Birkenstock loses German court fight to call its sandals art
Birkenstocks may be ubiquitous on the streets of Europe but they cannot be considered art, Germany's Federal Court of Justice has ruled.
Birkenstock, which is headquartered in Linz am Rhein in western Germany and says its tradition of shoemaking goes back to 1774, had filed a lawsuit against three competitors who sold sandals that were very similar to its own.
The shoe manufacturer claimed its sandals 'are copyright-protected works of applied art" that may not simply be imitated.
Under German law, works of art enjoy stronger and longer-last intellectual property protections than ordinary consumer products.
The Porsche 356 car is protected by the law as is furniture by the Swiss-French artist Le Corbusier, and lighting designed by the Bauhaus art movement.
The company asked for an injunction to stop its competitors from making copycat sandals and order them to recall and destroy those already on the market.
The copycat companies were not identified in the court statement.
Before Germany's highest court for civil trials weighed in this Thursday, the case had been heard at two lower courts, which disagreed on the issue.
A regional court in Cologne initially recognised the shoe models as works of applied art and granted the orders, but Cologne's higher regional court later overturned the orders on appeal, German news agency dpa reported.
The appeals court said it was unable to establish any artistic achievement in the wide-strapped sandals with a big buckle.
On Thursday, the Federal Court of Justice sided with Cologne's higher regional court and dismissed the case.
In its ruling, it wrote that a product can't be copyrighted if "technical requirements, rules or other constraints determine the design."
So when it comes to Birkenstock's sandals, functionality and craft trumps art – at least in the eyes of the law.
'For the copyright protection of a work of applied art – as for all other types of work – the level of design must not be too low,' the court wrote.
'Purely technical creation using formal design elements is not eligible for copyright protection. Rather, for copyright protection, a level of design must be achieved that reveals individuality.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Debenhams drops 'classy and unique' diamond watch down from £2,700 to £213
Shoppers have praised the timepiece as 'awe-inspiring' For those wanting a sparkly new addition to their watch collection, Debenhams is continuing to slash the price off a range of luxury timepieces that are sure to command attention. Shoppers are even able to save thousands of pounds on these gorgeous accessories. One beautiful timepiece that shoppers won't want to miss is the GV2 Palmanova Blue Dial Watch. Originally priced at £2,695, watch enthusiasts can now snap up this diamond watch for only £213.75 in the sale. Slashing 92 per cent off its price tag, Debenhams is saving shoppers a whopping £2,481.25. Designed and crafted by luxury brand Gervil, this GV2 watch is said to be characterised by its strength and beauty. Inspired by the stunning star-shaped Renaissance fortress - Palmanova - Gervil has described this watch as one of their "newest masterpieces". With an "awe-inspiring" octagonal bezel, the blue dial also captures the eye with its six delicately placed diamonds at the 12 o'clock hour marker. In contrast, the watch also features a date window just above the six o'clock marker for added practicality. Powered by a Swiss quartz movement, this watch will keep its wearer efficiently on time while also exuding a confident elegance. The 33mm case is also coated in an anti-reflective sapphire crystal to allow users to easily see the time. This timepiece is finished off with a stainless steel bracelet and deployment buckle for added comfort and security. On top of this, the watch has a water resistance of 30m, so it should be able to withstand any accidental drops into water. GV2 Palmanova Blue Dial Watch £2,695 £213.75 Debenhams Buy Now Product Description Another luxury watch in the Debenhams sale is the GV2 Milan Silver Dial Diamond Watch. Usually retailing for £2,895, savvy shoppers can now buy it for £390. Featuring a diamond encrusted design, this elegant silver watch would make the perfect companion to a formal event. For those looking for something more budget friendly, H. Samuel had put the Hugo#Friend Watch down to a clearance price of £99. Normally priced at £199, the watch features a dark blue dial that beautifully contrasts with the rose gold bracelet, hour markers and hands. Back to the GV2 Palmanova watch, the timepiece currently hasn't got any reviews on the Debenhams website. While this may put some shoppers off, the watch has managed to garner a perfect five star rating on the Gervil website - although this is only from a few shoppers. One shopper left high praise of the watch, writing: "The craftsmanship on this watch is truly exquisite. The background history of the Gevril brand is so interestingly impressive, that I say it every time I'm asked about my watch. "The tones and dimensions of each metal are at the perfect measure giving the watch a surreal look on anyone's wrist. The band goes from wide near the face to thin in width giving it a feminine complimentary flattering look. The photos truly do not give this watch justice! "It looks amazing in person and the weight alone is value in itself. The diamonds are perfectly placed and the face of the watch was designed with a simple faint spiral design that gives the watch an enrichment and classy feel. I hope Gevril continues to embark on the elegant timeless pieces such as this one. Very well done!" A third satisfied customer also said: "I was so happy when I received my watch so beautiful and price was very good." While a fourth shopper added on: "It's a very nice watch classy and unique. Super excited to use it now." For those who want to buy the GV2 Palmanova Blue Dial Watch, click HERE. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
