NA panel slams 'brutal' tax law
A parliamentary committee on Friday expressed serious reservations over the recently promulgated the Tax Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 2025, declaring it a brutal measure.
A meeting of the National Assembly's Standing Committee on Finance was held at the Parliament House under the chairmanship of Syed Naveed Qamar. During the meeting, members belonging to the PPP expressed reservations over the presidential decree.
Commenting on it, Qamar noted that the tax ordinance was issued just a day before the National Assembly session. "This is highly inappropriate. What was the emergency that required issuing a tax ordinance before the June budget?" he asked.
Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial stated that while sales tax law allows production monitoring, this provision was absent in income tax.
He claimed that poultry companies were involved in tax evasion, noting that the cost of producing a chick is Rs65 to Rs75, while companies are making Rs100 profit per chick daily.
"A company had been paying Rs1.3 billion in annual tax but actually it owed Rs10 billion. After action was taken against the company, chicken prices began to decrease," he stated.
He said income tax returns of similar companies are fraudulent. "The presidential ordinance grants the FBR authority to monitor production and empowers it to recover taxes after orders from the Commissioner Appeals, Assessment Officer, and Tribunal,' he said.
The chairman revealed that tax evasion in the tobacco sector is estimated between Rs250 to Rs300 billion and that provincial police and administration will be given powers to catch tax evaders.
However, he admitted the ordinance will not yield substantial recovery, estimating only a 5% to 10% increase or about Rs30 billion in additional revenue. He said both the Federal Cabinet and the president had made an informed decision in issuing the ordinance.
Naveed Qamar warned that police officers may abandon their regular duties to pursue tax enforcement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan debt stock reaches all-time high of Rs75trn
KARACHI: The federal government's total debt stock surged by over Rs 6 trillion during the first ten months of this fiscal year (FY25) due to massive borrowing to finance the budget deficit. According to a statistic released by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) on Wednesday, the central government's total debt, comprising domestic and external liabilities, rose by 9 percent during July-April of FY25. Overall, the stock reached an all-time high level of Rs 74.936 trillion by the end of April 2025 compared to Rs 68.914 trillion as of June 2024, depicting an increase of Rs 6.022 trillion. The major growth in debt stocks was attributed to domestic borrowings, which rose by 11.37 percent or Rs 5.363 trillion to reach Rs 52.523 trillion in April 2025 up from Rs 47.16 trillion in June 2024. The domestic debt comprised long-term loans worth Rs 44.132 trillion and short-term borrowings amounting to Rs 8.328 trillion. Pakistan govt's debt stock soars to Rs73.6trn by March-end External debt, in rupee terms, saw an increase of Rs 659 billion during the first ten months of FY25, reaching Rs 22.413 trillion by the end of April 2025 compared to Rs 21.754 trillion in June 2024. The SBP reported that the Weighted Average Customer Exchange Rate of the US dollar was Rs 278.3668 in June 2024 and Rs 280.9739 in April 2025. The federal government's debt showed a notable increase of Rs 1.248 trillion in April 2025 due to massive borrowing to finance the budget deficit. On a month-on-month (MoM) basis, the federal government's debt stock rose by 2 percent from Rs 73.688 trillion in March 2025 to Rs 74.936 trillion in April 2025. Analysts noted that the tax collection by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is 26 percent higher during the first eleven (July-May) months of this fiscal year compared to previous year; however, cumulatively FBR has failed to achieve the target. The shortfall in revenue collection has compelled the federal government to borrow from domestic and external resources. FBR had missed its revenue collection target by some one trillion rupees in the first eleven months of this fiscal year due to lower imports and slowing economic growth. The FBR has collected some Rs10.233 trillion between July-May of FY25 as against the budgetary target of Rs11.241 trillion for the same period. The SBP has already emphasised the need for a sharp acceleration in tax revenue growth to meet the annual targets. Achieving the primary balance target remains a significant challenge for the government. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
16 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PM writes to opp to confer on new CEC
After months of dead air and no movement on key electoral appointments, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday extended an olive branch to National Assembly Opposition Leader Omar Ayub, inviting him for consultations on the appointment of a new Chief Election Commissioner (CEC). In a letter, the premier stated that the term of the CEC, as well as that of two other members of the ECP, ended on January 26. However, all three have continued their duties under Article 215 of the Constitution. He stated that, according to Article 218, proposals for the CEC and its members must be submitted to the parliamentary committee. The letter comes as the constitutional logjam has been festering since January, as the five-year terms of CEC Sikandar Sultan Raja, Sindh Member Nisar Durrani and Balochistan Member Shah Muhammad Jatoi ended on January 26. The process, laid out clearly in Article 213, requires a consensus between the prime minister and the opposition leader. In the event of no agreement, both sides are supposed to send separate lists of three names to a 12-member bipartisan committee, which would then pick one and send it to the president for formal appointment. However, the process has been gathering dust. Though the seats of the CEC and two members expired in January, the government allowed the 45-day constitutional deadline for new appointments, which lapsed on March 12, to come and go without resolution. The impasse now rests