Canterbury Council's Freshwater Management Challenged In Court
The first of two back-to-back court cases challenging the Canterbury regional council's freshwater management begins at the Christchurch High Court today., Senior reporter
The first of two back-to-back court cases challenging the Canterbury regional council's freshwater management begins at the Christchurch High Court today.
The Environmental Law Initiative (ELI) will ask the court to quash a rule in the regional plan which allows certain farming discharges as a permitted activity.
Senior researcher Anna Sintenie said ELI will argue the rule – which allows the discharge of nutrients onto or into land to be a permitted activity in some circumstances, but can result in contaminants entering water – breaches the Resource Management Act.
She said the council should be protecting the health of Canterbury's waterways and people for generations to come, but has instead been 'illegally permissive' of activities that have led to significant pollution.
The organisations will be back in the High Court the following week, as ELI seeks to have a consent for the Mayfield Hinds Valetta (MHV) irrigation scheme deemed unlawful.
In 2021, the council granted MHV Water Ltd a consent to discharge nitrogen over more than 58,000 hectares in the Hinds/Hekeao Plains.
Sintenie said the organisation is seeking a similar outcome as they won in 2024, when the court found the council had unlawfully granted a resource consent for the neighbouring Ashburton Lyndhurst Irrigation Ltd irrigation scheme (ALIL), and quashed the consent.
The regional council and ALIL have appealed the decision.
She said in the wake of the court's findings in the ALIL case – that the council's decision to grant the discharge consent breached the RMA, and that the council had failed to consider other relevant policies requiring it to avoid adverse effects on indigenous biodiversity and the 'natural character' of coastal and freshwater environment – ELI took another look at the council's water management and protection.
The group will also argue the council failed to consider the potential impacts on local drinking water supplies, and should have notified the community.
It was just down to the court's timetabling that the cases had been scheduled back to back, Sintinie said.
But it was no coincidence the organisation was scrutinising the Canterbury Regional Council's decison-making, consent management and protection of freshwater.
'We've had a focus on water quality outcomes in Canterbury because we can see there's a significant nitrogen pollution issue in the region.
'We believe in this context of significant pollution, there's a high responsibility on ECan [the regional council] to be sure it's properly managing these issues.'
The majority of the country's freshwater is located in Canterbury (about 70 percent), as is the bulk of the nation's irrigated land.
The council declined to comment while the cases were before the court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
17 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Primary sector and tourism driving growth
The South has had some great news recently, with Southland and Otago emerging as the top-performing regions in the country in Kiwibank's recent report. Much of this success can be attributed to the primary sector and tourism, which are driving the economic recovery. This positive trend coincides with farmer confidence surging to its highest level in eight years. Federated Farmers' Confidence Survey indicates a remarkable shift in sentiment, driven by farm profitability at its highest level ever recorded. Additionally, 23% of farmers are forecasting increased production over the next 12 months. This in turn means more economic activity in our region, spurring more opportunities and job growth. There's been further big news for productivity with the biggest building consent reform in decades set to eliminate system blockages and speed up the delivery of new homes and infrastructure. Making it easier and more affordable to build is an important part of this government's economic growth plan. In another excellent move for progress, the government's second RMA Amendment Bill has passed into law, bringing in sweeping changes to many of the handbrakes on New Zealanders' lives, helping to drive economic growth, and laying the groundwork for job creation. The Resource Management Act (RMA) has been holding New Zealand back for decades. We're making it quicker and simpler to boost housing supply, reduce red tape, and consent renewable energy for the primary sector. Productivity and growth translates into more job and business opportunities, as well as increased funding for the public services that enhance our quality of life, including healthcare and education. On education, the government's proposing to replace NCEA with a new national qualification. One of the changes put forward is to create new subjects and standards to support stronger vocational pathways. Many employers in our region are involved with vocational training, and it would be great to get your perspective during the consultation period which is open until September 15. I've had some great feedback about the two new seasonal work visas that were announced last week. Much of Southland's prosperity centres around agriculture and tourism. The success of these seasonal industries is essential for our local economy and the many businesses associated with them.