NBC News
4 hours ago
- NBC News
'No plans' for a Trump-Musk call to tamp down their feud, White House chief of staff says
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump will not be calling billionaire Elon Musk on Friday after their feud exploded into public, White House chief of staff Susie Wiles. 'There are no plans for that today," Wiles told NBC News when asked about reporting by Politico that White House aides scheduled a call Friday with the billionaire Tesla CEO to try to patch things up between the two men. Trump is "not interested" in a call, a senior White House official told NBC News. White House press secretary said Trump is focused on the "One Big Beautiful Bill," the GOP domestic policy bill that Musk trashed, which triggered their falling out. "That's the mindset he left the Oval Office in yesterday," Leavitt said. A Trump administration official added, 'There could be anything — I'd like to de-escalate a very unfortunate situation. But there are no calls on the books, at least not now.' The spat began Thursday when Trump criticized Musk's recent attacks on the Republican policy measure over its estimated increase to the deficit, and turned into a full-scale blow-up that sent ripples through the halls of Congress and Tesla's stock prices. 'I'm very disappointed because Elon knew the inner workings of this bill better than almost anybody sitting here, better than you people,' Trump told reporters in the Oval Office during a bilateral meeting with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. 'I'm very disappointed in Elon," Trump said. "I've helped Elon a lot.' Trump suggested that Musk, who earlier this week called the GOP bill a 'disgusting abomination,' was upset that the bill cut out a tax credit implemented by the Biden administration to incentivize electric vehicle purchases. Musk denied he was knowledgeable about the legislation. "False, this bill was never shown to me even once and was passed in the dead of night so fast that almost no one in Congress could even read it!" Musk wrote in a post to X. The two men spent the rest of the day Thursday lobbing insults at each other on their own social media platforms — Musk on X and Trump on Truth Social.
Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Spanish island 'sounds alarm' over tourist issue and it doesn't involve Brits
The Alcudia and Can Picafort hoteliers association has sounded the alarm that bookings on the island are down on last year, particularly among holidaymakers from Germany Germans are abandoning a beautiful holiday island beloved by Brits. Brits and Germans have long been among the biggest forces in European travel, both sharing similar tastes in sunshine resorts on the coast. It seems that our neighbours on the Continent are now growing a little tired of a well-worn holiday classic - Majorca. The Alcudia and Can Picafort hoteliers association has sounded the alarm that bookings on the island are down on last year, especially among travellers from Germany, their principal markets. Bar and restaurant takings were down by between 15 and 20 percent compared to last year, which is a significant blow for an industry already struggling. The president of the Association, Pablo Riera-Marsa, said: "We are seeing how the German market, traditionally our number one market, is the one that has slowed down the most. In addition, we are detecting that this season, last-minute bookings are once again becoming more popular, with tourists waiting for special offers and promotions before making their purchase decisions." The travel chief warned that the "Champagne effect" which followed the coronavirus pandemic, when many tourist destinations enjoyed long periods of high demand as pent-up travellers sought holidays following the lockdowns, is now over. "It is essential to continue to focus on quality, sustainability and differentiation, especially in a context in which the market is once again stabilising and last-minute bookings are becoming increasingly important," Mr Riera-Marsa added, the Majorca Daily Bulletin reported. Dwindling demand from some markets is not the only issue facing holidaymakers at the moment. Workers in a popular Spanish holiday destination are threatening to strike during the peak season. READ MORE: Magaluf hotel pool rules ditched as 'towel warriors' cause sunbeds chaos Hotel bosses in Tenerife are facing a stark threat from union leaders: agree to a pay rise within the next fortnight or brace for strike action in the peak of summer. Hospitality chiefs were hit with an ultimatum last week by the General Union of Workers, the UGT, announcing to employers: "You have 15 days to raise wages or there will be a strike in the summer." Sindicalistas de Base, the leading union on the bargaining committee, has warned that failure to reach a deal by June 13 will result in a call to action with strikes during July and August. The unions demanded an unconditional salary hike retroactive to January 2025 as a precondition to discussing the rest of the items. The impending strikes could be an echo of the walkouts experienced during Easter Thursday and Friday, after protracted negotiations failed to lead to a deal. The rallying cry of the workers is for a 6.5% wage hike – an additional 4.5% atop the 2% already sanctioned by the collective agreement.
