Smartphone bans in Dutch schools have improved learning, study finds
National guidelines, introduced in January 2024, recommend banning smartphones from classrooms and almost all schools have complied. Close to two-thirds of secondary schools ask pupils to leave their phones at home or put them in lockers, while phones are given in at the start of a lesson at one in five.
Researchers surveyed 317 secondary school leaders, 313 primary schools and conducted 12 focus groups with teachers, teaching assistants, students and parents. Secondary schools reported that children found it easier to concentrate (75%), the social environment was better (59%) and some said results had improved (28%).
Dr Alexander Krepel, a researcher at the Kohnstamm Instituut, said interactions between pupils had improved the most. 'It's not possible to secretly take a picture of someone in the classroom and then spread it in a WhatsApp group, so there's an increase in social safety,' he said. 'Especially in the breaks between the lessons, students would be on their phones and now they're forced to talk … Maybe they also get into a fight a bit more often but schools, teachers and students are quite happy with how the atmosphere is better.'
Initial fears surrounding the ban proved unfounded, according to Freya Sixma, spokesperson for the VO-raad secondary education council, which represents schools and governing boards. 'There was quite a lot of protest at first from schools, teachers, students, parents, questions about how it would all work,' she said. 'But now you see that actually everyone is pretty happy.'
The study showed in special schools, where exceptions can be given for learning support devices, about half reported that the ban had had a positive or very positive effect. In primary schools, smartphones did not have a huge effect before the ban, but a quarter were positive about it.
Mariëlle Paul, the minister for primary and secondary education, said the national guideline helped classroom discipline. 'Teachers and school leaders indicated that if an individual teacher wanted to ban the mobile from his or her class it would always be a discussion,' she said. 'More inexperienced teachers would have difficulties enforcing that.'
MPs could take a lesson from the results, too, Paul added. 'Even we as adults should admit that whatever is going on, the apps, WhatsApp, Snapchat or Instagram have a form of addictiveness. We once tried to do it for a debate on education … but that was pretty difficult.'
Sign up to This is Europe
The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment
after newsletter promotion
Statistics Netherlands reports that 96% of children go online almost every day, mostly through their phones. Last month, the caretaker government advised parents to ban social media for under-15s and limit screen time, while one MP has proposed a total ban on smartphones in schools.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
38 minutes ago
- BBC News
cj0yn6y2m3do (GIF Image, 1 × 1 pixels)
Bethan Lewis Education and family correspondent, BBC Wales Aoife Aoife from Swansea will be arriving at her school as early as possible to pick up her GCSE results and will hopefully start celebrating soon after Pupils will open their GCSE results on Thursday ahead of a major shake-up to qualifications in Wales. New GCSEs to align with the reformed Curriculum for Wales will start being phased in from September. Thursday's results, like last year's grades, are expected to be broadly in line with the pattern before the Covid-19 pandemic - A-level grades published last week were similar to 2024 but remained higher than 2019. Aoife, 16, a pupil at St Joseph's Catholic School in Port Talbot, said: "I was anxious before the exams but I'm hoping my results will show that my hard work has paid off." In 2024 there were 62.2% grades at A* to C compared to 62.8% in 2019 and 64.9% in 2023. Aoife is aiming for top grades when she collects her results and hopes to study A-levels in September before fulfilling her dream of an engineering career in motor sports. In addition to the core subjects of English, Welsh, maths and the sciences, Aoife chose to study history, French and further maths, and said she "put a lot of pressure on myself when it came to revision." Catrin from Bala, Gwynedd, is a fourth generation farmer and wants to continue in agriculture. The 16-year-old hopes to get a minimum of five Cs, including maths and Welsh, to study for a Level 3 in agricultural engineering at Coleg Glynllifon. The Ysgol Godre'r Berwyn pupil who will be opening her results in the car on the way to work said she hoped to get "the right grades that I need for my future". Careers adviser Dylan Evans said young people could speak to Careers Wales service Working Wales for free if they are looking for guidance. "My advice to parents of teens collecting their GCSE results this week is to listen and reassure them," he said. "Reassure them that there's support out there for whatever they want to do next – and if they need to change their plan, that's OK too." Getty Images As well as getting GCSE grades, pupils will find out results of vocational and entry level qualifications and the Welsh Baccalaureate Ian Morgan, chief executive of Wales' main exam board WJEC, said he expected GCSE results this year to be similar to pre-Covid years. Year 11 pupils who took their GCSEs this summer moved from primary to secondary school at the height of the pandemic in 2020. "I think we've seen some challenges over the last four or five years and this is the first year really that learners are able to show their knowledge, understanding and skills in a way that hasn't been impacted by any other changes in the past," he said. Exams largely returned back to normal last year after measures to reflect the impact of the pandemic were dropped - a more gradual process in Wales than in England. Another difference is that GCSEs in Wales are graded A* to G, whereas England has a numbered nine to one system. The new Curriculum for Wales started being rolled out in schools three years ago. Phase one of the changes includes a merged English language and literature GCSE and a new look Welsh second language qualification. Mr Morgan said the 15 new GCSEs from September were "a real exciting opportunity for learners to show what they can do, what they understand, and show their knowledge". He added: "Now it's up to the teachers, who I know have worked diligently over the last 12 months to better understand the qualifications and specifications, to start teaching from September."
