Time to ditch workplace ‘bring a plate' functions? Editorial
For a few hours, it was probably quite a good day.
But as two workers began to feel ill, things went south.
With an arrest now made, police and the justice system will decide if it was a deliberate poisoning or an accidental act – but regardless, it's certainly no Australian beef wellington incident.
In this case, it resulted in two workers taking a very short walk down to the Emergency Department to try to get an explanation of what was wrong with them.
Once the results came back, the cake became the talk of the hospital and, soon after, the nation.
Health NZ says it takes the incident extremely seriously and acted immediately to ensure appropriate steps were taken.
Perhaps one of the steps that it, and other employers around NZ, could take is to look at food-related social occasions.
Good employers will occasionally offer a catered morning tea to staff as a gesture of goodwill.
However, the public service has become cautious when it comes to offering the same benefits, fearing headlines that emphasise the cost and the subsequent public backlash.
A quick look at social media comments on a story about $30,000 Christmas breakfast Napier City Council put on for its staff last year shows the risk of perception that publicly funded organisations face when putting on meals.
Maybe the cannabis cake will change that.
Perhaps, instead of platitudes about it being an unacceptable act, it could be a catalyst to ditch the forced 'bring a plate' functions, and instead give workers something they don't have to prepare themselves.
That might be better than playing potluck.
Sign up to the Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
5 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Opinion: Youth vaping is a problem, let's look at the evidence
It risks reinforcing a narrative implied by e-cigarette companies, including some owned by Big Tobacco: that New Zealand should never clamp down on e-cigarettes or smoking rates may rise again. Let's re-examine the evidence. Beaglehole claims: 'So far, there is no evidence that teen vaping leads to smoking.' This is incorrect. I was an investigator on the only New Zealand study to date to directly compare adolescent smoking trends before and after e-cigarettes became available. We found that the decline in 14– and 15-year-olds initiating smoking – and smoking regularly – significantly slowed after the emergence and rise of vaping in New Zealand. Had pre-vaping trends in adolescent smoking continued, the smoking initiation rate in 2023 would have been around 6.6%, rather than the 12.6% it ultimately reached. Also, our new study – published today in The Medical Journal of Australia – adds to the evidence, albeit from the other side of the Tasman. As in New Zealand, we found that Australia's progress in reducing adolescent smoking significantly slowed after the emergence and rise of vaping. In both countries, the pattern is similar in a manner that seems unlikely to be a coincidence. While youth vaping may be less of a problem in Australia than in New Zealand, it is still a serious problem. But it's not just our New Zealand and Australian studies. There is also a large body of evidence from international cohort studies – the strongest type of observational study for understanding cause-and-effect relationships. These studies track individuals over time and have consistently found that adolescents who vape are more likely to go on to smoke. None have yet been conducted in New Zealand, but their findings are so consistent across countries and cultures that it seems likely a New Zealand cohort study would show the same. To suggest all of these studies provide 'no evidence that teen vaping leads to smoking' is simply inaccurate. What about adult smoking? Beaglehole's claim that vaping has significantly contributed to its decline in New Zealand also deserves a closer look. It is true that adult daily smoking in New Zealand declined more sharply than expected between 2020 and 2023 – from 11.9% to 6.8%, a period when daily vaping rose rapidly from 3.5% to 9.7%. This four-year window is what many e-cigarette advocates rely heavily on when declaring victory on behalf of e-cigarettes. But the most recent New Zealand data diverge from that narrative. Despite daily vaping continuing to increase from 9.7% in 2023 to 11.1% in 2024, the rate of daily smoking failed to decrease for the first time in a decade. Other countries offer further reason for caution. In England, although smoking rates declined between 2016 and 2023, there was no acceleration in that decline among adults aged 18-24 and 25-44, despite a sharp rise in e-cigarette use from 2021. Among those aged 45 and over, the decline in smoking not only failed to accelerate – it actually slowed. Smoking rates in New Zealand were already falling before e-cigarettes emerged – and they continued to fall afterwards. This progress is at least partly due to the impact of strong tobacco control policies accumulating over many years – policies that continue to influence smoking patterns today. These include smokefree bars and restaurants, regular increases in tobacco excise taxes, graphic health warnings on packaging, point-of-sale display bans, plain packaging and legislation prohibiting smoking in cars carrying children. At best, vaping may have slightly sped up the decline in adult smoking. At worst, it may have made no difference – or even slowed progress – while embedding a commercial nicotine industry that will be hard to wind back. The risk of overstating the evidence is that it fuels the idea that New Zealand now needs a thriving vaping industry. That if it's reined in, smoking will inevitably rise. It's a convenient narrative. Especially for companies that profit from it. Vaping may have a role to play in quitting smoking. But that doesn't mean efforts to limit access to young people who have never smoked should be dismissed. Now more than ever, New Zealand should double down on a progressive, evidence-based approach to tobacco control. Decades of hard-won progress shouldn't now be handed to an industry eager to claim the credit.
