DeepSeek vs ChatGPT: How China's AI rival handles sensitive questions differently
In a demonstration of the AI's censorship in real-time, DeepSeek was shown altering its answers when questioned about Tiananmen Square and President Xi Jinping. During testing, the chatbot was asked about the 1989 Tiananmen Square Massacre, only to respond with, 'I am sorry, I cannot answer that question. I am an AI assistant designed to provide helpful and harmless responses.'
The chatbot's censorship extends to a wide range of topics deemed politically sensitive by the Chinese government, including the White Paper Movement, Hong Kong's pro-democracy protests, and China's human rights record in Xinjiang. When asked about the White Paper Movement, DeepSeek initially provided a response describing the protests but quickly changed the answer to 'Sorry, that's beyond my current scope. Let's talk about something else.'
DeepSeek's refusal to address such issues is in line with China's strict censorship laws, which are implemented across the country's digital landscape, including social media and now, AI tools.
On lighter topics, DeepSeek offered a politically correct version of the story when asked about the Winnie the Pooh meme mocking President Xi Jinping, stating that the bear symbolizes "joy and friendship" in China, while ChatGPT acknowledged the meme's use as political satire and resistance against Xi.
The differences in these two chatbots' responses point to the broader issue of censorship and control over information.
Experts argue that DeepSeek's rapid rise as a competitor to U.S. tech giants like OpenAI poses a serious challenge, not just in terms of performance but in how it promotes China's official narratives globally.
Despite its impressive performance, which has made it the most downloaded app on the Apple App Store, DeepSeek's refusal to engage with topics such as Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Xinjiang highlights the troubling export of China's censorship policies to the West. The AI's ability to avoid politically sensitive issues has raised alarms about the future of AI technology under Chinese control.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
13 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Wang Yi to visit India for border talks
Foreign Minister Wang Yi will visit India for the first time in three years. Photo (file) Foreign Minister Wang Yi will visit India for the first time in three years to discuss the latest round of border talks, the Chinese foreign ministry has confirmed. During the trip from August 18 to 20, the top Chinese diplomat will serve as the "special representative of the China-India boundary question" in the 24th round of border talks "at the invitation of the Indian side", according to a Saturday statement from the ministry. This series of negotiations aims to address long-standing border disputes, which have seen a temporary de-escalation following years of tension. Wang is expected to meet top Indian officials including National Security Adviser Ajit Doval. The two last met in Beijing in December to review disengagement in eastern Ladakh along the disputed border, known as the Line of Actual Control, where an estimated 50,00060,000 troops remain deployed on each side. "We stand ready to work with India to act on the important common understandings reached between leaders of our two countries, maintain the momentum of high-level exchanges, cement political mutual trust, enhance practical cooperation, properly handle differences, and promote the sustained, sound and steady development of China-India ties," Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Lin Jian said on Thursday in response to speculation about a trip by Wang. "China and India are both major developing countries and important members of the Global South," he said. "A cooperative pas de deux of the dragon and the elephant as partners helping each other succeed is the right choice for both sides." Wang's trip comes ahead of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to China to attend the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) summit from August 31 to September 1. The easing of tensions between China and India has gathered pace while New Delhi's relationship with Washington is strained by growing trade disputes. China and India had already been working to improve relations following the deadly clash between their troops in the disputed Galwan Valley in June 2020. Wang's last visit to India was a brief working trip on March 25, 2022, just weeks after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Backchannel talks since late last year have yielded more incremental progress. Both armies completed disengagement at multiple friction points along the Line of Actual Control, and New Delhi reopened visa slots for Chinese nationals earlier this year, while Beijing resumed access to Tibet for Indian pilgrims. Both countries have also announced plans to resume direct flights.
