Birmingham Heartlands Hospital left woman in cubicle without food
A hospital has promised to improve its A&E after a family told the BBC their 77-year-old mother was left in a "dirty" cubicle for 22 hours. Jill Clarke was admitted to Heartlands Hospital in Birmingham with a chest infection on 19 April, and her family claim she was left alone all night without any food or drink. Her son Peter said that when his mother was finally seen, she was given a meal he would not feed "to a pig" and was later left bruised by a ward nurse. A spokesperson for the hospital apologised and said it was experiencing high levels of demand.
Ms Clarke, from Shirley, requires full time care and lives with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), which causes breathing difficulties.She was discharged from Heartlands on 23 April, and is recovering from the infection. But her family have been left furious by her treatment during the four-day stay, and believe the current state of the hospital is unacceptable.
Mr Clarke claimed his mother had been put on a trolley with dried blood on, and then left in a "filthy" A&E cubicle with used syringes on a nearby window.The 45-year-old shared pictures of a meagre-looking meal his mother was apparently given, despite not having been offered anything to eat or drink for a long time. "I wouldn't have fed that meal to a pig," he said. "It was disgusting and they were giving that to a 77-year-old lady who hadn't eaten in 24 hours."
Mr Clarke further claimed his mother was hurt by a nurse who had been unable to put her cannula in properly.It happened after Ms Clarke was taken from the cubicle and put onto a ward, with a photo appearing to show her with a bruised arm. The hospital did not comment on this claim specifically. The family have made a formal complaint.
Mr Clarke explained his relatives had a proud history of working in the NHS. For many years, he was employed as a switchboard operator and a porter at West Middlesex University Hospital in London. The family, who now live in the West Midlands, have had to take Ms Clarke to Heartlands three times in the past five months. While Mr Clarke said April's visit was the worst, he believed the service was consistently poor. "It's every single day," he said. "It needs a complete shut down and a thorough deep clean."If [my] old boss had walked into A&E at Heartlands and did a quality control check, he would have shut the A&E down."
Heartlands Hospital is run by University Hospitals Birmingham. The trust has found itself under scrutiny since being heavily criticised in a March 2023 report over cases of bullying and a toxic environment. In February last year, inspectors said urgent and emergency care at Heartlands had improved from inadequate to requires improvement. A further Care Quality Commission probe in November found concerns about surgery and medical services at the hospital were "unfounded".
A Heartlands Hospital statement said all concerns were taken seriously and were being looked into appropriately."We are sorry to hear about Mrs Clarke's experience and we're grateful to her son Mr Clarke, for raising their concerns about her care," a spokesperson said. "Our emergency department is experiencing high levels of demand which can make maintaining the environment challenging at very busy times. "We have now instigated an intensive programme to improve the environment for all our patients."
Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
23 minutes ago
- BBC News
Paralysed man spends year writing letter of thanks
Three years ago, Leonard Mullin's life changed forever.A fall down the stairs at his home in County Tyrone left him paralysed from the chest down with limited use of his limbs."I remember going down the stairs and the next thing I remember is waking up days later in hospital," he told Leonard that the accident had caused an injury to his said: "My injury means that my movement is extremely limited. The accident left me a quadriplegic."I get some flickers of movement in my legs and in my arms, but very little."Leonard says he is thankful to be alive. "I'm lucky to have good family," he said."Mum found me first and then my sisters came to my aid, and then my neighbours and they phoned the ambulance."After the call to emergency services, the Northern Ireland Air Ambulance was Air Ambulance is a charity that works alongside staff from the Northern Ireland Ambulance Service. Leonard credits the Helicopter Emergency Medical Service that came to his aid that day with saving his an expression of his gratitude, Leonard decided to hand-write a letter of thanks to the paramedics that were there on the day of his accident. While putting pen to paper is something most of us do without thinking about, for Leonard, every letter and word he writes is a said: "I wanted to do something personal, something I could do myself, but it has been extremely challenging."I can only do so many words and letters a day and I have to use my left arm on days I am able to, but it takes up so much energy."It has taken more than year, but writing a couple of words a day, Leonard finished the letter to coincide with the third anniversary of his accident which occurred earlier this week."Finishing this letter has taken so much out of me, to me it's like climbing the highest mountain, but now that it's done, it means everything to me." The final paragraph of Leonard's letter reads:"Please share my heartfelt thanks with everyone involved in my rescue. I will forever hold your team in the highest regard, with deepest appreciation, Leonard Mullan."BBC News NI was there to capture the moment Leonard finished the letter and hand-delivered it to some of the paramedics that helped save his life. Damien McAnespie from Air Ambulance NI said: "This is an incredible challenge that Leonard set for himself."He and his family should be very proud of what he has achieved."Following the emotional scenes of Leonard handing over the letter, he said that he hoped his story might provide others with added: "Finishing the letter feels like the best achievement of my life and words cant express my gratitude to the air ambulance and the ambulance crew."But I also hope it shows people that even if you have a spinal injury like mine, if you don't give up, you will be surprised with what you can achieve, just keep on going."