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
The Asian candidates vying for a seat on regional councils
Clockwise from top left: Omar Faruque, Alan Wang, Syed Khurram Iqbal and Yadana Saw. Photo: Supplied As billboards are erected for local elections nationwide, a number of Asian candidates have put their hands up to contest seats in regional councils. New Zealand has 11 regional councils that serve areas such as Northland, Bay of Plenty and Otago. The councils play a key role in managing natural resources such as land, air and water, supporting biodiversity and biosecurity, regional transport, as well as building resilience for climate change and natural hazards. Although there has been speculation that regional councils may be tossed on the scrapheap due to Resource Management Act reform, four Asian candidates have thrown their hats into the ring for the election. Yadana Saw and Omar Faruque are seeking election in Greater Wellington, Syed Khurram Iqbal is standing in Hawkes Bay and Alan Wang is vying for a seat in Environmental Canterbury. Yadana Saw Photo: Supplied Yadana Saw is an incumbent councillor for the Greater Wellington Regional Council. She was first elected to the council in 2022, seeking re-election to one of the five seats available for the Wellington constituency. Saw's parents came to New Zealand from Myanmar. Born and bred in New Zealand herself, Saw primarily wants to give something back to the place her family was able to put down roots. Having started her campaigning and activism when she was in university, Saw then worked in media, including RNZ, before trying her hand at local politics. Saw says that regional councils play a key role in people's day-to-day lives. She is most concerned about how storm water in the Wellington region is being managed, noting that it is currently being channelled into drains and becoming polluted before flowing into rivers and harbours. "I think there are really good solutions that all councils and communities and manawhenua and businesses need to work together to solve it," Saw says. Constructing wetlands and using other ways to retain rainwater so that it stays out of drainage systems and can be used for gardening may be part of the solution, she says. Omar Faruque Photo: Supplied Omar Faruque is eyeing one of three seats available for the Lower Hutt constituency in the Greater Wellington Regional Council. It is the first time he has stood as a candidate in local government elections. Coming from Bangladesh in 2005, Faruque studied applied finance and public policy at Victoria University of Wellington. Faruque has also worked as a prison officer, actor, model and fashion photographer. He says the region's problematic public transport system, aging water infrastructure and outdated emergency plans all deserve attention. If elected, he pledges to launch a feasibility study to build another water treatment plant in Stokes Valley, a "New Cross Valley" plan to develop the local economy, including building a film studio in Wainuiomata, as well as replacing the eight territorial councils with a transformed regional council. "I have been encouraged by community elders, local leaders, seniors [and] neighbours," Faruque said. "It's my call to stand as a candidate to serve for the greater wellbeing of the regional community. ... It is the right time to challenge the status quo." Syed Khurram Iqbal Photo: Supplied Syed Khurram Iqbal, a chartered engineer, arrived in New Zealand from Pakistan in 2017 and has been living in Napier with his family. Working as a senior project manager at Napier City Council, Iqbal is seeking election in one of three seats for the Napier constituency in the Hawkes Bay Regional Council. Frustration over delays on flood repairs after Cyclone Gabrielle and pollution to aquifers, as well as bus cuts that affect students and other commuters, have motivated him to stand for the first time, he says. "For a decade, I have managed critical infrastructure projects and chaired many panels," Iqbal said, adding that he knows how to turn a plan into action. "But seeing families displaced by floods and aquifers poisoned by nitrates ignited a new purpose: to expedite solutions for Napier's safety and fairness." He promises to fast-track flood defence measures, clean water sources through auditing industrial polluters and funding free well tests, restore certain bus routes and allocate grants to help small businesses adapt to extreme weather. "From volunteering in cyclone recovery to demanding industrial accountability, I have seen how expertise and empathy can drive change," Iqbal said. "Now, as a father and community leader, I'm determined to build a Napier where our children thrive - not just survive on past decision makers." Alan Wang Photo: Supplied Alan Wang is standing for one of two spots in the Christchurch Central constituency at Environmental Canterbury Regional Council (Ecan). He worked as a food scientist in China before coming to New Zealand in 2012, studying applied science at Lincoln University. Wang then studied environmental health at Massey University during the Covid-19 pandemic. Currently working as an environmental health officer at Christchurch City Council, the first-time candidate says he has experience working with drinking water, recreational water and wastewater. Growing up in rural China, Wang has seen firsthand what happens when the local governments cut down native forests to make charcoal for steel production. He is primarily focused on discharges to air, water and land in his campaign. "Ecan should take a more proactive approach," Wang said. "I think we should prioritise regenerating native flora in some sensitive areas, for example, hills above the bays, to reduce the pathogen level in the water." He says it would be wrong to disestablish regional councils, so he decided to step up during this "difficult time". "Christchurch is my home," he says. "I believe I can do more and better for our society if I am elected as a regional councillor of Canterbury."
Scoop
3 days ago
- Scoop
Landlord Confidence On A Knife Edge: 80% Says Election Will Decide
AUCKLAND, 14 August 2025 — New data from the Auckland Property Investors Association (APIA) shows New Zealand's rental sector is in a state of cautious watchfulness. Four in five landlords say their investment confidence hinges on the next general election, reflecting both the scale of current reforms and the uncertainty of what comes after them. Major Findings Election-dependency risk: 80% of landlords say their confidence depends on the outcome of the next election, with 56% saying 'significantly.' Policy climate challenge: 56.9% believe the current policy environment is unsupportive of investment while 41.5% view it as stable or supportive. Many see today's uncertainty as short-term disruption caused by the scale of reform, particularly the overhaul of the Resource Management Act, which aims to fix long-standing problems in planning and housing supply. Transparency unlock: 82% say they would be more willing to support reforms, even those they initially disagree with, if the government provided clearer data and policy rationales. Compliance squeeze: Nearly half (48.2%) report compliance has become harder since October 2023, pointing to an opportunity to streamline administration alongside policy change. 'Confidence is the foundation every investment rests on,' says Sarina Gibbon, GM of APIA. 'Overhauls like the RMA reforms are major resets. We have to accept that some disruption is the cost of fixing deep problems. What worries investors is the risk that the next government will tear up the plans before the work is done. Housing needs policies that outlast election cycles so investors can commit with certainty.' She adds, 'Some parties are naturally more inclined toward private investment, but this survey shows investors care more about stability than partisanship. Certainty of policy settings matters more than who wins, because it's the only thing that keeps capital in the market long enough to build the homes we need.' APIA Recommendations For policymakers: Bipartisan commitment to core housing settings will reduce the risk that new reforms are unravelled by the next administration. For the housing market: Predictability attracts capital. Short-term disruption is acceptable if the long-term rules are clear and durable. For voters: Housing stability and political stability go hand in hand. A cycle of reversing policies every three years undermines both supply and affordability. About Auckland Property Investors Association (APIA) The Auckland Property Investors Association (APIA) is a leading advocacy group representing the interests of property investors throughout Auckland. Committed to promoting education, advocacy, and networking opportunities, APIA actively shapes policies impacting the property investment landscape. APIA strives to cultivate a supportive environment for property investors while advocating for policies that uphold the rights and responsibilities of both landlords and tenants.
