
Review: I tried Tom Kitchin's Michelin Star lunch menu in Edinburgh
I perform a quick mental run-through of all the restaurants I've visited over the years as each page is turned. Qualms over carbon footprints aside, would any of them warrant that level of commitment to be here today?
Perhaps The Kitchin will be the first. And if so, what great luck for me that it's taken just a train to Edinburgh and a stroll down Leith Walk to make my reservation.
Priced at £69.00, the Lunch Menu is comprised of three courses with the option to splurge one step further should the selection of fine Scottish cheeses displayed in a neat trolley on the restaurant floor catch your eye.
Judging by the number of tables that have ordered thin-stemmed glasses of champagne as a precursor to their meal, I'd wager a couple of extra quid for the pleasure won't be an issue for most.
The interiors at The Kitchin share a theme with those at chef Tom Kitchin's Stockbridge venue Scran and Scallie, which I visited earlier this year after the Gastropub was once again named as the best of its kind in Scotland.
(Read more: It's £25 for ham, eggs and chips at Scotland's Best Gastropub - and worth every penny)
Stag printed wallpaper, 'distressed' upholstery and flourishes of velvet or fluffy faux fur on stools used as a perch for designer handbags, there's a circa 2013 twee-ness to it all. Like you've walked into the section of a glossy home interiors mag titled 'highland chic'.
It's fitting for the menu, though, with the philosophy here said to be 'a true reflection of passion for the finest, freshest Scottish seasonal produce'. A small, illustrated map handed over sometime before a boule of crusty, warm bread arrives at the table confirms that the ingredients used for the lunch menu have been sourced from across Scotland's land and sea.
Before we get to the courses I've selected from the set menu (there were three options for starters mains and desserts as well as a fully veggie alternative) there are a few small bites including a pani puri-esque wheat puffed shell filled with a super light, savoury mousse followed by a teeny-tiny ball of beetroot with big earthy flavour.
Pictured: Lobster and Prawn dumpling on pea and lovage velouté (Image: Newsquest) Serving tables is a two-person job at The Kitchin, and once the warm-up dishes have been cleared away, a duo approaches the table, one carrying a tray and the other poised to gently lift a plate of Newhaven lobster and prawn dumpling, pea and lovage velouté and lobster shell oil from it so that each element looks exactly as it did when leaving the pass.
It's a visually striking dish, the vibrant green of the pea velouté surrounding a dumpling that's smooth and pale in contrast. The mystery as to what this outer layer is hiding, along with the aroma from that fragrant lobster shell oil, demands that you sit up and pay attention. Who cares about any leftover bread from the pre-starters? This is the only thing in the restaurant I want to be eating right now.
Tearing through the outer layer reveals plenty of gorgeous Scottish seafood stuffed into this pocket of goodness, firm, fresh and utterly delicious. The outer coating of the dumpling, it transpires, is a fraction too thick, meaning that I never fully lose myself in the dish as I'd like to. With each spoonful, the delicate flavours and texture of smooth, sweet peas are overshadowed by a nagging chewiness. Still, it's a strong start, refined yet warm and comforting.
Pictured: Pork Loin with braised violet artichoke and black olive tapenade (Image: Newsquest)
Next, it's Clash Farm pork loin with braised violet artichoke and black olive tapenade. It's not quite as pretty as the starter, four strips of meat laid out like toast soldiers atop a glossy jus that's just slightly seeped from a neat circle and edged towards the rim of the plate.
There are some serious, salty flavours battling it out here. The artichokes, buttery soft and herbaceous, a spoonful of potent olive tapenade and a meaty jus reduced until almost sticky and intense. Then there's the pork to pull it all back from the brink, with the delicate layer of fat in particular benefiting from the punchiness of it all.
Read more:
We're back on top form presentation-wise with the dessert of Yuzu meringue tart torched gently until golden brown and nestled into a ring of plump Colbeggie farm berries with a quenelle of strawberry sorbet on the side.
Pictured: The 'Strawberry and Bramble' dessert (Image: Newsquest)
It's a superb pud, a happy marriage of tangy citrus and marshmallow-like Italian meringue executed with a delicate touch. Berries are one of Scotland's greatest seasonal treasures, and a mix of brambles and raspberries effortlessly elevates the dish.
Because he's gone all in with the tasting menu, and tackled almost twice as many courses as I have, the man from London has finished his meal only just before me.
As I savour the final spoonful of dessert, he fills the waiter in on his plans for the connecting train journeys that will see him home later that evening. He seems content that the meal has been worth it, 'I don't usually like scallops,' he says, 'but that was unlike any I've ever tasted before."
I'm glad to hear his efforts have not been in vain, and if the lunch menu has provided a snapshot of what's on offer in the tasting menu, can watch him leave feeling confident that The Kitchin has lived up to expectations.
The Kitchin is located at 82 Commercial Street in Edinburgh

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Evening Standard
3 hours ago
- Evening Standard
Heathrow reveals plan for £21bn third runway
One of Scotland's last 'untouched' private islands for sale for the price of a home in London Remote 90-acre Scottish island for sale for less than a home in London


