
Opinion: AISH clawback underscores Alberta's fraying social contract
But gratitude is not justice, and survival is not dignity.
Former premier Peter Lougheed once understood that. When he created the Assured Income for the Severely Handicapped (AISH), it was visionary, a bold commitment to lifting Albertans with disabilities out of poverty and away from the stigma of welfare. It was a moral promise, not just a budget line, to protect those who could not protect themselves — not out of pity, but out of principle.
That promise has been broken.
Today, AISH is framed as 'generous,' but only in the most cynical of comparisons. Alberta pays slightly more than other provinces, in a country where every disability program leaves people below the poverty line. Bragging about being the best of the worst is not a mark of excellence; it's a distraction.
The current rate of $1,902 per month sounds decent until you try to live on it in Calgary or Edmonton. After rent, utilities and food, most recipients are left choosing between medication and bus fare. This isn't generosity, it's slow deprivation, dressed in news releases.
And now, the Canada Disability Benefit, a long-awaited federal program meant to lift people out of poverty, is being clawed back by Alberta. AISH recipients are told to apply, only to have every federal dollar deducted from their provincial benefit. What should have been a turning point is instead a trap.
Alberta isn't supplementing, it's siphoning.
This is not how a just society behaves.
Justice means supporting people with disabilities not just in survival, but in well-being. It means recognizing that many want to work, but face unpredictable health conditions, chronic pain, PTSD or fatigue, which make conventional employment impossible. True justice offers flexibility, accommodation and stability, not punishment for failing to meet able-bodied expectations.
Yet, the myth persists that people with disabilities should be content with what they're given. That mere existence should be enough to inspire gratitude. It's a degrading expectation.
No one tells millionaires to be grateful for tax breaks. No one asks oil companies to be thankful for subsidies. But people with disabilities? They're told to smile while the social safety net is exchanged for a trampoline with a hole in it.
I've seen what happens when the system fails. When an adult with a disability loses the parent they relied on, they don't just lose a caregiver, they lose their home, their structure and their hope. They fall, and there's no net. And when they spiral into mental-health crises, the system shrugs. This isn't a fluke; it's the outcome of choices made by people in power.
And yet, Albertans with disabilities remain resilient. They remain proud. They are grateful, not for crumbs, but for every person who treats them with respect, for every doctor who listens, every stranger who sees their worth, every advocate who still has the energy to fight.
But make no mistake, they are owed more than gratitude. They are owed justice. For justice is the price of civilization.
Lougheed understood this more than 40 years ago. The current government has forgotten. Instead of defending dignity, they chase surpluses and weaponize austerity.
But we, persons with disabilities, understand.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Alberta's United Conservatives call in lawyers in Progressive Conservative name fight
EDMONTON – Alberta's governing United Conservative Party has brought in its lawyers to challenge a rogue splinter group in a fight over resurrecting the province's legacy Progressive Conservative party brand. The UCP has sent a cease and desist letter to two former United Conservative caucus members who are now seeking to challenge Premier Danielle Smith's government by forming a new party using the old Progressive Conservative name. UCP executive director Dustin van Vugt, in a statement Wednesday, said the cease and desist letter was sent to protect the Progressive Conservative Association of Alberta copyright and trademarks that belong to the UCP. 'The PC Alberta name, logo and goodwill were being used by people with no right to it,' he wrote. Van Vugt said neither of the ex-UCP caucus members were part of PC Alberta. 'Their attempt to usurp the goodwill associated with our legacy party in order to confuse voters and avoid the hard work of building a political movement is particularly insulting to the thousands of former PC Party members and supporters who are now contributing members of the UCP,' he wrote. The Progressive Conservatives ran Alberta's government for four decades before collapsing and merging with the Wildrose Party into the new United Conservatives in 2017. The UCP has been Alberta's governing party since 2019. Peter Guthrie, a former cabinet minister in Smith's government, along with former UCP backbencher Scott Sinclair, made headlines earlier this month announcing their plans to resurrect the PC name for a party that would challenge the UCP. Guthrie said Wednesday the letter shows the UCP is worried, and trying to intimidate those who want to move the province's political sphere back to 'normality.' 'They're fearful of us getting off the ground here and offering options to Albertans,' he said in an interview. Guthrie said they're still gathering signatures to register, but now they're also working to join and rebrand the centrist Alberta Party. 'We can get to that official party status now without having to get caught up in all the legal games that the UCP is trying to play here,' he said. Guthrie and Sinclair, both voted out of caucus earlier this year for challenging UCP policies, have said that Smith's government has lost its way, is catering to a narrow band of extremists and separatists, and that centrist conservatives need a place to park their vote. The would-be PCs have told supporters the Alberta Party will take on new board members and begin taking steps to change the name to reflect a progressive conservative alternative in the province. 'It may be that we have to tweak it a bit, but you can't own 'progressive' and you can't own 'conservative,'' said Guthrie. He added the Alberta Party is looking for a new direction, and the partnership makes sense. 'The Alberta Party has that infrastructure in place, and we've come out of the gates — we've had this incredible amount of interest. We started with a very small team, and we've had thousands of people trying to contact us,' he said. The collaboration means it's likely they'll need to hold a leadership contest, Guthrie said, since the Alberta Party already has a leader. Lindsay Amantea took on the role on an interim basis last year. The Alberta Party did not immediately respond to a request for comment. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025.


