro-machinery worth USD 1 million for food processing and storage, to Trinidad and Tobago's National Agricultural Marketing and Development Corporation (NAMDEVCO) was appreciated. Prime Minister Modi, during a symbolic ceremony, handed over the first batch of machinery for NAMDEVCO. Prime Minister Modi also offered India's assistance in areas of natural farming, seaweed-based fertilizers, and millet cultivation, as per the statement. On healthcare, Prime Minister Modi commended the Government of Trinidad and Tobago for recognizing Indian Pharmacopoeia which will ensure closer collaboration in pharmaceutical sector and improved access for the people of Trinidad and Tobago to quality and affordable generic medicines from India as well as provision of medical treatment in India. 'He also announced that in the coming months, a prosthetic limb fitment camp for 800 individuals will be organized in Trinidad and Tobago. Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar thanked Prime Minister Modi for healthcare assistance which will take healthcare cooperation beyond medicines and equipments. She expressed Trinidad and Tobago's gratitude for the donation of twenty (20) Haemodialysis Units and two (2) Sea ambulances from the Government of India to assist in the provision of better-quality healthcare,' the statement said. Trinidad and Tobago underscored the value of development cooperation while welcoming the signing of a MoU on Quick Impact Projects, which will enable implementation of community development projects in Trinidad and Tobago in a timely and effective manner with India's assistance, the MEA statement said. (ANI)
Hans India
3 hours ago
- Hans India
BJP leader accuses CM of spreading fake news on Covid-19 vaccines
Bengaluru: BJP MP Lahar Singh Siroya on Friday accused Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah of spreading fake news with his recent remarks linking Covid-19 vaccines with a spate of heart attack deaths in the state's Hassan district, saying there is no vaccine against 'dissident' activities. The CM has suggested that the recent heart attack deaths in Hassan district may be linked to the vaccination drive. He also claimed the vaccines were 'hastily' approved. Taking a dig at Siddaramaiah, the BJP MP said that the Karnataka government has been speaking about tough legislation, including a seven-year jail term and fine, against the promotion and spread of fake news. 'At the rate at which Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has been speaking, I think someone will register the first complaint against him for spreading #fakenews on #Covid vaccines. The Union government has already clarified on this issue,' he said in a post on 'X'. According to him, the Congress' effort is to demoralise the scientific community, which saved millions of lives during the pandemic. 'I hope someone in the Congress cautions him (Siddaramaiah). Perhaps there is nobody left to caution him because nobody in his own High Command or locally think his government will survive for long. There is no vaccine against dissident activities,' Siroya said in the post.