BBC News
38 minutes ago
- BBC News
Parents on low wages struggling to get school uniform grant
Parents on low wages in parts of Scotland are struggling to access financial support for school uniforms that would be available in other council areas, the BBC has of Scotland's councils pay the grant to people on universal credit who earn a salary from employment of less than £850 a month - roughly equal to 16 hours a week at minimum some councils will pay the clothing allowance to people earning as much as twice that amount. The Child Poverty Action Group is calling for thresholds to be raised across Scotland, saying parents can easily be in poverty and not qualify for the support. Scottish government guidance says families on low incomes should be able to access a minimum of £120 a year for a primary pupil and £150 for a secondary pupil - figures which have not risen for three years. But the eligibility for who gets the cash is set by local councils and varies widely across the 120,000 pupils receive the clothing grant but Jen, a single parent who lives in Balloch with her 10-year-old son, says she is angry and frustrated that she does not works 22 hours a week in a care home but struggles to cover her her income leaves her above the £933 a month threshold for the school uniform grant set by West Dunbartonshire a few miles up the road in the Stirling Council area, Jen's income would put her well below its £1,851 threshold and she would qualify for the majority of Scotland's councils stop the grant when families on Universal Credit have earnings of over £850 a month, the same criteria that is used for free school eight councils allow people on much higher incomes to claim the allowance, with some using council tax rebate or housing benefit as criteria. Jen says she spends about £450 a year on school uniform and shoes for her son."It makes you a bit anxious, of the feeling of how you're going to be able to afford all these clothes, because kids grow dramatically," she says."They're one clothes size one minute and then they've just shot right up. "They can go to school one minute and then they wake up the next day and go, 'oh my shoes don't fit'." Jen says: "We all want our kids in the best kind of stuff so they're not getting bullied in school."She says she is angry that by working 22 hours a week she is just over the limit for accessing the grant."We are trying to work and better ourselves for our kids and then we aren't getting the help at the end of it," she says. Leading campaign organisation, The Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG), is calling for thresholds to be raised across Spencer, CPAG's cost of the school day project manager, said the school uniform grant should be available to all parents on Universal Credit, as the benefit itself is an indicator of low income. Universal Credit is a paid to those who are out of work or on low incomes - 37% of recipients across the UK are in employment."It would make it more fair and consistent across the country and most importantly it would mean that more children on low incomes would be receiving this vital support," Ms Spencer said."Parents tell us that uniform is a really difficult and a big cost for them, especially in larger families where you've got uniform to buy for lots of children." Julia Grindley, of the Edinburgh uniform bank charity, says she sees many people who are in poverty who end up at her door because they are not eligible for state support. "About 40% of children who are referred to us for a clothing crisis pack are not eligible for the School Clothing Grant even though they are living in poverty," she said. "Many of those have one or two parents who are working. "If they earn just £10 over the threshold they can actually end up worse off than families that are not working."It's very frustrating that families have to come to us because they can't access things that they really should be eligible for." School funding grant In 2018 the then education secretary John Swinney announced reforms to the school clothing grant saying it would "remove the stress and stigma which can often be associated with struggling to afford essential school items".But councils set very different thresholds for those on universal credit to receive an award.A West Dunbartonshire Council spokeswoman said: "We are committed to supporting low-income families and our threshold for eligibility for a school clothing grant is more generous than the offer in 70% of other authority areas across Scotland."The Scottish government said it had provided funding of £14.2m for the school funding grant this year.A spokesman said: "Our funding helped to create a national grant level which provides eligible families with at least £120 to help with the cost of clothing for school for each child."Local authorities are responsible for the administration and distribution of this grant. "We are aware that local authorities apply differing eligibility criteria and would encourage synergies so that families on similar income levels in different areas are treated fairly."Last year, the Scottish government published guidelines on how to make uniforms more accessible and affordable. They said schools should use generic items and colours that could be bought from a range of suppliers, promote uptake of the school clothing grant and ensure branded items are not encouraged. What's the solution? West Calder High School in West Lothian has completely re-designed its uniform to make it more affordable and accessible. The school asked pupils and the local community what they wanted to wear, in line with the new government guidance. The pupils asked for comfort and style and opted for a t-shirt and hoodie rather than a blazer and tie. Older pupils still wanted a shirt and blazer to differentiate them from young pupils but all the items are available through the school to cut the Gerry Higgins said the school now buys the basic uniform in bulk and sells a full uniform to parents for £10. He said a traditional uniform with shirt and tie would cost £56."You will have young people who will deliberately not come into school because of the cost of the school day," he said. "It might be that they don't realise that is the reason but they cannot afford to look the same as other young people."
BBC News
38 minutes ago
- BBC News
Wales' papers: Boy injured in hit and run and council's £5k driveway demand
Copyright 2025 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