at the feet of both the treasury and opposition, with neither side making serious contact until the PM's letter. On the other hand, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) has already taken the government to court in March. A petition filed in the Islamabad High Court by Ayub and Senate Opposition Leader Shibli Faraz lambasts the inaction as a constitutional violation. It names the federal government, Senate chairman, National Assembly speaker and the ECP as respondents. The petition urges the court to compel the National Assembly speaker to constitute the required parliamentary committee and calls on the Senate chairman to provide names of senators for the same. It further asks the court to order the prime minister to hold meaningful consultations with Ayub, as required under Article 213, and to declare the continued presence of the CEC and two expired members as illegal. Constitutional experts point to the 26th Amendment, which altered Article 215(4) to allow officeholders to continue "till successors are appointed". Both opposition and observers allege the amendment is a legislative patch over executive indecision, especially when key posts meant to guarantee fair elections remain in limbo. Of the four members of the ECP, only the Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa representatives - Babar Hassan Bharwana and Justice (retd) Ikramullah Khan - still have valid tenures, both stretching till mid-2027. It is worth noting that CEC Sikandar Sultan Raja's tenure has been full of political minefields. Opposition parties, particularly the PTI, have accused him of everything from election mismanagement to open partisanship. He has been criticised for failing to ensure timely general elections and for stripping the PTI of its iconic 'bat' symbol ahead of the 2024 polls. The ECP has also come under fire for failing to implement the Supreme Court's verdict on reserved seats and for not holding Senate elections in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, a delay denounced by critics as undermining federal parliamentary integrity.
Express Tribune
18 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt decides to tighten solar net metering rules
Listen to article The government has decided to tighten regulations for solar net metering users in a second attempt, after the first one faced a strong backlash and was blocked by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif. Under the new plan, the government will abolish the zero-bill facility for solar net metering by introducing various measures. Additionally, consumers will be allowed a sanctioned load of 1.0x, down from the current load of 1.5x. This means they will be forced to switch to hybrid solar systems by using lithium batteries. Under the current net metering system, the consumers share electricity with power distribution companies (DISCOs) at a buyback rate of Rs27 per unit. However, as part of the new plan, the government is seeking to end this electricity sharing system and DISCOs will pay only Rs10 per unit to the rooftop solar owners who have a net metering system. Experts believe this will lead to an additional expenditure of $1 billion on the import of lithium batteries every year. The plan was discussed during a meeting held between different stakeholders and power ministry officials. Power Division minister chaired the huddle. The Power Division has proposed several measures that will kill the spirit of net metering. According to the proposed plan, the concept of net metering has been abolished and a new concept of net billing with a revised buyback rate is being introduced. This means there will be no exchange of electricity units; rather DISCOs will pay a reduced buyback rate of Rs10 to consumers instead of the existing Rs27 per unit. At present, DISCOs offer a credit billing facility on a quarterly basis, which is being abolished. In its place, a cash facility will be available for the excess electricity exported to the national grid by the solar meter owners and the time period has been reduced to a monthly basis. However, no change has been proposed in the categories of consumers as commercial, domestic and all other consumers will be eligible to take benefit of the new policy. The contract period for a licence has been reduced from seven years to five years. Meanwhile, Federal Minister for Energy Awais Ahmad Khan Leghari, in a statement, said that the government was not abolishing the net metering policy, but was considering changing its current mechanism to a more effective, transparent and sustainable model. He recalled that in 2017-18 he himself played a key role in introducing net metering and at that time the system was in its infancy. "Now, the scope of net metering has expanded and it is having a serious impact on the grid, which must be addressed in a timely manner." He stressed that the government did not intend to harm any consumer or business, but all decisions were being taken while keeping in mind the national interest and long-term sustainability of the energy system. "If we mention the purchase of units, then this is also being considered and there is talk of bringing it to the energy purchase price, so that the system automatically adjusts with fluctuations in rates. All these suggestions are under consideration," the minister said. He pointed out that if the payback period for net metering customers was about three years or less, it would be suitable for any investment. "If a customer is consuming 40% of the electricity himself, the return of money in three years is an acceptable business model. These reforms are not a deterrent, but a step towards a better, balanced and sustainable system," he added. During the meeting, the energy minister presented a comprehensive outline of the ongoing energy reforms. In this regard, the government has eliminated 9,000 megawatts of expensive and unnecessary projects, which were a burden on the system. He said that a levy was imposed on the captive power consumers to bring them back to the grid, which resulted in an increase in electricity demand. Since June 2024, the cross-subsidy given to the industry has reached Rs174 billion, which has reduced industrial tariffs by 31% and caused a significant rise in industrial consumption.