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
New ambulances to deliver faster care to East of England patients
The East of England will receive 29 new ambulances to help deliver faster emergency care for new ambulances will replace ageing vehicles in the organisation's fleet by March than £4.5m will be invested in the new vehicles for the East of England Ambulance Trust as part of a nationwide Secretary Wes Streeting said the vehicles would "make a real difference to patients". The rollout follows the government's new package of investment and reforms to improve patients' experiences of urgent and emergency care this year. This included caring for more patients in the community, rather than in by about £450m of funding, the plan aimed to deliver about 40 new Same Day Emergency Care and Urgent Treatment also aimed to create up to 15 mental health crisis assessment centres so patients can avoid waiting in A&E for hours for 500 new ambulances will be provided to services said: "These 29 new ambulances will make a real difference to patients in the East of England, replacing old and tired vehicles and getting to patients in minutes, rather than hours."We can't fix more than a decade of underinvestment and neglect overnight. But through the measures we're setting out today, we will deliver faster and more convenient care for patients in emergencies." Follow East of England news on X, Instagram and Facebook: BBC Beds, Herts & Bucks, BBC Cambridgeshire, BBC Essex, BBC Norfolk, BBC Northamptonshire or BBC Suffolk.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
I'm a trainer specialising in longevity – these are the five exercises that have the biggest impact on my clients
One of the biggest misconceptions about exercise is how quickly its effects take hold. While some impacts are immediate, like the release of feel-good hormones, most real change takes time and a good degree of consistency. However, some exercise and lifestyle tweaks offer better return on investment than others. This is something Welltolead founder and longevity specialist Ollie Thompson has found over the course of his 10-plus-year career. Below, he shares the five habits that have repeatedly made the biggest difference to his clients' health, fitness and everyday functionality, including prescriptive tips to help you reap the benefits on your mind and body after a day, week, month and year. 1. Increase your daily step count – consistently and often Walking more is one of the most common modern health recommendations, yet in Thompson's eyes, it remains undervalued. His advice is also more nuanced than most, going beyond a simple daily step count to hit. 'When it comes to building a routine for healthspan and longevity, the details really do matter,' he says. 'I believe we get much more benefit when our steps are broken up throughout the day. This approach not only helps you reach your step goals, but also supports muscle and joint health by keeping your body engaged more consistently.' Long periods of sitting leave muscles and joints underutilised, leading to stiffness, discomfort and an increased risk of developing muscular and joint problems over time. 'Moving regularly throughout the day helps maintain circulation, keeps muscles gently engaged and supports joint health, all of which contribute to feeling better and reducing pain risks as you age,' Thompson explains. Thompson's tips: Aim for a daily step count of at least 10,000 steps. I understand this isn't easy for most people, especially with work, family and life commitments, so focus on spreading those steps out across the day. Try to move at least once every 30-60 minutes during your day, whether it's a short walk, climbing the stairs or just pacing around a little. Setting reminders on your phone or watch can help make this a consistent habit. Changing positions regularly, standing up more often or using a walking pad can be an excellent way to integrate more movement into your routine. I also recommend a short 10-15 minute walk directly after a meal – research suggests this can significantly improve blood sugar regulation, help digestion and reduce post-meal energy crashes, making it a great habit to support energy and long-term metabolic h ealth. 2. Build your nutrition around protein and fibre It can be hard to navigate the world of nutritional advice without being bombarded by a new fad diet or dietary hack. Thompson suggests ignoring these in favour of a simpler approach. 'I've found that helping clients focus on just two fundamentals – protein and fibre – can radically improve their energy levels, body composition and long-term health,' he says. 