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Waikato med school business case beats Auckland and Otago
Option 2 was a specialist medical training programme focused on rural health run by those two universities and was estimated to cost $10.2b, while option 3, the new medical school at Waikato, was estimated to cost $9.1b, making it the cheapest overall – although the University of Auckland has criticised the assumptions behind this costing. Director-General of Health Dr Diana Sarfati and University of Waikato vice-chancellor Professor Neil Quigley, watched by Health Minister at the time, Shane Reti, and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, signing the Memorandum of Understanding for a third medical school in 2024. Photo / Mark Mitchell The Waikato medical school was also estimated to deliver greater benefits, leading to a benefit-cost ratio of 1.99, meaning each dollar spent on the school produced $1.99 in benefit. Option 1 and 2 had a ratio of 1.5 and 1.8 – placing them only narrowly behind Waikato. Health Minister Simeon Brown told the Herald the school was a 'game-changer for the long-term growth of our medical workforce in New Zealand'. 'Cabinet agreed to this proposal following the Ministry of Health undertaking a business case and a cost-benefit analysis which demonstrated this proposal would be the most effective at building this critical health workforce for New Zealand,' he said. The University of Auckland's Dean of Medical and Health Sciences Professor Warwick Bagg told the Herald he was 'deeply concerned' by the business case, which seemed to have a predetermined outcome: to favour the Waikato medical school the National Party took to the last election. He said the assumptions of the report were flawed. The capital cost for the new school at Waikato of $232 million was far greater than the other two options, which had costs of $49m and $81.5m respectively. The ongoing operational costs racked up over the years 2026 to 2042 were higher for the first two options, at $513.6m and $508m compared with $361.6m at Waikato. Bagg said this modelling made unfair and inaccurate assumptions about the existing two medical schools that put them at a disadvantage. For example, the business case said that it is 'more certain that Option 3, the Waikato school, has a lower operating cost … simply due to it being a shorter programme'. While it is correct that the Waikato Medical School is a shorter programme, tailored to just graduates, the students admitted the school will still have to offer an undergraduate programme somewhere, probably in New Zealand, which the Government will have to subsidise. Bagg said the cost of turning Waikato's students into graduates who can be admitted into the school isn't reflected in the business case. Lifting those costs out of the business case made Waikato look better overall. 'They are focused on the four-year graduate programme … they haven't focused on the three years that they'll have to do to get into that medical school,' he said. He said another way the high capital costs for Waikato have been 'offset' is the business case has found 'more benefits for the Waikato medical school'. The business case is particularly reliant on the assumption that far more Waikato graduates will go on to be GPs – and GPs who work rurally – than graduates of other schools. The business case found increasing capacity at the existing medical schools would result in just 23% of those graduates staying on to become GPs, while the joint rural training programme would result in 33% of its graduates becoming GPs. In the Waikato medical school's case, 38% of its graduates would become GPs. The business case notes that having a higher number of GPs in the community increases people's health. The fact the Waikato school provides the greatest number of GPs therefore weighs heavily in its favour. Benefits and costs of the three options analysed. Table / Ministry of Health Bagg said Sapere, who provided cost-benefit analysis for the business case, 'haven't used the data we provided them' to calculate the GP figure for the option of increasing capacity at Auckland And Otago. He said 'about 35%' of graduates from Auckland and Otago medical schools are working as GPs eight years after graduating – a far higher figure than the 23% quoted in the business case. He said this lower figure came from a survey of graduates' intentions when they graduated, not what they actually ended up doing. 'We told Sapere this assumption was incorrect,' he said. The assumptions for the number of GPs graduating from Waikato were based on figures from Australia's University of Wollongong Graduate School of Medicine, which will be a model for the Waikato school. Brown defended the modelling behind the business case. He said the school will 'offer a post-graduate medical qualification based on similar successful programmes in Australia'. 'These programmes include a year-long primary care placement and encourage students to work in primary care settings following graduation. The selection criteria of students alongside their long-term placements in primary care will both support a higher degree of these medical students to work in primary care after graduation,' he said. No expectation of ratepayer funding for med school – Brown Brown poured cold water on concerns councils could be asked to stump up for the new school. Brown's Cabinet paper suggested territorial authorities – local councils – are being lined up for a contribution to the school. A paragraph from the Cabinet paper progressing the school, which will be joint-funded by the Crown, the university and philanthropists, noted, '[t]he University of Waikato has identified $151.859 million which they will ... contribute towards the new medical school costs'. 