Minister's Death Spooks Russian Elite Amid Corruption Clampdown
Roman Starovoyt was buried in Saint Petersburg on Friday, with his family weeping at his open coffin before it was lowered into the ground.
The 53-year-old was found dead in his car on Monday in an elite Moscow suburb -- hours after Putin issued a decree to fire him, with no explanation.
Russian investigators say he shot himself.
Media reports said he was being investigated for corruption and could have been arrested within days.
While government departments sent flowers and some ministers attended a memorial ceremony in Moscow a day earlier, there was unease over the fate of Starovoyt, who had climbed the ranks of Russia's bureaucracy to a seat in the cabinet.
Many who came to the ceremony in Moscow refused to speak to AFP.
"It's a great loss. Very unexpected," said Valentina, a 42-year-old translator whose husband worked with Starovoyt.
"He was very active, cheerful and loved life very much. I don't know how it happened."
Starovoyt had been governor of Russia's western Kursk region before being promoted to Moscow, just a few months before Ukrainian troops captured dozens of border settlements in a surprise cross-border incursion.
His successor was arrested in the spring for embezzling funds intended to beef up the fortifications that Ukraine ended up slicing through with ease.
"They tried to make him the scapegoat... It's easier to put the blame on a civilian official," political commentator Andrey Pertsev told AFP.
The case is one part of a wider crackdown on officials alleged to have enriched themselves at the expense of the Russian army during the Ukraine offensive.
The crackdown is a Kremlin campaign that has ripped up previous norms about what is acceptable for Russian officials.
"There used to be rules, where people knew that once you climbed up high enough, they wouldn't mess with you," Pertsev said.
"But they do not work any more."
In a sign of how out of favour Starovoyt had become, Putin has not publicly commented on his death.
Asked if Putin would attend the ceremony in Moscow, his spokesman told reporters: "The president has a different work schedule today."
At the funeral in Saint Petersburg on Friday, two regional governors were the highest-ranking officials to show face.
While Putin has criticised corruption and vowed to stamp it out throughout his 25 years in power, his rule has been characterised by systemic graft, critics say.
The smattering of high-profile arrests has more typically been used to target opponents or come about as the result of infighting among those lower down Russia's chain of power.
But the military offensive against Ukraine has changed that.
"Something within the system has started to work completely differently," analyst Tatiana Stanovaya wrote after Starovoyt's death.
"Any action or inaction that, in the eyes of the authorities, increases the state's vulnerability to hostile actions by the enemy must be punished mercilessly and uncompromisingly," Stanovaya said.
In such a climate, it was inevitable that heads would have to roll over the Kursk failings.
Nina Khrushcheva, a professor at The New School, a university in New York City, said Starovoyt's apparent suicide showed the Russian elite was "scared".
The current climate is such that "it is impossible to leave the top brass", said Khrushcheva, who is also the great-granddaughter of Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev.
"This is something we have not really seen since 1953," she told AFP, referring to Joseph Stalin's execution of a close ally.
To the Kremlin, the Ukraine military campaign is a "holy war" that has rewritten the rules of loyalty and service.
"During a holy war, you don't steal... You tighten your belts and work 24 hours a day to make the weapons you need."
That atmosphere, said Stanovaya, has created a "sense of hopelessness" among officials in Moscow that is unlikely to fade.