Winnipeg Free Press
4 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Alberta concerned over Ottawa plan to accept newcomer parents, grandparents this year
EDMONTON – Alberta's immigration minister says he's concerned about the federal government's plan this year to accept thousands of parents and grandparents of immigrants already in Canada. Joseph Schow responded Tuesday to a federal notice that Ottawa plans to take in 10,000 applications from those who have previously expressed interest in sponsoring family members. In a statement, Schow said provincial health-care systems, housing and social services don't have the capacity and could be overwhelmed. Schow took issue with the 10,000 figure. Federal Immigration Minister Lena Diab's office said the federal government's actual countrywide target for approvals this year for the parent and grandparent immigration stream is higher at 24,500. Diab's office said Schow was responding to a notice that the ministry is preparing to take in 10,000 applications for consideration from already settled immigrants who expressed interest in 2020 in sponsoring their parents or grandparents. 'Family reunification is an important part of Canada's immigration system, helping Canadian citizens and permanent residents sponsor their loved ones to live and work alongside them in Canada,' a spokesperson for Diab said in an email, adding that the federal government is committed to reuniting as many families as possible. 'Opening intake for 10,000 applications will help us meet this commitment and will not increase the target.' Schow's office said it was under the impression the 10,000 was the 2025 target, and his concern remains the same. Schow said in the Tuesday statement that he understands 'the importance of family reunification, (but) inviting large numbers of parents and grandparents into the country without proper co-ordination with provinces places disproportionate strain on already busy health systems.' 'This creates serious concerns for both Albertans and the newcomers themselves, who may not receive timely care if our system is overwhelmed.' The minister didn't directly answer questions about whether he wants to see the parent and grandparent target reduced or eliminated. In an email, he said the 'root issue' is the federal government setting immigration targets without provincial input. 'The more direct concern with this program is its impact on health care,' Schow added. 'Seniors are more likely to require medical and long-term care, and bringing in thousands more without additional supports increases pressure on a system already managing high demand.' Diab's office said since parents and grandparents accepted under the program require a sponsor to financially support them, it doesn't put any excessive burden on provincial services. 'Family reunification not only leads to social and cultural benefits but also economic benefits,' said the spokesperson. 'Those coming through this program are often supporting the household in Canada, including by providing childcare. This helps parents enter the workforce and strengthen Canada's economy.' Schow said Alberta's government wants overall immigration reduced to below 500,000 per year, and that provinces need to 'have a stronger role in selecting newcomers to meet local needs.' Under targets set last fall, Ottawa is aiming to approve just over 1 million immigration applications this year, including temporary residents on work visas, international students, refugees and new permanent residents like parents and grandparents of newcomers. On Wednesday, premiers from across Canada collectively called on the federal government to engage more with provincial governments on immigration targets and increase the share of economic immigrants each province is allocated under the provincial and territorial nominee program. The joint federally and provincially run program works to fast track the permanent residency process for workers in sought after sectors. For Alberta, that includes health care, technology and law enforcement. 'Provinces and territories are best positioned to understand their local labour market needs and call on the federal government to support their respective priorities,' reads a joint statement from premiers following their three-day meeting in Ontario. Schow's comments also come as a panel chaired by Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is touring the province to hear from citizens on a number of topics, including whether Alberta should create its own immigration permitting system and block non-approved newcomers from accessing services like health care. At the panel's most recent town hall in Edmonton, a member of the public accused Smith of 'punching down on immigrants.' Smith said the province is trying to find solutions to housing affordability, hospital capacity, classroom sizes and 'increasing pressure on our social programs.' 'There has to be a reasonable amount of newcomers that are able to come here, fit into the economy, be able to be self-supporting,' Smith told the audience. 'That is, I think, a bit high at the moment.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025.


Calgary Herald
6 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Former United Conservative MLAs seek to join, rebrand Alberta Party as Progressive Conservative Party
Two former United Conservative Party (UCP) MLAs say they are now seeking to join and rebrand the Alberta Party as part of their effort to ultimately revive the province's once-dominant Progressive Conservative (PC) Party amid legal threats from their former party. Article content Earlier this month, Airdrie-Cochrane MLA and former cabinet minister Peter Guthrie along with Lesser Slave Lake MLA Scott Sinclair announced plans to relaunch the PC Party after both were ejected from the UCP caucus. Article content Article content Article content 'Ultimately, it made a lot of sense to us. The Alberta Party has the infrastructure,' Guthrie told Postmedia in an interview. 'This allows us to get to our end faster.' Article content The email states the Alberta Party will be expanding its board to include some of Guthrie and Sinclair's team and will be initiating steps towards a name change via Elections Alberta. Article content Article content Alberta Party interim leader Lindsay Amantea issued a statement reading, 'we are exploring opportunities and partnerships that would raise the level of political discourse, and refocus the conversation on improving the lives of all Albertans, not just insiders.' Article content The party had four MLAs between 2011 and 2019 but saw its vote share decline from nine per cent in 2019 to less than one per cent in 2023 after running 19 of a possible 87 candidates. Amantea has served as interim leader since April of last year after former leader Barry Morishita's resignation in November of 2023. Article content Article content Guthrie said he and Sinclair share some ideological ground with the Alberta Party, calling their collaboration a chance to bring the centre together ahead of the rumoured possibility of a spring election. Article content The pair's efforts to restore the PC brand have met with the threat of legal action from the UCP. Article content UCP executive director Dustin van Vugt told Postmedia the party sent a cease and desist letter to protect the PC copyright and trademarks it says it owns. Article content 'The PC Alberta name, logo and goodwill were being used by people with no right to it,' he wrote in an email. Article content 'Neither of these MLAs were ever even members of PC Alberta, so their attempt to usurp the goodwill associated with our legacy party in order to confuse voters and avoid the hard work of building a political movement is particularly insulting to the thousands of former PC Party members and supporters who are now contributing members of the UCP.'