Scotsman
8 hours ago
- Scotsman
Chaos caused by North Sea cable break shows why we must act to stop Scottish islands being cut off
Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... In the Northern Isles, you are never so aware of the things you rely upon as when they are no longer there. That, I suspect, has been the rueful thought of many islanders in recent days after an undersea cable breakage last weekend. Whether it was the switchboard at the Balfour hospital in Kirkwall being knocked out, undertakers unable to operate, island airports facing delays, shops unable to process card payments or simply their internet or mobile connections at home, people have had a sharp reminder of how reliant we have become on these connections for our everyday needs. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad We cannot wind back the clock on our reliance on the internet. Now is the time for our governments to take notice and take action so that Scottish islands cannot be so easily cut off in future. Residents of Orkney and Shetland saw internet and other services disrupted after a cable linking the islands to the UK mainland was damaged (Picture: Adrian Dennis) | AFP via Getty Images Risk of a catastrophe Technological advances bring all sorts of improvements of efficiency, accessibility and opportunity that were not there before in the more 'far-flung' islands of Scotland just as much as anywhere else (who counts as far-flung being a matter of perspective of course). It is sometimes worth taking a look around, however, and recognising the risks of our communities relying too much on too few potential points of failure. After all, in some ways you could say that last week's cable cut was the 'best-case' scenario for disruption. Cable breakages in the summer are better than cable breakages in the winter, when storms and cold weather can turn a 'nuisance' into a 'catastrophe'. One constituent contacted me after the outage saying that her only way to get a signal and communicate with anyone was to stand outside her local community hall. That is irritating in the summer but far more problematic in the colder months. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Even in these warmer months, however, there are serious challenges. One islander wrote to me this week because her father, who recently had a stroke, has had no way to contact her should he have a fall, due to the connectivity disruption. Another has had to rely on the help of neighbours to submit a job application and prepare for an interview. Building up our defences What has come through in my inbox time and again from islanders is the poor communication of network providers and the inconsistency of their support for customers – a tale as familiar in Edinburgh as it is in Lerwick. Every part of the country should have the same expectation of reliable, well-reinforced communications (and energy) links – and it is in every part of this country's interest to build up these defences. After all, Britain may be a larger island than those in Orkney or Shetland but it is an island all the same. Many of the same risks to connectivity that apply north of the Pentland Firth apply to the UK as a whole – with far wider potential consequences. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad All indications are that this latest cable cut was accidental, but after reports of Russia targeting undersea cables in the Baltic, we cannot be complacent about our own infrastructure. We have all grown to rely upon instant connections for so much of our economy and our society. We may not be prepared for what happens when those connections can no longer be taken for granted.


Scottish Sun
10 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Extraordinary UK island home to dolphins, panoramic cliff views & salmon fishing is on sale for less than a two-bed flat
Estate agents say the island would be perfect for transforming into a glamping site, or using as a film set ISLE TAKE IT Extraordinary UK island home to dolphins, panoramic cliff views & salmon fishing is on sale for less than a two-bed flat Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A BREATHTAKING UK island home to seals and the rolling cliffs is on sale for less than the price of some two-bed flats. Accessible by boat or helicopter, the 90-acre uninhabited island is immersed in the wilderness, making it perfect for anyone keen to escape the hustle and bustle. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 Insh Island is up for sale for £500,000 Credit: Facebook 5 The island has stunning coastline Credit: Facebook 5 The island features a "cave house" Credit: Facebook Insh Island, located in the Inner Hebrides, is one of Scotland's "last untouched private islands". The entire island is currently on the market for £500,000, which is less than the average price for a two-bed flat in central London. It offers panoramic views of the vast Atlantic Ocean, and is home to incredible marine wildlife, such as dolphins and seals. From dramatic cliffs to magnificent stargazing, the slice of wilderness has everything you need to relax and unwind in nature. Spend hours strolling along the untouched coastal paths, or, if you're feeling adventurous, grab a kayak and head out to sea, or grab a rod and fish for wild salmon. Insh Island is located close to Easdale, Scotland's smallest inhabited island, which is home to the World Stone Skimming Championships. From Easdale, you can easily take a 3-5 minute passenger ferry to Ellenabeich on Seil Island from where you can head north to Oban, the nearest large town. The island has no established buildings on it, but there is a "cave house" on the northwestern coastline. It's a completely blank canvas, perfect for transforming into a private family retreat, or a conservation project. According to estate agents Savills, there is plenty of opportunity for renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar power. Little Diomede is a tiny remote island where US is just 2 MILES from Russia The agents add that there is great potential for a glamping site or organic farm on the island. Savills said: "Beyond its natural appeal, Insh Island represents a compelling investment. "As demand for exclusive, eco-conscious destinations continues to grow, this island is ideally suited for tourism, wellness retreats, or even use as a film location. "Land of this kind, wild, private, and unspoiled,is increasingly rare and offers lasting legacy value." Property agent Cameron Ewer added: "One of Scotland's last, untouched private islands. "As someone who appreciates the value of natural beauty, this is just too good an opportunity for any like-minded investor to ignore." Shuna Island And Insh isn't the only Scottish Island that is currently on sale after Shuna Island went on the market for the first time in 80 years. Spanning across 1,110 acres, the island has been in the hands of the same family for the last eight decades. The island, which has eight residential properties on it, as well as a castle, is on the market for a whopping £5.5 million. It is located just off the coast from Appin, Argyll and Bute and features a working farm and a holiday home business. Shuna Castle, which was built in the early 20th century is in ruins, but offers panoramic views of the stunning Scottish coast. 5 H6P9P2 Insh Island Scotland September 2013 Credit: Alamy