"Going forward, the system will be ready to sacrifice increasingly prominent figures," she warned. 'They tried to make a scapegoat of Starovoyt,' political commentator Andrey Pertsev says AFP The reported suicide of Russia's transport minister has shocked the country's elite AFP Putin did not attend the funeral or farewell ceremony AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
34 minutes ago
- Int'l Business Times
China's Economy Grows 5.2% On Trade War Truce
China's economy expanded more than five percent in the second quarter of the year, official data showed on Tuesday, after analysts predicted strong exports would provide crucial support despite trade war pressures. The country's leadership is fighting a multi-front battle to sustain growth, a challenge made more difficult by Donald Trump's tariff campaign. The US president has imposed tolls on China and most other major trading partners since returning to office in January, threatening Beijing's exports just as it becomes more reliant on them to stimulate economic activity. The two superpowers have sought to de-escalate their trade spat after reaching a framework for a deal at talks in London last month, but observers warn of lingering uncertainty. Trump upped the ante on Monday, warning Russia's trading partners -- which include China -- that he will impose "very severe" tariffs reaching 100 percent if Moscow fails to end its war on Ukraine within 50 days. Western nations have repeatedly urged China -- a key commercial ally of Russia -- to wield its influence and get Vladimir Putin to stop his three-year-old war with Ukraine. Official data on Tuesday showed the Chinese economy grew 5.2 percent in April-June, matching a prediction by an AFP survey of analysts. But retail sales rose 4.8 percent on-year, below the 5.3 percent forecast in a Bloomberg survey of economists, suggesting efforts to kickstart consumption have fallen flat. However, factory output gained 6.8 percent, higher than the 5.6 percent estimate. "The national economy withstood pressure and made steady improvement despite challenges," National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) deputy director Sheng Laiyun told a news conference. "Production and demand grew steadily, employment was generally stable, household income continued to increase, new growth drivers witnessed robust development, and high-quality development made new strides," he said. Data from the General Administration of Customs on Monday showed exports rose much more than expected in June, helped by the US-China trade truce. Imports also rose 1.1 percent, higher than the 0.3 percent gain predicted and marking the first growth this year. Customs official Wang Lingjun told a news conference on Monday that Beijing hoped "the US will continue to work together with China towards the same direction", state broadcaster CCTV reported. The tariff truce was "hard won", Wang said. "There is no way out through blackmail and coercion. Dialogue and cooperation are the right path," he said. However, many analysts are anticipating slower growth in the next six months of the year, with persistently sluggish domestic demand proving a key drag. Data released last week showed that consumer prices edged up in June, barely snapping a four-month deflationary dip, but factory gate prices dropped at their fastest clip in nearly two years. The producer price index, which measures the price of wholesale goods as they leave the factory, declined 3.6 percent year-on-year last month, extending a years-long negative run. Economists argue that China needs to shift towards a growth model propelled more by domestic consumption than the traditional key drivers of infrastructure investment, manufacturing and exports. Beijing has introduced a slew of measures since last year in a bid to boost spending, including a consumer goods trade-in subsidy scheme that briefly lifted retail activity.
Int'l Business Times
34 minutes ago
- Int'l Business Times
Asian Markets Mixed As China's Economy Meets Forecasts
Markets were mixed Tuesday as positive Chinese economic data was offset by weak consumer spending, while optimism that governments will hammer out deals to avoid the worst of Donald Trump's tariff threats provided support. Beijing said gross domestic product expanded 5.2 percent in April-June thanks to a surge in exports as businesses front-loaded shipments ahead of the US president's stiff levies, and after the superpowers agreed to work on a long-term pact. While the reading was slightly slower than the first quarter, it was in line with forecasts in an AFP survey and comes after figures on Monday showed exports soared more than expected in June, including a strong recovery in goods sent to the United States. Meanwhile, industrial output came in above expectations. However, Tuesday's reports showed efforts to boost consumer activity continue to fall flat, with retail sales expanding 4.8 percent last month, well below estimates in a Bloomberg study and highlighting the work leaders face in kickstarting the economy. China's recovery has been hamstrung by a bruising trade war with the United States, driven by Trump's sweeping tariffs, though the two de-escalated their spat with a framework for a deal at talks in