Express Tribune
14 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Locals in Balochistan helping identify terrorists: DG ISPR
The chief military spokesperson said on Saturday that residents in Balochistan are increasingly providing information on terrorists and their facilitators, a move he called critical to the success of counterterrorism operations in the restive province. Lt Gen Ahmed Sharif, Director General of the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR), told students in a special session of the army's internship programme that intelligence-based operations (IBOs) rely heavily on local cooperation. "We don't conduct sweeping operations unless locals support us by identifying threats. Military presence alone doesn't secure an area – local ownership is the key," he said in a candid discussion with the students, where he addressed questions surrounding military operations, regional concerns, and national unity. "If a citizen provides shelter to terrorists or keeps explosives in his house, he will have to face the consequences," Lt Gen Sharif said while dispelling the impression that military operations target communities. "The entire region or village cannot be punished for the terrorism of one person," he added. "Our operations are not about displacing communities or punishing entire regions. We only move against confirmed terrorists based on solid intelligence." He said security forces were working to expose not only terrorists but also their facilitators and supporters. "The people of Balochistan are standing up against terrorism and pointing out those who harbour or facilitate terrorists," Lt Gen Sharif added. Balochistan, which borders Iran and Afghanistan, has been plagued by a decades-long Baloch separatist insurgency as well as attacks by religious extremists. The province has seen frequent assaults on security forces, government installations, and Chinese-backed projects. The military spokesperson praised the people of Balochistan for what he described as growing resistance to terrorist groups, saying many were "helpless and fed up with the terrorists." He cited the examples of young Baloch professionals, including female deputy commissioners, as signs of progress. He specially mentioned Dr Samad Yar Jang, a Cambridge-trained scientist, and Shahzaib Rind, Pakistani Wushu and Kickboxing champion, known for his success in Karate Combat. He added that Baloch women now serve in senior administrative positions, such as deputy commissioners, which he said symbolise progress and empowerment. The talented and educated Baloch youth has become the masters of its destiny, he added. "There's a common misconception that Baloch youth are disconnected from Pakistan. In reality, they understand the bond between their province and the nation very well," the military spokesperson said. Lt Gen Sharif also paid tribute to Major Muhammad Anwar Kakar, an officer martyred in a bomb attack in Balochistan. Major Kakar Shaheed, a brave son of the soil, had previously played a key role in repelling an attack on the PC Hotel in Gwadar in 2019, he added. "From officers to civilians, sacrifices are being made every day to keep Pakistan secure." Referring to the ideological roots of Pakistan, Lt Gen Sharif said that Pakistan was created on the basis of "Kalima" not on ethnic or linguistic lines. "The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) has taught us that no race or ethnicity is superior to another. That's the foundation of our country," he added. He also pointed out the diverse ethnic makeup of Balochistan, saying that more than 30% of its population comprises Pashtuns, and many Baloch tribes live outside the province in Sindh and South Punjab. "Pakistan is not just a country; it's an idea rooted in unity, faith, and purpose," he added.
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Oil lower as Trump-Putin talks loom
HOUSTON: Oil prices closed down nearly $1 on Friday as traders awaited talks between US President Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin, which could lead to an easing of the sanctions imposed on Moscow over the war in Ukraine. Brent crude futures settled 99 cents, or 1.5%, lower at $65.85 a barrel, while US West Texas Intermediate crude futures eased $1.16, or 1.8%, lower at $62.80. Trump arrived in Alaska on Friday for his summit with Putin after saying he wants to see a ceasefire in the war in Ukraine 'today.' Trump has said he believes Russia is prepared to end the war, but he has also threatened to impose secondary sanctions on countries that buy Russian oil if there is no progress with peace talks. Putin also arrived in Anchorage. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Russia expects the talks to bring results, Russia's Interfax news agency reported. 'President Trump will likely threaten further tariff pressure on India and possibly China as far as oil imports from Russia if the meeting stalemates, which is keeping a nervous trade to crude,' said Dennis Kissler, senior vice president of trading at BOK Financial. 'If a ceasefire announcement is made, it will be taken as a negative to crude near-term,' Kissler added. For the week, WTI dropped 1.7%, while Brent eased 1.1%. Weaker economic data from China, meanwhile, raised concerns over fuel demand. Chinese government data showed factory output growth slumped to an eight-month low and retail sales growth expanded at its slowest pace since December, weighing on sentiment despite stronger oil throughput in the world's second-largest crude user. Throughput at Chinese refineries rose 8.9% year-on-year in July, but that was down from June levels, which were the highest since September 2023. Despite the increase, China's oil product exports last month were also up from a year ago, suggesting lower domestic fuel demand. Forecasts of a growing oil market surplus also weighed on sentiment, as did the prospect of higher-for-longer US interest rates. Oil rig count, an indicator of future supply, rose by one to 412 this week, Baker Hughes data showed.C+ output.