'It's a simple shift that delivers big results. 'Protein supports muscle repair and maintenance, which is especially important as we age. It also plays a key role in satiety, which is key in helping to manage hunger, reduce snacking and support fat loss. 'Fibre, on the other hand, is critical for gut health, blood sugar control and sustaining energy throughout the day. It also helps you feel fuller for longer, which naturally supports healthier portion control.' Thompson's tips: Start each meal with protein and fibre. Aim for a palm-sized portion of protein (about 25-40g, depending on your needs) with every main meal – this could be chicken, fish, eggs, Greek yoghurt, tofu, lentils, protein powder, etc. Each day, you should be aiming for 1.5-2g of protein per kilogram of bodyweight. Aim to include a handful or two of fibrous vegetables and/or whole-food fibre sources like oats, beans, berries or whole grains with each meal. Aim to consume at least 25-30g of fibre per day. By repeating this simple framework at most meals, your energy, appetite and overall Health will improve dramatically without needing a restrictive or complicated diet plan. 3. Don't neglect your hips and posterior chain The posterior chain refers to the muscles that run along the back side of your body – think hamstrings, glutes and back muscles. Thompson has consistently identified these as 'problem areas' among clients, particularly in those who spend a lot of their day sitting at a desk. 'These muscles are essential for maintaining good posture, producing power and strength, and keeping your body moving well and pain-free,' he says. 'But modern life tends to impair the function of these areas. Long hours spent seated can leave the hips tight, the glutes not working as they should, and the pelvis in a rotated position. 'Over time, this can create imbalances that lead to stiffness, a loss of range of motion, lower back discomfort, dysfunction with how you walk and a higher risk of injury.' He has found that consistently strengthening the muscles of the posterior chain and mobilising the hips can counter these unwanted effects, and go 'a long way to future-proofing the body, from both a function and a pain prevention perspective'. Thompson's tips: Train your glutes, hamstrings and key hip muscles – such as the hip flexors, glute medius and adductors – at least once per week, ideally within a full-body or lower-body workout. Prioritise movements like glute bridges, hip thrusts, Romanian deadlifts, kettlebell swings, Copenhagen planks, hamstring curls and single-leg variations of lower-body exercises such as the Bulgarian split squat. Aim to target these key muscle groups with a few challenging sets of 8-12 repetitions each week. I recommend five sets for the hamstrings, five sets for the glutes and two or three sets on each of the key hip muscles mentioned. Alongside direct strength training for these areas, attempt to break up long periods of sitting with short bursts of movement such as standing and walking. Even better, adopt a short stretching routine into your day that involves you stretching these muscles using moves like a hamstring stretch, couch stretch and 90/90 stretch. 4. Make the most of your rest periods Strength training is a key ingredient in any recipe for longevity – the point above makes that abundantly clear. Typically, this means performing one set of an exercise, resting for 60-plus seconds, then repeating. But Thompson says this rest period need not be 'dead time' during a savvy exerciser's session. 'Those short breaks are actually a huge opportunity to work on non-conflicting areas of your body,' he says. 'By staying active between sets – performing mobility drills or doing low-intensity dynamic stretches – you're making more efficient use of your training time by working on these crucial areas that need attention but often get missed out.' 'It's a method I've used for years with many of my clients that has helped them to achieve excellent results without spending more time working out.' Thompson's tips: Use your rest periods to do something intentional. For example: stretch your hip flexors with a couch stretch on a bench; mobilise your thoracic spine [or mid-spine] over a foam roller; hold a deep squat as you slow down your breathing; do a scapula push-up between sets of lunges. Pick movements that target stiff areas but don't conflict with what you're training. For example, hold a deep squat between sets of chest press. 