'This contribution shows significant support for a new medical school from a range of stakeholders from private trusts and foundations, individuals, and territorial authorities'. But Brown told the Herald, 'as Minister of Health, I have no expectation that councils will financially contribute to the new Waikato Medical School'. University of Waikato vice-chancellor Neil Quigley told the Herald earlier this week about half of the university's $150m share of the school could come from donations. 'At the moment, we're well on the way to the 50% of donations just with a relatively small number of large trusts and very wealthy individuals so we don't see that as particularly challenging,' he said. Brown defends information release Labour's health spokeswoman Ayesha Verrall called for the business case to be published on Monday to show the assumptions underlying Cabinet's decision to proceed with the school. 'Treasury has raised concerns about this project. Decisions about the future of NZ's medical workforce are critical and must be transparent. The Government needs to release the costings quickly,' Verrall said. The business case was published by the Ministry of Health about 6pm on Friday, a time often associated with the Government trying to bury information because people are enjoying their weekend. Brown defended the timing of the release, saying: 'Cabinet made the decision to progress with the third medical school on Monday with officials tasked with preparing material for proactive release following this decision. 'Normally Cabinet decisions and supporting information are required to be proactively released 30 days following a decision, however due to the significant interest in this decision, this was sped up to ensure the information could be made available as quickly as possible.'
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Less than half of recent nursing graduates employed by Heath NZ
Nursing students and recent graduates say they are being "failed" by Health NZ, which has employed just 45% of mid-year graduates. Health NZ figures show just 323 of 722 applicants have got jobs in hospitals through its Advanced Choice of Employment Mid-Year matching process. Co-president of the Nurses Organisation student unit, Bianca Grimmer - who is set to graduate at the end of the year - said it was "really discouraging". "It's certainly affecting all of our cohorts from year one to year three, lot of uncertainty and students wondering if they continue with their degree or look at finding a job somewhere else. "Te Whatu Ora used to hire 80-90% of all graduates. We were blindsided this time last year when only three in every five mid-year graduates were hired. This year is even worse." Health NZ said for the mid-year matching process, there were 173 applications from graduates who were still looking for jobs after graduating at the end of last year. National Chief Nurse Nadine Gray said those who did not get hospital jobs were placed in the talent pool, which was open to all registered employers across the health sector. In recent years, the majority of initially unmatched applicants had successfully secured positions from the talent pool with about 84% of nurses eventually finding roles in both 2023 and 2024. "Graduate RNs [registered nurses] often look to hospitals for their first role, and while we are working to employ as many graduate RNs as possible, I want to encourage students to look right across the health system when looking for their first job." The government was investing in expanding and strengthening the nursing workforce in primary and community care, Gray said. The investment includes: $30 million over five years to fund 400 graduate nurses into primary and community care each year, with providers receiving $15,000 for employing a nurse in an urban setting and $20,000 in a rural setting. $34.2 million over five years to fund 120 nurse practitioner training places in primary care each year from 2026. An additional $21.6 million over four years to accelerate advanced tertiary education for up to 120 primary care registered nurses annually. The Nurses Organisation said a recent survey of 1246 nursing students found 62% would consider seeking a nursing job overseas if they were unable to get a new graduate job in Aotearoa New Zealand. This increased to 73% for Māori students. Bianca Grimmer said nursing students recently attended a jobs expo where Australian recruiters were offering graduates better wages and conditions. "We have a health system in crisis and desperately need more homegrown nurses. With 30,000 Kiwis leaving for Australia in the past year, this short-sighted decision by Te Whatu Ora will see more graduate nurses packing their bags." About 36,000 of NZNO's Te Whatu Ora members are preparing for a 24-hour national strike on July 30 after Collective Agreement negotiations stalled. The union said Health NZ's "refusal to commit to its obligation to employ new graduates" was one of the sticking points.