London last month. But observers warn of lingering uncertainty. "The national economy withstood pressure and made steady improvement despite challenges," National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) deputy director Sheng Laiyun told a news conference. "Production and demand grew steadily, employment was generally stable, household income continued to increase, new growth drivers witnessed robust development, and high-quality development made new strides," he said. And the US president upped the ante Monday, warning Russia's trading partners -- which include China -- that he will impose tariffs reaching 100 percent if Moscow fails to end its war on Ukraine within 50 days. After a strong start to the day, Hong Kong pared an early rally while Shanghai dipped into negative territory. Elsewhere, Tokyo, Sydney, Singapore, Wellington, Taipei and Jakarta rose, with Seoul and Manila in the red. Trump also Monday said he will impose antidumping duties on most imports of fresh tomatoes from Mexico, with the US Commerce Department accusing its neighbour of engaging in unfair trade. That came after he said he would hit the country and the European Union with 30 percent levies, having announced a slew of measures against key partners last week if deals are not struck by August 1. However, analysts said investors viewed the warnings as negotiating ploys rather than a genuine move, citing previous threats that were later rowed back. The mixed performance in Asian markets followed a healthy day on Wall Street, where the Nasdaq hit another record high. Bitcoin edged down after hitting a record high above $123,200 on Monday thanks to optimism over possible regulatory changes for crypto assets in the United States. Tokyo - Nikkei 225: UP 0.1 percent at 39,507.28 (break) Hong Kong - Hang Seng Index: UP 0.5 percent at 24,315.92 Shanghai - Composite: DOWN 0.4 percent at 3,503.99 Euro/dollar: UP at $1.1674 from $1.1670 Pound/dollar: UP at $1.3434 from $1.3428 Dollar/yen: DOWN at 147.63 yen from 147.77 yen Euro/pound: UP at 86.90 pence from 86.88 pence West Texas Intermediate: DOWN 0.4 percent at $66.70 per barrel Brent North Sea Crude: DOWN 0.3 percent at $68.98 per barrel New York - Dow: UP 0.2 percent at 44,459.65 (close) London - FTSE 100: UP 0.6 percent at 8,998.06 (close)
Int'l Business Times
an hour ago
- Int'l Business Times
Divided EU Weighs Action Against Israel Over Gaza War
EU foreign ministers on Tuesday will discuss a raft of options for action against Israel over the war in Gaza -- but likely will not agree on any. The bloc's foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas has put forward 10 potential steps after Israel was found to have breached a cooperation deal between the two sides on human rights grounds. The measures range from suspending the entire accord or curbing trade ties to sanctioning Israeli ministers, imposing an arms embargo and halting visa-free travel. But despite growing anger over the devastation in Gaza, EU states remain divided over how to tackle Israel and diplomats say there appears to be no critical mass for any move. "I was asked to give the inventory of the options that could be taken and it's up to the member states to discuss what do we do with these options," Kallas said Monday. The tone of discussions will be shaped strongly by how Israel is implementing a promise to the EU to improve humanitarian access to Gaza. Kallas said Thursday she had struck a deal with her Israeli counterpart, Gideon Saar, to open more entry points and allow in more food. Gaza's two million residents are facing dire humanitarian conditions as Israel has severely limited aid during its devastating war with Palestinian militant group Hamas. "We see some good signs of more trucks getting in," Kallas said Monday. "But of course we know that this is not enough and we need to push more (so) that the implementation of what we have agreed also happens on the ground." At a meeting of EU and neighbouring countries in Brussels on Monday, Jordanian foreign minister Ayman Safadi said the situation in Gaza remained "catastrophic". Israel's Saar, speaking at the same meeting, sounded confident his country would avoid further EU action. "I'm sure not any of them will be adopted by the EU member states," said the foreign minister. "There's no justification whatsoever." While the EU appears unable for now to take any further moves against Israel, just getting to this stage has been a considerable step. The bloc only agreed to review the cooperation deal after Israel relaunched its devastating operation in Gaza following the collapse of a ceasefire in March. Until then deep divisions between countries backing Israel and those more favourable to the Palestinians had hamstrung any move. The war was sparked by Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack on Israel, which led to 1,219 deaths, most of them civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Of the 251 people taken hostage by militants that day, 49 are still held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. Hamas-run Gaza's health ministry says that at least 58,386 Palestinians, most of them civilians, have been killed in Israel's retaliatory campaign. The UN considers those figures reliable.