5. Focus on sleep quality, even when quantity isn't perfect Despite being a blanket prescription in most health circles, bedding in for eight hours of sleep per night is a pipe dream for most people. If you are unable to increase your sleep quantity, Thompson recommends honing your sleep quality for tangible results. 'Sleep is the body's most powerful recovery tool. It supports nearly every function of the body, from muscle repair and hormone regulation to mental sharpness, immunity and more,' he says. 'But in real life, aiming for a perfect eight hours every night just isn't always realistic. Work, kids, stress, travel – life gets in the way. 'What I've found makes the biggest difference is having a simple, consistent structure you can stick to, even during busier or more chaotic weeks. It's not about being perfect – it's about maximising sleep quality when quantity is compromised.' Thompson's tips: Establish a consistent wake-up time. This is one of the simplest ways to regulate your body clock, even if your bedtime shifts. Build a short wind-down routine you can stick to. This might involve being screen-free for 15-30 minutes, or doing low-stimulation activities such as reading, writing and light stretching before sleep. Ensure your bedroom is dark, cool and as quiet as you can make it. Cut off caffeine after 2pm and limit alcohol in the evening. I often prescribe my 2/2/2 rule to my clients; no more than two alcoholic drinks, no more than two times per week, and not within two hours of bed. What changes can you expect to see from making these changes? After one day: The first change you are likely to notice is an increase in your energy levels, Thompson says. 'Simply moving more, especially outdoors in natural light, and having a better night of sleep can have an almost immediate impact on how you feel.' After one week: Seven days in, the compounding effects of regular movement and targeted mobility work should be coming to fruition. 'You may start to notice stiffness and muscle tension easing up, and your body feeling a little looser,' Thompson says. After one month: Sticking to the behaviours above, Thompson says you will likely feel more mobile and stronger after a month, with higher energy levels and less stiffness throughout the day. 'By this point, the actions start to feel more like habits and become part of your routine, rather than a chore you need to remind yourself to do,' he adds. After one year: A year is a long time to stick to anything, but if you can habituate some – or all – of Thompson's recommendations, he says you can 'expect to feel substantially better day-to-day'. 'Your movement will feel easier, and both your physical and mental energy will be at new highs. These changes will have become a natural part of your life, and a day where you don't hit 10,000 steps will feel odd and strangely uncomfortable,' he continues. 'You'll be creating opportunities to get outside and move your body; your overall nutrition will look different, with protein, fibre, vegetables and beans taking centre stage; and you'll protect your sleep like you protect your exercise time.' The mindset shift that makes the greatest difference of all There is one further recurring theme Thompson has spotted among his successful clients – and it's not physical. 'One of my biggest learnings over the years is that many clients start their fitness journey with short-term, appearance-driven goals – losing weight for a holiday, looking good for an event or fitting back into some old wardrobe favourites,' he explains. 'But what's been interesting to witness, time and time again, is how quickly those goals shift. Once people begin training consistently and start feeling the benefits, their perspective changes. Aesthetic goals take a back seat to something deeper: how they feel in their bodies and how well they can live their lives. That mindset shift is where the real transformation happens.' Thompson works with a diverse range of clients, from business founders and bankers to stage performers and doctors. And after training with him for some time, one of their greatest goals invariably becomes living better for longer. 'I genuinely love that this mindset shift happens so often,' he says. 'I regularly use it to help clients realise that the ability to feel great and remain physically capable in your sixties, seventies, and eighties doesn't begin when you get there – it starts in your thirties, forties, and fifties. This is the prime window to elevate your health and strength, future-proofing your body for the decades ahead.'
